- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Maharashtra v. Harishchandra And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
Respondent 1, Harishchandra, owned agricultural lands in Village Reogaon, Taluka Jalna, Maharashtra. On the “appointed day” (26 January 1962) for the Maharashtra Agricultural Lands (Ceiling and Holdings) Act, 1961, he was in statutory possession of 64 acres and 23 gunthas. He filed a return under Section 12 of the Act asserting that 4 acres were uncultivable and 3 acres were occupied by a public road.
The Surplus Land Determination Tribunal, Jalna initially excluded Survey No. 143 and part of Survey No. 144, declaring only 9 acres and 24 gunthas as surplus. On appeal by the State of Maharashtra, the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal found that some lands had been wrongly omitted and remanded the matter for fresh consideration. Respondent 1 did not object to this remand.
Upon remand, the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal included Survey No. 143 and held that Respondent 1 possessed 30 acres and 31 gunthas of surplus land. The Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal dismissed Respondent 1’s subsequent appeal and confirmed the revised finding.
Respondent 1 then invoked Article 227 of the Constitution before the Bombay High Court. The High Court allowed the petition, holding that the Revenue Tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction in remanding the matter on an issue not raised before it. The State challenged this decision before the Supreme Court under Article 136.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution, the High Court could set aside findings of fact made by the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal after a remand that had been accepted without objection by the affected party.
- Whether the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal acted within its jurisdiction in remanding the matter for fresh determination of surplus land despite the absence of a cross-objection by the State.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court emphasized two interconnected considerations:
- Waiver and Acquiescence: Respondent 1 neither objected to the remand order before the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal nor challenged it during the proceedings before the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal on remand. By submitting to the remand, he waived any right to question its propriety at a later stage.
- Limits of Article 227 Review: The High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction does not extend to re-appreciating findings of fact, particularly where the party now objecting earlier acquiesced in the procedure that generated those findings. Setting aside factual determinations in such circumstances was viewed as an overreach.
Because the respondent had voluntarily accepted the remand and participated in the subsequent proceedings, the Supreme Court concluded that the High Court’s interference was unjustified. Consequently, the findings of the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal—affirmed by the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal—stood restored.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is allowed; the Bombay High Court’s judgment is set aside, and the orders of the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal (remand order dated 30 July 1976 and affirming order dated 5 April 1977) together with the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal’s order dated 25 December 1976 are affirmed.
Implications are confined to the parties: Respondent 1 must surrender the surplus land as determined (30 acres and 31 gunthas). The decision hinges on waiver and the supervisory scope of Article 227, but the Court sets no broader precedent beyond reinforcing established limits on High Court interference in factual determinations.
B.C Ray, J.— Special leave granted. Delay in filing the application for special leave under Article 136 of the Constitution is condoned. Heard learned counsel for both the parties. The only question that poses itself for decision in this appeal is whether the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India can set aside the findings of facts arrived at by the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal, Jalna pursuant to an order of remand made by the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal, even though Respondent 1 submitted to the order of remand without questioning its propriety and validity.
2. Respondent 1 Harishchandra was the owner of Survey Nos. 143, 144 and half portion of 161 situated it Village Reogaon Taluka, District Jalna, Maharashtra. He was in statutory possession of the same under the provisions of Section 38-E of the Hyderabad Tenants and Agricultural Land Act, 1950. The total land in his possession on the appointed day i.e on January 26, 1962 when the Maharashtra Agricultural Land (Ceiling and Holding) Act, 1961 came into force was 64 acres and 23 gunthas. In accordance with the provisions of Section 12 of the said Act, Respondent 1 having in his possession lands more than the ceiling prescribed under the said Act, submitted a return declaring therein that 4 acres of land out of the said lands was potkharab and uncultivable and 3 acres of land was occupied by public road passing through his land bearing Survey No. 143. The Surplus Land Determination Tribunal, Jalna after enquiry held that the area of Survey No. 143 be excluded and the area of Survey No. 144 be taken into account. It was also held that 2 acres of land from Survey No. 144 is pot-kharab area. On these findings, Respondent 1 was held to be holding surplus land to the extent of 9 acres and 24 gunthas.
3. Respondent 1 preferred an appeal against the said order of the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal before the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal. The State did not file any cross-objection against any of the findings arrived at in the said judgment. It was, however, contended on behalf of the State that certain other land held by Respondent 1 was not taken into consideration while determining the ceiling limit of the lands Respondent 1 was entitled to hold and retain in his possession in accordance with the provisions of the said Act and as such it was contended that the findings arrived at by the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal by its order dated March 26, 1976 were erroneous. The Revenue Tribunal after hearing both the parties accepted the contention of the State and remitted the case back on remand to the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal, Jalna for fresh enquiry and decision after setting aside the judgment and order of the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal. Respondent 1, however, did not make any objection against the order of remand made by the Tribunal and on the other hand submitted to it.
4. The Surplus Land Determination Tribunal pursuant to the order of remand heard both the parties and revised its earlier findings by including Survey No. 143 in the holding of Respondent 1. The Tribunal also held lhat Respondent 1 had in his possession surplus land to the extent of 30 acres and 31 gunthas.
5. Feeling aggrieved by the said judgment and order dated December 25, 1976, Respondent 1 preferred an appeal before the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal. The Tribunal dismissed the appeal and confirmed the findings of the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal by its order dated April 5, 1977. No objection, however, was raised on behalf of Respondent 1 as to the validity of the order of the remand of the case either before the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal when the Tribunal heard the matter on remand, or before the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal at the time of hearing of the appeal against the said order.
6. Respondent 1, thereafter, filed an application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India before the High Court of Judicature, Bombay, challenging the legality and validity of the order made on December 25, 1976 by the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal as well as the order dismissing the appeal made by Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal affirming the findings of the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal after the said order of remand. The said Special Civil Application 6 of 1978 was allowed by the High Court, Bombay by its order dated June 23, 1983 setting aside the judgment and order dated March 26, 1976 passed after remand by the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal, Jalna and also the judgment and order passed by the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal confirming the said judgment and order on holding that the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal acted in excess of its jurisdiction to remand the matter on the issue, which was not the subject matter before the appellate authority. It was held that the order of remand was erroneous and it required to be rectified by the court. The exercise of powers under Article 227 of the Constitution was held to be justified on the ground of advancement of justice.
7. On a consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case, we are constrained to hold that the judgment and order made by the High Court, Bombay cannot be sustained for the reasons stated hereinbelow:
8. The Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal undoubtedly held that the decision rendered by the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal by its order dated March 26, 1976 was erroneous as the Tribunal had excluded certain lands held by Respondent 1 while determining the surplus land in possession of the petitioner in accordance with the provisions of Section 12 of the Maharashtra Agricultural (Ceiling and Holdings) Act, 1961. The Tribunal, therefore, sent the case back on remand to the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal, Jalna on setting aside its aforesaid judgment and order for deciding the matter afresh. It is not disputed that the State of Maharashtra did not file any cross-objection before the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal questioning or assailing any of the findings made by the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal. It is also pertinent to mention in this connection that Respondent 1 did not also raise any objection against passing of the said order of remand by Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal on setting aside the order of the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal at the instance of State of Maharashtra. On the other hand Respondent 1 submitted to the order of remand and waived its right to object against the order of remand. Thereafter the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal, Jalna made the aforesaid order after hearing the parties holding that Respondent 1 had in his possession at the relevant date surplus land to the extent of 30 acres and 31 gunthas after including the land of Survey No. 143 reversing its earlier findings. The said judgment and order was confirmed by the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal.
9. Considering all these circumstances and specially the fact that Respondent 1 waived his right to object to the order of remand by submitting to it, the judgment and order rendered by the High Court of Judicature, Bombay is set aside and the order of remand made by the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal on July 30, 1976 as well as the order dated December 25, 1976 passed by the Surplus Land Determination Tribunal and confirmed by the judgment and order of the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal dated April 5, 1977 after remand are hereby affirmed. There will, however, be no order as to costs in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case.
Alert