Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Patiraji (Smt) v. Mamta And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Mar 15, 1973
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns agricultural land at Bibiganj, District Sultanpur, Uttar Pradesh. Ram Adhar and the respondents were recorded co-tenants. Upon Ram Adhar’s death on 24 February 1949, the appellant, Smt. Patiraji, sought a declaration under the U.P. Tenancy Act, 1939 that she, as his widow, had become a co-tenant. Although successful before the Assistant Collector, she lost in appeal before the Additional Commissioner and then the Board of Revenue (1 July 1954), which found she was not Ram Adhar’s widow.

Meanwhile, the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950 (“the Act”) came into force on 1 July 1952. Relying on an entry in the khasra for Fasli year 1356 (1 July 1948 – 30 June 1949) showing her in occupation from 24 February 1949, Patiraji instituted the present suit under Sections 20(b) and 232 of the Act, claiming Adhivasi rights and seeking possession.

The trial court dismissed the suit; the Additional Commissioner allowed her appeal and decreed possession; the Board of Revenue affirmed that decision. The respondents’ writ petition was allowed by a Single Judge of the Allahabad High Court, who held the entry covered only part of the year and therefore conferred no Adhivasi status. A special appeal was dismissed in limine on 31 October 1966. The present appeal came before the Supreme Court by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Section 20(b)(i) of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950, a person recorded as an “occupant” for only part of Fasli year 1356 is entitled to Adhivasi rights in the land.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Her name was recorded in the khasra of Fasli 1356 as an occupant from 24 February 1949; such an entry, by virtue of Section 20(b)(i), automatically confers Adhivasi status.
  • Consequently, she was unlawfully dispossessed by the respondents and entitled to restoration of possession.
  • It was suggested that she ought to be deemed a joint occupant with Ram Adhar for the whole year.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The khasra entry covers only a part of Fasli 1356 and therefore does not satisfy Section 20(b)(i).
  • The appellant was previously held not to be Ram Adhar’s widow and cannot rely on heirship.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shyam Sunar Lal v. Mangali, 1963 ALJ 286 Section 20(b)(i) benefits only those recorded as occupants for the entire Fasli 1356. Cited to reinforce the settled interpretation adopted by the High Court and Board of Revenue.
Ram Chander v. Chhotu, 1957 ALJ 24 Same principle as above. Used to show consistent judicial approach denying rights to partial-year occupants.
Girdhari v. Raghubir Singh, 1958 ALJ 183 Same principle as above. Further authority supporting the High Court’s view adopted by the Supreme Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice Y.V. Chandrachud, speaking for the Court, emphasised that Section 20(b)(i) grants special rights—even to trespassers—only on a strictly defined condition: being “recorded as occupant” for the whole of Fasli 1356. Any broader reading would:

  • Contradict the plain language of the statute.
  • Encourage successive trespassers to seize possession briefly in hopes of qualifying for valuable rights.
  • Render the provision administratively unworkable, because the revenue records (prepared after three seasonal inspections each year) often show different occupants at different times.

The Court explained the land-recording procedure under the Uttar Pradesh Land Records Manual, noting that transient possession frequently appears in the “remarks” column of the khasra. Recognising each such possessor would, in the Court’s view, “set the pace for lawlessness.”

The uniform jurisprudence of the Allahabad High Court and the Board of Revenue—illustrated by the cited cases—confines Adhivasi status to those recorded for the entire year. The Board of Revenue’s contrary decision in this case was attributed to its erroneous assumption that Patiraji was Ram Adhar’s sole heir, a finding already rejected in earlier proceedings.

The khasra entry itself stated that the appellant was in occupation only “from 24 February 1949,” unmistakably less than the whole Fasli year (1 July 1948 – 30 June 1949). A belated contention that she had been a joint occupant throughout the year lacked evidentiary support and had never been raised earlier.

Holding and Implications

Appeal dismissed with costs; the judgment of the Allahabad High Court is affirmed.

The immediate effect is that Smt. Patiraji is denied Adhivasi rights and cannot regain possession from the respondents. Beyond the parties, the decision ratifies and strengthens the prevailing interpretation that Section 20(b)(i) protects only those occupants recorded for the full Fasli 1356 year, thereby discouraging transient possession and potential abuse of the statute.

Show all summary ...

Y.V Chandrachud, J.— The question which arises for consideration in this appeal is whether the appellant Patiraji is entitled to the “Adhivasi” rights under Section 20(b)(i) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950 (“the Act”).

2. One Ram Adhar and the respondents were co-tenants of certain lands situated at Bibiganj, District Sultanpar. On the death of Ram Adhar on February 24, 1949 the appellant took proceedings under the U.P Tenancy Act, 1939 for a declaration that she was the widow of Ram Adhar and as such, had become a co-tenant along with the respondents. The appellant succeeded before the Assistant Collector but in appeal, the Additional Commissioner and then the Board of Revenue took a contrary view, holding that the appellant was not the widow of Ram Adhar. The judgment of the Board of Revenue is dated July 1, 1954.

3. In the meanwhile, the Act had come into force on July 1, 1952. The appellant then brought the present suit, treated as one under Section 20(b) read with Section 232 of the Act. The case of the appellant is that her name was recorded as an occupant in the Khasra of 1356-F, that she has therefore become an Adhivasi under Section 20(b)(i) and is consequently entitled to possession of the lands from which she was unlawfully dispossessed by the respondents. The trial court dismissed the suit but the Additional Commissioner allowed Patiraji's appeal and decreed her suit. Respondents carried an appeal against the decision of the Additional Commissioner to the Board of Revenue but that appeal was dismissed. The respondents then filed a writ petition in the High Court of Allahabad, which was allowed by a learned Single Judge of that Court. He held that the entry in favour of the appellant appeared in the Khasra of 1356-F for a part of the year only and therefore she was not entitled to the Adhivasi rights. Special Appeal No. 344 of 1956 against that judgment was dismissed by a Division Bench in limine on October 31, 1966. This is an appeal by special leave against that decision.

4. The sole foundation of the appellant's claim is an entry which appears in the Khasra of 1356-F, which is to the following effects:

“Ram Adhar Pandey Bakasht Waris Baqa Biz Smt Patiraji Motwaffi Bewa Ram Adhar Pandey Tarikh February 24, 1949 Se., that is to say ‘Ram Adhar Pandey in cultivation heir in possession Smt Patraji widow of deceased Ram Adhar Pandey from February 24, 1949’.”
The importance of this entry consists in the special benefit which such entries confer under Section 20(b)(i) of the Act:
“20. Every person who....
(b) was recorded as occupant
(i) of any land … in the Khasra or Khatauni of 1356-F ... shall ... be called Adhivasi of the land and shall, subject to the provisions of this Act, be entitled to take or retain possession thereof.”
None of the four explanations to Section 20 is relevant for the present purpose.

5. Looking at the provision contained in Section 20(b)(i), it seems to us plain that the Adhivasi rights can be claimed by those persons only who are recorded as occupants for the whole of the Fasli year 1356. It is important to remember that the rights conferred by Section 20(b)(i) are available even and mostly to trespassers. Clearly therefore, there is, in the first instance, no justification for construing the provision with greater liberality than the language warrants. Special rights conferred by the Act ought to be subject to the special limitations imposed by the Act.

6. Apart from this aspect, any other view of Section 20(b)(i) would make it unworkable in practice and would set the pace for lawlessness amongst trespassers. If different persons are in occupation of a land during different parts of the year, whom shall the court recognise as an Adhivasi and by what test shall the court pick and choose? Under the Uttar Pradesh Land Records Manual, the Lekhpal, has to make three field-to-field inspections of every village in his halka, beginning respectively on August 15, January 15 and April 15 of every year. (Rule A-55.) On the basis of these inspections, the Lekhpal has to make entries in the “Khasra”, that is to say in the field-book, in Form No. P-A-3 (Rule A-60). If a person other than a tenure-holder as classified in Part I or Part II of the Khatauni, is found to be in actual occupation, his name is to be recorded in the “Remarks” column (column 24) as “baqabza so and so” (Rule A-71, para 3). It may so happen, and decided cases show that it does so happen, that different persons are found to be in possession of a land at the time of the tri-annual inspections. The Lekhpal has to enter their names as occupants, may be in the remarks column, but the picture emerging at the close of the year will reveal that different persons were in occupation of the land — some one during the Kharif season, some one during the Rabi season and some one probably taking charge, on the sly, of a bona vacantia. When the true owner is away, the trespassers will play and the law which governs them is might is right. It cannot be the policy of the Act that everyone of these fleeting trespassers must find recognition and be made eligible for the acquisition of Adhivasi rights. None of them, in our opinion, can qualify for these valuable rights. It was urged that the last entry-holder should be recognised as an occupant to the exclusion of others but there is neither logic nor good sense in such a course. The last holder may have been in possession for a fractional part of the year and such possession may adventitiously coincide with the April visit of the Lekhpal. Besides, such a construction, as said already, will only encourage greater lawlessness amongst trespassers. Every one of them will make a frantic attempt to be last in the queue.

7. Rightly therefore, the High Court of Allahabad and the Board of Revenue, U.P have been uniformly taking the view that the right conferred by Section 20(b)(i) can be availed of by those persons only who are recorded as occupants for the entire Fasli year 1356 and not by those who are recorded as occupants for a part of the year. (See Shyam Sunar Lal v. Mangali 1963 ALJ 286, Ram Chander v. Chhotu; 1957 ALJ 24 (Rev) Girdhari v. Raghubir Singh etc. 1958 ALJ 183 (Rev)) It would seem that the Board of Revenue struck a discordant note in the instant case only, but it is necessary to point out that the Board rested its decision on the circumstance that the appellant was the “sole heir” of Ram Adhar. In making that assumption the Board was in error, because in the earlier proceedings it was held that the appellant was not the widow of Ram Adhar and she traced no other line of heirship.

8. It is clear from the entry on which the appellant relies that her name was entered as an occupant as from February 24, 1949. The Fasli year 1356 commenced on July 1, 1948 and ended on June 30, 1949. As the entry does not show that the appellant was in occupation of the land throughout the year, she is not entitled to the Adhivasi rights under Section 20(b)(i) of the Act.

9. Some attempt was made to contend that the appellant was shown as a joint occupant along with Ram Adhar during the lifetime of the latter and therefore she must be held to have been in possession for the whole year. An uncertified copy of the entry to which counsel drew our attention does not bear out this submission and in fact such a contention was never raised at any earlier stage.

10. In the result we confirm the judgment of the High Court and dismiss the appeal with costs.