Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vishwa Nath v. State Of Jammu & Kashmir .

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 5, 1983
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a Head Constable acting as Naib-Courty at Ram Nagar, was entrusted on 7 February 1972 with government money amounting to Rs 619, seized in FIR Nos. 16 and 17. Instead of immediately depositing the funds as required, he used the money for personal purposes and made no Rahdari Register entry, thereby concealing the defalcation. On 8 August 1972, after the shortage was detected, he refunded the entire amount via ASI Dharam Dutt.

Criminal proceedings followed:

  • 15 December 1973 – Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Ram Nagar convicted him under Section 409 RPC, sentencing him to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 500.
  • 26 April 1974 – Sessions Judge, Udhampur dismissed his appeal and affirmed the conviction.
  • 28 November 1974 – High Court of Jammu & Kashmir dismissed his revision petition.
  • The present appeal was filed before the Supreme Court after special leave was granted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant’s subsequent refund of the embezzled amount extinguishes criminal liability under Section 409 RPC.
  2. Whether the concurrent findings of the courts below on misappropriation warrant interference by the Supreme Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments (through amicus curiae)

  • Did not harbour an intention permanently to misappropriate the money; circumstances prevented timely deposit.
  • Fully refunded the amount before trial and has already served the custodial sentence.
  • Setting aside the conviction would prevent loss of employment and consequent ruin.

State’s Arguments

  • Refund after detection does not negate the offence; misappropriation was complete once the money was used personally.
  • Had the defalcation remained undiscovered, the appellant would have retained the money.
  • Relied on Shri Krishan Kumar v. Union of India, AIR 1959 SC 1390, to assert that restitution does not erase criminal breach of trust.
  • Sought dismissal of the appeal with no interference in conviction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shri Krishan Kumar v. Union of India, AIR 1959 SC 1390; (1960) 1 SCR 452 Refund of misappropriated funds does not absolve liability under criminal breach of trust provisions. Referenced by the State; the Supreme Court noted it was unnecessary to rely on any precedent and based its decision solely on the facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court affirmed the factual findings of the lower forums, emphasizing that:

  • The appellant, a public servant, had dominion over government funds and was under a legal duty to deposit them immediately.
  • He intentionally violated statutory procedure by failing to record the funds in the Rahdari Register and personally using the money for over six months.
  • Such conduct constituted criminal breach of trust under Section 409 RPC; the offence was complete once misappropriation occurred, irrespective of later restitution.
  • The refund of the money after detection neither negated mens rea nor cured the substantive offence.
  • Given these circumstances, and finding no legal error in concurrent judgments, the Court saw no ground to interfere with the conviction or sentence.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED; CONVICTION AND SENTENCE AFFIRMED.

Direct Impact: The appellant remains convicted under Section 409 RPC, with the sentence of one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 500 standing confirmed. Broader Implications: The decision reiterates that restitution after discovery does not nullify criminal breach of trust by a public servant, but it does not establish new precedent beyond applying settled principles to the facts.

Show all summary ...

Amarendra Nath Sen, J.— The accused who happened to be a Head Constable was tried by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Ram Nagar on a charge under Section 409, RPC The Judicial Magistrate by his judgment dated December 15, 1973 Held that the charge against the accused had been established and he convicted the accused under Section 409 RPC and sentenced him to undergo RI for a period of one year and to pay a fine of Rs 500. Against the judgment and order of the Judicial Magistrate the accused filed an appeal in the Court of Sessions Judge, Udhampur. The Sessions Judge by his judgment and order dated April 26, 1974 upHeld the conviction and dismissed the appeal. The accused filed a revision application in the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and the High Court by its judgment and order dated November 28, 1974 dismissed the said petition. With special leave granted by this Court, the accused has filed this appeal.

2. The brief facts, which are not in dispute, are as follows: The accused, the appellant before us, was entrusted as incharge Courty Ram Nagar on February 7, 1972 with government money of Rs 619. As a public servant entrusted with government money, the accused was required to deposit the amount forthwith in accordance with law. The accused did not deposit the money and had used the same for personal purposes. When it was later found out that there had been defalcation of the amount by the accused, he deposited this money through one Dharam Dutt, ASI, on August 8, 1972. There was thus an embezzlement of the said amount entrusted to the accused by him.

3. The main defence taken by the accused at the trial was that as there had been a case of embezzlement in Udhampur he had been asked by one Anchal Singh not to send the money. Anchal Singh has been examined as a witness and had falsified the explanation given by the accused. The Judicial Magistrate and also the Sessions Judge have both carefully considered the facts and circumstances and have analysed the evidence on record. They have both come to the conclusion that there had been embezzlement of government money by the accused who had used the government money for his personal use. This finding has been accepted by the High Court.

4. Mr Mulla, who was good enough to appear as amicus curiae on behalf of the appellant in this appeal before us, could not seriously dispute the findings of the lower courts. He submitted before us that the accused had returned the money and the accused had also already served the term of imprisonment imposed on him. It is his submission that there had been no intention on the part of the accused to misappropriate any government money but under the force of circumstances the accused had not been in a position to deposit the money earlier. He submitted that taking into consideration the facts and circumstances under which the appellant had failed to deposit the money forthwith and the fact that he had in fact refunded the entire amount and also undergone the term of imprisonment, the conviction of the accused should be set aside, as otherwise the accused would lose his job and would be utterly ruined.

5. Mr Altaf Ahmed, appearing on behalf of the State has submitted that there is no ground for any interference with the conviction of the accused by this Court. He has severely commented on the conduct of the accused prior to the discovery of the defalcation of the amount by him. He has argued that if the discovery of the defalcation had not been made, the accused would have misappropriated the said amount. It is his argument that when the fact of embezzlement came to be found out, the accused offered to return the amount and in fact he did refund the entire amount. He submits that the fact of refund of the amount does not absolve the accused of the offence of embezzlement of the government money entrusted to him. In this connection he has referred to the decision of this Court in the case of Krishan Kumar v. Union of India AIR 1959 SC 1390, (1960) 1 SCR 452, 1959 Cri LJ 1508.

6. We do not consider it necessary to refer to any decision. The facts and circumstances of this case clearly establish that there was embezzlement of the government money by the accused, inasmuch as the accused had put to personal use the government money entrusted to him, instead of depositing the same in the proper place. The fact that the accused refunded the amount when the act of his defalcation came to be discovered, does not absolve him of the offence committed by him. The accused happened to be a public servant of the Police Department and was posted as Naib-Courty. He was entrusted with the amount seized in two cases FIR Nos. 16 and 17. In complete violation of the directions of law he had failed to send the amount to Sadar Courty, Udhampur and with criminal intention he had not made any entry of the money in Rahdari Register, while he made its entry in the Malkhana Register No. 1, so that his misappropriation of the amount might not be detected by anybody. He committed criminal breach of trust with respect to this money over which he had complete dominion by putting the same to his use between February 7, 1972 to August 8, 1972. The refund of the amount after detection does not absolve him of the offence.

7. The appeal fails and is hereby dismissed.