- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dilip Kumar Gon v. Durga Prasad Singh .
Factual and Procedural Background
Durga Prasad Singh, Khatir Ali, and Abdul Hamid submitted nomination papers to contest the 1972 election for the Bihar Legislative Assembly from 147-Jamtara Assembly Constituency (General). On February 9, 1972, the Returning Officer rejected the nomination papers of Khatir Ali and Abdul Hamid. Consequently, Durga Prasad Singh was declared elected.
An elector of the constituency (the present appellant) filed an Election Petition challenging Durga Prasad Singh’s election on the ground that the Returning Officer had improperly rejected the nomination papers of Abdul Hamid and Khatir Ali. A single judge of the High Court dismissed the petition, holding that the defects in the nomination papers were substantial. The appellant appealed to the Supreme Court of India.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the omission by Abdul Hamid—contesting for a General (non-reserved) seat—to delete references to “Scheduled Caste” in the nomination form constituted a defect in law.
- If such omission was a defect, whether it was of a “substantial character” justifying rejection of the nomination papers under the Representation of the People Act, 1951.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The “defect” relied on by the Returning Officer—failure to delete the words “Scheduled Caste” and to specify a caste—was not a defect in law for a candidate contesting a General constituency.
- Even if considered a defect, it was not of a substantial character and therefore could not warrant rejection of the nomination papers.
Respondent's Arguments
This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Amolak Chand v. Raghuveer Singh, AIR 1968 SC 1203; (1968) 3 SCR 246 | A candidate contesting a General constituency is under no statutory obligation to declare his caste; mention of caste in Form 2-A is superfluous for General seats. | Relied upon to hold that Abdul Hamid’s failure to delete “Scheduled Caste” or specify a caste did not constitute a legal defect, much less a substantial one, warranting rejection. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court found that Jamtara was a General constituency, not a reserved seat. Under Section 33(2) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, the statutory requirement to declare caste or tribe applies only to candidates for reserved constituencies. Consequently, failure to delete “Scheduled Caste” in the nomination form did not violate any legal mandate for a General seat.
The Court noted the Returning Officer’s own admission that he knew Abdul Hamid was not a member of a Scheduled Caste and that Hamid had deposited the required security. Hence, the omission was a procedural irregularity without legal consequence. Relying on Amolak Chand v. Raghuveer Singh, the Court held that the defect was neither existent in the eye of law nor of a substantial character.
Therefore, the High Court’s affirmation of the Returning Officer’s decision was “manifestly erroneous.”
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal and the Election Petition are allowed; the election of Durga Prasad Singh is declared void due to improper rejection of Abdul Hamid’s nomination papers. Costs awarded to the appellant throughout.
Implications: The decision voids the returned candidate’s election and underscores that, for General constituencies, failure to delete references to “Scheduled Caste/Tribe” in Form 2-A cannot be treated as a substantial defect. The ruling reaffirms existing precedent but does not establish a new principle of law.
R.S Sarkaria, J.— Durga Prasad Singh, respondent herein, Khatir Ali and Abdul Hamid, filed their nomination papers before the Returning Officer for contesting the election to the Bihar Legislative Assembly from 147-Jamtara Assembly Constituency (General). The date for scrutiny of the nomination papers was February 9, 1972. The Returning Officer rejected the nomination papers of Khatir Ali and Abdul Hamid ignoring the objections that were raised on their behalf. Durga Prasad Singh was declared duly elected.
2. The appellant, an elector of the Constituency, filed an Election Petition challenging the election of Durga Prasad Singh inter alia on the ground that the nomination papers of Abdul Hamid and Khatir Ali had been improperly rejected. A learned Single Judge of the High Court who tried the petition decided that issue against the petitioner, and in consequence, dismissed the petition. Hence this appeal.
3. Before us, Mr R.K Garg, learned counsel for the appellant has confined his arguments to the rejection of the nomination paper of Abdul Hamid only. It is submitted that the defect on the basis of which the Returning Officer rejected Abdul Hamid's nomination papers, was not a defect in the eye of law. At any rate, proceeds the argument, it was not a defect of a substantial character which could notify rejection of the nomination papers.
4. There is merit in this contention.
5. What happened was that in the column of the printed nomination form, meant for making a declaration of the candidates of the Scheduled Caste/Tribe contesting for a Reserved Seat, Abdul Hamid had not (a) filed his specific caste in the blank meant for that purpose and further (b) he had in that column, left the words “Scheduled Caste” unscored. The Returning Officer rejected the nomination papers on the ground that the failure of the candidate to delete the words “Scheduled Caste” means that “he belongs to Scheduled Caste which is not true” and consequently, “the nomination papers are not filled up properly”.
6. The learned Judge of the High Court upheld this rejection, holding that “the candidate's filling of these entries were on the face of it, not proper and did not comply with the requirements of law on this subject” and further that this defect was not “trivial or technical” but of a substantial character.
7. In our opinion, in the circumstances of the case, the rejection of the nomination papers of Abdul Hamid was manifestly erroneous. The High Court's view that in scoring out only the word “Jan-Jati” (tribe) and leaving the word “Jati” (caste) untouched in the aforesaid column of the nomination form, Abdul Hamid had failed “to comply with the requirement of the law on the subject” was entirely misconceived. It overlooked the fact that the Jamtara Constituency was a “General” Constituency, and the seat for which the candidates wanted to contest the election was not a Reserved seat. Section 33(2) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, or any other statutory provision does not enjoin upon a candidate who is contesting the election for a General seat and not for a Reserved seat, to specify in his declaration his caste or tribe. Further, the Returning Officer appearing as RW 2, had clearly admitted that at the time of the scrutiny of the nomination papers, he was aware that Abdul Hamid was not a member of the Scheduled Caste and that he had deposited Rs 250 as security. The omission to strike off the column in the printed nomination form relating to Scheduled Caste/Tribe did not amount to a defect in the eye of law, much less was it a defect of a substantial character, warranting rejection of the nomination papers. In Amolak Chand v. Raghuveer Singh AIR 1968 SC 1203, (1968) 3 SCR 246 the nomination papers of two candidates contesting for a General Constituency were rejected on a similar ground. Holding that the rejection was improper, Ramaswami, J. speaking for the Court stated the law on the point thus:
“The printed Form 2-A is meant both for General and Reserved Constituencies but while it is obligatory for candidates in the reserved constituency to make a declaration in the proper column that he is a member of a particular caste or tribe, there is no such rule with regard to General Constituency. Section 33(2) of the Act imposes an obligation on the candidate in the reserved constituency to make a declaration in the proper column, but there is no such direction in the statute with regard to the General Constituency. In our opinion, the mention of the caste of the candidate in the nomination form was a clear superfluity because it was not necessary for the candidate to fill in the column when he was contesting in a General Constituency.”
8. In the light of what has been said above, we would, reverse the finding of the High Court and hold that the nomination papers of Abdul Hamid were improperly rejected by the Returning Officer.
9. In the result, we would on this short ground, allow this appeal and the Election Petition and declare the election of Durga Prasad Singh, respondent herein to be void. The appellant shall have his costs throughout.
Alert