Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Susheela Misra (Mrs) v. Delhi Administration .

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 29, 1983
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Court issued notice upon receiving a letter addressed to the Chief Justice of India, which was treated as a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution. The letter was written by Mrs. Susheela Misra, wife of Mr. V.S. Misra, a retired Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Commerce. She alleged that police officers under the Delhi Administration were harassing her husband by visiting their residence at odd hours, compelling him to attend the police station under the pretext of questioning, detaining him for long periods, and subjecting him to harassment and torture.

In response, the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Mr. B.K. Gupta, filed an affidavit stating that an investigation into a suspected case of espionage involving a Western Mission in India was underway. He averred that Mr. Misra possessed vital information relevant to the investigation and that officers were empowered under Section 8 of the Official Secrets Act, 1923, to summon individuals for questioning to elicit information. The allegations of harassment were denied, and the actions were characterized as part of the lawful investigation.

The Court directed the petitioner to file a rejoinder and requested an affidavit from Mr. V.S. Misra. Mr. Misra adopted the rejoinder filed by his wife; however, his affidavit did not contain any specific assertion of harassment.

At the hearing, counsel for the respondents stated that future questioning of Mr. Misra, if necessary, would be conducted pursuant to a written request issued under the authority of a competent officer, specifying the time and place, for a reasonable period, and following the same procedure if further questioning were needed. The Court directed that such questioning must take place during daytime—never after sunset and before sunrise. The petitioner’s counsel sought a blanket prohibition on police visits to Mr. Misra’s residence, which the Court declined to grant, noting an expectation of reasonable and responsible conduct by police officers consistent with their duties. The writ petition was disposed of with liberty to approach the Court if any legitimate grievance arose.

Legal Issues Presented

The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Alleged harassment of Mr. V.S. Misra by police officers under the Delhi Administration, including late-night visits, compelled attendance at the police station, prolonged detention, and mistreatment.
  • Requested that police officers be directed not to visit Mr. Misra’s residence.

Respondent's Arguments

  • An espionage investigation involving a Western Mission in India was ongoing, and Mr. Misra was believed to have vital information pertinent to key aspects of the investigation.
  • Officers were empowered under Section 8 of the Official Secrets Act, 1923, to summon individuals for questioning to elicit information; allegations of harassment were denied.
  • Undertaking through counsel that any future questioning would be initiated by a written request under the authority of a competent officer, specifying time and place, conducted for a reasonable period, with the same procedure followed if further questioning became necessary.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • The Court took cognizance of the petition as a letter under Article 32, reflecting concern over alleged police harassment balanced against the needs of an ongoing espionage investigation.
  • On the evidentiary record before it, the Court noted that while the petitioner alleged harassment, Mr. V.S. Misra’s own affidavit—filed at the Court’s request—contained no specific assertion of harassment, weakening the basis for stronger or blanket prohibitory relief.
  • The respondents’ affidavit invoked Section 8 of the Official Secrets Act, 1923, as the statutory authority for summoning individuals for questioning. The Court did not dispute this statutory power and instead fashioned procedural safeguards to ensure fairness.
  • Relying on the assurance provided by the respondents’ counsel, the Court directed a structured protocol for any questioning of Mr. Misra: it must proceed upon written request issued by a competent authority, specify the time and place, occur for a reasonable duration, and follow the same process if further sessions are required.
  • To protect against undue intrusion and inconvenience, the Court imposed a temporal safeguard: all questioning must occur during daytime and never after sunset and before sunrise.
  • The Court declined to issue a blanket prohibition against police visits to Mr. Misra’s residence, reasoning that such an absolute restriction could unduly constrain lawful police functions and expressing confidence that officers would act reasonably and responsibly in discharging their duties.
  • Finally, the Court provided the petitioner liberty to approach the Court again if any legitimate grievance arose notwithstanding these directions, indicating ongoing judicial oversight while disposing of the present petition.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

Implications:

  • Any questioning of Mr. V.S. Misra related to the investigation must be initiated by a written request issued under the authority of a competent officer, specifying the time and place.
  • Questioning must be conducted for a reasonable period and, if further questioning is necessary, the same written-request procedure must be followed.
  • All questioning must occur during daytime; no questioning is permitted after sunset and before sunrise.
  • No blanket prohibition was imposed on police visits to the petitioner’s residence; however, police are expected to act reasonably and responsibly.
  • The petitioner is at liberty to approach the Court if any legitimate grievance arises in implementing these directions. The order sets procedural safeguards for this case but establishes no broader precedent through cited case law.
Show all summary ...

1. We issued notice in this matter pursuant to a letter received by the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India treating it as a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution. The letter was written by Mrs Susheela Misra wife of one Mr V.S Misra, who retired as Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Commerce. The grievance broadly stated was that the police officers working under the Delhi Administration were unnecessarily harassing Mr Misra by visiting her house at odd hours, by compelling Mr V.S Misra to go to police station under the pretext of questioning him and detained there for long hours and harassed and tortured. In response to the notice, an affidavit was filed by Mr B.K Gupta, Deputy Commissioner of Police, stating therein that an enquiry was going on with regard to a suspected case of espionage in which a Western Mission located in India was involved and that Mr V.S Misra was in possession of some vital information and was in a position to shed light on some of the important aspects of this investigation. It was further stated that for these reasons it had become necessary to call him for questioning and that the officers were empowered under Section 8 of the Official Secrets Act, 1923 to summon anyone for questioning to elicit information. The allegation of harassment was denied and it was stated that in the exercise of power conferred by Section 8 of the Official Secrets Act, 1923 investigation was carried on. After the counter-affidavit was filed, we directed the petitioner, the wife of Mr V.S Misra, whose letter has been treated as writ petition, to file a rejoinder and we also requested Mr V.J Francis, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, to file an affidavit of Mr V.S Misra himself. Mr V.S Misra merely adopted the rejoinder affidavit filed by his wife the petitioner, but there is not a whisper of harassment which he is alleged to have suffered.

2. When the petition was taken up today, Mr K.G Bhagat, learned counsel for the respondent, stated that hereafter whenever it becomes necessary to question and elicit information from Mr V.S Misra in connection with investigation under progress a written request would be sent to him under the authority of an officer competent to do so specifying therein time and place when Mr V.S Misra must attend and he would be questioned for a reasonable period and if further questioning is necessary the same procedure would be followed. We direct that this questioning must be during the day time and in no case after sunset and before sunrise.

3. Some grievance was made by Mr V.J Francis, learned counsel for the petitioner, that the police officer should not visit the house of Mr V.S Misra. Such a blanket direction cannot be given and it is assumed that police officers would be behaving in a reasonable and responsible manner consistent with the duties which they are bound to discharge.

4. The directions herein given should satisfy the petitioner but if any legitimate grievance in this connection surfaces the petitioner is at liberty to move the Court. With this observation, the writ petition is disposed of.