- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
V.M Tarkunde v. Union Of India And Others
Supreme Court of India – Interlocutory Order (Vacation Bench)
Factual and Procedural Background
These interlocutory proceedings arise from a transferred writ petition in which the petitioner challenges the Union of India’s decision not to extend the terms of two Additional Judges of the Delhi High Court—Justice Vohra and Justice Kumar. In an earlier order dated 8 May 1981, the Supreme Court directed the Union Government to decide whether any of the three concerned Additional Judges should be re-appointed as Additional Judges, appointed as permanent Judges, or “otherwise” dealt with. The Government has since communicated its decision to extend Justice Wad’s tenure but not to continue Justices Vohra and Kumar. During the Court’s summer recess, a Vacation Judge was requested to consider interim relief pending the final hearing scheduled for 20 July 1981.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Union Government’s refusal to extend the tenure of Justices Vohra and Kumar is prima facie mala fide and unconstitutional.
- Whether a Vacation Judge, despite the constraints of Order 7 Rule 4 and Order 6 Rule 2 of the Supreme Court Rules, may invoke the Court’s inherent power under Order 47 Rule 6 to grant interlocutory relief maintaining the status quo.
- Whether Article 224(1) of the Constitution gives Additional Judges a right to continue beyond their specified term when High Court arrears remain high—an issue reserved for detailed examination at the final hearing.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The workload in the Delhi High Court has increased, and arrears continue to mount.
- The Chief Justice of India and the Chief Justice of the Delhi High Court recommended a two-year extension for all three Additional Judges, implying no concerns as to their competence or conduct.
- The junior-most judge (Justice Wad) was granted a one-year extension, while the two senior judges were not—suggesting the decision was based on extraneous considerations.
- These uncontroverted facts establish a prima facie case that the Government’s decision is mala fide and unconstitutional, warranting interim maintenance of the status quo.
Respondents' Arguments
- It was contended that a Vacation Judge’s powers are circumscribed by Order 7 Rule 4 read with Order 6 Rule 2 of the Supreme Court Rules, limiting the relief that can be granted during recess.
- No material justifying the Government’s decision was supplied, and the Union Government declined the Court’s suggestion to reconsider its stance.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Vacation Judge held that, notwithstanding the rules governing vacation matters, the Court retains inherent jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 6 to issue interim orders necessary for the ends of justice. Because the petition seeks only interlocutory relief and does not finally determine rights, the Judge found it within his competence to consider maintaining or varying the status quo.
On the merits, four undisputed facts were considered crucial: (a) rising arrears in the Delhi High Court, (b) recommendations by the Chief Justice of India and the Chief Justice of the High Court favouring a two-year extension for all three judges, (c) the decision to extend the junior-most judge while discontinuing the two seniors, and (d) the absence of adverse material against Justices Vohra and Kumar. These facts collectively support a prima facie inference that the Government’s decision may be influenced by extraneous considerations, rendering it susceptible to constitutional challenge under Article 224(1).
The Court acknowledged that whether Article 224(1) confers a right of continued tenure is a “ticklish and debatable” constitutional question requiring full argument at the final hearing. Consequently, the Vacation Judge opted to keep all issues open and avoided pronouncing on the merits at this interlocutory stage.
Holding and Implications
ORDER: Notice was issued to the respondents “to show cause why the status quo in respect of the two Judges should not be maintained and continued during the pendency of the main petition,” which is set for hearing on 20 July 1981 when the Court reopens.
Implications: The order preserves the controversy for plenary consideration and signals heightened judicial scrutiny of the Executive’s exercise of appointment powers under Article 224(1). No final rights have been adjudicated; the interlocutory measure merely requires the Union Government to justify its decision at the forthcoming hearing.
1. In these interlocutory proceedings the question is what order this Court should pass regarding the prayer for maintenance of status quo in respect of the two learned Judges of the Delhi High Court (Justice Vohra and Justice Kumar) whose term the Union of India has decided not to extend pending final disposal by this Court of serious and vital issues raised by the petitioner in his transferred writ petition.
2. It is true that this Court by its Order dated May 8, 1981 directed the Union of India to take a decision whether any of the concerned three Additional Judges should be reappointed for a further term as Additional Judges or they should be appointed as permanent Judges or otherwise and the expression “or otherwise” in the order undoubtedly means that a decision not to extend their term and drop any of them could be taken by the Union of India. This Court has now been informed that the decision to extend the term of Justice Wad has been taken and communicated to the Chief Justice of the Delhi High Court and that a decision not to extend the terms of the other two Judges has been taken and hence there is no occasion to communicate that decision to anyone.
3. It was felt that when this Court was seized of a serious matter raising vital questions of interpretation of the relevant Articles of the Constitution having a bearing on the independence of Judiciary, the Union of India could have been discreet not to have pre-empted the issues as it were by its aforesaid decision before this Court decided the issue finally. I, therefore, made a suggestion to counsel for the respondents to ask the Government to reconsider its decision and allow the learned Judges to continue as Additional Judges till the final decision on the merits of the issues raised in the writ petition was reached by this Court. But it is unfortunate that the Union Government has not seen its way to accept or to respond to the Court's suggestion. Judicial decorum prevents me from making further comments.
4. A question regarding the powers of the Vacation Judge to give relief in these proceedings was raised and it was urged that the Vacation Judge's powers are circumscribed by the Rules of this Court, particularly, Order 7 Rule 4 read with Order 6 Rule 2. However, at the same time this Court's inherent power under Order 47 Rule 6 to make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of justice has been preferred and would be available to a Vacation Judge sitting in the vacation as the Court. After all, it must be remembered that I am not disposing of any matter finally but dealing with grant of interim reliefs at interlocutory stages and, in my view, maintenance of status quo or any variation thereof at interlocutory stages as and when situation or occasion arises would be within the competence of the Vacation Judge and the only question is what would be the proper order that I should make at this stage after the Government's decision not to extend the term of the two learned Judges has been communicated to this Court.
5. It is well settled that exercise as well as non-exercise of a constitutional power for extraneous or non-germane considerations is mala fide and unconstitutional and this principle will apply to power contained in Article 224(1) of the Constitution. In view of the following uncontroverted facts which have come on record, namely,
(a) the work in the Delhi High Court has not decreased but on the other hand the arrears in that High Court have been mounting (a fact not disputed by the respondents);
(b) the Chief Justice of India and the Chief Justice of Delhi High Court had recommended the extension for these Judges for two years (an averment not controverted by the respondents) suggesting that there is nothing against their continuance as regards behaviour capacity or competence;
(c) the juniormost amongst the three concerned Judges has been given extension by one year;
it would appear clear that the petitioner could be said to have made out a prima facie case that the decision not to extend their terms is based on extraneous and non-germane considerations and, therefore, mala fide and unconstitutional. In the absence of any material being furnished by the Union of India to the Court indicating how and why such decision was taken the inference that the decision was prima facie male fide and unconstitutional receives strength. The question is what would be the proper interlocutory relief that could be granted in such situation.
6. The question whether the period specified in Article 224(1) for which Additional Judge could be appointed gives fixity of tenure to the incumbent or whether the period merely furnishes a guarantee to the incumbent that he shall continue until the expiry of that period even if the volume of work in the High Court falls considerably and, therefore, on proper construction of Article 224 there is a right in the Additional Judges to continue even after the period has expired when the mounting arrears still obtain is a ticklish and debatable question and requires further investigation and deeper consideration at the stage of final hearing by the Court. That being the position and since I wish to keep the issues alive I would pass the following order:
“Notice to show cause why the status quo in respect of two Judges should not be maintained and continued during the pendency of the main petition, which will be heard on July 20, 1981 when the Court reopens after summer vacation.”
Alert