Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Punjab And Others v. M/S Subhash Trading Company. .

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 20, 1975
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Four appeals were filed by the State of Punjab and its assessing authorities against different assessee-respondents. The lead matter, Civil Appeal No. 2235 of 1970, concerned Subhash Trading Company, a registered dealer in Jagraon (District Ludhiana) under the Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948 (“the Act”).

The respondent purchased unginned cotton, performed ginning, and sold the resulting ginned cotton (approximately one-third of the weight) and cotton seeds (approximately two-thirds). For the assessment year 1961-62 it declared a gross purchase turnover of about Rs. 4 lakh, treating the entire purchase price of unginned cotton as deductible under Section 5(2)(a)(vi) of the Act on the footing that the finished products were sold to registered dealers in the course of inter-State trade.

On 16 March 1964 the Assessing Authority, Ludhiana, allowed the deduction only to the extent of one-third (the value of ginned cotton). The assessee filed a writ petition before the Punjab & Haryana High Court; a learned Single Judge, relying on Patel Cotton Company Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Punjab, allowed the petition and directed modification of the assessment. A Letters Patent Appeal by the State was dismissed in limine. Certificates were granted, and the matters reached the Supreme Court, where they were heard together because they were, in substance, governed by the Court’s earlier judgment in State of Punjab v. Shakti Cotton Company.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the entire purchase price of unginned cotton is deductible from the gross turnover under Section 5(2)(a)(vi) of the Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948, or only the proportion attributable to ginned cotton.
  2. Whether, after the 1967 amending legislation and in light of the decision in Shakti Cotton Company, fresh assessments are required to be framed under Section 11-AA of the Act.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Punjab v. Shakti Cotton Company (1972) 2 SCR 289; (1972) 1 SCC 88 Laid down the post-amendment scheme for assessment of declared goods and directed that reassessments be made under Section 11-AA. Treated as controlling; the present appeals were ordered to be disposed of strictly in accordance with its directions.
State of Punjab v. Chandu Lal Kishori Lal (1969) 3 SCR 849; (1969) 1 SCC 695 Held that the price of cotton seeds is deductible from the purchase turnover of unginned cotton. Referenced as covering, “simpliciter”, the deduction question concerning cotton seeds.
Bhawani Cotton Mills Ltd. v. State of Punjab (1967) 3 SCR 577; AIR 1967 SC 1616; (1967) 20 STC 290 Declared earlier assessment provisions of the Act defective and invalid. Forms part of the historical context leading to the 1967 Amendment and Validation Act.
Rattan Lal & Co. v. Assessing Authority (1969) 2 SCR 544; AIR 1970 SC 1742; (1970) 25 STC 136 Upheld the constitutional validity of the Punjab General Sales Tax (Amendment & Validation) Act, 1967. Cited to confirm that the amended Section 11-AA provides a valid machinery for fresh assessments.
Patel Cotton Company Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Punjab (1964) 15 STC 865 (P&H) Punjab & Haryana High Court decision recognising full deduction for unginned cotton purchases. Formed the basis of the Single Judge’s order in favour of the assessee, later modified by the Supreme Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court, speaking through N.L. Untwalia, J., noted that the factual matrix of the four appeals was “identical” to that in Shakti Cotton Company and that any distinctions suggested by the appellants’ counsel were “illusory.” The Court therefore applied the analytical framework already elaborated in Shakti Cotton Company, which had traced the legislative history from the original Act, through the defects identified in Bhawani Cotton Mills, to their cure by the 1967 Amending and Validation Act upheld in Rattan Lal.

Under the amended scheme, purchase tax on declared goods such as cotton is leviable at the stage of purchase by the “last dealer” (Section 5(3)(a)(2) of the Act as amended). Determining whether an assessee is that “last dealer” is a factual enquiry reserved for the Assessing Authority. Consequently, any prior assessments made without reference to the amended provisions or without this factual investigation were regarded as incomplete or legally vulnerable.

Because the High Court had merely directed modification of the assessments without specifying the governing statutory procedure, the Supreme Court clarified that reassessment must proceed under the special machinery of Section 11-AA (inserted by the 1967 Amendment Act), and must follow the interpretative guidance furnished in Shakti Cotton Company.

Holding and Implications

Appeals disposed of with directions for fresh assessments. The Court modified the High Court’s order only to state that “in all these cases fresh assessments will have to be made under Section 11-AA … in the light of the judgment of this Court in Shakti Cotton Company.” No order for costs was made.

Implications: The matters are remanded to the Assessing Authority for de novo assessments consistent with Section 11-AA and the principles set out in Shakti Cotton Company. The judgment does not create new substantive law but reinforces the binding effect of the earlier Supreme Court decision and ensures uniform application of the 1967 amendment.

Show all summary ...

N.L Untwalia, J.— All these four appeals by the State of Punjab and others against the different assessee respondents are covered by the decision of this Court in State of Punjab v. Shakti Cotton Company (1972) 2 SCR 289, (1972) 1 SCC 88 and have got to be disposed of in accordance with the said decision. Since the learned Counsel for the appellants endeavoured to draw a distinction between the facts of the aforesaid cases and those in the instant appeals, we shall briefly state the facts of one of the appeals i.e Civil Appeal No. 2235 of 1970 and show that the distinction sought to be made is illusory.

2. Subhash Trading Company the respondent in Civil Appeal No. 2235 of 1970 was carrying on business at Jagraon in the district of Ludhiana. It was a dealer registered under the Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948 — hereinafter called the Act. The company amongst others used to carry on the business of purchasing unginned cotton and after ginning the same used to sell the ginned cotton and the cotton seeds. Roughly speaking, the proportion of the two products was one-third and two-third, that is to say, out of 3 maunds of unginned cotton were produced one maund of ginned cotton and two maunds of cotton seeds. For the year 1961-62 the company submitted a return under the Act showing the figure of gross purchase turnover at Rs4 lakhs and odd, which included the purchase figure of unginned cotton. The assessee claimed that it had sold the entire ginned cotton and cotton seeds produced out of the unginned cotton to registered dealers and in course of inter-State trade and commerce. It, therefore, claimed deduction of the entire amount of the price of unginned cotton from its gross turnover under Section 5(2)(a)(vi) of the Act. The assessing authority, Ludhiana by its assessment order dated March 16, 1964 allowed deduction to the extent of one-third only that is to say in respect of the price of ginned cotton. The company filed a writ petition in the Punjab & Haryana High Court and challenged the order of the assessing authority as being without jurisdiction and illegal. The learned Single Judge of the High Court disposed of the writ petition by his order dated January 29, 1965 passed in the following terms:

“The point involved in this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution stands concluded by a Bench decision of this Court in Patel Cotton Company Private Ltd. v. State of Punjab (1964) 15 STC 865 (Punj). The petition is consequently allowed and the assessing authority is directed to modify the order and give such relief as may be permissible in accordance with the law laid down by the Division Bench.”

Letters Patent appeal filed by the appellants was dismissed in limine by a Division Bench of the High Court. The facts of the other appeals are identical. All the appeals were filed by certificate of the High Court.

3. The entire history of the law involved in these appeals, its implications and effect have been very elaborately considered by this Court in the case of Shakti Cotton Company. The said company had filed a writ application in the year 1964 in the High Court, to challenge the assessment order passed on September 26, 1963. The assessee had claimed the entire amount of the purchase price of unginned cotton as deductible under Section 5(2)(a)(vi) of the Act and had also challenged the legality of the assessment. A question, simpliciter, as to whether the price of cotton seeds was deductible from the purchase turnover of unginned cotton was fully covered by the decision of this Court in State of Punjab v. Chandu Lal Kishori Lal (1969) 3 SCR 849, (1969) 1 SCC 695. But the legality of the assessment under the Act as it stood at the time of the passing of the assessment orders was challenged with success in the case of Bhawani Cotton Mills Ltd v. State of Punjab (1967) 3 SCR 577, AIR 1967 SC 1616, (1967) 20 STC 290. The defect in the said law, as pointed out by this Court in the said case, was rectified by issuance of two ordinances followed by Punjab General Sales Tax (Amendment and Validation) Act, 1967 (Act 7 of 1967). The validity of the amending law was upheld by this Court in Rattan Lal & Co. v. Assessing Authority (1969) 2 SCR 544, AIR 1970 SC 1742, (1970) 25 STC 136. After tracing the entire history of the law, Vaidialingam, J. delivering the judgment of this Court in the case of Shakti Cotton Company pointed out at p. 302:

“It will be seen from the amendments, referred to above, that an entirely new scheme, so as to say, has been evolved in the matter of assessment to sales tax of declared goods. In the case before us, we are concerned with “cotton” which is an item of “declared goods” under the Central Act. There is no controversy that purchase tax is to be levied in respect of the said commodity. Under the new sub-section (3) clause (a) sub-clause (2) of Section 5 of the Act, in the case of purchase tax, the levy is to be at the stage of purchase of such goods by the last dealer. Therefore, the question whether the assessee comes under this clause, for levy of purchase tax, which is a question of fact, will have to be investigated.”

4. The orders made in the case of Shakti Cotton Company were in these terms:

“We have already pointed out that in all the appeals, except in Civil Appeal No. 1466 of 1969, the learned Single Judge has directed the assessing authority to reconsider and vary the order of assessment. That direction has been confirmed by the Letters Patent Bench in the said appeals. Those directions, in our opinion, do not require any interference by this Court, except to make it clear that the fresh assessments will have to be made under Section 11-AA of the Amendment Act, and subject to the directions contained in this judgment.”

5. In our opinion all the present appeals have also got to be disposed of in identical terMs The directions given by the learned Single Judge are to be modified only to this extent that in all these cases fresh assessments will have to be made under Section 11-AA as introduced in the Act by the Amendment Act in the light of the judgment of this Court in the case of Shakti Cotton Company . The appeals are accordingly disposed of in the manner stated above. There will be no order as to costs in any of the appeals.”