- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Tara Chand v. State Of Rajasthan And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
Shri Shishupal (“the detenu”) was preventively detained under Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA) by an order passed by Shri L. N. Gupta, Commissioner & Administration, Secretary, Home Department, Rajasthan. He was arrested on 2 November 1979 and the grounds of detention were served on 3 November 1979.
On 3 November 1979, the detenu’s brother, Tara Chand, sought revocation of the detention order. This request was rejected on 19 November 1979. The Advisory Board heard the detenu on 30 November 1979, issued a report justifying the detention on 3 December 1979, and the State Government confirmed the detention on 15 December 1979.
On 23 February 1980 the detenu sent two representations: one to the Central Government under Section 11 of COFEPOSA and another to the detaining authority. According to the petition, neither representation had been decided upon when the writ petition was filed. The representation destined for the detaining authority reached it only on 27 March 1980—after a delay of one month and five days.
The present writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution sought a writ of habeas corpus challenging the legality of the continued detention.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the constitutional safeguards under Article 22(5) were violated by failing to inform the detenu of his right to make a representation and the proper addressee of such a representation.
- Whether the unexplained delay of one month and five days in forwarding and considering the detenu’s representation infringed the requirement of “speedy” consideration mandated by Article 22(5).
- Whether the detaining authority could lawfully refuse to consider the detenu’s representation on the ground that he had already been heard by the Advisory Board.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The detenu was never informed of his right to make a representation or the authority to whom it should be addressed, contrary to Article 22(5).
- There was “extreme callousness” and an inordinate delay by the detaining authority in dealing with the representation dated 23 February 1980.
- The refusal to forward the representation to the Advisory Board, merely because the detenu had previously appeared before it, violated constitutional guarantees.
Respondents’ Arguments
- The State received the detenu’s application to the Central Government on 6 March 1980, sought comments from the Collector of Customs on 7 March 1980, received them on 13 March 1980, and forwarded its own comments to the Central Government on 14 March 1980. The State disclaimed knowledge of subsequent Central Government action.
- The application addressed to the detaining authority was portrayed as a request for documents and reconsideration by the Advisory Board, not a substantive representation against the detention.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court emphasized that Article 22(5) imposes two distinct obligations: (1) the detaining authority must afford the detenu the earliest opportunity to make a representation and (2) the authority must consider that representation with reasonable promptitude, separate from any obligation to place materials before the Advisory Board. The representation dated 23 February 1980 reached the detaining authority only on 27 March 1980, evidencing “gross negligence and extreme callousness.” Even after receipt, the authority merely sought comments from the Collector of Customs and provided no decision or communication to the detenu. The Court found this unexplained delay and non-consideration to be a clear breach of the constitutional mandate for speedy consideration of representations in preventive-detention cases.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition was allowed and the detenu was ordered to be released forthwith (Order dated 15 April 1980).
Immediate effect: Shri Shishupal’s detention was quashed and he was set at liberty. Broader implication: the decision reaffirms that any substantial delay or administrative indifference in processing a preventive-detention representation violates Article 22(5) and renders the detention illegal. No new legal precedent was expressly created, but the judgment reinforces strict judicial scrutiny of procedural compliance under COFEPOSA and similar statutes.
R.S Sarkaria, J.— This is a petition for the issue of a writ of habeas corpus on behalf of Shri Shishupal (hereinafter called “the detenu”) who has been preventively detained in pursuance of an order passed under Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (hereinafter called “the COFEPOSA”). The detention order was passed by Shri L.N Gupta, Commissioner & Administration, Secretary, Home Department, Rajasthan, Jaipur. The detenu was arrested in pursuance of that order on November 2, 1979. The grounds of detention were served on the detenu on November 3, 1979.
2. On November 3, 1979 the detenu's brother Tara Chand addressed a letter to the detaining authority on behalf of the detenu praying for revocation of the order of detention. This letter was more in the nature of complaint against the Customs Officer, and less than a representation against the grounds of detention. The prayer made in this letter was rejected on November 19, 1979.
3. A meeting of the Advisory Board was held on November 30, 1979. The detenu was heard by the Board. The Board made a report on December 3, 1979 justifying the detention. The detention was confirmed by the State Government on December 15, 1979.
4. On February 23, 1980, the detenu made a representation to the Central Government praying for revocation of his detention under Section 11 of the COFEPOSA. Another representation of the same date was sent by the detenu to the detaining authority.
5. It is alleged in the petition that these representations have not been considered by the Central Government or the detaining authority up to the date of the writ petition. The representation dated February 23, 1980, of the detenu against the grounds of his detention reached the detaining authority on March 27, 1980, that is, after a delay of one month and five days.
6. It was contended on behalf of the petitioner; that there has been an infringement of the constitutional safeguards and imperatives embodied in Article 22 (5) of the Constitution inasmuch as—
(i) The detenu was never told that he had a right to make a representation and to whom the representation was to be addressed.
(ii) There was extreme callousness and delay on the part of the detaining authority in considering the detenu's representation, dated February 23, 1980, against the grounds of detention.
(iii) The authority's refusal to send the representation of the detenu to the Advisory Board on the ground that he had been heard in person by the Board.
7. Shri Vishnu Dutta Sharma, Additional Director of Prosecution, Home Department, Government of Rajasthan, has filed a counter-affidavit on behalf of Respondents 1, 2 and 4. In para 21 of this counter, it is admitted that the petitioner had sent an application under Section 11 of the COFEPOSA for revocation of the detention order to the Central Government and that application was received in the office of the Home Secretary on March 6, 1980 for para-wise comments. It is further stated in that para:
“The Home Secretary on March 7, 1980 forwarded the same to the Collector of Customs, Jaipur for sending his comments. The comments of the Collector of Customs, Jaipur were received on March 13, 1980 in the office of the Home Secretary. The State Government sent its comments to the Secretary, Ministry of Finance, New Delhi on March 14, 1980. The answering respondents are not aware as to how the Central Government has dealt with the matter thereafter.”
8. In the counter, it is further denied that a representation dated February 23, 1980 on the same lines as the revocation application to the Central Government, was sent to the detaining authority. It is added that the application dated February 23, 1980 of the detenu addressed to the detaining authority, was only for supply of copies of the relevant documents and for reconsideration by the Advisory Board. It is significantly admitted that this application (representation) dated February 23, 1980 of the detenu was received by the Home Secretary to the Government of Rajasthan on March 27, 1980 through the Inspector General of Prisons. Thereupon the copies were called for from the Collector, Customs and supplied to the detenu on April 1, 1980.
9. In spite of these evasive answers contained in para 21, it is clear that the representation dated February 23, 1980 of the detenu made by him through the jail authorities reached the detaining authority only on March 27, 1980. It was substantially in the same terms as the representation addressed to the Central Government for revocation of the detention under Section 11. This delay of one month and five days in communicating the representation of the detenu from the jail to the detaining authority demonstrates the gross negligence and extreme callousness with which the representation made by the detenu was dealt with by the respondents or their agents. Even after this huge delay, the representation was sent to the Collector for comments, and no intimation has been sent to the detenu about the fate of his representation dated February 23, 1980, addressed to the detaining authority. In fact, as it appears from the counter, the detaining authority refused to consider the same merely because the detenu had requested that this representation be forwarded to the Advisory Board, also. The mere fact that the meeting of the Advisory Board had been held earlier was not a valid excuse for the detaining authority in not considering the representation of the detenu at all.
10. It is well settled that in case of preventive detention of a citizen, Article 22(5) of the Constitution enjoins that the obligation of the appropriate Government or of the detaining authority to afford the detenu the earliest opportunity to make a representation and to consider that representation speedily is distinct from the Government's obligation to constitute a Board and to communicate the representation, amongst other materials, to the Board to enable it to form its opinion and to obtain such opinion. In the instant case, there has been a breach of these constitutional imperatives.
11. It was on this short ground, we had by our Order dated April 15, 1980, allowed this writ petition and directed the release of the detenu forthwith.
Alert