Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Azhar Ali Khan And Others v. Commissioner, Municipal Corporation Of Delhi And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 18, 1984
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The present opinion concerns two connected miscellaneous petitions arising out of Writ Petition No. 1194 of 1979 filed by graduate Junior Engineers against the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD):

  • CMP No. 3068 of 1984 – filed by the MCD (first respondent) seeking a direction that, in view of an alleged “change in circumstances,” it need not fill vacancies in the Assistant Engineers’ seniority list (1978-79) through direct recruitment.
  • CMP No. 3069 of 1984 – filed by the original writ-petitioners praying (i) that contempt proceedings be initiated against Respondents 1 and 2 for non-compliance with this Court’s order dated 13 July 1983, (ii) for immediate implementation of that order by appointing the remaining eligible petitioners to 32 vacancies, and (iii) for an injunction preventing the respondents from filling the posts through diploma-holder Junior Engineers on ad hoc or “current duty charge” basis.

The 13 July 1983 order had: (a) directed MCD to appoint eight petitioners from the select list approved on 2 May 1979, (b) quashed earlier ad hoc/current-duty-charge promotions made on 10 April 1978 and 21 June 1979, (c) ordered that all remaining direct-recruitment quota posts be filled from the same select list within six months, and (d) forbade further ad hoc promotions contrary to the Recruitment Regulations.

Subsequently, the Corporation passed Resolution No. 493 dated 26 September 1983 proposing 100 % departmental promotion and instructing its Commissioner not to fill any Assistant Engineer post through direct recruitment pending amendment of the Recruitment Regulations. This resolution and the alleged expiry of the 1979 select list formed the basis of MCD’s request in CMP 3068 and its defence to the contempt allegation in CMP 3069.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Municipal Corporation of Delhi can avoid compliance with this Court’s order dated 13 July 1983—specifically the filling of remaining Assistant Engineer vacancies by direct recruitment from the 2 May 1979 select list—on the grounds of (a) Resolution No. 493 (26 September 1983) and (b) alleged expiry of the select panel.
  2. Whether the Corporation’s failure to revert diploma-holder Junior Engineers appointed on ad hoc/current-duty-charge basis, despite quashing of the relevant orders, constitutes contempt of court.
  3. Whether respondents are liable to contempt proceedings and consequential directions for non-implementation of the 1983 judgment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners (CMP No. 3069 of 1984)

  • MCD has not filled the remaining 32 vacancies (including 15 direct-recruitment quota posts) with the eligible graduate Junior Engineers despite repeated representations and this Court’s explicit directions.
  • The Corporation has failed to revert ad hoc promotees appointed by the quashed orders of 10 April 1978 and 21 June 1979, thereby defying the Court’s judgment.
  • Resolution No. 493 is an afterthought intended to circumvent the binding Recruitment Regulations and the Court’s order.
  • Contempt action is necessary to secure compliance and to restrain MCD from filling posts through diploma holders or any other irregular method.

Municipal Corporation of Delhi & Respondents 1–2

  • They have complied with the order to appoint eight Assistant Engineers from the select list.
  • Further appointments are impossible because Resolution No. 493 mandates 100 % promotion and prohibits direct recruitment until amended rules receive UPSC approval.
  • The 2 May 1979 select panel was valid only for two years (based on a Commissioner’s circular) and allegedly lapsed on 1 May 1981, rendering appointments therefrom impermissible.
  • Reversion of ad hoc promotees is “dependent” on fresh appointments; without new appointees the administrative vacuum prevents reversion.

Promotees affected by possible reversion (represented by Dr Y.S. Chitale)

  • Assert that their reversion would be improper in view of Resolution 493, which purportedly bars direct recruitment required to fill resultant vacancies.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court rejected each justification advanced by the Corporation and the promotees:

  • Effect of Resolution 493: The resolution, enacted after the 13 July 1983 judgment, cannot override or constitute a legal impediment to complying with a binding judicial directive grounded in existing Recruitment Regulations approved under Section 480(2) of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act.
  • Alleged expiry of the select panel: The Corporation had itself relied on the same panel in July 1981 when it undertook to appoint eight candidates. Having partly utilised the list, it cannot now contend that it expired on 1 May 1981.
  • Non-reversion of ad hoc promotees: The quashing of the orders dated 10 April 1978 and 21 June 1979 was unconditional. Reversion should have been “forthwith”; linking it to future appointments is contrary to the clear mandate of the 1983 judgment.

Consequently, the Court:

  1. Directed Respondents 1 and 2 to revert the eight ad hoc/current-duty-charge appointees within ten days, warning that failure would invite contempt proceedings.
  2. Ordered the Corporation to fill all remaining direct-recruitment-quota vacancies of Assistant Engineer from the 2 May 1979 select list within one month, again reserving liberty to the petitioners to seek contempt action upon default.
  3. Held that neither Resolution 493 nor the purported expiry of the panel constitutes a valid defence or “supervening circumstance.”

Holding and Implications

CMP No. 3068 of 1984 is DISMISSED.

CMP No. 3069 of 1984 is ALLOWED to the extent indicated.

Respondents must (a) revert the eight ad hoc promotees within ten days and (b) appoint the remaining eligible petitioners as Assistant Engineers within one month, failing which fresh contempt proceedings may be initiated. No costs were awarded.

Implications are confined to enforcing compliance with an earlier Supreme Court judgment; no new legal precedent was created, but the decision reinforces the principle that administrative resolutions cannot negate judicial directions grounded in existing statutory regulations.

Show all summary ...

A. Varadarajan, J.— C.M.P No. 3068 of 1984 is by the first respondent in Writ Petition No. 1194 of 1979 (Municipal Corporation of Delhi) for a direction that having regard to changed circumstance the Corporation need not fill in the gaps in the seniority list of 1978-79 relating to Assistant Engineers by direct recruitment. C.M.P No. 3069 of 1984 is by the petitioners in the same writ petition for taking proceedings against Respondents 1 and 2 in the writ petition for contempt of this Court's order dated July 13, 1983 made in the writ petition and for directing those two respondents to forthwith implement that order and fill up the available 32 posts of Assistant Engineers from amongst the petitioners “who were qualified and eligible according to the recruitment rules” and to restrain those respondents from filling up the posts in the direct recruitment quota from amongst diploma holders on current duty charge or on ad hoc basis or in any other manner.

2. By our order dated July 13, 1983 we allowed prayers Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5 in the writ petition as indicated in our judgment with costs and dismissed the writ petition in other respects. Prayer No. 1 in the writ petition was to direct Respondent 1 in the writ petition to fill up eight posts of Assistant Engineers from amongst those in the select panel approved on May 2, 1979. As regards that prayer what has been ordered by us is this: [SCC para 45, p. 593: SCC (L&S) p. 459]

…there is nothing wrong in the Respondent 1-Corporation proceeding to appoint Assistant Engineers (Civil) by direct recruitment as per the Recruitment Regulations or in fixing the 50: 50 quota and working it out or in the selection of the petitioners in Writ Petition No. 1194 of 1979 as Assistant Engineers pursuant to the decision to appoint eight Assistant Engineers (Civil) by direct recruitment in the interviews held for that purpose on March 6 and 7, 1979 and that Respondents 1 and 2 should issue orders of appointment to those posts to eight of the petitioners in Writ Petition No. 1194 of 1979 who are in the select list within six weeks from this date (July 13, 1983), if not already issued as undertaken by Mr U.R Lalit (Senior Counsel of Respondents 1 and 2) on July 29, 1981 within five months from that date.

3. Prayer No. 2 in the writ petition was to quash the office order dated April 11, 1978 entrusting Junior Engineers with current duty charge of the posts of Assistant Engineers and the office order dated June 21, 1979 promoting 2 Junior Engineers as Assistant Engineers on current duty charge on their own pay scale. As regards that prayer what we have stated in our order in the writ petition is this: [SCC para 54, p. 598: SCC (L&S) p. 464]

Continuing current duty charge and ad hoc appointments for such a long period exceeding the period of one year mentioned in the said memorandum dated December 30, 1976 of the Government of India is irregular though that memorandum could not be stated to be automatically binding on Respondent 1. What is totally wrong is that appointment of Junior Engineers on current duty charge as Assistant Engineers has been made by the impugned order dated June 21, 1979 even after the approval of the select list prepared for the appointment of eight Assistant Engineers without issuing orders for appointment even to eight out of those persons who are in the select list. In these circumstances we hold that the appointment of six diploma-holder Junior Engineers by the order dated April 10, 1978 (Annexure I) and of two such Junior Engineers by the order dated June 21, 1979 (Annexure M) as Junior Engineers on current duty charge for periods which are proved to be too long is irregular and we quash the same.

4. Prayer No. 3 in the writ petition was to direct Respondent 1 to fill up the remaining posts of Assistant Engineers in the direct recruitment quota from amongst the empanelled petitioners who were graduate Junior Engineers. As regards that prayer what we have ordered in the writ petition is this:[SCC para 46, pp. 593-94: SCC (L&S) pp. 459-60]

Respondent 1 is admittedly bound by the Recruitment Regulations made with the approval of the Central Government as required by Section 480(2) of the Act and it shall fill the remaining posts of Assistant Engineers (after filling up the eight posts of Assistant Engineers as aforesaid in regard to prayer No. 1) in the direct recruitment quota which are kept vacant in the seniority list dated September 2, 1978 (Annexure G in Writ Petition No. 1194 of 1979) and any further posts which might have become available thereafter or become available in view of our decisions in these two writ petitions or otherwise in accordance with those Recruitment Regulations within six months from today (July 13, 1983) or from the date on which further vacancy to the posts of Assistant Engineers in the direct recruitment quota arises, as the case may be, if permissible from out of the select list approved on May 2, 1979.

5. Prayer No. 5 in the writ petition was to restrain Respondent 1 from giving ad hoc promotions to current duty charge holders amongst Junior Engineers. As regards that prayer what we have ordered in the writ petition is this:[SCC para 55, p. 598: SCC (L&S) p. 464]

Respondent 1 shall not make current duty charge/ad hoc appointments and promotions except strictly and truly in accordance with the instructions and Regulations referred to above and other instructions, if any, issued in that regard.

6. In CMP No. 3069 of 1984 filed by the petitioners in the writ petition for taking proceedings for contempt of this Court's order dated July 13, 1983 made in the writ petition and for giving directions it is alleged that Respondent 1 has not complied with this Court's order to fill up the remaining posts of Assistant Engineers (remaining after filling up 8 posts of Assistant Engineers as mentioned above). It is stated that the total number of posts still available as on the date of CMP No. 3069 of 1984 is 32, that there were 26 direct recruitment quota posts as on the date of the writ petition as detailed therein, that 11 out of those 26 posts have been filled up already leaving 15 posts and that those 15 posts are to be filled up from amongst the remaining empanelled petitioners/Graduate Junior Engineers viz., Petitioners 1, 2, 4, 6 to 9, 11, 13, 16, 20 and 29 in accordance with this Court's order made in the writ petition. The petitioners' complaint is that it has not been done in spite of letters and telegram dated July 13, 1983, August 19, 1983, September 7, 1983, October 5, 1983 and October 7, 1983 sent by the petitioners and their counsel and Union and that on the other hand it appears from CMP No. 3068 of 1984 filed by Respondent 1 for directions that a Resolution No. 493 dated September 26, 1983 has been passed for filling up all the posts of Assistant Engineers by promotion and not by direct recruitment. It is also alleged in CMP No. 3069 of 1984 that Respondent 1 has not reverted the diploma holders/Junior Engineers mentioned in the office orders dated April 10, 1978 and June 21, 1979 in spite of the fact that those orders have been quashed by our order dated July 13, 1983 made in the writ petition. It is in these circumstances that the prayers in CMP No. 3069 of 1984 mentioned above have been made.

7. In CMP No. 3068 of 1984 it is alleged that 8 posts of Assistant Engineers have been filled up as per this Court's order and that as per the recommendations of the Appointment, Promotion, Disciplinary and Allied Matters Committee of the Corporation that the Recruitment Regulations for the posts of Assistant Engineers in the general wing be amended so as to provide for 100 per cent departmental promotion Resolution No. 493 dated September 26, 1983 has been passed by the Corporation and the Commissioner of the Corporation has thereby been prohibited from filling up any post of Assistant Engineer by direct recruitment even while the recruitment rules are to be approved by Union Public Service Commission and therefore it has become necessary for the Corporation to approach this Court for a direction that in view of the change in the circumstances the Corporation need not fill up the gaps in the seniority list of 1978-79 relating to Assistant Engineers by direct recruitment.

8. No counter-affidavit has been filed in CMP No. 3068 of 1984 evidently because the stand of the respondents in that petition is reflected by the allegations made in CMP No. 3069 of 1984. In the counter-affidavit of the Assistant Commissioner (Engineering) of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi filed in CMP No. 3069 of 1984 it is stated that the order of this Court to issue orders of appointments to 8 degree holder/Junior Engineers out of those in the select list approved on May 2, 1979 has been complied with and that the appointment for the remaining posts of Assistant Engineers in the direct recruitment quota could not be made in view of the said Resolution No. 493 of 1983 dated September 26, 1983 to fill up all the posts of Assistant Engineers only by promotion and not by direct recruitment. It is further stated in the counter-affidavit that this Court has ordered that the vacant posts of Assistant Engineers remaining after absorbing 8 graduate Junior Engineers from the select list approved on May 2, 1979 may be filled from that select list if it is permissible to make the appointments from out of that list. It is contended that the select panel was for a period of two years as per a circular issued by the Commissioner and therefore the panel should have got exhausted by May 1, 1981. As regards the non-reversion of ad hoc appointees/promotees mentioned in the orders dated April 10, 1978 and June 21, 1979 it is stated in the counter-affidavit that their reversion is dependent upon appointments to the posts of Assistant Engineers being made, which could not be done in view of the supervening circumstance viz., Resolution No. 493 dated September 26, 1983, and that it is wrong to say that the representations made in the letters etc. referred to in CMP No. 3069 of 1984 were not considered from the point of view of implementing the judgment of this Court, but they were considered before the Corporation approached this Court for directions in CMP No. 3068 of 1984.

9. Dr Y.S Chitale, appearing for the persons whose appointments/promotions were made by those orders dated April 10, 1978 and June 21, 1979 submitted that those persons would have to be reverted as per this Court's order dated July 13, 1983 in the writ petition and he invited our attention to the said Resolution No. 493 dated September 26, 1983 as being a bar to the Corporation making appointments as per this Court's order. Mr Ghosh appearing for Respondents 1 and 2 also relied upon the said Resolution and prayed for the direction asked for in CMP No. 3068 of 1984 being given. There is no substance in the explanation given by Respondent 1 for not reverting the Junior Engineers who were appointed/promoted by those orders dated April 10, 1978 and June 21, 1979 which have been quashed by our order dated July 13, 1983. There is no direction in our order that the quashing is subject to any condition, much less to appointments being made as per our order dated July 13, 1983 to the posts of Assistant Engineers. The reversion of those incumbents should have been made forthwith in compliance with our order dated July 13, 1983 quashing those office orders dated April 10, 1978 and June 21, 1979. We hereby direct Respondents 1 and 2 to comply with this Court's order quashing those two office orders by reverting the concerned officers within 10 days from this date. If this is not done within 10 days from the date of this order the petitioners in CMP No. 3069 of 1984 may draw this Court's attention and move afresh for action being taken against Respondents 1 and 2 for contempt of this Court's order.

10. Respondents 1 and 2 cannot be allowed to circumvent this Court's order dated July 13, 1983 made in the writ petition regarding the appointment of Assistant Engineers from the select panel of graduate Junior Engineers approved on May 2, 1979 by pleading the Resolution dated September 26, 1983 as a supervening circumstance or by contending that the select list approved on May 2, 1979 got exhausted or had expired on May 1, 1981. When Mr U.R Lalit made the offer on July 29, 1981 to make the 8 appointments of Assistant Engineers from that select list approved on May 2, 1979 it was evidently in force and the appointments to those 8 posts were made only from out of that list thereafter. Now it is not open to Respondent 1 to contend that the select list was valid only for 2 years and had expired on May 1, 1981. Resolution No. 493 dated September 26, 1983 has been passed in the face of our clear direction to fill up the remaining posts of Assistant Engineers in the direct recruitment quota as per the Recruitment Regulations made with the approval of the Central Government as required by Section 480(2) of the Act which were in force. That Resolution is said to have been submitted to the Union Public Service Commission for its approval. The validity of that Resolution and the question whether it could override the said Recruitment Regulations already in force was not canvassed by the learned counsel for Respondents 1 and 2 or the learned counsel appearing for the promotees covered by those orders dated April 10, 1978 and June 21, 1979. The Resolution which is of its own making cannot be pleaded by Respondent 1 as any inability or bar to comply with this Court's direction given in the writ petition on July 13, 1983. Respondents 1 and 2 shall make the appointments of Assistant Engineers for the remaining posts of Assistant Engineers in the direct recruitment quota as per our order dated July 13, 1983 and out of the select list approved on May 2, 1979 within one month from today failing which the petitioners in CMP No. 3069 of 1984 may draw this Court's attention to that fact and move a fresh petition for taking proceedings against Respondents 1 and 2 for contempt of this Court's order dated July 13, 1983. CMP No. 3069 of 1984 is allowed accordingly to that extent. CMP No. 3068 of 1984 is dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.