- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant was prosecuted for offences under Sections 489-B and 489-C of the Indian Penal Code after he handed a counterfeit two-rupee note to a friend to buy a circus ticket. The booking clerk suspected the note’s authenticity and alerted the police, who recovered ninety-nine additional two-rupee notes from the appellant. The trial court convicted him and imposed concurrent sentences of one year’s rigorous imprisonment, six months’ rigorous imprisonment, and a fine of ₹500. The High Court affirmed the conviction. The present opinion disposes of the appellant’s further appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution proved that the appellant had knowledge or reason to believe that the two-rupee notes in his possession were counterfeit, as required for conviction under Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC.
- Whether mere possession of counterfeit currency, absent evidence of its obvious falsity or the appellant’s awareness, is sufficient to draw a presumption of knowledge.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- He received the money legitimately after selling three quintals of tamarind fruit two days earlier to an unknown purchaser.
- He was unaware that the notes were counterfeit and only learned of their falsity during police interrogation.
- No prosecution witness testified that the notes were so obviously fake that an ordinary person would recognize them as such.
- The High Court erroneously treated his statements before the committing court and the sessions court as inconsistent on the question of knowledge.
Respondent's (Prosecution) Arguments
- According to counsel Mr Nettar, possession of counterfeit notes alone warrants an inference that the possessor knew they were counterfeit.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the appellant’s statements under Section 342 CrPC before both the committing court (Ex. P-13) and the sessions court. It found no inconsistency: in both, the appellant reiterated that he obtained the money from a tamarind sale and lacked knowledge of its falsity. The Court emphasized that:
- No evidence was led to show the notes were of such appearance that an average person would immediately recognize them as counterfeit.
- The prosecution failed to ask the appellant any targeted questions about his awareness of the notes’ nature.
- Without proof of either the notes’ obvious counterfeit character or the appellant’s actual knowledge, the legal requirement of “knowledge or reason to believe” under Sections 489-B and 489-C remained unfulfilled.
Consequently, the High Court’s reliance on an alleged inconsistency was misplaced, and the presumption suggested by the prosecution could not be drawn.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Allowed; Conviction and Sentences Set Aside; Appellant Acquitted.
The immediate effect is the appellant’s release from criminal liability and associated penalties. The decision underscores that possession of counterfeit currency, by itself, does not establish the requisite mens rea; the prosecution must demonstrate either the obvious counterfeit nature of the notes or the accused’s awareness of their falsity. No new precedent was formally set, but the ruling reinforces existing standards of proof for offences involving counterfeit currency.
S. Murtaza Fazal Ali, J.— The appellant has been convicted in this appeal under Sections 489-B and 489-C and has been sentenced to RI for one year and to RI for six months respectively and fine of Rs 500. The sentences have been directed to run concurrently. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant has stated that it is true that the appellant was found in possession of a counterfeit two rupee note and the accused handed over the note to a friend to purchase a ticket for a circus show. The booking clerk on seeing the note got suspicious. He immediately informed the Sub-Inspector of Police and on search of the Appellant 99 two rupee notes were recovered. The appellant in his statement under Section 342 stated that two days ago he sold three quintals of tamarind fruits to a person whom he did not know and that person gave him a sum of Rs 390. These currency notes have been given to him by the purchaser. He also said that he did not know that these currency notes were counterfeit and he came to know of it for the first time when he was interrogated by the police. There is no evidence of any witness to show that the counterfeit notes were of such a nature or description that a mere look at them would convince any person of average intelligence that it was a counterfeit note. Nor was any such question put to the accused under Section 342 CrPC. The High Court has affirmed the judgment of the learned Sessions Judge on the ground that in his statement under Section 342 made before the committing Court the accused has made a statement different from that made in the Sessions Court and therefore the appellant had reason to believe that notes in his possession were counterfeit notes. Here the High Court is not correct because even in the statement before the committing Court in Ex. P-13 which appears at p. 154 of the paper-book, the appellant has stuck to the same statement which he made before the Sessions Court that he had sold three quintals of tamarind fruits and from the purchaser he received a sum of Rs 390 in two rupee notes. We are not able to find any inconsistency between the answer given by the accused in his statement under Section 342 before the Sessions Judge and that before the Committing Court specially on the point that the appellant had the knowledge or reason to believe that the notes were counterfeit. Mr Nettar submitted that once the appellant is found in possession of counterfeit notes, he must be presumed to know that the notes are counterfeit. If the notes were of such a nature that mere look at them would convince anybody that it was counterfeit such a presumption could reasonably be drawn. But the difficulty is that the prosecution has not put any specific question to the appellant in order to find out whether the accused knew that the notes were of such a nature. No such evidence has been led by the prosecution to prove the nature of the notes also. In these circumstances, it is impossible for us to sustain the conviction of the appellant. For these reasons, therefore, the appeal is allowed, conviction and sentences passed on the appellant are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted of the charges framed against him.
Alert