- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chhaganlal Mansukhlal And Another v. K.K Bhatt And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal centered on Rule 49 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Rules, 1965, whose vires and reasonableness were identified as the principal grounds of challenge. The court set out the text of Rule 49 and, for interpretive context, Rule 48. During the hearing, counsel for both sides agreed that Rule 49 (which contemplates fee payment upon entry of agricultural produce into specified market areas) does not apply where the produce falls within sub-rule (2) of Rule 48. The court accepted this interpretation, concluding that Rule 49 has no application to cases covered by Rule 48(2). Mr. Sorabjee did not press any other grounds. The appeal was accepted to the extent of the interpretive ruling and otherwise dismissed, with no order as to costs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Rule 49 requires fees to be paid at the stage of entry of agricultural produce into the market area when the produce is covered by sub-rule (2) of Rule 48.
- Challenges to the vires and reasonableness of Rule 49 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Rules, 1965.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court’s analysis focused on the textual interpretation of Rules 48 and 49. It noted the consensus between counsel that Rule 49—requiring fees to be paid as soon as agricultural produce is brought into the market area—does not govern situations covered by Rule 48(2). Rule 48(2) exempts specified transactions, namely:
- Produce brought from outside the market area into the market area for use therein by industrial concerns situated in the market area or for export, where a declaration is made and a certificate obtained in Form V (subject to the proviso to Rule 48(2)).
- Sales or purchases to which sub-section (3) of Section 6 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act applies.
Accepting the joint interpretation, the court held that this conclusion “flows directly from the language” of the rules. Accordingly, it determined that Rule 49 has no application to any case falling within the ambit of Rule 48(2). Beyond this interpretive holding, no further analysis was undertaken because no other points were pressed.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: Rule 49 does not apply to cases covered by Rule 48(2); therefore, fees under Rule 49 are not payable at the entry stage for such transactions. The appeal is ACCEPTED TO THE EXTENT OF THIS INTERPRETATION and is otherwise DISMISSED, with no order as to costs.
Implications: The immediate effect is that agricultural produce qualifying under Rule 48(2) is not subject to Rule 49’s entry-stage fee requirement. The opinion does not discuss broader implications or establish additional principles beyond this interpretive clarification.
A.D Koshal, J.— Rule 49 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Rules, 1965, the vires and the reasonableness of which have been the main points of challenge in this appeal, runs thus:
“49. (1) The fees on agricultural produce shall be payable as soon as it is brought into the principal market yard or sub-market yard or market proper or market area as may be specified in the bye-laws:
Provided that the fees so paid shall be refunded—
(i) on production of sufficient proof that such produce was not sold within the limits of the market area; or
(ii) if such produce is brought from outside the market area into the market area for use therein by the industrial concerns situated in the market area or for export and in respect of which a declaration has been made and a certificate has been obtained in Form V. subject to the proviso to sub-rule (2) of Rule 48.
(2) The licence fees payable under Rule 56 or 57 shall be paid along with the application for licence but in case the market committee refuses the grant or renewal of a licence the fees recovered shall be refunded to the applicant.”
2. In order to interpret this rule it is also necessary to set out the provisions of Rule 48. They are:
“48. (1) The market committee shall levy and collect fees on agricultural produce bought or sold in the market area at such rate as may be specified in the bye-laws subject to the following minima and maxima viz.
(i) rates when levied ad valorem shall not be less than 10 paise and shall not exceed 40 paise per hundred rupees;
(ii) rates when levied in respect of cattle, sheep or goat shall not be less than 10 paise per animal and shall not exceed Rs 2 per animal.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this rule a sale of agricultural produce shall be deemed to have taken place in a market area if it has been weighed or measured or surveyed or delivered in case of cattle in the market area for the purpose of sale, notwithstanding the fact that the property in the agricultural produce has by reason of such sale passed to a person in a place outside the market area.
(2) No fees shall be levied on agricultural produce brought from outside the market area into the market area for use therein by the industrial concerns situated in the market area or for export and in respect of which declaration has been made and a certificate has been obtained in Form V:
Provided that if such agricultural produce brought into the market area for export is not exported or removed therefrom before the expiry of twenty days from the date on which it was so brought, the market committee shall levy and collect fees or such agricultural produce from the person bringing the produce into the market area at such rates as may be specified in the bye-laws subject to the maxima and minima specified in sub-rule (i):
Provided that no fee shall be payable on a sale or purchase to which sub-section (3) of Section 6 applies.”
3. Learned counsel for the parties are agreed that the provisions of Rule 49 are not attracted and no fees are payable under it at the stage of entry into a market area if the agricultural produce in question is covered by sub-rule (2) of Rule 48 i.e when such produce fulfills either of the following conditions:
(1) It is brought from outside the market area thereinto for use therein by the industrial concerns situated therein or for export and in respect thereof a declaration has been made and a certificate has been obtained in Form V.
(2) The sale or purchase of such produce comes within the purview of sub-section (3) of Section 6 of the Gujarat Agricultural Produce Markets Act.
4. After hearing learned counsel for the parties, we accept this interpretation of Rules 48 and 49 which flows directly from the language employed therein, and hold that Rule 49 will have no application to any case which falls within the ambit of sub-rule (2) of Rule 48.
5. Mr Sorabjee does nor press any other point in support of the appeal which is accepted to the extent of the above interpretation of Rules 48 and 49 but is otherwise dismissed with no order as to costs.
Alert