Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bachan And Another v. Kankar And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 26, 1972
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns agricultural Plots Nos. 573 and 1039 of Village Hathawra, Pargana and Tehsil Saidpur, District Ghazipur. The appellants (sons of Ram Dhari) claim sub-tenancy/adhivasi rights, while the respondents (heirs of Deep Chand) claim to be sirdars based on their alleged possession.

Key litigation steps include:

  • 1953: Respondents file a civil suit against Math Sri Chand and, on compromise, are declared sirdars; contemporaneous Section 145 CrPC proceedings also end in their favour.
  • 1953–1958: Ram Dhari sues respondents and Mansa Ram, obtaining a decree in 1955, affirmed in appeal in 1958; a second appeal is stayed because consolidation proceedings commence.
  • Consolidation Proceedings:
    • The respondents are recorded as sirdars under Section 8 of the U.P. Consolidation of Holdings Act, expunging Ram Dhari’s name.
    • The appellants’ mother, and later the appellants themselves, challenge these entries under Sections 8 and 12 but initially fail (orders dated 8 May 1960 and 4 July 1960).
    • Upon revision, the Deputy Director remands the matter; however, the respondents’ allotment is confirmed, and possession is delivered to them on 29 March 1961.
    • 22 June 1963: The Settlement Officer (Consolidation) allows the appellants’ appeal, directs deletion of the respondents’ names, and restores the appellants’ names.
    • 7 September 1963: The Deputy Director of Consolidation dismisses the respondents’ revision.
  • The respondents file a writ petition; a learned Single Judge, affirmed by a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court (13 July 1965), quashes the Settlement Officer’s and Deputy Director’s orders.
  • The present appeal is by special leave against that High Court decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an entry in the khasra/khatauni of 1356 Fasli, introduced allegedly out of hostility by a Patwari, is “fictitious” so as to preclude the respondents from acquiring adhivasi/sirdari rights under Section 20(b)(i) of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950.
  2. Whether the High Court erred in holding that the Deputy Director of Consolidation lacked jurisdiction to treat the impugned entry as fictitious.
  3. Consequently, whether the High Court was justified in quashing the orders of the Settlement Officer (Consolidation) and the Deputy Director of Consolidation.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • Deep Chand’s name was recorded as kabiz (in possession) in the khasra and khatauni of 1356 Fasli; hence, under Section 20(b)(i) he became an adhivasi, and the respondents subsequently became sirdars.
  • The entries, even if made through Patwari hostility, were not “fictitious”; therefore, their correctness or incorrectness was immaterial for conferring statutory rights.

Appellants' Arguments

  • Complaints against the Patwari in 1947 demonstrate that the entry in favour of Deep Chand was mala fide, false, and therefore fictitious.
  • The Settlement Officer’s factual finding that the entry was “mala fide, contrary to rules and false” is final and binding; the Deputy Director rightly affirmed this.
  • The High Court erred in elevating a fraudulent entry to an “irreproachable” status and in overriding consolidation authorities’ findings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sonawati v. Sri Ram, AIR 1968 SC 466; (1968) 1 SCR 617 A surreptitious or non-genuine entry in khasra/khatauni cannot confer adhivasi rights under Section 20 of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act. The Court analogised the present entry to the “surreptitious” entry in Sonawati and held that a fictitious entry cannot create rights.
Ram Das v. Deputy Director of Consolidation, (1971) 1 SCC 460; AIR 1971 SC 673 Even if an occupant is recorded, a fictitious entry negates adhivasi rights; consolidation authorities can recognise and act upon such fictitiousness. Used to reinforce that a fabricated Patwari entry cannot be the sole basis for respondent’s claimed rights; High Court’s contrary view was erroneous.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court emphasised that Section 20(b)(i) accords adhivasi rights only when the relevant khasra/khatauni entry is made in accordance with law. The Court:

  1. Reiterated the procedural safeguards prescribed in the U.P. Land Revenue Act and the Land Records Manual for preparing authentic khasras/khataunis.
  2. Held that an entry introduced “by devious methods” through Patwari hostility is “mendacious,” lacks authenticity, and is therefore “fictitious.”
  3. Applied Sonawati and Ram Das to conclude that a fictitious entry cannot bestow adhivasi or sirdari status.
  4. Rejected the High Court’s view that the Deputy Director lacked jurisdiction, noting that he relied on the Settlement Officer’s final factual findings and even civil-court observations branding the entry as fictitious.
  5. Criticised the High Court for treating a fraudulent entry as irreproachable, thereby overlooking evidence and basic legal principles that “fraudulent or mala fide actions have no legal sanction.”

Holding and Implications

HELD: The High Court’s judgment is set aside; the orders of the Settlement Officer (Consolidation) and the Deputy Director of Consolidation are restored. Costs of the appeal, including court-fee and advocates’ fee, are payable by the respondents.

Implications: The decision reaffirms that only genuine revenue-record entries confer adhivasi/sirdari rights under Section 20 of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act. It strengthens the authority of consolidation officers to investigate and disregard fictitious entries, without setting a new precedent beyond applying established Supreme Court jurisprudence.

Show all summary ...

A.N Ray, J.— This is an appeal by special leave from the judgment, dated 13 July, 1965 of the High Court of Allahabad dismissing Special Appeal No. 314 of 1965.

2. The respondents in the present appeal confined their relief in the High Court to Plots Nos. 573 and 1039 of Village Hathawra, Pargana and Tehsil Saidpur, District Ghazipur.

3. The facts in the present appeal are these. The respondents made an application under Article 226 of the Constitution for quashing the order of the Deputy Director of Consolidation, dated September 7, 1963 dismissing the revision petition of the respondents against the order of the Settlement Officer (Consolidation), Ghazipur, dated June 22,1963 ordering the entry of the names of the appellants in respect of the plots in dispute in the present appeal.

4. The circumstances under which the names of the appellants were entered and the names of the respondent were expunged by the appropriate authorities are as follows.

5. Litigation concerning the plots in dispute had gone on. Ram Dhari, father of the appellants claimed to be sub-tenants of Math Sri Chand in respect of the said plots. The respondents on the other hand claimed possession of the plots and also claimed adhivasi sirdari rights on the basis of being occupants. Mansa Ram Sarbarakar of the Math made an application under Section 145 of the Criminal Procedure Code against the respondents. The respondents brought civil suit in the year 1953 against Math Sri Chand and claimed tenancy rights by adverse possession. The parties entered into a compromise of the suit. The respondents as a result of the compromise were held to be sirdars of the plots in dispute. The proceedings under Section 145 of the Criminal Procedure Code also ended in favour of the respondents.

6. Ram Dhari and his sons the present appellants were not parties either to the suit filed by the respondents or the proceedings under Section 145 of the Criminal Procedure Code brought by Mansa Ram against the respondents. Ram Dhari, father of the appellants held a suit in the year 1953 against the respondents and Mansa Ram. On December 21, 1955 there was a decree in favour of Ram Dhari. The decree was upheld on appeal on July 21, 1958. The respondents filed a second appeal in the High Court. The second appeal was stayed because of consolidation proceedings.

7. The respondents were recorded under Section 8 of the U.P Consolidation of Holdings Act as sirdars in respect of the said plots by expunging the name of Ram Dhari, father of the appellants. The appellants mother thereafter made an application against the said order passed by the Assistant Consolidation Officer under Section 8 of the Act. The Assistant Consolidation Officer ordered that the order might be re-agitated subsequently under Section 12 of the Act. The appellants filed an objection under Section 12 of the Act. The appellants claimed that they had acquired adhivasi and sirdari rights and that their names had been recorded. The objection was dismissed on May 8, 1960 by the Consolidation Officer. The appellants filed an appeal against the judgment dated May 8, 1960. The appeal was dismissed by the Settlement Officer (Consolidation) on July 4, 1960.

8. The appellants thereafter filed a revision petition before the Deputy Director of Consolidation. He remanded the same to the Consolidation Officer for further enquiry. Before the remand order was passed by the Deputy Director the statement of the proposal had been published under Section 20(1) of the Consolidation Act, 1953. The appellants did not file objections under Section 20(2) of the Act. Eventually, the allotment of the plots was confirmed in favour of the respondents. Possession was delivered to the respondents on March 29, 1961. New revenue records were finally prepared and published. On February 20, 1963 the Consolidation Officer, Ghazipur dismissed the objections of the appellants. The appellants filed an appeal under Section 12 of the U.P Consolidation of Holdings Act. The appeal was allowed on June 22, 1963. The Settlement Officer accepted the appeal and allowed the objection of the appellants and directed that the names of the respondents be expunged and that the names of the appellants be entered on records. The respondents filed a revision application under Section 48 of the Consolidation of Holdings Act, 1953. The Deputy Director of Consolidation dismissed the revision application on September 7, 1963.

9. The respondents thereafter filed a writ petition in the High Court. The respondents asked for quashing the order of the Deputy Director of Consolidation, dated September 7, 1963 and of the Settlement Officer (Consolidation) dated 22 June, 1963.

10. The learned Single Judge quashed the orders, dated September 7, 1963 and June 22, 1963. The order was maintained by the Bench decision of that High Court.

11. The respondents' contentions in the High Court were these. The name of Deep Chand, father of the respondents was recorded as Kabiz (meaning thereby in possession) in the remarks column of the khasra and khatauni of 1356 Fasli. The respondents therefore claimed that Deep Chand was an adhivasi under Section 20(b)(i) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act. The respondents further contended that they became sirdars in the year 1954 and therefore their claims were rightly recorded as sirdars in the revenue records.

12. The appellants' contentions in the High Court were these. Ram Dhari, father of the appellants and other villagers in the year 1947 made complaints against the Patwari of the village. The Sub-divisional Officer on May 22, 1947 made an order punishing the Patwari. The Settlement Officer in the consolidation proceedings rightly allowed the objection of the appellants and directed that the names of the respondents be expunged and that the names of the appellants be entered on record. The Deputy Director of Consolidation in the order dismissing the respondents' revision application treated the finding of the Settlement Officer against the village Patwari as a finding that the entry in favour of Deep Chand, father of the respondents was fictitious.

13. The High Court held that though the entry in favour of the respondents was motivated by hostility or ill-will against the appellants it was made by the Patwari in discharging his duties. The High Court then said that though it might have been an incorrect entry and the incorrectness was on account of hostility of the Patwari against Ram Dhari, father of the appellants yet the entry could not be said to be fictitious or forged or fabricated. The High Court held that the entry in favour of Deep Chand, father of the respondents under Section 20(b)(i) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act was not a fictitious entry. The learned Single Judge as well as the Division Bench held that the respondents were entitled to Adhivasi rights merely on account of the entry and it was wholly irrelevant whether the entry was correct or not.

14. The High Court fell into the error of treating the entry as irreproachable. A fictitious entry is one which is not genuine. It is an unreal entry.

15. This Court in Sonawati v. Sri Ram AIR 1968 SC 466 (1968) 1 SCR 617 said that Section 20 of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1951 conferred certain rights upon persons whose names were recorded in the revenue records in respect of agricultural land. In Sonawati case this Court found that there was strong evidence which was relied on by the Revenue Court that the name of Pritam Singh predecessor-in-interest of the appellants was surreptitiously entered in the Khasra. The first appellate court there did not at all consider that evidence. The surreptitious entry in Sonawati case was held by this Court to disentitle the appellants to any adhivasi right under Section 20 of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act.

16. This Court recently in Ram Das v. Deputy Director of Consolidation, Ballia, (1971) 1 SCC 460, AIR 1971 SC 673 dealt with the contention of the appellants on the one hand who were recorded as Sir Khudkasht-holders of the plots in dispute and the contention of the respondents on the other who were entered as sub-tenants in respect of those plots in the year 1356 Fasli. Suits were filed between the parties. A compromise was entered into the suits. It was admitted by the respondents that the appellants were Bhoomidars and that the respondents had no interest. The further admission in the compromise was that the entry in the revenue records in favour of the respondents was fictitious. The respondents subsequently applied for setting aside the compromise decrees on the ground that they had been obtained fraudulently. During the pendency of the suits consolidation proceedings under the U.P Consolidation of Holdings Act, 1953 commenced. The Consolidation Authorities held that the suits were not maintainable because on the date on which the suits were filed the respondents had become sirdars. The appellants filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging the order of the Consolidation Authorities. The High Court held in that case relying on the earlier decisions of that Court that even if the entry was fictitious the respondents who were recorded as occupants would, under Section 20(b) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1951 become adhivasi of the disputed land. This Court relying on the earlier decision in Sonawati case held that there was evidence to show that the entry was fictitious and the person whose name was entered on the record on the material date could not claim the right of an adhivasi.

17. The rulings of this Court establish that the decision of the learned Single Judge as well as that of the Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court is erroneous. Section 20 of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950 speaks of a person recorded as occupant to become adhivasi of the land and will be entitled to take or retain possession as mentioned in the section. One of the principal matters mentioned in the section is that the Khasra or Khatauni of 1356 Fasli is to be prepared under Sections 28 and 33 of the U.P Land Revenue Act, 1901. The U.P Land Records Manual in Chapter A-V in para A-55 to A-67 lays down the manner in which the Khasra or the field book showing possession is to be prepared by the Patwari in the areas to which Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950 applies. There are detailed instructions about the manner in which the enquiry should be carried out about actual possession and change in possession and corrections in the map and field book, the form in which the khasra is to be prepared. The form of khasra is given in para A-80. The form shows that the Lekhpal has to prepare a consolidated list of entries after partial or proper investigation. Again, para A-70 to A-73 to the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act show how entries have to be made in khataunis every year showing the nature of tenure of each holder. The khatauni is meant to be a record of tenure-holders. The manner of changes to be made there is laid down in para A-82 to A-83. Entries are to be checked. Extract has to be sent to the Chairman, Land Management Committee as contemplated in paragraph A-82 (iii). In this context Section 20(b)(i) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act which speaks of the record “as occupant” in the khasra or khatauni of 1355 Fasli refers to the khasra or khatauni being prepared in accordance with the provisions of the Land Revenue Act, 1961. Khasra is the field book provided for by Section 28 of the Land Revenue Act. Khatauni is an annual register prepared under Section 32 of the Land Revenue Act 1951. It has to be emphasised that the entry under Section 20 (b)(i) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950 in order to enable a person to obtain adhivasi rights must be an entry under the provisions of law.

18. This Court has held that entries which are not genuine cannot confirm adhivasi rights. The High Court wrongly held that though the entry was incorrect it could not be said to be fictitious. It is too obvious to be stressed that an entry which is incorrectly introduced into the records by reason of ill-will or hostility is not only shorn of authenticity but also becomes utterly useless without any lawful basis.

19. The learned Single Judge of the Allahabad High Court held that the Deputy Director of Consolidation did not have the jurisdiction while dismissing the revision application in the consolidation proceedings to hold that the entry was fictitious. The Deputy Director of Consolidation pointed out that the entry was held to be fictitious by a civil court also. The Settlement Officer was the final Court of fact. The order of the Settlement Officer found that the entries relied on by the respondents were mala fide, contrary to rules and false. The view of the learned Single Judge confirmed by the Division Bench is antithetic to the basic principles that fraudulent or mala fide actions have no legal sanction.

20. The High Court erred in quashing the order of the Deputy Director of Consolidation and the order of the Settlement Officer. The High Court overlooked the evidence. The High Court relied on surreptitious entry as lawful entry. A fabricated entry is obviously a fictitious entry. In the present case, the entry was introduced by the Patwari by devious methods. Such entry is mendacious.

21. For these reasons, the order of the High Court is set aside. The court-fees payable by the appellants shall be recovered from the respondents and their advocate's fee shall be taxed and paid by the respondents. The appellants shall be entitled to their costs of this appeal.