Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ram Parkash Sharma v. State Of Haryana .

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 18, 1978
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The police recovered a substantial sum of money from the appellant in connection with an offence registered against one Bansi Lal. The money was seized and reported to the Special Judge but had not yet been formally produced before the court. The Special Judge held that he lacked authority to order release of the money because it was not before him; this view was affirmed by the courts below. The appellant sought relief in the present appeal, and the Supreme Court granted leave to determine whether such power exists under the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a criminal court has power under Section 457 CrPC to release property that has been seized by the police and reported to the court but has not yet been produced before it.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Basavva Kom Dyamangouda Patil v. State of Mysore, (1977) 4 SCC 358 The court’s discretion to release or retain seized property, balancing prompt return against the need to preserve evidence. Reinforced the view that, although property should not be held indefinitely, the court must remain vigilant and consider future evidentiary requirements before ordering release.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed Chapter 34 of the CrPC, outlining a three-part scheme for disposal of property:

  • Section 457 covers property seized by police but not yet produced before any court.
  • Section 451 governs property already produced before the court.
  • Section 452 applies after conclusion of inquiry or trial.

Given that the money was seized and only reported, Section 457 squarely applied. The Court rejected the lower courts’ view that absence of formal production deprived the Special Judge of jurisdiction. Nonetheless, it cautioned that the power to release is discretionary: the judge must assess whether retaining the property is necessary for investigation or trial. If retaining the specific currency notes is important—e.g., because the prosecution alleges they were buried—the court may deny release; otherwise, release may be ordered upon the appellant furnishing adequate security.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF — The Supreme Court held that the Special Judge does possess power under Section 457 CrPC to order release of property seized by the police but not yet produced before the court. The matter is remitted to the Special Judge to determine, after investigation, whether the seized currency notes must be retained; if not, the property should be released on adequate security. The decision clarifies the scope of Section 457 but sets no broader precedent beyond reaffirming judicial discretion in handling seized property.

Show all summary ...

1. Leave granted.

1-A. The short point that arises in this appeal is as to whether the criminal court has power to release property seized by the police from a person and reported to the Special Judge, but not yet produced before the Court. We think the court has such power and that seems to be the scheme of the Code itself.

2. Chapter 34 of the Criminal Procedure Code deals with disposal of property. There is a trichotomy in the sense that where property has been seized by the police, but not produced before the court, the power to dispose it of is covered by Section 457. Where property has been seized and/or otherwise produced before the court, the manner to dispose of such property is governed by Section 451. If the question of disposal arises after the enquiry or trial in any criminal court is concluded, the disposal of the property involved in the case is governed by Section 452. We need not go elaborately into the implications of each provision since we are not called upon to do so in the present case.

3. Section 457 covers the facts of the present case. The police have recovered a considerable sum of money from the appellant and the money is stated to be seized in connection with an offence registered against an accused person, namely, Bansi Lal. Whether the appellant himself will be a witness or an accused is not possible to state at the present moment according to the counsel for the State. Be that as it may, the situation is squarely covered by Section 457 CrPC. However, the fact that the court has power to dispose of property seized by the police but not yet produced before the Court does not mean that the Special Judge must always release such property to the person from whom the property has been recovered, especially when the stage of the case is in suspicion, the investigation is not over and charge-sheet has not yet been laid. The court has to be circumspect in such a situation before releasing the property. While we reverse the decision of the courts below that the Special Judge had no power to release the seized property, we should not be taken to mean that whenever the claimant asks for the property back, he should be given back the said property. That has to be decided on its own merits in each case and the discretion of the court has to be exercised after due consideration of the interests of justice including the prospective necessity of the production of these seized articles at the time of the trial. If the release of the property seized will, in any manner, affect or prejudice the course of justice at the time of the trial, it will be a wise discretion to reject the claim for return.

4. In the present case, Counsel for the State is unable to state whether in future prosecution may have to rely upon the currency notes in specie seized from the appellant. It is quite on record that they may be so required especially having regard to the circumstance that the monies are stated by the prosecution to have been buried although the appellant, in this Court, stoutly denies this allegation. All that we need do at the moment is to uphold the power of the court to release the property and direct the Special Judge to hold an investigation into the necessity for the notes seized to be retained with the police or in the court for future use at the time of the inquiry or trial. If he is of the opinion that the notes are so required, the property shall not be released. If, on the other hand, the notes are not needed in any manner in the later stages of the inquiry or trial, it will be proper for the court to release the property on the appellant furnishing adequate security.

5. In reaching the conclusion we have taken note of the decision of this Court in Basavva Kom Dyamangouda Patil v. State of Mysore (1977) 4 SCC 358. Of course, the appellant should not indefinitely keep property in its custody nor need the court keep the property seized and produced before it unduly long but this does not whittle down the need for the court to be vigilant when an application is made for return of property seized by the police as to the necessity of such property being required in the future course of the trial.

6. Having regard to these circumstances, the court will pass appropriate orders under Section 457 CrPC, regarding the disposal of the property seized by the police in this case. The Special Judge will dispose of the matter expeditiously since considerable time has elapsed. The appeal is disposed of accordingly.