- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
V. Veerarajan And Others v. Government Of Tamil Nadu And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
Lucas T.V.S. Limited, Madras, proceeded against 154 workmen for alleged misconduct that included wilful disobedience, acts subversive of discipline, remaining within the establishment after authorised hours without permission, and shouting slogans. After domestic enquiries, 134 workmen were reinstated while 20, including the present 7 (later reduced to 6 after one settled), were dismissed.
Conciliation failed, and the Government of Tamil Nadu declined to refer the dispute for adjudication under Section 10(1) read with Section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. A writ petition challenging this refusal was dismissed by a Single Judge of the High Court; a Division Bench affirmed that dismissal. The workmen obtained special-leave to appeal before the Supreme Court.
On 9 July 1985 the Supreme Court held that the State Government’s sole reliance on the propriety of the domestic enquiry and proportionality of punishment was an “irrelevant ground,” but, on the employer’s request, remitted the matter for reconsideration within 30 days. The Government again refused to refer the dispute, setting out seven fresh grounds. The appeal was thereafter heard on the validity of those grounds.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the seven reasons advanced by the Government of Tamil Nadu for refusing to refer the industrial dispute were germane, relevant, and legally sustainable under Section 10(1) read with Section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act.
- Whether, in the circumstances, the Supreme Court should itself direct a reference or remit the issue to the State Government once more.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants’ Arguments
- The seven grounds relied upon by the State are either repetitions of the earlier irrelevant grounds or otherwise extraneous to the statutory test for making a reference.
- Discrimination is evident: all 154 workmen admitted guilt during settlement talks, yet only 20 were denied reinstatement.
- Precedents such as Bombay Union of Journalists, M.P. Irrigation Karamchari Sangh, and Ram Avtar Sharma limit the Government’s role to a prima facie inquiry; deciding merits or proportionality usurps the Labour Court’s function.
State Government’s Arguments
- The statute permits a prima facie evaluation to decide expediency; the impugned order stays within the permissible limit.
Employer’s Arguments
- The grounds show the Government took a broad, overall view encompassing industrial peace and past unrest; such administrative discretion is not subject to appellate review by the Court.
- If the Court finds the grounds irrelevant, it should remit the matter again rather than order a reference.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Workmen of Syndicate Bank, Madras v. Government of India, 1986 Supp SCC 483 | Appropriate Government cannot refuse reference solely because domestic enquiry was fair and punishment proportionate. | Cited to classify the State’s original ground as “clearly an irrelevant ground.” |
| Ram Avtar Sharma v. State of Haryana, (1985) 3 SCC 189 | Reiterates limited scope of Government’s scrutiny under Section 10. | Relied on to invalidate the State’s renewed focus on proportionality. |
| Bombay Union of Journalists v. State of Bombay, AIR 1964 SC 1617 | Government may undertake only a prima facie examination; final adjudication belongs to the Tribunal. | Invoked by appellants to show the State over-stepped by deciding merits. |
| M.P. Irrigation Karamchari Sangh v. State of M.P., (1985) 2 SCC 103 | Government should be “very slow” to decline reference; only patent frivolousness justifies refusal. | Used to argue that the present refusal lacked statutory justification. |
| Nirmal Singh v. State of Punjab, 1984 Supp SCC 407 | Supreme Court may direct a reference forthwith where refusal is illegal. | Supported the Court’s power to issue a direct reference order. |
| Sankari Cement Alai Thozhilalar Munnetra Sangam v. Govt. of T.N., (1983) 1 SCC 304 | Similar instance where Court mandated reference. | Reinforced the appropriateness of issuing a direct reference in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court recalled that in its 9 July 1985 order it had already found the earlier refusal unsustainable but remitted the matter to afford the Government an opportunity to cite other relevant grounds. Upon examining the seven new grounds, it agreed with the appellants that:
- Grounds concerning defence supplies and past industrial unrest were extraneous to the statutory criteria for reference.
- The reiteration that charges were proved and punishment proportionate merely rephrased the earlier discredited basis.
- The Government’s attempt to balance “industrial peace” versus adjudication amounted to deciding the merits, a task reserved for the Labour Court.
Given the lapse of more than seven years since dismissal and the absence of any legally valid reason, the Court concluded that “this is a fit case where a reference should be made.” Prior precedents authorising the Court to order reference directly were invoked to justify immediate intervention.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is allowed. The State of Tamil Nadu is directed to refer the industrial dispute concerning the remaining six workmen to the appropriate Labour Court within one month. The Labour Court shall dispose of the reference within four months of receiving it. Costs of Rs 3,000 are awarded to the appellants, recoverable from Respondent 1.
Implications: The decision reinforces that an appropriate Government cannot refuse a reference by substituting its judgment on the merits or proportionality of punishment for that of the statutory Tribunal. While no novel legal principle is announced, the judgment strengthens existing jurisprudence limiting executive discretion and ensures the workmen’s dispute proceeds to adjudication without further delay.
Ranganath Misra, J.— 154 workmen were proceeded against by the management of Lucas T.V.S Limited, Madras, for wilful disobedience of lawful orders of superiors, acts subversive of good and proper behaviour within the establishment after authorised hours of work without permission and shouting of slogans within the establishment amounting to misconduct under Standing Orders. Later 134 of them were taken back to employment. In regard to 7 of the dismissed workmen conciliation was undertaken and upon its failure, disputes raised under Section 11-A of the Industrial Disputes Act were asked to be referred to the Labour Court for adjudication. When Government declined to make a reference, the High Court was moved. The learned Single Judge rejected the writ petition and the Division Bench upheld such rejection. This appeal by special leave is against the order of the Division Bench of the High Court.
2. This Court on 9-7-1985 after hearing counsel for parties came to the conclusion:
“Now it is clear from the order made by the State Government on 11-10-1979 which order has been reaffirmed by the State Government by its order dated 3-5-1981, that the only ground on which the State Government refused to make a reference of the dispute to the Labour Court was that, in its opinion, the domestic inquiry had been conducted by Respondent 3 (employer) according to the principles of natural justice and the punishment imposed by Respondent 3 on the appellants was not disproportionate to the gravity of the offence committed by them. This is also borne out from para 6 of the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of Respondent 1 ... where it has been clearly stated that the Labour Department of the Government of Tamil Nadu opined that the management had conducted a fair and proper inquiry and also taken in consideration the gravity of the offence before dismissing the appellants and the punishment imposed on the appellants was not disproportionate having regard to the nature of the charges proved against them. This ground on which the State Government has acted in refusing to refer the dispute to the Labour Court is clearly an irrelevant ground. It is now settled law as a result of the decisions of this Court in Workmen of Syndicate Bank, Madras v. Government of India 1986 Supp SCC 483, 1987 SCC (Lab) 19, (1985) 1 LLJ 93 and Ram Avtar Sharma v. State of Haryana (1985) 3 SCC 189, (1985) 67 FJR 94 that the appropriate government cannot decline to make reference of an industrial dispute arising out of the termination of the service of a workman on the ground that the domestic inquiry resulting in the termination of the service of the workman was in the opinion of the State Government in conformity with the principles of natural justice and that the punishment imposed on the workman was not disproportionate to the offence with which he was charged....
We would therefore have ordinarily allowed the appeal and set aside the judgments of the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court and directed the State Government to make a reference of the industrial dispute between the appellants and Respondent 3. But Dr Chitale appearing on behalf of Respondent 3 urged that there might be some other relevant grounds which may still be required to be considered by the State Government before deciding whether to make a reference or not and the case should therefore go back to the State Government to reconsider the question in the same manner in which this Court directed the State Government to reconsider in the Workmen of Syndicate Bank case 1986 Supp SCC 483, 1987 SCC (Lab) 19, (1985) 1 LLJ 93 But this is a case in which more than 7 years have elapsed since the appellants were dismissed from service and they are still nowhere near a reference. We would therefore set aside the judgments passed by the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench and direct the State Government to reconsider the matter without taking into account the aforesaid irrelevant ground and come to a decision within a period of 30 days from the date of receipt of the copy of this order whether it would make a reference of the industrial dispute to the Labour Court. We would keep the appeal pending before us and as soon as the decision is reached by the State Government, which of course should be within a period of 30 days from the date of receipt of the copy of this order by the State Government, intimation of such decision shall be given to the court so that the court can then consider whether the decision reached by the State Government is legally justified or not. We are informed that V. Kondiah Appellant 2 has already settled the dispute with Respondent 3 and therefore the Question of making a reference of the dispute will have to be considered by the State Government only in regard to the remaining 6 appellants.”
3. After the matter went back the State Government has made the following order:
“Accordingly the Government have re-examined the conciliation report first read above and all other connected relevant records and consider that it is not necessary to refer the cases of Thiruvalargal K. Arinathan, A.C Kabaleswaran, V. Srinivasan, V. Veerarajan, P. Subramanian and H. Indirarajan for adjudication both on merits and on expediency for the following reasons:
(1) Lucas T.V.S Limited are suppliers of some items to the Defence.
(2) There was industrial unrest followed by violence and stoppage of work in this establishment in 1977 due to inter-union rivalry.
“Again there was industrial unrest due to inter-union rivalry in this establishment in 1978 employing 2400 workmen. To avoid recurrence of such incidents and stoppage of work again in 1978 the management took disciplinary action against 154 workmen. The management took back 134 workmen out of 154. The 7 workmen are among those who were dismissed considering the gravity of the offence.”
(3) The management charge-sheeted these 7 workmen under the specific provisions of the standing orders for misconduct such as wilful disobedience of lawful orders of the superiors, acts subversive of good and proper behaviour within the establishment, being within the establishment after authorised hours of work without permission shouting slogans within the establishment etc.
(4) All the workmen admitted the charges framed against them during the enquiries and hence the management dismissed them from service based on these enquiries and taking into account their past services.
(5) Since the workmen themselves have admitted the charges against them, the Government consider that the charges have been proved.
(6) The Government also considered the nature of proven charges and the quantum of punishment imposed on them with a view to decide the question whether the reference should be made or not.
(7) Considering the proven charges and the need to preserve industrial peace in the establishment the Government con-sider that this is not a fit case for adjudication both on expediency and on merits.
“No action is considered necessary in respect of the case of Thiru A. Kondaiah who has settled his accounts finally with the management.”
4. With reference to the order made by the State Government the appeal has been further heard. Mr Ramamurthi for the appellants, learned Attorney-General for the Government of Tamil Nadu and Dr Chitale for the management have advanced their respective contentions.
5. The seven grounds given in support of the order refusing to make a reference have been challenged by Mr Ramamurthi as irrelevant. The facts that the company manufactures and supplies certain items to the Defence Department of the Union of India and there was industrial unrest followed by violence and stoppage of work, according to learned counsel, are not germane and relevant for the purpose of deciding as to whether the dispute raised by the 6 workmen should be referred to industrial adjudication. So far as the third ground is concerned, according to Mr Ramamurthi, it is in effect repetition of the earlier grounds which this Court found to be irrelevant. The language has been changed and the grounds have been made descriptive and detailed. Coming to the fourth ground it is contended that all the 154 delinquent workmen had accepted their guilt when negotiation for a settlement was undertaken. There was no justification for the employer to discriminate between 134 workmen who were restored to service and the remaining 20 including the 6 appellants to whom re-employment was not given. Mr Ramamurthi states that Ground 5 is totally irrelevant. Similarly, Grounds 6 and 7 are not at all material and do not justify the refusal to refer the dispute. In support of the appeal the learned counsel has further contended that in a series of decisions beginning with the case of Bombay Union of Journalists v. State of Bombay AIR 1964 SC 1617, (1964) 1 LLJ 351 this Court has clearly laid down that it is open to the State Government to take the broad features into consideration while exercising jurisdiction under Section 10(1) of the Act. If the dispute in question raises a question of law the appropriate Government should not purport to reach a final conclusion on the said question of law because that would normally lie within the jurisdiction of the Industrial Tribunal. Similarly, on disputed questions of fact the appropriate government cannot purport to reach final conclusions for that again would be the province of the Industrial Tribunal. Gajendragadkar, J. as he then was speaking in that case indicated:
“… it would not be possible to accept the plea that the appropriate Government is precluded from considering even prima facie the merits of the dispute when it decides the question as to whether its power to make a reference should be exercised under Section 10(1) read with Section 12(5), or not. If the claim made is patently frivolous, or is clearly belated, the appropriate government may refuse to make a reference. Likewise, if the impact of the claim on the general relations between the employer and the employees in the region is likely to be adverse, the appropriate government may take that into account in deciding whether a reference should be made or not. It must, therefore, be held that a prima facie examination of the merits cannot be said to be foreign to the inquiry which the appropriate government is entitled to make in dealing with a dispute under Section 10(1).…”
Mr Ramamurthi also placed reliance on the decision in the case of M.P Irrigation Karamchari Sangh v. State of M.P (1985) 2 SCC 103 where it has been said:( and 109, paras 5 and 7)
“Therefore, while conceding a very limited jurisdiction to the State Government to examine patent frivolousness of the demands, it is to be understood as a rule, that adjudication of demands made by workmen should be left to the Tribunal to decide. Section 10 permits appropriate government to determine whether dispute ‘exists or is apprehended’ and then refer it for adjudication on merits. The demarcated functions are (1) reference, (2) adjudication. When a reference is rejected on the specious plea that the Government cannot bear the additional burden, it constitutes adjudication and thereby usurpation of the power of a quasi-judicial Tribunal by an administrative authority namely the appropriate government.... What the State Government has done in this case is not a prima facie examination of the merits of the question involved.
There may be exceptional cases in which the State Government may, on a proper examination of the demand, come to a conclusion that the demands are either perverse or frivolous and do not merit a reference. Government should be very slow to attempt an examination of the demand with a view to decline reference and courts will always be vigilant whenever the government attempts to usurp the powers of the Tribunal for adjudication of valid disputes. To allow the Government to do so would be to render Section 10 and Section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act nugatory.”
6. In the case of Ram Avtar Sharma v. State of Haryana (1985) 3 SCC 189, (1985) 67 FJR 94 the ratio in the Bombay Union of Journalists case AIR 1964 SC 1617, (1964) 1 LLJ 351 has been reiterated.
7. Learned Attorney-General for the State of Tamil Nadu submitted that the statute authorises the State to take a prima facie view of the matter for the purpose of ascertaining whether it was a fit case wherein exercise of jurisdiction under Section 10(1) read with Section 12(5) of the Act was called for and a reference was warranted. The State Government in declining to make a reference in the present case has kept itself within the limit set by law as delineated by this Court.
8. Dr Chitale contended that the grounds advanced in support of refusal to make a reference were clearly tenable and indicated that a broad and overall view of the matter was taken by the State Government. Since the jurisdiction of this Court is not appellate and the order of the State Government is administrative in character, no interference was warranted. Dr Chitale further added that if we took the view that the grounds advanced by the State Government were neither germane nor relevant, the matter should go back to the State Government for a fresh disposal as it is not for this Court to direct a reference to be made.
9. Having heard learned counsel for the parties we are of the view that this is a fit case where a reference should be made. In the order of this Court in the present case on 9-7-1985 it has been clearly stated that a direction to make a reference would have been given but for the submission advanced by Dr Chitale that the matter should go back and the State Government should be given an opportunity of giving other valid reasons, if any, in support of its order. In the case of Nirmal Singh v. State of Punjab 1984 Supp SCC 407, 1984 Lab IC 1312 this Court gave a direction that reference be made forthwith. Similarly, in the case of Sankari Cement Alai Thozhilalar Munnetra Sangam v. Govt. of T.N (1983) 1 SCC 304, (1983) 1 LLJ 460 this Court gave a direction for making of a reference.
10. The criticism advanced by Mr Ramamurthi in regard to the reasons given by the State Government seem to be well founded and we are of the opinion that the respondent State Government should have a direction to refer the dispute for adjudication by the labour court. The State Government's order should be made within one month from today and the Labour Court to which the dispute may be referred shall have a direction to dispose of the reference within four months hence from the date of receipt of the reference.
11. The appellants shall be entitled to costs. Hearing fee is assessed at Rs 3000 and is recoverable from Respondent 1.
Alert