- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Annapurna Biscuit Manufacturing Co., Kanpur v. Commissioner Of Sales Tax, U.P, Lucknow .
Supreme Court of India: E.S. Venkataramiah, J. (Civil Appeal on Special Leave)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, a registered firm engaged in manufacturing and selling biscuits in Uttar Pradesh, was assessed to sales tax for the year 1972-73. Relying on a State Government notification dated 6 October 1971, which fixed a concessional two-per-cent tax on “cooked food,” the appellant claimed the same rate for its biscuit turnover of Rs 35,09,920.38. The Assistant Commissioner (Tax Assessment) rejected the claim, treating biscuits as an unclassified commodity taxable at 3.5 per cent. Successive appeals before the Deputy Commissioner (Appeals) and the Judge (Appeals), Sales Tax, Lucknow failed, as did a revision before the Allahabad High Court. The present appeal was brought to the Supreme Court by special leave under Article 136 of the Constitution.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the term “cooked food” used in the notifications issued under Section 3-A(2) of the U.P. Sales Tax Act, 1948, encompasses “biscuits,” thereby entitling the appellant to the lower tax rate of two per cent.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- Biscuit is a form of food intended for human consumption and is prepared by baking, which is a recognised method of cooking; it should therefore be classified as “cooked food.”
- Dictionary definitions were cited to show that “cooking” includes preparation by boiling, baking, roasting, or broiling, bringing biscuits within the ambit of the term.
- The corresponding Hindi version of the notification uses the phrase “pakaya hua bhojan,” which, according to the appellant, is broad enough to include biscuits.
No specific arguments from the respondent are recorded in the opinion.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Hinde v. Allmond (1917) | Words denoting articles of food must be given their ordinary, commonsense meaning in the relevant statutory context. | Invoked to emphasise that “cooked food” should be understood as it is in everyday usage in Uttar Pradesh, not in an abstract or dictionary sense. |
| Annapurna Biscuit Manufacturing Co. v. State of U.P. (1975) 35 STC 127 (All.) |
Biscuit is not “confectionery.” | Referenced to illustrate earlier judicial reluctance to widen the ordinary meaning of food-related expressions to include biscuits. |
| CST v. Jassu Ram Bakery Dealer (1976) 38 STC 461 (All.) |
Held that biscuits are not “cooked food.” | Expressly approved and followed. |
| CST, M.P. v. Ballabhdas Iswardas (1968) 21 STC 309 (M.P.) |
Similar finding that biscuits are not “cooked food.” | Expressly approved and followed. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court reiterated the settled principle that, in taxing statutes, words must be interpreted as they are commonly understood in the locality where the law operates. While acknowledging that “cooking” in a technical sense could include baking, the Court stressed that the decisive question was how the public in Uttar Pradesh would understand the term “cooked food” or its Hindi counterpart “pakaya hua bhojan.” In ordinary parlance, a hotel or restaurant customer asking for cooked food would not expect biscuits. The Court also found persuasive the contemporaneous Hindi notification, which conveyed a sense of a meal rather than a snack or bakery product. Previous decisions from the Allahabad and Madhya Pradesh High Courts, which had declined to treat biscuits as cooked food, were expressly approved. Accordingly, the appellant’s reliance on dictionary meanings was rejected in favour of a commonsense, contextual interpretation.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED. The assessment of biscuits at 3.5 per cent as an unclassified commodity stands affirmed; no order as to costs.
The ruling confirms that “cooked food” under the relevant U.P. sales-tax notifications does not extend to biscuits. While the decision turns on contextual statutory interpretation rather than creating new doctrine, it solidifies existing judicial consensus and provides clarity for tax assessments involving bakery products in Uttar Pradesh.
E.S Venkataramiah, J.— The short point for consideration in this appeal is whether the expression “cooked food” used in certain notifications issued under the U.P Sales Tax Act, 1948 (U.P Act 15 of 1948)(hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) can be construed as including within its meaning “biscuits” also.
2. The assessee, the appellant herein, is a registered firm engaged in the business of manufacture and sale of biscuits intended for human consumption. The assessee is a registered dealer under the Act. During the assessment proceedings under the Act for the year 1972-73 the assessee claimed that the turnover relating to biscuits manufactured and sold by it amounting to Rs 35,09,920.38 was liable to be taxed at two per cent which was the rate prescribed by a notification issued by the State Government for cooked food contending that “cooked food” included “biscuits” also. The notification relied on was one issued on October 6, 1971 under sub-section (2) of Section 3-A of the Act in supersession of an earlier notification dated July 1, 1969. In both the notifications the tax was fixed at two per cent of the turnover payable at all points of sale in the case of cooked food. The Assistant Commissioner (Tax Assessment), Sales Tax, Kanpur who was the assessing authority rejected the contention of the assessee that cooked food included biscuits also and imposed tax at the rate of three and a half per cent on the turnover relating to biscuits treating the same as an unclassified commodity. An appeal filed against the order of the assessing authority before the Deputy Commissioner, Sales Tax and a further appeal before the Judge (Appeal), Sales Tax, Lucknow were unsuccessful. The High Court of Allahabad also declined to interfere with the said order. This appeal by special leave is filed against the order of the High Court under Article 136 of the Constitution.
3. The only ground urged before us is that biscuits should have been treated by the authorities under the Act and by the High Court as cooked food and sales tax should have been levied on the turnover of biscuits at the rate prescribed in respect of cooked food under the notification referred to above. The argument urged on behalf of the appellant is that biscuit which was consumed by human beings for nourishment is food and since it is prepared by baking which is a kind of cooking process it should be treated as cooked food. Relying on some foreign English dictionaries it is contended that cooking means preparation of food by application of heat as by boiling, baking, roasting, broiling etc. and biscuit should therefore be treated as cooked food. What is of significance in this case is that the Hindi version of the notification issued uses the expression (pakaya hua bhojan) for ‘cooked food’ found in the notification in English language.
4. It is a well-settled rule of construction that the words used in a law imposing a tax should be construed in the same way in which they are understood in ordinary parlance in the area in which the law is in force. If an expression is capable of a wider meaning as well as narrower meaning the question whether the wider or the narrower meaning should be given depends on the context and the background of the case. In Hinde v. Allmond the question was whether tea was an “article of food” within the meaning of an Order designed to prohibit the hoarding of food namely Food Hoarding Order of 1917. The learned judges held it was not even though in some other decisions it had been held to be an “article of food”. Shearman, J. one of the judges said that he rested his judgment on the “common sense interpretation of the word ‘food’ in the Order, apart from its meaning in any other statute”. It is interesting to note that in a case before the Allahabad High Court in Annapurna Biscuit Manufacturing Co. v. State of U.P (1975) 35 STC 127 (All) the assessee had contended that biscuit was an article of confectionery and that contention was negatived. It is relevant to note, as we have mentioned earlier, that when the Hindi text of the notification was issued contemporaneously with the English version, the words (pakaya hua bhojan) were used as the equivalent of the words ‘cooked food’.
5. It may be that biscuit is served at tea time and in its wider meaning “cooked food” may include biscuit. But ordinarily biscuit is not understood as cooked food. If a person goes to a hotel or restaurant and asks for some cooked food or (pakaya hua bhojan) certainly he will not be served with biscuits in Uttar Pradesh. While it is not necessary to state in the present case as to what all items may be called as cooked food, we can definitely say that in the context and background of the notification biscuit cannot be treated as cooked food.
6. The High Court of Allahabad has in an earlier case in CST v. Jassu Ram Bakery Dealer (1976) 38 STC 461 (All) held that biscuit was not cooked food. The High Court of Madhya Pradesh has also taken the same view in CST, M.P v. Ballabhdas Iswardas (1968) 21 STC 309 (MP). We approve of the views expressed in the aforesaid decisions.
7. There is no ground to interfere with the orders under appeal. In the result, this appeal fails and is dismissed. No costs.
Alert