Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shiv Singh v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 17, 1972
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Shiv Singh, the petitioner, was appointed as a Linesman in the Jullundur East Telegraph Engineering Division in 1954. On November 7, 1966, the Department reorganised two existing divisions—Jullundur East and Jullundur West—creating a third, the Ferozepur Telegraph Engineering Division. Several Linesmen working in the territory that became Ferozepur, including Kamta Prasad and eleven others (the “optees”), opted for transfer back to Jullundur East but could not be accommodated because of lack of vacancies.

On June 13, 1967, Shiv Singh and others were selected for promotion to Sub-Inspector in Jullundur East; Singh assumed the higher post on June 16, 1967. Subsequently, a union complaint revealed that the optees had not been considered for the 1967 promotion exercise in either division. Acting on this information, the Director of Telegraphs cancelled the 1967 selection on August 6, 1968, and ordered that the optees be considered.

The petitioner participated in an all-India postal strike on September 19, 1968, despite a ban issued under the Essential Services Maintenance Ordinance. A fresh selection board convened on July 5, 1969 selected the optees as Sub-Inspectors; those who had joined the strike, including Shiv Singh, were not considered. On July 7, 1969, the Divisional Engineer, Telegraphs East Division, formally approved the new selection and reverted the petitioner to his substantive post of Linesman.

Invoking Article 32 of the Constitution, the petitioner challenged the cancellation of his promotion and sought confirmation as Sub-Inspector. After initial hearing on September 20, 1972, the Supreme Court called for further affidavits; the matter was decided on the supplemented record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the optee Linesmen, who had opted for Jullundur East but were physically posted in Ferozepur Division, were “Linesmen in the Division” within the meaning of Rule 464 of the Posts and Telegraphs Manual and therefore eligible for promotion in Jullundur East in 1967.
  2. Whether the petitioner’s reversion and non-consideration in the 1969 selection were mala fide, having been motivated by his participation in the prohibited strike of September 19, 1968.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The optees were not “Linesmen in the Division” on the relevant date and were therefore ineligible for consideration; their later inclusion rendered the cancellation of the 1967 selection illegal.
  • His reversion and exclusion from the 1969 promotion list were mala fide and punitive, rooted solely in his participation in the strike.

The opinion does not detail any specific arguments advanced by the respondents.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Eligibility of the Optees (Issue 1): The Court interpreted the phrase “linesmen in the Division” in Rule 464 broadly. Because the optees had formally opted for Jullundur East in 1966 and an administrative directive required their eventual repatriation and inclusion in promotional exercises there, they were to be deemed Linesmen of Jullundur East for promotion purposes. Their exclusion from the 1967 selection rendered that selection invalid, justifying its cancellation. Hence, the petitioner acquired no vested right to confirmation.

Effect of Strike Participation (Issue 2): Strikes in the Posts and Telegraphs Department had been prohibited under the Essential Services Maintenance Ordinance. After the strike, the Ministry of Home Affairs issued an Office Memorandum (October 19, 1968) directing that adverse entries for strike participation would affect promotion or confirmation for five years. Although a June 16, 1969 order from the Director-General, Posts and Telegraphs, appeared more lenient, the Court held it was overridden by the Ministry’s binding memorandum. The Divisional Engineer’s admission that he followed this directive when excluding the petitioner showed compliance with governmental policy, not mala fides. Because the cancellation order pre-dated the strike and the later selection complied with the memorandum, the allegation of mala fide reversion failed.

Holding and Implications

Petition Dismissed.

The Supreme Court upheld the cancellation of the 1967 promotion and the petitioner’s reversion, finding no illegality or mala fide action. The immediate effect is that Shiv Singh remains a Linesman without retrospective confirmation as Sub-Inspector. The judgment turns on administrative interpretation and adherence to government directives; it sets no new precedent beyond affirming that departmental orders consistent with higher-level government memoranda must be followed.

Show all summary ...

S.N Dwivedi, J.— It is a petition under Article 32 of the Constitution. The petitioner, Shiv Singh, challenges the order of the Divisional Engineer, Telegraphs East Division, Jullundur, the third respondent, dated July 7, 1969 and prays for his confirmation to the post of the Sub-Inspector in the scale of Rs 105-155.

2. This case was first heard on September 20, 1972. The Court adjourned the further hearing of the petition and directed the respondents to file a further affidavit with respect to certain matters. The respondents have now filed an affidavit. The petitioner has filed an affidavit in reply and the respondents have also filed a rejoinder affidavit.

3. Facts of the case are now abundantly clear. At one time there were two Divisions, called the Jullundur East and Jullundur West Telegraphs Engineering Divisions. Jullundur East Telegraph Engineering Division will hereinafter be called as Jullundur East. The petitioner was employed as a Linesman in Jullundur East in 1954. On November 7, 1966, there was reorganisation of the aforesaid two Divisions, and a new Division was created. The new Division was called the Ferozepur Telegraph Engineering Division. On the eve of the aforesaid reorganisation and establishment of a new Division, Kamta Prasad and eleven other respondents were working as Linesmen within the area which became the newly created Ferozepur Telegraph Engineering Division. They opted for Jullundur East. But they could not be posted in Jullundur East for want of vacancies.

4. The petitioner along with certain other linesmen was selected for the post of Sub-Inspector by the Divisional Engineer Telegraphs, Jullundur East on June 13, 1967. He was appointed as Sub-Inspector with effect from June 16, 1967. A similar selection for the post of Sub-Inspector was, it appears, held in the Jullundur Telegraph Engineering Division. But Kamta Prasad and others were considered for promotion neither there nor in Jullundur East. The Circle Secretary, All India Telegraph Engineering Employees Union and Linesmen Staff and Class III Union, Jullundur Branch, complained to the Postmaster General, Punjab Circle, by letter, dated May 28, 1968 that the Divisional Engineer Telegraph, Jullundur East had not considered the “optees” for appointment as Sub-Inspectors. The Postmaster General made an enquiry about the relevant facts on July 8, 1968. The enquiry revealed that the “optees” had not been considered in both Divisions. Consequently, on August 6, 1968, the Director of Telegraphs passed an order cancelling the selection of the petitioner and others. He further directed that the aforesaid optees should also be considered for promotion to the post of Sub-Inspector. The order regarding cancellation of the selection was issued by the office of the Postmaster General on August 20, 1968.

5. On September 19, 1968 there was a general strike in the Postal Department. The petitioner admittedly participated in the general strike. On July 5, 1969 Kamta Prasad and other respondents “optees” were selected as Sub-Inspectors. The petitioner and certain other persons who had participated in the strike were not selected. On July 7, 1969 the Divisional Engineer Telegraph, Jullundur East approved the aforesaid selection. Pursuant to this approval, the petitioner was sent back to his substantive post of linesman.

6. Two arguments have been advanced on behalf of the petitioner: One, Kamta Prasad and other respondents “optees” were not eligible for appointment as Sub-Inspectors in Jullundur East; two, the petitioner had been reverted mala fide on account of his participation in the strike.

7. As regards the first argument, reliance is placed on the words “in the Division” in Rule 464 of the Posts and Telegraphs Manual, Volume IV. The main part of Rule 464 provides that vacancies in the grade of Sub-Inspectors should be filled from the grade of “linesmen in the Division”. The argument is that the respondents “optees” were actually working in the Ferozepur Engineering Division at the time of the petitioner's selection in May 1967 and were accordingly not “Linesmen in the Division”. It appears to us that it is a too narrow interpretation of the phrase “in the Division”. We think that the “optees” who had opted for Jullundur East in 1966 and who, for no fault of their own, were working in the Ferozepur Division at the relevant time, should be deemed to be “linesmen in the Division” for the purpose of Rule 464. Indeed, there was in force a direction of the appropriate authority to that effect on the relevant date. According to it, the “optees” should be repatriated in the Division of their choice as early as possible and whenever fresh vacancies occurred. It also provided that even though they were not working in the Division of their choice, they should be considered for promotion in that Division as and when vacancies occurred. As the respondents “optees” were not considered at all for promotion to the post of Sub-Inspector in May 1967 the selection of the petitioner and others was invalid. Accordingly it has been rightly cancelled. The petitioner can have no legitimate grievance.

8. Coming to the second argument, it may be pointed out at the outset that strikes in the Posts and Telegraphs Services were banned by an order of the Central Government under Section 3 of the Essential Services Maintenance Ordinance, 1968. In spite of that order, the petitioner and others struck work on September 19, 1968.

9. As regards the effect of participation in the strike on promotional prospects, there were several orders by different authorities. It is not necessary to mention every one of them. Notice may be taken of two orders. On June 16, 1969, the Director General, Posts and Telegraphs, issued an order to the effect that the employees who had participated in the strike would be considered for promotion provided they were not guilty of acts of violence, active instigation or intimidation and their work and conduct subsequent to September 1968 had been found to be satisfactory. The petitioner seeks to rely on this order. But this order was ineffective on account of the Office Memorandum of the Ministry of Home Affairs, issued on October 19, 1968. The Office Memorandum provided that the adverse entry in the character roll of an employee who took part in the strike would be taken into consideration for promotion or confirmation. All employees who were on unauthorised absence on September 19, 1968 would suffer the consequences of strike for five years. Accordingly, the petitioner cannot rely on the order of the Director General. The petitioner obviously became ineligible for promotion as Sub-Inspector on account of the office memorandum for a period of five years. So he could not be considered for promotion as Sub-Inspector in July 1969, when the respondents “optees” and certain other persons were selected as Sub-Inspectors.

10. It is admitted by the Divisional Engineer Jullundur East that the petitioner was not considered for promotion as Sub-Inspector on account of the aforesaid directive of the Ministry of Home Affairs. The plea of the petitioner that he has been reverted mala fide on account of his participation in the strike is clearly untenable. There is no mala fide. The order cancelling his selection was passed one month before the strike. The Divisional Engineer was bound to follow the directive of the Ministry of Home Affairs and hold a fresh selection according to it.

11. There is no force in the petition and accordingly it is dismissed. Parties shall bear their own costs.