Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bhupendra Singh v. State Of U.P And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Dec 15, 1980
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant received a notice from the prescribed authority under Section 10(2) of the U.P. Imposition of Ceiling on Land Holdings Act, 1960 (as amended) proposing to declare 25.93 acres of his land as surplus. In response, he objected that (i) all of his land was unirrigated, not irrigated as alleged, and (ii) he had already transferred 40 acres (20 acres each to Pushpek Singh and Raghubir Singh Sondhi) by registered sale deeds dated July 23 and August 9, 1971 for adequate consideration, in good faith, and after delivering possession. These transfers, he asserted, were made to raise funds for the construction of a residential house in Delhi while he was serving in the Army.

The prescribed authority rejected the objections, ignored the transfers, and declared 25.93 acres surplus. On appeal, the Appellate Authority (District Judge, Rampur) held on December 8, 1977 that the entire holding was unirrigated but nonetheless disregarded the two sales, reasoning that no “compelling necessity” for those transfers had been proved. A writ petition to the Allahabad High Court (Civil Misc. Writ Petition 4499 of 1977) was dismissed on May 23, 1978. The present appeal to the Supreme Court was brought by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the two registered sale deeds executed in 1971 could be excluded from the appellant’s holding under proviso (b) to Section 5(6) of the Ceiling Act when no “compelling” or “impelling” necessity for the transfers was shown.
  2. Whether, for the purpose of calculating the ceiling area, the appellant’s entire land should be treated as unirrigated.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The transfers were genuine, for adequate consideration, and effected after obtaining permission from Army authorities.
  • The sole purpose of the sales was to raise funds to construct a residential house in Delhi, constituting ordinary management of personal affairs and therefore protected under Section 5(6) proviso (b).
  • Because he had absolutely divested himself of title and possession, the burden of proving “good faith” stood discharged; no further proof of compelling necessity was required.

Respondent's Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Brijendra Singh v. State of U.P., (1981) 1 SCC 597 Once a tenure-holder proves that a transfer was genuine, for adequate consideration, and not collusive, the onus to establish “good faith” is discharged; no further proof of impelling necessity is required under Explanation II to proviso (b) of Section 5(6). The Court held that the factual matrix in the present appeal was “almost identical” and therefore the rule in Brijendra Singh squarely applied, compelling recognition of the two 1971 sale deeds.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first observed that the Appellate Authority had already determined, and the High Court had affirmed, that the appellant’s land was unirrigated; this finding had become res judicata.

Turning to the disputed transfers, the Court noted that the Appellate Authority expressly found the sales to be genuine, for adequate consideration, and not benami. The sole basis for disregarding them was the absence of “compelling necessity.”

Invoking its recent judgment in Brijendra Singh, the Court reiterated that:

  • A tenure-holder who has genuinely, absolutely, and irrevocably divested himself of the land for adequate consideration and in the ordinary course of managing his affairs satisfies the statutory requirement of “good faith.”
  • The statute does not impose an additional burden of proving an impelling or compelling necessity unless there are indicia of collusion or intent to evade the Ceiling Act.

Because the present transfers met all criteria identified in Brijendra Singh—genuineness, adequate consideration, lack of collusion, and absolute divestment—the Court concluded that the prescribed and appellate authorities erred in ignoring them.

Holding and Implications

The appeal was ALLOWED. The orders of the High Court, the Appellate Authority, and the prescribed authority were set aside. The matter was remitted to the prescribed authority with directions:

  • Re-determine the appellant’s ceiling and surplus area after giving full effect to the two 1971 transfers.
  • Treat the entire holding as unirrigated, that issue having attained finality.

Implications: The decision enforces the precedent that genuine, arm’s-length transfers made before the “crucial date” cannot be ignored merely for lack of “compelling necessity.” It provides clarity on the evidentiary burden under Section 5(6) proviso (b) of the U.P. Ceiling Act but does not create a new doctrine beyond affirming the rule in Brijendra Singh. No order as to costs was made.

Show all summary ...

R.S Sarkaria, J.— Special leave to appeal granted.

2. This is an appeal by special leave against a judgment, dated May 23, 1978, of the High Court of Allahabad, whereby Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petition 4499 of 1977 arising out of Revenue Appeal 253 of 1977 was dismissed.

3. The prescribed authority under Section 10(2) of the U.P Imposition of Ceiling on Land Holdings Act, 1960 (U.P Act 1 of 1961) (as amended by U.P Act 18 of 1973) issued notice to the appellant to show cause why 25.93 acres of land be not declared as surplus with him. In response to this notice, the appellant filed objections stating, inter alia, (i) that the entire land was unirrigated and it had been wrongly shown in the notice as irrigated land; (ii) that he had sold 40 acres of his land (20 acres to Pushpek Singh and 20 acres to Raghubir Singh Sondhi) on July 23, 1971 and August 9, 1971 by registered sale deeds, for adequate consideration and in good faith; and (iii) that the sales were effected to raise funds for constructing a residential house in Delhi. He further stated that he had delivered possession to the vendees. The prescribed authority rejected the objections of the appellant and ignored these sales and declared 25.93 acres of land as surplus with the appellant.

4. Against that order of the prescribed authority, the appellant carried an appeal to the Appellate Authority (District Judge, Rampur), who, by his order dated December 8, 1977, partly allowed the appeal and held that the whole of the land held by the appellant was unirrigated land. With regard to the aforesaid two sales made by the appellant, the Appellate Authority held that the sales were genuine, but the same could not be upheld because “no compelling necessity had been brought on record to show that the sales were not made to avoid any ceiling law”.

5. The appellant's contention was that since he was in the Army Service, he had made these sales after obtaining permission from the Army Authorities in order to raise funds for building a residential house for himself in Delhi. The Appellate Authority did not hold that the sales were not for adequate consideration or were fictitious or benami. On the contrary, he found them to be genuine, but ignored the same simply because in his opinion, raising funds for building a residential house in Delhi, was not a valid compelling necessity for the sales.

6. We have by our judgment in Brijendra Singh v. State of U.P (1981) 1 SCC 597 allowed the appeal of Brijendra Singh, in which the facts found by the Appellate Authority were almost identical. The sales in that case were also made to raise funds to meet the expenses of constructing a residential house in Delhi. In that case, also, the sales were found to be genuine and for adequate consideration, but were ignored merely on the ground that no impelling necessity for the sales had been established and that the purpose of raising funds for building a residential house at Delhi was not such a necessity. We have held in that case that:

“Once it is established by the transferring tenure holder that the transfer in question was effected in the course of ordinary management of his affairs, was made for adequate consideration and he has genuinely, absolutely and irrevocably divested himself of all right, title and interest (including cultivatory possession) in the land in favour of the transferee, the onus under Explanation II [to proviso (b) of Section 5(6)], in the absence of any circumstances suggestive of collusion, or an intention or design to defraud or circumvent the Ceiling Act, on the tenure holder to show that the transfer was effected in ‘good faith’, will stand discharged, and it will not be necessary for the tenure holder to prove further that the transfer was made for an impelling need or to raise money for meeting a pressing legal necessity.”
This rule laid down in Brijendra Singh case (1981) 1 SCC 597 squarely applies to the sales in question in the instant case. The sales were held to be genuine and for adequate consideration in favour of persons who were not alleged to be related to the appellant in any way. They were not benami sales; the tenure holder did not reserve any immediate or deferred benefit for himself or the other members of his family under these sales which were made under an irrevocable registered instrument. They were made in the course of ordinary management of his affairs by the transferor viz. to raise funds for building a house at Delhi. All the facts and conditions necessary to claim the protection of Section 5(6) proviso (b) were satisfied in this case.

7. We, therefore, allow this appeal, set aside the orders of the High Court and the Appellate Authority and the prescribed authority and send the case back to the prescribed authority with the direction that it shall not ignore these two transfers, and after taking these transfers into account determine afresh the ceiling area of the appellant. We make it clear that the prescribed authority shall determine the ceiling area and surplus area of the appellant on the basis that the whole of the land held by the tenure-holder (appellant) on the crucial date was unirrigated land, as the decision of the Appellate Authority (which was upheld by the High Court) on that issue has become res judicata.

8. In the circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs of this appeal.