- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Himachal Pradesh v. Wazir Chand And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
On the night of 7 August 1972, Parshottam Lal, who allegedly carried about Rs 8,000 after winning a private lottery, was fatally stabbed near the house of Accused 1, Wazir Chand, shortly after leaving a cinema in Kangra. Before dying, the victim made an oral dying declaration to witness Deshraj, naming Wazir Chand as the assailant and referring to the presence of Accused 2 Raj Kumar (brother of Wazir Chand) and Accused 3 Joginder Singh.
The police recovered blood-stained clothes and, on Wazir Chand’s disclosure, a blood-stained knife. Raj Kumar’s disclosure allegedly led to the recovery of the victim’s watch and ring. Joginder Singh was arrested with minor cash and a railway ticket.
The Sessions Court convicted Wazir Chand under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to death; Raj Kumar and Joginder Singh were convicted under Section 302/34 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment. On reference and appeal, the Himachal Pradesh High Court: (i) acquitted Raj Kumar and Joginder Singh, and (ii) altered Wazir Chand’s conviction to Section 304 Part II IPC, imposing 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment.
The State appealed against the acquittals and sentence reduction (Criminal Appeal 59 of 1975). Wazir Chand cross-appealed seeking full acquittal (Criminal Appeal 369 of 1975). The Supreme Court decided both appeals together.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court erred in acquitting Accused 2 and 3 by holding that the dying declaration did not implicate them beyond reasonable doubt.
- Whether the conviction of Accused 1 should be for murder under Section 302 IPC or for culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 IPC, considering Exception 4 to Section 300 (sudden fight) and the plea of private defence.
- Whether recoveries and injuries on the accused constituted sufficient corroboration of the dying declaration to sustain convictions.
Arguments of the Parties
State of Himachal Pradesh (Appellant in Criminal Appeal 59 of 1975)
- The dying declaration, once accepted, points to active participation of all three accused; the Sessions Court’s convictions should therefore be restored.
- Recoveries of the blood-stained knife and clothes (Accused 1) and the watch and ring (Accused 2) corroborate the dying declaration.
- Injuries on Accused 1 and 3 indicate their involvement in a struggle with the deceased, reinforcing guilt.
Accused 1 – Wazir Chand (Appellant in Criminal Appeal 369 of 1975 / Respondent)
- Claimed he acted in exercise of the right of private defence: while peeling an apple for his pregnant wife, he was attacked by the deceased and two companions, was felled, and used the knife only to save himself.
- Sought full acquittal or further mitigation of sentence.
Accused 2 – Raj Kumar & Accused 3 – Joginder Singh (Respondents)
- Denied presence and participation; challenged reliability of the dying declaration and alleged corroborative evidence.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Narain Singh v. State of Punjab (1963 3 SCR 678) | The court cannot isolate inculpatory portions of an accused’s statement under Section 342 CrPC from the exculpatory explanation. | Used to evaluate how much of Wazir Chand’s statement about private defence could be accepted without unfairly discarding the accompanying explanation. |
| Nishi Kant Jha v. State of Bihar (1969 1 SCC 437) | The court may rely on parts of the accused’s statement when supported by other evidence. | Supported selective acceptance of Wazir Chand’s admission that he inflicted injuries, read with corroborative prosecution evidence. |
| Sampat Singh v. State of Rajasthan (1969 1 SCC 367) | Permits partial reliance on the accused’s version to determine that he exceeded the right of private defence. | Cited in considering whether Wazir Chand exceeded any right of self-defence and whether Exception 4 to Section 300 applied. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
Acquittal of Accused 2 and 3: The dying declaration clearly attributes the stabbing only to Accused 1, and ambiguous wording (“Shamal”) regarding Accused 2 and 3 could equally denote mere presence. No independent evidence—such as reliable recoveries or credible eyewitness testimony—corroborated their participation. Alleged recovery of the victim’s watch and ring from a third party 23 days after the incident, long after Raj Kumar surrendered, lacked evidentiary weight. Injuries on Joginder Singh were minor and could be explained by a prior altercation with a third party. Hence, the benefit of doubt was extended.
Liability of Accused 1: The Court accepted (i) the dying declaration naming Wazir Chand as the assailant; (ii) recovery of his blood-stained clothes and knife; and (iii) medical evidence showing Injury 1 was sufficient to cause death. However, there were significant indications of a sudden mutual fight: scuffle marks, torn clothing, abrasions on Wazir Chand, and a prior quarrel involving the deceased’s companion and Accused 3 moments earlier.
Applying the jurisprudence on considering an accused’s own statement, the Court rejected Wazir Chand’s full private-defence claim as improbable (a lone man overpowering three aggressors with only minor abrasions), but accepted that the confrontation was sudden and unpremeditated. Therefore, Exception 4 to Section 300 (sudden fight in the heat of passion without undue advantage) was attracted. Given that a deadly weapon was used and a vital injury inflicted, the offence amounted to culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part I, not Part II as held by the High Court.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Supreme Court dismissed the State’s appeal against the acquittal of Accused 2 and 3; partly allowed the State’s appeal against Accused 1 by converting his conviction to Section 304 Part I IPC; and dismissed Wazir Chand’s cross-appeal. The 10-year rigorous imprisonment imposed by the High Court was affirmed.
Implications: The judgment reaffirms the need for clear corroboration before extending a dying declaration’s sweep to co-accused, and clarifies that partial reliance on an accused’s Section 342 statement is permissible when consistent with objective evidence. No new precedent was set, but the decision underscores the nuanced application of Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC in cases of sudden mutual fights.
D.A Desai, J.— Both these appeals by special leave arise out of a judgment rendered by High Court of Himachal Pradesh in Reference 1 of 1973 and Criminal Appeal 36 of 1973. Both the appeals arise from the same judgment and were therefore heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment.
2. The occurrence which gave rise to the present appeals took place on August 7, 1972 a little after 10.30 p.m Parshottam Lal according to prosecution who was fatally injured in this occurrence had a few days prior to August 7, 1972 earned a prize in the amount of Rs 5100 in a private lottery. Along with some other amount which he had with him, it is alleged, he usually kept Rs 8000 in his pocket. On the date of the occurrence deceased Parshottam Lal accompanied by one Om Parkash alias Pashi visited Jyoti Cinema in the second show. Accused 2 Raj Kumar was also in the theatre at that time. At about this time Accused 1 Wazir Chand (appellant in Criminal Appeals 369/75 and Respondent 1 in Criminal Appeals 59/75) and Joginder Singh (Respondent 3 in Criminal Appeals 59/75) were seen conversing among themselves in the verandah of the theatre. The second show was over around 10.30 p.m Deshraj PW 3 who was also enjoying the picture came out of the theatre and proceeded towards his house and on the way he crossed Accused 3 Joginder Singh whose clothes appeared to have been stained with blood. Proceeding ahead, Deshraj heard a shout and rushed in that direction. He found Parshottam Lal injured lying on the ground and he inquired from Parshottam Lal as to what had happened whereupon Parshottam Lal told him that: “Wazir Chand hawker doing business near Prem Bus Company injured him with a knife and at that time Joginder Singh son of Nathu of Girth Sakna and Raj Kumar, brother of Wazir Chand were with him and they beat him and information should be given to his relatives”. Deshraj went to the house of Parshottam Lal and informed his wife Smt Pushpa, PW 5 and she along with Daya Ram and Sita Ram came to the scene of occurrence but in the meantime Parshottam Lal succumbed to his injuries. Deshraj gave information of the offence at Kangra Police Station around midnight time and investigation was commenced. A search of the clothes of the deceased then put on by him led to the recovery of Rs 71 and a bunch of keys. The point worthy of notice is that the large cash which Parshottam Lal was alleged to be carrying was not found on his person and a suspicion arose that the motive for murder was robbery. A search of the house of Accused 1 Wazir Chand was taken and except a paltry amount no cash was recovered. Accused 1 Wazir Chand was arrested on August 8, 1972 from the house of Raghunath Singh, PW 16 and at the time of his arrest on a search of his person, Banyan, Exhibit P-18, and Pant. Exhibit P-19 alleged to have been stained with blood, were recovered. Information given by Accused 1 while in custody led to the recovery of bloodstained knife, Exhibit P-1 from a bush of Neelkanthi and it was attached. Accused 2 Raj Kumar could not be traced till August 20, 1972 when he surrendered in the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Pathankot. He was arrested and the information given by him while in custody led to the recovery of a ring and a watch pledged with one Jagir Singh, PW 21 on August 31, 1972. Accused 3 Joginder Singh was arrested by Head Constable Sunka Ram, PW 23 on August 9, 1972 and on a search of his person currency notes worth Rs 28.15, one iron ring and a railway ticket were recovered. After completing the investigation, the accused were charge-sheeted and ultimately came to be committed to the Court of Session where a charge was framed against Accused 1 Wazir Chand for committing murder of Parshottam Lal punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, and against Accused 2 Raj Kumar and Accused 3 Joginder Singh for committing an offence under Section 302, read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
3. The defence of Accused 1 Wazir Chand was that he caused injury to Parshottam Lal in exercise of the right of private defence of body in that when he was peeling apple for his wife who was then pregnant, deceased Parshottam Lal accompanied by Onkar Chand PW 17 and one Om Prakash alias Pashi came over there and started beating him. At that time Parshottam Lal according to the defence of Accused 1 Wazir Chand felled him and sat on his chest and was pressing and he felt suffocated and wielded his knife not to kill Parshottam Lal but to save himself. The defence of Accused 2 Raj Kumar and Accused 3 Joginder Singh was one of total denial.
4. The learned Sessions Judge rejected the evidence of motive and he accepted the dying declaration as giving a truthful version of the occurrence and held it proved. He also accepted the circumstantial evidence in the form of recovery of bloodstained knife. Exhibit P-1 at the instance of Accused 1 Wazir Chand and bloodstained clothes on the person of Wazir Chand at the time of his arrest. Evidence in the form of recovery of watch and ring belonging to deceased Parshottam Lal on the information given by Accused 2 Raj Kumar was accepted. He also accepted the evidence about the injuries found on the person of Accused 1 Wazir Chand and Accused 3 Joginder Singh and along with the recovery of button Exhibit P-10, and concluded that there was good deal of struggle at the spot where Parshottam Lal was found lying injured. On this evidence the learned Sessions Judge convicted Accused 1 for an offence under Section 302 and awarded him capital punishment. He also convicted Accused 2 and 3 for an offence under Section 302, read with Section 34 IPC and sentenced each of them to suffer imprisonment for life. The sentence awarded to Accused 1 was submitted to the High Court for confirmation. All the three accused appealed against their conviction and sentence.
5. The High Court held that the charge against Accused 2 and 3 is not brought home to them and in the case of Accused 1 Wazir Chand, it was held that on the evidence he could be convicted for an offence under Section 304 Part II of the Indian Penal Code and accordingly set aside his conviction for an offence under Section 302 IPC and the capital punishment, and awarded him rigorous imprisonment for 10 years. The State of Himachal Pradesh has questioned the correctness of the judgment of the High Court in respect of the three accused in Criminal Appeal 59 of 1975. Accused 1 questioned the correctness of his conviction and sentence in Criminal Appeal 369 of 1975.
6. The autopsy on the dead body of Parshottam Lal was performed by Dr Shushma Sood, PW 1 on August 8, 1972 at 2.30 p.m She found four injuries on the dead body. They were as under:
(1) Incised wound horizontal in direction 2″ × ½″ × 2″ situated about 3″ below and 2″ below medial to the right nipple covered with blood. On washing the tissues it still was stained with blood. The wound was running downwards in direction.
(2) Incised wound on the back about 1¼″ × ½″ × 2″ in dimension situated about 4″ above the left anterior superior iliac spine and 9” lateral to the vertebral column. Wound was running obliquely and was covered with dark coloured blood.
(3) Incised wound about 2″ × 1¼″ × ½″ situated lateral to the second cervical vertebra on the left side of nape of neck.
(4) Incised wound about 1″ × ½″ × ½″ situated about 1″ below the occipital eminence on the left side. It was running horizontally. The bone underlying was intact. No mark of ligature anywhere on the neck. Scalp, skull vertebrae, membranes brain, spinal cord were healthy.
In her opinion Injury 1 was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. She said that after the receipt of injuries deceased could live for about 15 to 20 minutes or may as well survive for about 2-3 hours, and during this period he could understand and speak. There was some comment on this part of her evidence because in col. 20 of notes of post-mortem examination, Exhibit P-4, she has stated that the death was sudden. It was suggested that the word ‘sudden’ would mean instantaneous and if the death was instantaneous, Deshraj, PW 3 could not have reached in time when deceased Parshottam Lal would be alive and would be able to make dying declaration to Deshraj. We are not impressed by this criticism. Both the Courts have rightly rejected this criticism. As Dr Sood made it very clear that there will be a time-lag of about 15-20 minutes from the receipt of injuries and it may even extend to 2-3 hours before the death occurred and it should be remembered that even though the deceased had received four separate incised wounds, only injury 1 was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death as opined by Dr Sood. Therefore, the suggestion that the death would be instantaneous and there was no chance for the deceased to make dying declaration has been rightly negatived.
7. It must at once be noticed that in this case there is no witness to the occurrence in the sense that no one has spoken to his having seen the accused causing injuries to deceased Parshottam Lal. The direct testimony is finished by the dying declaration of the deceased and that evidence is of vital importance to connect the accused with the offence. PW 3 Deshraj spoke of the dying declaration and the learned Sessions Judge has reproduced the dying declaration in the judgment. It also finds place in the FIR Ex. PG given by Deshraj at Kangra Police Station. The incident occurred a little while after 10.30 p.m on August 7, 1972 and Deshraj lodged first information at Kangra Police Station at 12.15 mid-night. He was closely cross-examined. Some minor discrepancies were sought to be pointed out in the dying declaration which was reproduced in the oral evidence and the record of which is to be found in the first information report Exhibit PG. Evidence of Pushpa, PW 5 widow of the deceased would show that she was awakened by Deshraj and she was given information about the unfortunate occurrence. This clearly establishes that Deshraj was first to reach the scene of occurrence and through him Pushpa, widow of deceased, received information about the occurrence. Some minor discrepancies were pointed out to us in the evidence of Deshraj and we must frankly say that we are not impressed by any of them. Both the learned Sessions Judge and the High Court observed the correct principle for appreciating the evidence furnished by a dying declaration and both have recorded an affirmative conclusion that the dying declaration as deposed to by Deshraj was inherently true, voluntary and reliable. We, therefore, do not consider it necessary to repeat the same criticism. We are in agreement with the reasons recorded by both the Courts for acceptance of the evidence furnished by the dying declaration.
8. Mr Mahajan, learned Counsel for the State of Himachal Pradesh contended that once dying declaration is accepted as a truthful version of the occurrence it would unmistakably show that all the three accused were involved in the occurrence and that the learned Sessions Judge was right in convicting Accused 1 for an offence under Section 302 and Accused 2 and 3 under Section 302, read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, and the High Court was clearly in error in setting aside the conviction of Accused 2 and 3. In the earlier portion of this judgment we have reproduced the dying declaration. Scanning it, it becomes clear that it speaks of Accused 1 Wazir Chand causing injuries to Parshottam Lal and it speaks of the presence of Accused 2 Raj Kumar and 3 Joginder Singh. There was some controversy about one word “Shamal” as used in the dying declaration and it was urged on the one hand that it means participation in the assault and on the other hand it was stated that it may at best suggest presence. But it was said that the next following sentence would clearly show that deceased Parshottam Lal stated that all the three beat him. That interpretation of the last sentence has been negatived by the High Court saying that it is a very general phraseology not indicating participation in the assault. In fact, the first part of the dying declaration clearly attributes attack on deceased to Accused 1 only. As we are left on the question of participation of Accused 2 and 3 only on the dying declaration of the deceased as the other evidence offered for corroboration of the same does not appeal to us and when the language of the dying declaration is open to two interpretations and as the High Court has accepted the interpretation favourable to Accused 2 and 3, on the material as it is, it would not be proper to take another view of the matter. Therefore, it could not be said that dying declaration also involves Accused 2 and 3. If there was some other evidence directly suggesting involvement of Accused 2 and 3 in the attack on the deceased, it would have provided corroboration to the interpretation as was canvassed on behalf of the State but in the absence of such evidence it is not possible to accept the suggested interpretation of the dying declaration and base the conviction of Accused 2 and 3 solely on the same.
9. It was next contended that certain recoveries will clearly provide corroboration to the dying declaration. In respect of Accused 1 it was urged that when he was arrested on August 8, 1972 from the house of one Raghunath Singh, PW 16, which fact itself was considered a circumstance of incriminating nature against Accused 1, his clothes were found to be stained with blood and the report of the Serologist and Chemical Examiner, Exhibit PGG shows that the clothes of Accused 1 were stained with human blood. Thereafter he gave information leading to the discovery of knife Exhibit P-1. This knife is also shown to have been stained with human blood. This evidence of recovery of bloodstained clothes of the accused and a bloodstained knife on the informations given by him was not commented upon before us. Therefore, that evidence has been rightly accepted and it would certainly furnish corroboration to the dying declaration as against Accused 1.
10. It was next contended that Accused 2 Raj Kumar was not traced till he surrendered to the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Pathankot on August 19, 1972, and he was brought to Kangra on August 20, 1972 and was interrogated. On August 30 Raj Kumar was taken to Dhugiari and on the next day one Jagir Singh produced one golden ring Exhibit P-6 and one wrist watch Exhibit P-5 before the investigating officer Shri P.N Kapoor, PW 24 who attached them under memo marked Exhibit P-V, in the presence of Vidya Ram, PW 8. This watch and ring were identified by Pushpa as belonging to the deceased. Learned Sessions Judge relied upon this recovery to connect Accused 2 with the offence. Now, it must be recalled that the incident occurred on the night of August 7, 1972. Accused 2 Raj Kumar was in police custody from August 20, 1972. It was for the first time that he was taken to Dhugiari at the house of Jagir Singh on August 30, 1972. There is a long delay between the date of occurrence and the arrest of Raj Kumar and recovery. Again it is not clear from the memo of recovery that these articles were recovered on the information given by Accused 2 Raj Kumar. Of course Jagir Singh, PW 21 is examined and he said that the aforementioned two articles were pledged by Raj Kumar with him for a loan of Rs 200. However, even if this evidence of recovery is believed it would not establish participation of Accused 2 Raj Kumar in the assault because he may have got these articles even from Wazir Chand who is alleged to be the assailant of the deceased. Raj Kumar is not charged for retaining stolen property. Therefore, it is not possible to place any reliance on this recovery as directly suggesting participation in the attack on the deceased and the High Court has not rightly relied upon it. Therefore, there is no material evidence in this case which would corroborate dying declaration so far as Accused 2 is concerned.
11. The situation with regard to Accused 3 is not materially different. Deshraj, PW 3 has stated that a little while before he heard the shout of Parshottam Lal, Accused 3 Joginder Singh crossed him on the way and that at that time he found clothes of Accused 3 bloodstained. Accused 3 was arrested on August 9, 1972 while he was boarding a bus. Deshraj could not have clearly noticed at night time the fact that the clothes then put on by Accused 3 were bloodstained. The clothes are not forthcoming. There is no other evidence in the form of recovery of any incriminating article from Accused 3 or recovery on the information given by him and, therefore, there is no corroboration to the dying declaration so far as Accused 3 is concerned.
12. Mr Mahajan then invited our attention to the fact that both Accused 1 and 3 had some injuries on their person at the time of their arrest. Both Accused 1 Wazir Chand and Accused 3 Joginder Singh were examined by Dr S.R Chaki, PW 2 on the application submitted to him by the police officer on August 9, 1972. He found the following injuries on the person of Accused 1:
(1) One abrasion ¾″ × ¼″ transverse on the right side of face ½″ lateral to the lateral angle of right eye and ½″ below the lateral end of the right eyebrow covered brownish crust.
(2) One abrasion 1″ × ½″ vertical, on the left half of back of chest, 2″ below the lower angle of left scapula (i.e lower and of left scapula) covered with brownish crust.
(3) One abrasion 2″ × 1¼″ vertical, on the lower part of right half of back of chest, 5″ below the lower angle (i.e lower end) of right scapula, covered with brownish crust.
(4) One abrasion ¾″ × ½″ transverse, on the right half of back at the level of iliac crest and 1″ to the right of the mid-line of back covered with brownish crust.
(5) One abrasion 2½″ × 3/8″ vertical on the front of the left leg, 3″ below the left knee joint covered with brownish crust.
(6) One abrasion ½″ × ½″ on the front of left leg, i.e 7½″ below the left knee-Joint covered with brownish crust.
Similarly, he found the following injuries on the person of Accused 3:
(1) One abrasion 2″ × 1″ transverse, on the left side of left buttock, 2″ behind the anterior superior iliac spine and 1½″ below the iliac crest of left iliac bone covered with brownish crust.
(2) Abrasion on the inner mucous membrane of the upper lip against the right and left upper medial incisor teeth almost healed up.
(3) One abrasion ¼″ × ¼″ on the back of right chest 2″ above the inferior angle of right scapula and 4″ to the right of the mid-line of back covered with brownish crust.
13. In the opinion of Dr Chaki the injuries must have been received by the aforementioned two persons before 24 hours and within 72 hours of their examination. In this connection we must also take note of the version of Accused 1 and 3. Accused 1 has stated in his statement recorded by the learned Sessions Judge under Section 342 of the Criminal Procedure Code that while he was peeling apple for his wife who was pregnant sitting in his verandah at night, Parshottam Lal accompanied by Om Parkash alias Pashi and Onkar Chand came over there and one of the three had a stick. He said that he was attacked and beaten and he abused them loudly and then ran out of his verandah. He said that he was pursued and was felled in the back lane and Parshottam Lal sat on his chest and pressed it. He said that he felt great suffocation and he used his hands to escape and there was knife in one of his hands. He said that he had no intention to kill him but he was anxious to save himself. The suggestion seems to be that when he was felled on the ground and Parshottam Lal sat on his chest he suffered abrasions on his back. It may be pointed out that from amongst six abrasions on the person of Wazir Chand, 1 is on the face, 2, 3 and 4 are on the back and 5, 6 and 7 are on the left leg. Joginder Singh stated that he got the injuries when Om Parkash alias Pashi came to his shop and beat him accusing him of beating the servant of Om Parkash. Om Parkash is not examined as a prosecution witness. If prosecution comes out with the story that Parshottam Lal alone was attacked and beaten by the three accused and that they suddenly pounced upon him and that Parshottam Lal was unarmed, there was absolutely no ghost of a chance even in the ensuing scuffle that Accused 3 would be injured in the way Accused 3 has offered explanation about his injuries. This explanation gets some support from the evidence of Onkar Chand, PW 17 who has stated that Om Parkash alias Pashi complained to him that Joginder Singh beat his servant. Therefore, it is not possible to accept the submission that the presence of injuries on Accused 3 would provide corroboration to the dying declaration so as to hold that he participated in the assault.
14. It would thus appear that the High Court was perfectly justified in acquitting Accused 2 and 3 and there is no reason to take another view of the matter and the appeal preferred by the State against the acquittal of Accused 2 and 3 must fail.
15. Turning to the case of Accused 1 he was convicted by the learned Sessions Judge for an offence under Section 302 IPC and was awarded capital punishment. The High Court took the view that Accused 1 would be guilty of committing an offence under Section 304 Part II, IPC. Mr Mehta who appeared for Accused 1 urged that Accused 1 should be acquitted because he had caused injuries in exercise of the right of private defence of body.
16. Evidence furnished by the dying declaration corroborated by the recovery of bloodstained clothes from the person of Accused 1 Wazir Chand further corroborated by the recovery of a bloodstained knife on the information given by him would affirmatively establish that Accused 1 attacked deceased and caused him four injuries. Injury 1 is described by Dr Sood as one sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. Accused 1 himself has suffered abrasions. The nature of injuries on the deceased would indicate that Accused 1 was armed with a sharp-edged weapon and he did attack deceased Parshottam Lal. Having reached this conclusion, we are left to guess about the genesis of the trouble. The origin or the commencement of the occurrence to some extent is left to surmise. A reasonable prognosis may have to be made as to how the incident occurred.
17. In this connection we must refer to some facts which unquestionably emerge from the evidence. It is satisfactorily established that the deceased had visited the cinema show. Evidence clearly establishes that the incident occurred in front of the house of Accused 1. The site-plan indicates a trail of blood to a distance of 50 feet. It further evidences marks of scuffle and some buttons lying at the spot. Bush-shirt of the deceased Parshottam Lal was found unbuttoned and the banyan put on by him was found torn. It is not made clear in evidence whether the way to the house of Parshottam Lal from the theatre passed by the house of Wazir Chand. If that was not his normal route to his house he came there for some purpose.
18. In the absence of any witness to the occurrence and the deceased died giving only that part of the occurrence which implicates the accused, we are left with the statements of Accused 1 made by him under Section 342 CrPC about the origin of the occurrence. This would raise the question as to what value should be attached to the statement made by the accused under Section 342 CrPC, 1898. It is obligatory on the Court to question the accused on the circumstances appearing against him in evidence so as to enable him to explain the same. Sub-section (3) provides that the answers given by the accused may be taken into consideration in such inquiry or trial, etc. In order to give an opportunity to the accused to explain the circumstances appearing against him in evidence, the Court under Section 342 CrPC was required at the close of the trial to question the accused on such circumstances. The Court had to guard against cross-examination of the accused. The accused was to be questioned with regard to the circumstances appearing against him in evidence and not the inference that flows from the circumstances. The answers given by the accused have to be taken into consideration.
19. There was at one point of time some controversy whether the statement of the accused can be accepted in part and rejected in part. This situation arose where a part of the statement was inculpatory and a part of the statement was exculpatory. In Narain Singh v. State of Punjab (1963) 3 SCR 678, (1964) 1 Cri LJ 730 it was held that it is not open to the Court to dissect the statement and to pick out a part of the statement which may be incriminative, and then to examine whether the explanation furnished by the accused for his conduct is supported by the evidence on the record. If the accused admits to have done an act which would but for the explanation furnished by him be an offence, the admission cannot be used against him divorced from the explanation. The question again figured before this Court in Nishi Kant Jha v. State of Bihar (1969) 1 SCC 437, (1969) 2 SCR 1033, wherein the Court held that the Court may rely on a portion of the statement of the accused and find him guilty in consideration of the other evidence against him led by the prosecution. In Nishi Kant Jha case there was no eye-witness to the commission of the crime and the evidence was all circumstantial and the statement of the accused that he was present at the scene of the crime was a vital circumstance which taken in conjunction with other circumstances led the Court to come to the conclusion that he was guilty of the crime imputed to him. The ratio of the aforementioned cases was again examined in Sampat Singh v. State of Rajasthan (1969) 1 SCC 367, (1969) 3 SCR 228. On the facts of the case, after accepting a part of the statement of the accused it was held that he caused injuries in exercise of the right of self-defence but he exceeded the same. It was observed that it is permissible for the Court to rely on a portion of the statement of the accused and find him guilty in consideration of the other evidence against him led by the prosecution.
20. Where the commencement or genesis of the occurrence is not available because there was no witness to the occurrence available, the only direct version of the commencement of the occurrence would be found in the statement of the accused, if he chooses to give out his version of the occurrence. His statement has to be considered in the light of the evidence adduced by the prosecution and weighing his statement with the probabilities of the case either in his favour or against him.
21. In this case the direct testimony, if it can be so styled, is furnished by the dying declaration which speaks of who caused injuries to the deceased and who others were present. How the occurrence commenced or what was the genesis of the trouble is not found in the dying declaration. Accused 1 has given his version of the occurrence. According to him he was the victim of an assault and he was felled on the ground and in his attempt to get a release from the grip of Parshottam Lal he caused injuries to him by a knife which was accidentally in his hand. If this version accords with the probabilities of the case it may have to be examined whether he acted in exercise of the right of private defence of body and whether he exceeded the same. Accused 1 states that Parshottam Lal was accompanied by Om Parkash alias Pashi and Onkar Chand. Onkar Chand was examined as prosecution witness though Om Parkash was not examined. Onkar Chand, PW 17 does refer to Om Parkash telling him that Joginder Singh, Accused 3 had beaten his servant without reason and he also speaks about Accused 2 Raj Kumar and Accused 1 Wazir Chand rescuing Joginder Singh from Pashi. Therefore, just before the occurrence in which Parshottam Lal received injuries there was an incident involving Om Parkash alias Pashi and Accused 3 Joginder Singh and it may be recalled here that Joginder Singh has so stated in his statement under Section 342 CrPC.
22. The next aspect which we must bear in mind is that the site-plan shows that there were marks of scuffle and buttons torn out of the bush-shirt were found lying there and a torn bush-shirt of Wazir Chand was recovered. Bush-shirt of deceased Parshottam Lal was found unbuttoned and his banyan was torn. Now, if deceased Parshottam Lal accompanied by two persons came and if Wazir Chand was alone and he was felled on the ground, there was no ghost of a chance that Wazir Chand, Accused 1 could cause injuries to Parshottam Lal. He would be disarmed immediately even if he had a knife in his hand with which he, according to him, was peeling apple. Therefore, that part of the statement of Accused 1 is inherently improbable and must be rejected.
23. The very evidence indicates that a little before the occurrence there was mutual recrimination between Om Parkash and Joginder Singh and for that there is direct evidence of Onkar Chand, PW 17. It appears that the trouble started on Om Parkash beating Joginder Singh on the allegation that Joginder Singh had beaten the servant of Om Parkash. Thereafter the present occurrence occurred near the house of Accused 1. Parshottam Lal must have come there. Accused 1 would naturally be present there. There were marks of scuffle. A bush-shirt of Accused 1 Wazir Chand was torn. Buttons had come out. There was a trail of blood to a distance of 50 feet. On this evidence the High Court at number of places has observed that these circumstances would lead to an inference that the two parties, one led by deceased Parshottam Lal and another led by Wazir Chand had a quarrel, and in this quarrel Accused 1 Wazir Chand inflicted knife injuries on Parshottam Lal. At another stage it is observed that the High Court was left with only one inference that there was a mutual fight between Parshottam Lal and Wazir Chand and some persons supporting each party. This inference according to the High Court was reinforced by the fact that the conduct of Accused 1 and even Accused 3 would be the same as is attributed to them in a mutual fight. After examining these circumstances in detail, the High Court concluded that the only inference that can be drawn is that there was a mutual fight.
24. After having correctly concluded that a mutual fight took place, the High Court came to the conclusion that the accused had no intention to commit the murder and convicted him for an offence under Section 304 Part II, IPC. It is difficult for us to subscribe to this view.
25. Accused 1 has wielded a weapon like a knife, indisputably a dangerous weapon. He has caused four injuries one of which is necessarily fatal. He has received six abrasions. The proper legal and reasonable inference to be drawn from all the circumstances is that because of the earlier incident in which Om Parkash alias Pashi and Joginder Singh were involved something like a challenge was taken up and Parshottam Lal definitely accompanied by some others, more presumably Om Parkash alias Pashi came over to the house of Accused 1 and there was a mutual free fight between the parties. Accused 1 had returned to his house probably a little before the incident took place. Therefore, when Parshottam Lal appeared there was a sudden fight upon a sudden quarrel flowing from the earlier incident and in this both sides attacked each other. All the ingredients to attract exception 4 to Section 300 IPC are established. There is no premeditation. Parshottam Lal left the theatre and came over there. There was a fight that ensued in a sudden quarrel. The previous incident between Om Parkash alias Pashi and Accused 3 Joginder was the cause and in that heat of passion and sudden quarrel parties grappled and attacked each other and it cannot be said in the circumstances that any undue advantage was taken. It may be recalled here that Parshottam Lal was a hefty well-built fellow and if Accused 1 alone was to attack him he could not have escaped with few abrasions. Therefore, all the ingredients to attract exception 4 of Section 300 IPC are fully established.
26. As Injury 1 was fatal in the ordinary course of nature and Accused 1 had wielded a dangerous weapon and caused an injury on the vital part of the body and the blows were repeated inasmuch as four injuries were caused, the offence but for the application of exception 4 would be one under Section 302 IPC but as exception 4 is attracted, it would be reduced to Section 304 Part I IPC and the conviction of Accused 1 would be modified to one under Section 304 Part I IPC maintaining the sentence as awarded by the High Court as in our opinion that is adequate.
27. Accordingly, Criminal Appeal 59 of 1975 preferred by the State of Himachal Pradesh against original Accused 2 and 3 is dismissed and it is partly allowed as far as Accused 1 is concerned in that his conviction is modified to one under Section 304 Part I IPC maintaining the sentence of 10 years' rigorous imprisonment as awarded by the High Court. Criminal Appeal 369 of 1969 preferred by the original Accused 1 is dismissed.
Alert