Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Indrajit C. Parekh Of Ahmedabad And Another v. State Of Gujarat And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Mar 18, 1975
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The first appellant is a director and shareholder of the second appellant-company, which holds a permanent lease over land in the Dariapur-Kazipur area of Ahmedabad (Survey Nos. 56-A, 56-B and 58). The Employees State Insurance Corporation (respondent 3) asked the State of Gujarat (respondent 1) to acquire several plots, including the appellant’s land, for construction of dispensaries under the Employees State Insurance Scheme (ESIS).

On 31 October 1958 the State sanctioned only a token contribution of Re 1 towards the cost of acquiring each plot. A preliminary notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was first issued on 13 December 1960 for about 3,000 sq yds of Survey No. 56-A, but it was withdrawn. A fresh Section 4 notification dated 16 March 1962 covered about 5,600 sq yds from the north-west corner of the same survey number. After considering objections (which were overruled), the State issued a Section 6 declaration on 20 August 1962 for 5,632 sq yds.

The appellants filed a writ petition in the Gujarat High Court challenging the Section 4 and Section 6 notifications. The High Court dismissed the petition. On a certificate of fitness, the appellants appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government’s acquisition of the appellants’ land was a colourable exercise of power because the Government failed to apply its mind to the statutory pre-conditions for issuing a declaration under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, particularly where only a token contribution of Re 1 was made from public revenues.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Government’s “satisfaction” required by Section 6 could be formed only after it had the “entire picture” before it; this did not occur, rendering the declaration invalid.
  • A nominal contribution of Re 1 indicated that the State did not genuinely intend to acquire the land at public expense, making the action colourable. Reliance was placed on an observation in Somavanti v. State of Punjab that a token contribution may, in some circumstances, reveal a colourable exercise of power.
  • Inconsistencies in the stated area of the land (3,000 sq yds in the first Section 4 notification, 5,600 sq yds in the second, and 5,632 sq yds in the Section 6 declaration) showed lack of application of mind to the extent of land really required.
  • The description of the land in the Section 6 declaration as 5,632 sq yds “from the north-west corner of the land” was vague.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Somavanti v. State of Punjab, AIR 1963 SC 151; (1963) 2 SCR 774 A token (nominal) State contribution can satisfy the proviso to Section 6(1), but its adequacy must be assessed on the facts; a nominal contribution may, in some cases, indicate colourable exercise of power. The Court reiterated that a token contribution meets the statutory requirement under Section 6(1); lack of substantial payment does not ipso facto invalidate an acquisition. No other legal infirmity was shown in the present facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that Section 6 requires governmental satisfaction, after considering any Section 5-A report, that the land is needed for a public purpose. The stated purpose—construction of an ESIS dispensary—was undeniably a public purpose, and nothing on record suggested that the Section 5-A report was ignored.

Addressing the reliance on Somavanti, the Court clarified that although a token contribution might in some contexts signal colourable action, the mere fact of a Re 1 contribution does not itself vitiate the acquisition. No other legal provision was identified that the contribution violated.

The differing measurements of the land (3,000 sq yds, 5,600 sq yds, 5,632 sq yds) were interpreted as evidence that the Government refined its assessment rather than acted casually. The description in the Section 6 declaration was held sufficiently precise because a detailed plan was available for public inspection.

Finding no circumstance suggesting non-application of mind or misuse of power, the Court rejected the allegation of colourable exercise.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed with costs.

Consequently, the Gujarat High Court’s dismissal of the writ petition stands affirmed, and the land acquisition proceedings may continue. The decision re-affirms that a nominal State contribution can satisfy the proviso to Section 6(1) of the Land Acquisition Act where the acquisition is otherwise valid; no new precedent was set beyond this confirmation.

Show all summary ...

A.C Gupta, J.— This appeal on a certificate of fitness granted by the High Court of Gujarat is directed against an order of the said High Court dismissing the writ petition filed by the appellants challenging two notifications under Section 4 and Section 6 respectively of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”).

2. The first appellant is a Director and shareholder of the second appellant, a company incorporated under the Indian Companies Act, 1930. The second appellant is the permanent lessee of a plot of land situated in Dariapur-Kazipur area of the city of Ahmedabad bearing Survey Nos. 56-A, 56-B and 58. Respondent 3, the Employees State Insurance Corporation, established under the Employees State Insurance Act, 1948 forwarded nine proposals to the first respondent. State of Gujarat for acquisition of certain plots of land, including Survey No. 56-P. of Dariapur-Kazipur. In regard to these proposals the first respondent, State of Gujarat, passed a resolution on October 31, 1968 according sanction to the payment of a nominal contribution of Re 1 for each proposal

“for the acquisition of the private plots of land required to be acquired for the construction of the necessary dispensaries for the Employees State Insurance Scheme at Ahmedabad under the Land Acquisition Act.”
The resolution directed that
“the extra expenditure on this account should be debited to ‘38 Medical E.S.I.S, (3) Schemes under the Second Five Year Plan’ and not from the sanctioned grants for the current year thereunder.”
On December 13, 1960 the first respondent notified under Section 4 of the Act that an approximate area of 3000 sq yds out of Survey No. 56-A in Dariapur-Kazipur was likely to be needed “for the public purpose, namely, for Employees State Insurance Scheme, Ahmedabad at Dariapur-Kazipur, Taluka City”. However, on March 16, 1962 this notification was withdrawn and another notification under Section 4 of the Act was issued stating that an approximate area of 5600 sq yds from the north- west comer of the same Survey No. 56-A was likely to be needed for the public purpose of “Construction of dispensary building and other institutions connected with the E.S.I Scheme”. It appears that on July 31, 1962 the State of Gujarat passed a fresh resolution in respect of Plot No. 56-A sanctioning a nominal contribution of Re. 1 for its acquisition for the aforesaid public purpose and directing that the
“expenditure should be debited to the Budget Head ‘29-L Medical Employees’ State Insurance Scheme' and should be met from the grants sanctioned thereunder during the current financial year.”
As already stated, the earlier resolution covered nine proposals for acquisition including Plot No. 56-P which seems to be a mistake for 56-A. The appellants' objections to the proposed acquisition were overruled and on August 20, 1962 a declaration under Section 6 of the Act was made stating that after considering the report of the Collector under sub-section (2) of Section 5-A of the Act the Government of Gujarat was satisfied that 5632 sq yds of land from the north-west comer of Survey 56-A was needed to be acquired at the public expense for construction of dispensary building and other institutions connected with the ESI Scheme, Ahmedabad, which was a public purpose. The declaration added that a plan of the land was available for inspection at the office of the Special Land Acquisition Officer, (ESI) Scheme, Ahmedabad. The appellants filed a writ petition in the High Court of Gujarat challenging the said two notifications under Section 4 and Section 6 of the Act. The High Court having dismissed the petition, the appellants have preferred this appeal.

3. The only point pressed before us on behalf of the appellants is that the acquisition of the land in question is a case of colourable exercise of power as the State Government did not apply its mind to matters in respect of which it ought to have been satisfied before the declaration under Section 6 of the Act was made. Section 6 of the Act as it stood at the relevant time was in these terms:

“6. Declaration that land is required for a public purpose.—(1) Subject to the provisions of part VII of this Act, when the appropriate Government is satisfied after considering the report, if any, made under Section 5-A, sub-section (2), that any particular land is needed for a public purpose, or for a company, a declaration shall be made to that effect under the signature of a Secretary to such Government or of some officer duly authorised to certify its orders:
Provided that no such declaration shall be made unless the compensation to be awarded for such property is to be paid by a company, or wholly or partly out of public revenues or some fund controlled or managed by a local authority.”
It was contended that the satisfaction of the Government which is a prerequisite to a declaration under Section 6 could be reached only, as counsel for the appellants put it, “after the entire picture was before the Government”. But the “picture” till the stage is composed of only the notification under Section 4 and the report, if any, made under Section 5-A(2) of the Act. Section 4(1) of the Act reads:
“4. Publication of preliminary notification and powers of officers thereupon.—(1) Whenever it appears to the appropriate Government that land in any locality is needed or is likely to be needed for any public purpose, a notification to that effect shall be published in the Official Gazette, and the Collector shall cause public notice of the substance of such notification to be given at convenient places in the said locality.
* * *”
Therefore, it must appear to the Government that the land sought to be acquired is needed or is likely to be needed for a public purpose before a notification under Section 4 is published. Section 6 requires that before a declaration under that section is made the Government must be satisfied that the land is needed for a public purpose after considering the report, if any, made by the Collector under Section 5-A containing his recommendations on the objections made by the persons interested in the land. It is not disputed that the stated purpose of the acquisition is a public purpose. There is also nothing on record of this case to suggest that the Government did not consider the report under Section 5-A. The learned counsel for the appellants based his submissions on an observation made in the judgment of the majority in Somavanti v. State of Punjab AIR 1963 SC 151, (1963) 2 SCR 774, (1963) 33 Com Cas 745. In that case, this Court held that the expression, “partly out of public revenues” in the proviso to Section 6(1) did not necessarily mean that the Government's contribution must be substantial but contribution of only token amounts towards the cost of acquisition would satisfy the requirement of the proviso. Learned counsel however relied on the following passage in the judgment:
“We would however guard ourselves against being understood to say that a token contribution by the State towards the cost of acquisition will be sufficient compliance with the law in each and every case. Whether such contribution meets the requirements of the law would depend upon the facts of every case. Indeed the fact that the State's contribution is nominal may well indicate in particular circumstances that the action of the State was a colourable exercise of power.”
In view of the decision in this case that a nominal contribution out of public revenues would satisfy the requirement of the proviso to Section 6(1) the observation “whether such contribution meets the requirement of the law would depend upon the facts of every case” must necessarily be taken to refer to the requirement of some law other than the proviso to Section 6(1). No such law was pointed out to us; and it is not necessary for the purposes of this appeal to enter on a discussion as to what such other law could be. Clearly, a token contribution by the State does not ipso facto validate the acquisition, and it was contended that there are certain circumstances in this case which together with the fact that the State's contribution was only one rupee indicated that the Government did not really apply its mind to the proposal for acquisition, and the acquisition was thus a colourable exercise of power. The circumstances pointed but in support of this contention are these. In the notification under Section 4 of the Act issued on December 13, 1960 the area of the land proposed to be acquired was stated as “part of Survey No. 56-A measuring about 3000 sq yds”. As mentioned already this notification was withdrawn and a fresh notification under Section 4 was published on March 16, 1962 wherein the area was described as 5600 sq. yds. from the north-west corner of Survey No. 56-A. In the declaration under Section 6 the area was stated as 5632 sq yds from the northwest comer of Survey No. 56-A. It was argued that the fact that the area was differently stated in the two notifications under Section 4 and in the declaration under Section 6 as 3000 sq yds, 5600 sq yds and 5632 sq yds respectively showed that the Government did not apply its mind to the extent of the requirement which again suggested lack of serious application of the mind as to the purpose of the acquisition. We do not agree; on the contrary, the difference in the area as stated in the notifications under Section 4 and in the declaration under Section 6 indicates that the State Government was careful about the exact area that was likely to be needed for the purpose for which it was being acquired. It was also sought to be argued that the description of the land in the declaration under Section 6 as 5632 sq yds “from the north-west comer of the land” was vague. But this objection was never raised at any stage; further, the declaration under Section 6 stated that a plan of the land was open for inspection at the office of the Special Land Acquisition Officer and in the plan the area proposed to be acquired must have been clearly demarcated.

4. We do not find any merit in the appeal which is accordingly dismissed with costs.