Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Puran Lal Sah v. State Of U.P .

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 21, 1971
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, a contractor, submitted a tender to construct Mile 3 of the Nainital-Bhowali Road at 13 per cent below the rates specified in “Schedule B” of a Public Works Department (PWD) notice dated 30 September 1946. The tender was accepted and a formal contract executed on 20 November 1946.

The contractor alleged that the Schedule B estimates were premised on stone being available within 26 chains of the work-site. Because the relevant quarry lay inside Cantonment land, he was denied access and had to transport stone from Gadhera (79 chains) and Bhumedar (110 chains). He also encountered very hard shale rock not contemplated in the contract. Claiming entitlement to higher “current” rates for extra lead and unforeseen work—altogether Rs 48,840 plus interest—he served notice under Section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure and filed suit.

The trial court decreed Rs 26,313-14-0 in the contractor’s favour. On appeal, the Allahabad High Court (8 March 1965) reversed, holding there was no assurance of stone within 26 chains and that the contractor failed to invoke para 5 of the special instructions before executing extra work. The plaintiff obtained a certificate under Article 133(1)(a) of the Constitution and appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the PWD estimate indicating stone availability at 26 chains formed part of the contract and amounted to an assurance binding on the Government, thereby entitling the contractor to higher rates for longer lead.
  2. Whether clause 12 of the contract and para 5 of the special instructions governed the extra quantities/extra item (very hard shale), and if so, whether the contractor could nevertheless recover at rates higher than those originally tendered.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Clauses 8, 11 and 14 of the tender notice, read with clause 34 of the contract, incorporated the estimate into the contract; the notation of “26 chains” thereby constituted a contractual representation.
  • Local PWD officers gave oral assurances that, should stone not be found within 26 chains, higher rates would be sanctioned for stone quarried from 79 and 110 chains.
  • The non-availability of stone within 26 chains discharged the original contract; having nevertheless completed the work, the contractor was entitled to payment on a quantum meruit basis.
  • For quantities executed in excess of 30 per cent and for the extra item “very hard shale,” the current schedule of rates, not the tendered rates, should apply.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • No officer ever assured higher rates; the figure “26 chains” was used solely for internal calculation of estimates.
  • Under para 5 of the special instructions, the contractor was obliged to perform up to 30 per cent excess at tender rates and, if unwilling to execute more, to give written notice and settle fresh rates before commencing extra work—steps he never took.
  • Clause 12 bound the contractor to perform additional work on the same terms; thus no claim for enhanced rates is maintainable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Alopi Parshad and Sons Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 1960 SC 588; (1960) 2 SCR 793 Compensation quantum meruit is not available where consideration is fixed by contract. Used to reject the contractor’s alternative claim for payment on a quantum meruit basis, since the contract specified rates.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice P. Jaganmohan Reddy, delivering the judgment, affirmed the High Court’s conclusions, reasoning as follows:

  1. No contractual assurance of 26 chains lead. Neither the tender notice nor the contract expressly promised that stone would be available within 26 chains. The estimate was prepared on that assumption for PWD calculations, but this did not bind the Government. The contractor had inspected the site and verified availability himself; failure to obtain Cantonment permission was his risk.
  2. Rejection of extra-lead claim. Correspondence dated June–July 1947 showed the contractor sought higher lead before starting work and that PWD categorically refused, yet he proceeded without protest. Therefore, there was no inducement or subsequent agreement to pay higher rates.
  3. Quantum meruit unavailable. Even if stone non-availability constituted a breach (which it did not), the contractor elected to perform; the contract was never discharged. Under Alopi Parshad, payment must follow contractual rates when work is performed pursuant to an existing contract.
  4. Extra quantities governed by clause 12 and para 5. These provisions obliged the contractor to execute up to 30 per cent excess at tender rates and to give written notice before undertaking further extra work. No such notice was given; hence he cannot now demand higher rates for quantities in excess of 30 per cent or for “very hard shale.”
  5. Lack of evidence of new rate settlement. Recommendations by subordinate officers (e.g., letter of 15 June 1950) did not create contractual entitlement absent formal settlement or compliance with para 5.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED. The Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s judgment dismissing the contractor’s suit; each party was left to bear its own costs.

Implications: The decision reinforces that contractors cannot rely on internal departmental estimates or informal assurances to vary agreed rates. Strict compliance with contractual clauses—particularly those governing extra work—is required to claim enhanced remuneration. The ruling applies established principles and sets no new precedent beyond affirming existing contract-law doctrines.

Show all summary ...

P. Jaganmohan Reddy, J.— This appeal is by a Certificate under Article 133(1)(a) of the Constitution against the Judgment and decree of the Allahabad High Court, dated 8th March, 1965, setting aside the decree of the trial court and dismissing the suit of the plaintiff-appellant.

2. The appellant had submitted a Tender to Construct Mile 3 of Nainital-Bhowali Road at 13 per cent below the rates given in Schedule B to the Notice issued by the Government of the United Provinces on 30th September, 1946. This tender was accepted and a contract was signed on 20th November, 1946. It is alleged by the appellant that the rates given in Schedule B were based on the calculation that stone required for the Road construction work would be available at a distance of 26 Chains while as a matter of fact no stone was available within that distance. The appellant had in fact to get stone from Gadhera and Bhumedar from a distance of 79 and 110 Chains respectively. It is his contention that by reason of the nonavailability of the stone and the definite understanding and assurance given by the local authorities of the PWD that higher rates would be given for the extra work done over and above the work provided in the contract he carried on the work. It was also alleged that during the construction work on the road very hard shale rock came in the way not originally provided for in the contract as such he was entitled to get the costs for the works done at the current rates from the PWD which was not paid to him. In respect of these items of work done as also due to him having done the work by bringing stone from a longer distance than was given in the estimates the appellant claimed Rs 48,840-0-0 due as balance together with interest by way of damages at 12 per cent amounting to Rs 17,582-0-0, making a total of Rs 66,422-0-0. When this claim was rejected the appellant gave notice under Section 80 of the CPC and thereafter filed a suit for the above amount.

3. The defendant-respondent resisted the suit and pleaded that no assurance was given to the appellant by officers of the PWD as alleged, that the quantity of very hard shale shown in the plaint was incorrect and at any rate the contractor, under para 5 of the special instructions must be prepared to execute the work at the original tender rate in excess of the given quantities of work up to 30 per cent and if an increase in excess of 30 per cent is ordered over the work the contractor must intimate to the Engineer-in-charge in writing his willingness or refusal to do extra work at the original tendered rates. If he refuses to carry on at the original rates he is required to settle fresh rate for increased work over 30 per cent before doing the work.

4. On these averments the trial court held Issues 1, 2, 6 and 7 in favour of the appellant while Issues 3, 4 and 5 were decided against him. In the result a decree for a sum of Rs 20,495 for extra lead plus Rs 1653-14-0 for extra work done under the item very hard shale and Rs 4155 interest by way of damages on Rs 22,158-14-0 making a total of Rs 26,313-14-0 was passed with interest at 3 per cent per annum. In appeal the High Court reversed the decree holding that: “(1) the employment of the figure 26 Chains in the estimate was for no other purpose than that of calculation .... and if knowing that the same was available within 26 Chains it (PWD) worked out its estimates on that basis, it could not be held to have extended any assurance much less guarantee to the contractors that they would get stone within that distance”; (2) the plaintiff-appellant performed the work required of him without exercising his right under para 5 of the special instructions which gives the option to do the extra work in excess of 30 per cent but if he refuses to do the extra work at the originally tendered rates he should settle fresh rates for increased work over 30 per cent before doing the work which he failed to do. In view of these findings against the appellant the appeal of the respondent was allowed and the suit dismissed but in the special circumstances of the case left the parties to bear their respective costs in both the Courts.

5. The two main questions in this appeal are: (1) whether the estimate of the PWD formed part of the contract so as to be binding on both parties and whether any assurances were given to the appellant that he would be given higher rates for bringing the stone from places situated at 79 Chains and 110 Chains respectively; (2) whether clause 5 of the special conditions of the contract was applicable to the extra item of work contained in Ext. B-3 and whether he was entitled on the assurances given by the local officers to higher rate for the extra work done. Shri Bindra, learned Advocate for the appellant has referred us to clauses 8, 11 and 14 of the notice calling for the tender as also to certain letters and passages in the evidence to substantiate his contention that the estimates of the PWD were part of the contract and that in any case assurances were given to the appellant that when he could not get stone from distance of 26 Chains, to bring from Chains 79 and 110 for which higher rates would he paid. It may be stated that the PWD of the United Provinces, as it then was, had issued a tender notice consisting of 16 paras and the appellant was required to sign this tender notice in token of his having received it because ultimately under clause 34 of the conditions of the contract all papers signed by the parties to the contract and bond will be deemed to be part of the contract bond and have to be read as conditions to the contract. Clauses 8, 11 and 14 of the notice to which reference was made are as follows:

”8. All tenders should be on percentage rates above or below the rates given in the Schedule ‘B’.
11. Items not provided in the Schedule ‘B’ will be paid at current schedule of rate plus or minus the percentage above or below as tendered by the contractor whose tender is accepted for this work.
14. Contractors was advised to see the estimate, plans, specifications, special condition prescribed and site of work before tendering.”

6. It is obvious from these clauses that the rates are given in Schedule ‘B’ on the basis of certain plans and specifications. The person intending to tender for the work was required to examine this material and also inspect the site before tendering. These interactions were designed to make all those who were desirous of obtaining the contract responsible for their acts so that it cannot be said that any misrepresentation was made or they were misguided in any way. The contention of the learned Advocate for the appellant is that it was definitely stated in the estimates that stone was available at 26 Chains which representation was binding on the respondents and if no stone was available within that distance he was entitled to claim higher rates if he had to get stone from places farther away. In fact the appellant alleges that the engineers assured him that he would he paid higher rates.

7. We may here observe that in none of the clauses of the notice or conditions of contract or in any other document is there any specific mention that stone will be available at 26 Chains nor is there any assurance that if stone was not available within that distance the contractor will be paid higher rates. The mere fact that the estimates were prepared by the PWD on the basis of the stone being available at 26 Chains which respondents admitted as stated in the judgment of Civil Judge, Nainital, does not mean that there was any assurance or undertaking given that stone would be available at that place. In fact it is not denied that stone was available within the distance of 26 Chains but it was in the area belonging to the Cantonment, for the removal of which permission of the Cantonment authorities had to be taken. Evidently the contractor was not able to obtain that permission. In our view it was up to the contractor to have satisfied himself before entering into the contract that the Cantonment authorities would permit him to take stone from its jurisdiction just in the same way as permission will have to be taken from any private individual in whose land stone required for road building is found. If the contractor has failed successfully to negotiate with the owners of land from which he could bring stone it cannot be said that the estimate prepared by the PWD on the basis that the stone was available at 26 Chains was a statement which amounted to an assurance or constituted a condition of the contract.

8. The appellant as PW 1 stated in his evidence: “Before giving offer I saw the estimates and plan. In the estimate it was written that the stone would be found within 26 Chains. On this basis estimate was prepared through the PWD I enquired this from the Assistant Engineer also. He too informed that stone would be available within 26 Chains. On this basis I prepared the estimate .... In the beginning of the year 1947 I started work. I attempted to take out stones from within 26 Chains. The moment I startedto take out stones, the Cantonment authorities checked me. For this act I challaned, but I was acquitted. The entire area within 26 Chains was of the Cantonment”. Further on he says “I have seen the tender notice and I had gone through it; after that I signed it. Schedule ‘B’ was attached to the notice. I signed it after going through it. I submitted tender 13 per cent less than the scheduled rate ... before giving the tender I went to that place and found that the stones were available within 26 Chains, when I wanted to take them out I learnt that this was within the Cantonment boundary. I sought permission to take out stones from the Cantonment authorities, but it was disallowed”.

9. It is clear from this evidence that the appellant before giving the tender inspected the site, went to the place where stone was said to be available and after satisfying himself that the stone was available he gave the tender. A perusal of the documentary evidence would also show that he actually commenced work after his request to allow him higher rate was rejected which was long after the time when under the contract he was required to start the work. In fact just before the date fixed for the completion of the work, he had under Ext. B-4, dated the 12th June, 1947, made the following representation.

10. “That as agreed upon the contract deed of my contract Nainital-Bhowali Motor Road Mile 3 the lead of stones for masonary work is given only about half a mile. On inspecting the place I find it very difficult to get a quarry there as there is no stone at all. I am getting the stones from near the K.K Sanitorium which falls at a distance of two and a half miles from my place, as has already been brought to your and the CE's kind notice. Therefore, you are requested kindly to allow me a lead of two and a half miles distance”. On this the concerned authorities seem to have made the endorsement: “As lead and royalty is provided in the Schedule ‘B’ of the tender, the request cannot be acceded to. Draft reply is put up”. Accordingly by letter, dated the 21st June, 1947, he was informed as follows:

“Reference your application, dated 12th June, 1947. Please refer to Items 6, 7, 8 and 9 of Schedule B attached with your tender and on which basis you tendered your rate in this connection. As the rates noted therein provide all lead and royalty and there is no mention there that the rate contains a lead for half a mile, your request cannot be acceded to.”

11. This correspondence shows that the appellant's claim to have extra lead was definitely rejected as untenable even before he started the work under the contract, as is apparent from Ext. B-2, dated the 19th July, 1947. In that letter the appellant was being informed as follows:

“Please note that since you have signed the contract for the above work, the work must be started now in consultation with the Overseer-in charge, Nainital section. The date of start and completion will be as follows:
Date of start — November 20, 1946
Date of completion — July 19, 1947.”

12. It cannot therefore be said that the appellant was in any way induced by any assurances given by the PWD authorities that they would give a higher rate for the extra lead before he commenced work. The case of the appellant in these letters was that no stone was available within half a mile while in his deposition he gave a contrary version altogether. Subsequently he seems to have become hopeful because in the letter of the Assistant Engineer, dated 28th December, 1948, it is stated:

“In the estimate lead for 26 Chains was provided on the assumption that stone will be available within the distance from the quarries in Cantonment areas. Later on when the work was in progress the Cantonment authorities objected to quarrying stones from Cantonment land....”
Not doubt the Executive Engineer in his letter, dated 15th June, 1950, Ext. 22 has recommended the case of the appellant for a higher rate as he says “When the stones were not available from the Cantonment area it seems that the contractor naturally was forced to bring them from quarries situated outside the Cantonment area” and he further says “If these quarries are the- places from where stones were actually obtained then naturally the contractor is entitled to get the lead for the full quantity of stones brought by him to complete different items requiring the use of stones”.

13. The letter seems to be a recommendatory letter by a subordinate to the higher officer but it does not in any way establish the right of the appellant to obtain a higher rate, nor does the evidence justify this conclusion. In our view neither the terms and conditions of the contract nor the oral or documentary evidence justify the conclusion that the appellant was entitled to any extra lead.

14. Another argument was but forward by the learned Advocate for the appellant which is also based on the same assumption that the availability of stone at 26 Chains was a condition of the contract namely that once stone was not available at 26 Chains the contract was at an end and that because the appellant had done the work he should be paid on the basis of quantum meruit. This in our view is a far fetched argument and has no relation to the facts and circumstances of the case. Even assuming that the stand taken by the appellant that the availability of stone at 26 Chains was a condition of the contract was justified, he had notwithstanding the rejection of his claim even before he started the work, acquiesced in the stand taken by the respondents that he is not entitled to any higher rates, carried on and completed the contract as if there was no such condition. We therefore cannot understand the contention of the appellant's Advocate as to how the contract came to an end and who put an end to it. Even if at that stage the contract had been but an end to by the respondent which is no one case, as the appellant had not started the work no question of quantum meruit would arise. The principle of quantum meruit is rooted in English law under which there were certain procedural advantages in framing an action for compensation for work done. In order to avail of the remedy under quantum meruit, the original contract must have been discharged by the defendant in such a way as to entitle the plaintiff to regard himself as discharged from any further performance and he must have elected to do so. The remedy it may be noticed is, however, not available to the party who breaks the contract even though he may have partially performed part of his obligation. This remedy by way of quantum meruit is restitutory that is it is a recompense for the value of the work done by the plaintiff in order to restore him to the position which he would have been in if the contract had never been entered into. In this regard it is different to a claim for damages which is a compensatory remedy aimed at placing the injured party, as near as may be in the position which he wouldhave been in, had the other party performed the contract. This Court had in Alopi Parshad and Sons Ltd. v. Union of India AIR 1960 SC 588, 1960 (2) SCR 793, 1960 SCJ 763, (1960) 2 SCA 45 observed at p. 809:

“Compensation quantum meruit is awarded for work done or services rendered when the price thereof is not fixed by a contract. For work done or services rendered persuant to the terms of a contract compensation quantum meruit cannot be awarded where the contract provides for consideration payable in that behalf.”
Though in that case the basis of the principle was not explained, it nonetheless, lays down that where work is done under a contract persuant to the terms thereof no amount can be claimed by way of quantum meruit. In the view we have taken on the facts of the case we do not propose to examine the decisions cited at the Bar in this behalf. The claim of the appellant for higher rates which in fact was by way damages has been rightly disallowed by the High Court.

15. On the second question also the appellant cannot succeed because under clause 12 of the contract Ext. B-1, the plaintiff was bound to perform additional work which was required of him on the same terms and conditions on which he undertook to do the work for which he tendered. It appears that by a subsidiary contract entered into between the appellant and the PWD., Ext. B-3, on the 12th April, 1946, the appellant undertook to execute some additional work for the Department. The quantity of work which appellant actually performed was far in excess of what was mentioned in Ext. B-3. The Appellant therefore claimed payment for the work done by him in excess of the quantity mentioned in the contract plus 30 per cent at the current rate as against the stipulated rates. It was submitted on behalf of the State of U.P before the High Court that under clause 12 of the contract Ext. B-1 and para 5 of the special instructions the plaintiff was not entitled to any amount in excess of what he had already been paid. This contention was accepted because under the aforesaid clause 12 the contractor was bound to perform all additional work which was required of him on the same terms and conditions in which he undertook to do the main work. Para 5 of the special instructions further provides as follows:

“Contractors must be prepared to do at their original tender rate work in excess of the given quantities of work up to 30 per cent if an increase in excess of 30 per cent is ordered over the work the contractor must intimate to the Engineer Incharge in writing his willingness or refusal to do extra work at the originally tendered rates. In the latter case he should settle fresh rate for increased work over 30 per cent before doing the work.”
These instructions being part and parcel of the original contract Ext. B-1 would govern the parties. As such the appellant unless he gave notice under that para that he is not prepared to do the extra work over the 30 per cent at normal rates, he cannot claim anything other than at the rates mentioned in the contract, unless he had settled fresh rates for that extra work. There is no evidence nor is it claimed by the appellant that he had given any notice as required under para 5 of the special instructions and since he did the work without fulfilling these requirements he is not entitled to claim any amounts at a higher rate for the extra work done. As neither of the contentions have force the appeal is dismissed but in the circumstances without costs.