- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of U.P v. Suresh Chandra Srivastava And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
In 1967, Shankar Lal Bhargava, who was officiating as Stamp Reporter in the Registry of the Allahabad High Court, allegedly removed used court-fee stamps with the aid of two advocate clerks, Suresh Chandra Srivastava and Bishan Swarup. Three ₹1,000 stamps were reused in First Civil Appeal Nos. 281/67, 282/67 and 357/67. An internal inquiry disclosed that court-fee stamps worth ₹23,007.50 were missing from First Appeal No. 186 of 1960 and that similar removals had occurred in other cases. Believing a “well-organised gang” was defrauding the Government, the High Court’s Registrar—after obtaining permission from the Chief Justice—reported the matter to the Inspector-General of Police, U.P. The Criminal Investigation Department ultimately filed three charge-sheets alleging offences under Sections 262, 263, 467, 471, 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
The accused respondents moved the Allahabad High Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC), seeking to quash all proceedings on the ground that certain offences fell within the bar of Section 195 CrPC. By judgment dated 9 January 1979 the High Court quashed the charges under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B IPC but allowed prosecution for the remaining offences to continue. The State appealed to the Supreme Court of India by special leave; the present judgment disposes of those appeals.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court was correct in quashing proceedings for offences under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B IPC on the ground that no complaint under Section 195 CrPC had been filed and that the allegations did not disclose those offences.
- Whether prosecution for the other alleged offences—Sections 262, 263, 380/34 and 420/34 IPC—could proceed without a complaint under Section 195 CrPC.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court reviewed the complaint lodged by the Registrar and concluded that, on its face, the facts only supported offences under Sections 262, 263, 380 and 420 IPC. There was “not even a hint” of forging a document or using a forged document; therefore, Sections 467, 471 and 120-B IPC were not attracted.
Section 195(1)(b)(ii) CrPC bars courts from taking cognizance of certain forgery-related offences unless a complaint is filed by the court whose document is in question. However, the Court reiterated the settled principle that Section 195 affects only the specific offences enumerated therein unless the other offences form “an integral part of the same transaction.” Because the alleged conduct constituting Sections 262, 263, 380 and 420 IPC was distinct and did not involve forgery, these offences were outside the ambit of Section 195.
Accordingly, the High Court’s decision to quash the forgery-related charges was upheld—not because Section 195 applied, but because the allegations did not establish those offences. Conversely, the High Court correctly allowed the remaining charges to proceed without a Section 195 complaint.
Holding and Implications
Appeals dismissed; High Court judgment affirmed. The Supreme Court directed that the prosecutions for offences under Sections 262, 263, 380/34 and 420/34 IPC proceed without the need for a complaint under Section 195 CrPC.
Implications: The decision underscores that courts must examine whether the factual allegations actually make out forgery-related offences before invoking Section 195 CrPC. It reaffirms that distinct, non-forgery offences can be tried independently without the procedural bar of Section 195, preventing unnecessary derailment of prosecutions where the statutory pre-condition is inapplicable.
S. Murtaza Fazal Ali, J.— These appeals by special leave arise out of a judgment dated January 9, 1979 of the Allahabad High Court refusing to quash the proceedings in toto which were pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Allahabad, in exercise of the powers under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter to be referred to as the ‘Code’). The High Court, however, quashed the proceedings only in respect of offences under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code and directed prosecution of the respondents in respect of other offences to proceed according to law. In order to understand the implication of the judgment of the High Court, it may be necessary to narrate a few facts.
2. It appears that some time in the year 1967 Shankar Lal Bhargava, who was officiating as Stamp Reporter in the Registry of the Allahabad High Court, with the aid of Suresh Chandra Srivastava and Bishan Swarup, who were clerks of Advocates, removed used stamps and out of them reused three court-fee stamps of the value of Rs 1000 each in First Civil Appeal Nos. 281/67, 282/67 and 357/67. When the matter was detected, an enquiry was ordered and the Judicial Department of the High Court reported to the Registrar that court-fee stamps of the value of Rs 23,007.50 p. (on 15 sheets) were missing from the judicial file of First Appeal No. 186 of 1960. The enquiry further revealed that in several other cases also court-fee stamps had been taken out from the original files and reused in new cases. The Registrar of the High Court suspected that a well-organised gang of racketeers was operating in the High Court to defraud the Government by surreptitiously removing the used stamps from the judicial files and reusing them in new cases. The Registrar, with the permission of the Chief Justice of the High Court, reported the matter to the Inspector-General of Police, U.P, who ordered the Criminal Investigation Department of U.P to investigate into the matter and ultimately three charge-sheets were submitted for offences under Sections 262, 263, 467, 471, 420 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code.
3. The respondents filed an application before the High Court contending that as offences under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B, IPC fell within the purview of Section 195 of the Code, no prosecution could be launched without the procedure, laid down in Section 195, being followed. It is common ground that no complaint as required by the mandatory provisions of Section 195 of the Code having been made, the proceedings could not have proceeded. The High Court held that so far as the offences under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B, IPC were concerned as they fell within the ambit of Section 195(1)(b)(ii) of the Code, no cognizance could be taken by the Magistrate without a complaint being filed. The relevant portion of Section 195(1)(b) may be extracted thus:
“195. (1) No court shall take cognizance—
* * *.
(b)(ii) of any offence described in Section 463, or punishable under Section 471, Section 475 or Section 476, of the said Code, when such offence is alleged to have been committed in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any court, or
(iii) of any criminal conspiracy to commit, or attempt to commit, or the abetment of, any offence specified in sub-clause (i) or sub-clause (ii),
except on the complaint in writing of that court, or of some other court to which that court is subordinate.”
4. On the facts mentioned above, it is clear to us that in the complaint sent by the Registrar to the Inspector-General of Police, offences mentioned were offences under Sections 262, 263, 467, 380, 420 and 471 but from a perusal of the recitals in the original memorandum which formed the basis of the complaint it seems to us that the only offences which have been made out would be offences under Sections 262, 263, 380 and 420 which are obviously not covered by Section 195 of the Code.
5. The High Court held that the offences under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B, IPC even if made out could not be taken cognizance of by the trial court without a complaint under Section 195 of the Code. A perusal of the facts shows that there is not even a hint regarding forging any document or using a forged document. Taking the complaint at its face value, at the most the cases against the accused would fall within the ambit of Sections 262, 263, 380 and 420, IPC which do not require a complaint under Section 195. The fact that some persons aided and abetted the detaching of the used stamps from the old files and reusing them in the other cases does not involve any process of forgery or use of a forged document.
6. In these circumstances, therefore, it is not necessary for us to go into the broader question as to whether if offences under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B, IPC are committed, the complaint could proceed or not. The law is now well settled that where an accused commits some offences which are separate and distinct from those contained in Section 195, Section 195 will affect only the offences mentioned therein unless such offences form an integral part so as to amount to offences committed as a part of the same transaction, in which case the other offences also would fall within the ambit of Section 195 of the Code.
7. In the instant case, as already pointed out by us, on the facts narrated by the Registrar in his complaint no offence under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B, IPC is at all revealed and as such it is not necessary to go into the question as to what offences are connected with Sections 467, 471 and 120-B and which are severable from them. The High Court was fully justified in quashing the proceedings against the accused as far as offences under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B, IPC were concerned, not because they were covered by Section 195 of the Code but because allegations contained in the complaint did not constitute these offences. The High Court was further fully justified in directing that other offences mentioned above did not require a complaint under Section 195 and would have to be tried.
8. In the view that we take it is not necessary for us to decide the broader question of law posed by the High Court i.e whether or not offences under Sections 467, 471 and 120-B, IPC, along with other offences, were covered by Section 195 of the Code.
9. We, therefore, affirm the judgment of the High Court and dismiss the appeals and the special leave petitions and direct that cases under Sections 262, 263, 380/34 and 420/34, Indian Penal Code be tried without any complaint under Section 195 of the Code.
Alert