- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jugal Kishore Mandal And Others v. Fani Bhushan Kundu And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The dispute concerns a 10-cottah parcel (Plot No. 571 of Khatian No. 649, Mouza Belgachia Kismat, District Howrah). Originally owned by the Bagchi family, the entire holding—including an adjoining plot not in issue—was sold to Purushottam Sonar on 21 September 1927. On 28 August 1928 Purushottam mortgaged the property to the firm Shewpujanrai Indrashankarrai (“Shewpujan”). The mortgage was enforced: a preliminary decree for sale (21 June 1931) was made final, and on 11 January 1932 Shewpujan purchased the holding in the court auction and was supposed to obtain possession on 3 March 1932.
A survey under the Bengal Tenancy Act around 1939 nevertheless recorded Purushottam as the possessor. The landlords (Sarat Kumar Roy and another) sued Purushottam in 1945 for rent (Suit No. 351/1945), obtained an ex parte decree, and sold the property in execution. Defendant 1, Fani Bhusan Kundu, purchased it and received possession on 13 December 1946. Attempts by both Shewpujan and Purushottam to set aside the sale under Section 174, Bengal Tenancy Act, failed.
After discovering a small encroachment, Fani Bhusan sued and recovered complete possession. Despite this, on 9 August 1949 Aswini Kumar Mandal (plaintiff) bought the property from Shewpujan and sought to dislodge Fani Bhusan. Section 145 CrPC proceedings in 1950 confirmed Fani Bhusan’s possession. Aswini Kumar then filed the present title suit (originally Suit No. 307/1950, later T.S. No. 2/1955) for declaration, injunction or, alternatively, possession. Both the trial court and first appellate court dismissed the suit; the High Court, in second appeal, affirmed those decisions. The present appeal to the Supreme Court was by special leave.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Plot No. 571 is agricultural (raiyati) land governed by the Bengal Tenancy Act, or “Niskar” homestead land outside its ambit.
- If the Bengal Tenancy Act applies, whether the 1945 rent suit and subsequent auction sale conferred valid title on Defendant 1, Fani Bhusan Kundu.
- Whether the plaintiff’s suit is barred by limitation because neither he nor his predecessor had possession within twelve years before the suit.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants’ Arguments
- The land is “Niskar” homestead, not agricultural; therefore the Bengal Tenancy Act does not apply.
- Because the Act does not apply, the 1945 rent suit against Purushottam Sonar and the resulting auction sale could pass no title to Fani Bhusan—Purushottam’s interest had already been lost in 1932 when Shewpujan purchased the property.
- Consequently, Aswini Kumar’s 1949 purchase from Shewpujan conveyed good title, entitling him to the declaration and possession sought.
Respondent’s Arguments
The opinion does not detail specific arguments advanced by the respondent.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court found no merit in the appellant’s contention that the land was non-agricultural.
- Presumptive value of record-of-rights: The 1939 survey recorded the land as “Danga Puratan Patit” (high arable fallow land) in the possession of Purushottam, liable to an annual rent of Rs 2/2. This entry carried statutory presumption which the appellant failed to rebut.
- Conduct of the parties: Objections by Shewpujan during the survey were overruled; neither he nor Aswini Kumar pursued further remedies or mutation, reinforcing the correctness of the survey entry.
- Documentary inconsistencies resolved: Although the 1932 sale certificate described the land as “Niskar”, earlier and later deeds (including the Bagchi sale deed and Aswini Kumar’s 1949 deed) acknowledged a rental obligation, confirming the agricultural character.
- Effect of the Bengal Tenancy Act: Because the land is raiyati, the landlords were entitled to sue the recorded tenant, Purushottam, for rent notwithstanding the 1932 auction purchase by Shewpujan, whose failure to mutate under Sections 13 and 18-A left Purushottam as the person “representing the holding”.
- Title of Defendant 1: The 1946 auction sale in execution of the rent decree conveyed good title to Fani Bhusan. Alternatively, Purushottam had perfected adverse possession by then, so Fani Bhusan’s purchase would succeed on that ground as well.
- Limitation: Neither Aswini Kumar nor Shewpujan had possession within twelve years preceding the 1950 suit; hence the claim was also time-barred.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS.
The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s decree, conclusively upholding Defendant 1’s title and possession and authorising him to withdraw the money deposited by the appellants in the Court. The decision turns on established principles of the Bengal Tenancy Act and limitation law; it sets no new precedent beyond applying those principles to the facts.
D.G Palekar, J.— This is an appeal by special leave from the judgment and decree passed in second appeal by the High Court at Calcutta. The appeal arises out of a suit filed by the original plaintiff Aswini Kumar Mandal for declaration of his title and for possession. The property involved is 10 Cottahs in extent recorded as Plot No. 571 of Khatian No. 649 of Mouza Belgachia Kismat in the District of Howrah.
2. The said property formed part of one holding. The other part comprised Plot No. 570 Khatian No. 558 with which we are not immediately concerned. The holding originally belonged to the Bagchis who sold it to one Purushottam Sonar on September 21, 1927, for a consideration of Rs 800. On August 28, 1928, Purushottam Sonar mortgaged the property to a firm named Shewpujanrai Indrashankarrai. Shewpujan enforced the mortgage and a preliminary decree for sale was passed in his favour on June 21, 1931. The decree was made final the same year and in execution of the decree the holding was purchased in court auction by Shewpujan on January 11, 1932. Possession was supposed to be taken on March 3, 1932. Aswini Kumar Mandal purchased the holding from Shewpujan on August 9, 1949. That is the title on which the plaintiff filed the suit.
3. It would appear from the records of the case that the holding was surveyed under the Bengal Tenancy Act sometime in 1939 and so far as the present suit is concerned Plot No. 571 of Khatian No. 649 was shown to be in the possession of Purushottam Sonar. Objections had been raised to the entries made in the records of rights at the time of the survey on behalf of Shewpujan but the objections were rejected and the name of Purushottam Sonar was confirmed in the records of rights as being in possession. The High Court agreeing with the finding of the first appellate court has held that in spite of the property being purchased in auction by Shewpujan in 1932 the possession of this plot continued to be with Purushottam Sonar. The landlords were Sarat Kumar Roy and another and though the record of rights shows that Purushottam Sonar was recorded as ‘Dhakalkar’ paying a rent of Rs 2/2 per annum it does not appear that any rent was paid. So the landlords brought rent Suit No. 351 of 1945 against Purushottam Sonar for recovery of rent and obtained an ex parte decree. In execution of the decree the property was sold in court auction and was purchased by Defendant 1, Fani Bhusan Kundu. The Court put him in possession on December 13, 1916. Shewpujan and Purushottam Sonar filed applications under Section 174 of the Bengal Tenancy Act for setting aside the sale. Ultimately the applications were rejected. In the meantime Defendant 1 Fani Bhusan found that one Hossaini Box was in possession of about half a Cottah out of the plot. Fani Bhusan filed a suit against Hossaini Box and got possession of the whole plot. Thus when Fani Bhusan was in possession, plaintiff Aswini Kumar purported to purchase the property from Shewpujan in 1949.
4. Aswini Kumar sought to disturb Fani Bhusan's possession and thereupon proceedings were started under Section 145 of the Criminal Procedure Code. In the summary proceedings the Magistrate found that Fani Bhusan was in possession and hence on July 24, 1950, orders were passed restoring possession to Fani Bhusan. Thereupon Aswini Kumar filed the suit which was originally numbered as Suit No. 307 of 1950 but was subsequently tried as Title Suit No. 2 of 1955 of the Munsif court at Howrah. The suit was for a declaration of plaintiff Aswini Kumar's title and for an injunction or, in the alternative, for possession.
5. The High Court agreeing with the appellate court held that neither Aswini Kumar nor his predecessor in title. Shewpujan had obtained possession of the property at any time. The possession was that of Purushottam Kumar (sic) in spite of his interest in the property being sold in the Court auction in 1932. It was further held that the land was revenue paying agricultural land to which the Bengal Tenancy Act applied. Since Purushottam Sonar who was in possession, failed to pay the rent, the landlords, who were made parties to the suit, were held to be entitled to file rent suit against Purushottam Sonar and take out the plot for sale in execution of the decree against him. It was true that Shewpujan had purchased the interest of Purushottam Sonar in 1932 but since, Shewpujan, the purchaser, had not made any attempt to mutate the firm's name in this landlord's Sherista and the name of Purushottam Sonar continued in the records, the landlords were entitled to file the suit against Purushottam as representing the holding. The auction purchase by Fani Bhusan in the court sale in execution of the rent decree against Purushottam Sonar gave title in respect of the plot to Fani Bhusan. In any case, it was further held that Purushottam Sonar had perfected his title by adverse possession at the time of the court auction in 1946 and that way too Fani Bhusan obtained a good title to the property. The subsequent purchase by Aswini Kumar from Shewpujan did not pass any title to him. Even assuming that Aswini Kumar obtained title by reason of the sale deed in his favour by Shewpujan his suit was barred by limitation as neither he nor his predecessor Shewpujan was in possession within 12 years before the suit.
6. Mr Sarjoo Prasad appearing on behalf of the appellants, who are the representatives of the original plaintiff Aswini Kumar, contended that the plot in suit was not agricultural or raiyati land but “Niskar” home-stead land. Therefore, it was submitted, the Bengal Tenancy Act did not apply to the land and, if that Act did not apply, the rent suit filed by the landlords in 1945 against Purushottam Sonar alone and the subsequent auction sale in favour of Fani Bhusan in that proceeding would convey no title to Fani Bhusan because Purushottam Sonar had none having lost it as far back as in 1932 when Shewpujan purchased the property in court auction. Mr Sarjoo Prasad does not dispute that if the land is held to be agricultural land to which the Bengal Tenancy Act applied, Purushottam Sonar would properly represent the holding in 1945 and the subsequent proceedings in the rent suit would be sufficient to legally transfer the interest in the holding in favour of Fani Bhusan. So the real question involved in the suit was whether the land was agricultural land for which rent had to be paid to the landlords and to which the Bengal Tenancy Act applied. The first appellate court and the High Court have come to the conclusion that it was raiyati land and not Niskar land and since Shewpujan had failed to get his name mutated in place of Purushottam Sonar in the landlord's Sherista it was open to the landlord to consider Purushottam Sonar alone as representing the holding and the suit against him in 1945 was perfectly in order.
7. We are satisfied that there is no force in Mr Sarjoo Prasad's argument that the plot was not agricultural land to which the Bengal Tenancy Act applied. We have already pointed out that survey was introduced sometime before 1939 and in the record of rights prepared at that time by the Survey Officer the plot was shown in the name of Purushottam Sonar as the Dakhalkar. The record further shows that the landlords were Sarat Kumar Roy and Sarat Kumar Mukhopadhya and the amount of rent payable was Rs 2/2. It was shown as Dag No. 71 in Khatian No. 649 and below the column “class of land” the land was classified as 1 Danga Puratan Patit. In the absence of any satisfactory evidence to the contrary the record of right will have presumptive value. It appears that when the land was being surveyed an objection had been raised on behalf of Shewpujan with regard to the possession of Purushottam Sonar but the same was overruled. No further action seems to have been taken by Shewpujan in this respect. “Danga Puratan Patit” means “high arable land which was fallow since olden days”. That clearly shows that the land was agricultural land. We have already noted that both Shewpujan and Purushottam Sonar had applied in 1947 to the court for setting aside the auction sale in favour of Fani Bhusan but without success. Those applications were under the Bengal Tenancy Act. Even in the plaint Aswini Kumar did not allege that the land was not governed by the Bengal Tenancy Act nor was any issue claimed in that respect. It would thus appear that the land was agricultural land to which the Bengal Tenancy Act applied. Reference was made to the sale certificate in favour of Shewpujan in which the land was shown as “Nishkar” or rent free land. But that was of little significance. In Bagchis' sale deed in favour of Purushottam Sonar it was mentioned that the land was in possession of the Bagchis in Mokarari Mourashi right which means a heritable right on payment of fixed lump sum rent. The land was not land in fee simple. On the other hand, in the sale deed obtained by Aswini Kumar from Shewpujan in 1949 the land was described as belonging to Jamai land of Purushottam Sonar bearing a rental of Rs 2/2. Two things are therefore clear. One is that the land was agricultural land and that the same was held on a sub-tenure under a superior holder. In these circumstances the mention in the sale certificate that it was Niskar land is of little value.
8. Being agricultural land to which the Bengal Tenancy Act applied neither Shewpujan nor his vendee Aswini Kumar could object to the auction sale of the property in execution of the rent decree against Purushottam Sonar in 1945. The landlord could not have recognized Shewpujan as the tenant as he had failed to mutate the tenancy in his own name in the landlord's Sherista under Section 13, read with Section 18-A of the Bengal Tenancy Act. The High Court agreeing with the first appellate court held that in spite of the auction sale in 1932 in favour of Shewpujan, Purushottam Sonar had continued to be in possession throughout till Respondent 1 Fani Bhusan obtained possession of the land through court in December, 1946. Thereafter Fani Bhusan filed a suit to eject Hossaini Box who has a hut in a small portion of the land and Fani Bhusan got complete possession of the land in suit. It was, thereafter in 1949 that Aswini Kumar purchased from Shewpujan which was nothing but a purchase of litigation. Aswini Kumar created trouble for Fani Bhusan and there was a proceeding under Section 145 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The Magistrate directed that possession should be restored to Fani Bhusan and at that stage Aswini Kumar filed the present suit in 1950. It is obvious that Aswini Kumar had not obtained possession under his sale deed and neither he nor his predecessor in title was in possession within 12 years of the suit. The title had already passed in favour of Fani Bhusan as a result of the auction sale in the rent execution proceedings. Aswini Kumar, therefore, obtained neither title nor possession within 12 years of the suit and hence it was rightly dismissed.
9. The appeal is dismissed with costs. Liberty to Respondent 1 to withdraw the amount deposited by the appellants in this Court.
Alert