- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Maharastra : v. Dadamiya Babumiya Sheikh, Etc.
Factual and Procedural Background
On 2 March 1964, Abdul Wahab Ibrahim, an accused under the Customs Act, was produced before the Chief Presidency Magistrate, Bombay. He was released on bail upon executing a bond for ₹ 2 lakhs, supported by two sureties: respondent Laxman Bania (₹ 50,000) and respondent Dadamiya Babumiya Sheikh (₹ 1,50,000). The bond required the accused to appear before the Chief Presidency Magistrate on 12 March 1964 “or on such other dates as the Court may direct.”
The accused appeared on 12 March 1964 and the Magistrate extended the bail to 16 April 1964. On the same day, a circular order directed that future remand and bail matters under the Customs Act be placed before a “Miscellaneous Court” at the Esplanade Centre of Courts.
The accused failed to appear on 16 April 1964 in either the Chief Presidency Magistrate’s Court or the Miscellaneous Court. The Miscellaneous Court issued notices on 17 April 1964 and, on 27 May 1964, an Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate forfeited both surety bonds. In criminal revision, the Bombay High Court set aside that forfeiture but left liberty to the Chief Presidency Magistrate to proceed afresh.
Acting under Section 514 of the Criminal Procedure Code, the Customs authorities sought fresh action. The Chief Presidency Magistrate issued new show-cause notices, and on 17 March 1966 again ordered forfeiture of both bonds. The sureties again obtained revision before the High Court, which on 11 August 1967 quashed the second forfeiture. The present appeals by the State arise from that High Court judgment and were heard by the Supreme Court on special leave.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the circular order dated 12 March 1964 displaced the obligation, under the surety bonds, of the accused to appear before the Chief Presidency Magistrate on 16 April 1964.
- Consequently, whether the failure of the accused to appear on that date justified forfeiture of the surety bonds under Section 514, CrPC.
- Whether, in the circumstances, the Supreme Court should interfere with the High Court’s order under Article 136 of the Constitution.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondents (Sureties)
- The circular order modified the bond’s terms and relieved both accused and sureties of any obligation to appear before the Chief Presidency Magistrate on 16 April 1964.
- Because no obligation existed to appear in any other court on that date, the bond ceased to have operative effect and could not be forfeited.
Appellant State
- The circular order could not, by a unilateral administrative act, exhaust or vary the contractual obligations embodied in the surety bonds.
- The High Court erred in treating the bonds as discharged; their forfeiture by the Chief Presidency Magistrate was therefore valid.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court characterised a surety bond as a contract whose construction must give effect to its purpose—ensuring an accused’s presence for trial. While bonds may attract strict construction, interpretation should not defeat their essential objective.
The Court noted that the bonds in question required attendance before the Chief Presidency Magistrate until “otherwise directed by that Court.” The High Court doubted that any such direction existed for 16 April 1964, finding no record that the case was called in the Chief Presidency Magistrate’s Court and describing the supporting testimony of a Customs Officer as a “bare assertion.”
The Supreme Court held that this conclusion was a “possible view” on the evidence. Invoking the self-imposed limits on review under Article 136, the Court declined to re-appraise the factual basis of the High Court’s ruling. It expressly left open the broader legal question of a surety’s obligation where a case is transferred to another court.
Holding and Implications
Appeals DISMISSED.
The High Court’s order setting aside forfeiture stands, and the sureties’ bonds are not forfeited. The decision turns on the factual assessment of whether the accused was obliged to attend the Chief Presidency Magistrate on 16 April 1964; it sets no new precedent but reaffirms the Supreme Court’s restraint in exercising discretionary power under Article 136 when confronted with reasonable findings of fact by a High Court.
I.D Dua, J.— These two appeals are by special leave from the judgment of the Bombay High Court, dated August 11, 1967, allowing the criminal revision applications of two sureties and setting aside the order of the Presidency Magistrate forfeiting their bonds.
2. On March 2, 1964, one Abdul Wahab Ibrahim, who was accused of having committed certain offences under the Customs Act was produced before the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate for the purpose of securing his remand. The Chief Presidency Magistrate released him on bail on his executing a bond for a sum of Rs 2 lakhs with two sureties. The two respondents in this Court Laxman Bania and Dadamiya Babumiya Sheikh stood sureties, the former in the sum of Rs 50,000 and the latter in the sum of Rs 1,50,000. The bonds in both the cases were in identical terms. The sureties undertook that the accused would appear before the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate on March 12, 1964, or on such other dates as the Court may direct. On March 12, 1964, the accused appeared in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate when the period of bail was extended to April 16, 1964. According to the directions of the Court the accused Abdul Wahab Ibrahim was to appear in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate on April 16, 1964. He did not appear on that date in that court and it appears that he was not traceable because he did not surrender to his bail bond anywhere. A circular letter seems to have been issued by the Chief Presidency Magistrate on March 12, 1964, according to which all applications for remands and extensions of bail periods under the Customs Act and also miscellaneous applications pertaining to such cases were to be placed in future before the Miscellaneous Court at the Esplanade Centre of Courts. According to this circular it appears that surety applications and also fresh cases under Customs Act were to be filed in the Miscellaneous Court. It is common case before us that on April 16, 1964, the accused neither appeared in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate nor in the Miscellaneous Court. The Miscellaneous Court issued notices to the sureties on April 17, 1964 requiring them to show cause why their bonds be not forfeited. These notices were ultimately disposed of by the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate, Third Court on May 27, 1964 and the surety bonds of both the series were ordered to be forfeited. Criminal revision against the order of forfeiture was presented to the High Court where it was contended that the bonds having been executed for the purpose of guaranteeing the attendance of the accused in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate on the dates as directed by that court the bonds could not be forfeited by the Additional Chief Presidency Magistrate. The order of forfeiture was set aside by the High Court and it was observed that it would be open to the Chief Presidency Magistrate on proper proceedings to enforce the bonds if their conditions had not been fulfilled and if the court considered it proper to enforce them. The Customs Authorities then approached the Chief Presidency Magistrate under Section 514, CrPC and that court issued fresh notices to the sureties calling upon them to show cause why the bonds executed by them be not forfeited. On March 17, 1966, the Chief Presidency Magistrate held that there was good and convincing evidence to show that accused Abdul Wahab Ibrahim was absent from that court on April 16, 1964, when he was required to be present according to that court's directions, dated March 12, 1964. Both the bonds were accordingly forfeited. The Court also believed the evidence of the Customs Officers that the accused had neither appeared in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate nor in the Miscellaneous Court.
3. On revision by the two sureties, the High Court took the view that the accused was not bound to appear in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate on April 16, 1964, and therefore the bonds executed by the sureties were not liable to be forfeited. It had been contended before the Chief Presidency Magistrate and upheld by him that according to the practice and procedure of the Court the accused was bound to appear before that Court on April 16, 1964, in spite of the fact that case was considered to have been transferred to the Miscellaneous Court by virtue of the Circular Order because it was on the appearance of the accused in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate that he was to be directed by judicial order of that Court to appear in the Miscellaneous Court for further proceedings. The Customs Officer and the clerk of the Chief Presidency Magistrate's Court had deposed to this practice.
4. The High Court, however, on revision took a different view. It observed that the evidence given by the Clerk of the Chief Presidency Magistrate's Court had not deposed to such practice, though the Customs Officer had. According to the High Court the said clerk had stated that apart from the cases transferred under the Circular Order the procedure in other cases transferred by the Chief Presidency Magistrate was that on the case being called out in that Court, the accused would be directed to go to the transferee court for obtaining further orders. The High Court further felt that there was no satisfactory evidence, apart from the bare assertion of the Customs Officer, Ahuja, that this case was actually called out in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate on April 16, 1964, there being no noting to that effect on the official records. This view was considered to be supported by the fact that the Miscellaneous Court actually issued notices to the sureties why their bonds should not be forfeited.
5. Before us the short question canvassed at the bar relates to the effect of the Circular Order, dated March 12, 1964. According to Mr Daphtary, the learned counsel for the respondents, this Order had the effect of modifying the terms of the bond and of absolving the accused and the surety from any obligation to appear in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate on April 16, 1964. There being no obligation to appear in any other court on April 16, 1964, according to Mr Daphtary's argument, the accused and the sureties were completely absolved of all obligations under the bond and the bond virtually became a dead letter.
6. Mr H.R Khanna on behalf of the appellant State on the other hand contended that the bonds executed by the sureties could not get legally exhausted merely because of the Circular Order, and that the High Court was wrong in taking that view.
7. A surety bond is a contract and it is a question as to how far its terms can be considered to have been varied by any unilateral act. Each bond, it may be pointed out, has to be construed on its own terms. But in construing the terms of a surety bond for the production of an accused person, the purpose and object of executing it must be kept in view. Such a bond is executed for the purpose of ensuring the presence of the accused concerned in court in which he is standing his trial for a criminal offence at the hearing of the case. But for the execution of such a bond, the accused would have to remain in custody so that the trial may proceed smoothly.
8. Looked at from this point of view surety bonds in criminal cases must be held to be designed to an extent to serve a public purpose. In some cases it is of course said that surety bonds call for a strict construction. But the construction must not be so unduly strained as to result in defeating its essential purpose. Each bond has of course to be construed on its own terms, subject to what has just been stated.
9. In the present case the surety bonds relate to the production of the accused in the Court in which he was being tried. The High Court entertained some doubt if after the Circular Order the accused was under any obligation to appear in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate. But after giving expression to this doubt, the High Court felt that there was no satisfactory evidence, apart from bare assertion of the Customs Officer, Ahuja, that the present case was actually called out in the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate on April 16, 1964. The High Court also pointed out that there was no official noting on the record that the case was called and the clerk of the court was unable to state that case had actually been called out on that date. Now under the bonds in question the sureties undertook to assure that the accused would attend the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate on March 12, 1964, to answer the charge for which he had been arrested and would continue so to attend until otherwise directed by that Court. As in the opinion of the High Court, the material on the record does not show that the accused was required on April 16, 1964, to attend the Court of the Chief Presidency Magistrate for answering the charge in respect of which he had been arrested, and as, in our opinion, this view is a possible view to take on the existing record, we do not find any cogent ground for interfering with the impugned order under Article 136 of the Constitution. This Court, as has repeatedly been pointed out, does not interfere under Article 136 of the Constitution with every order of the High Court which may be considered to be erroneous in law. The High Court decided this case on its own peculiar facts and on the terms of the surety bond in question. No exceptional circumstances have been brought to our notice impelling us to exercise extraordinary power of this Court. Without expressing any considered opinion on the general question of the obligation of a surety in the event of the transfer of the case to some other court to produce the accused in the transferor or the transferee court, we dismiss the present appeals on the short ground that no case for interference under Article 136 of the Constitution has been made out.
Alert