Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Hussain Bhai And Others v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Madras .

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 16, 1971
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

For Assessment Year 1948-49 the Income-tax Officer (ITO) originally assessed Abdullabhai Fazalali on 30 September 1948 on an income of Rs 9,102, considering only share and property income. Later, the Department discovered a cash deposit of Rs 40,000 made by the assessee on 28 July 1947. After the assessee’s death (1 August 1954) a notice under Section 34(1)(a) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922 was served on his legal representative, Hussainbhai Abdullabhai, on 9 February 1957. Assessment was completed on 15 March 1957 but the Appellate Assistant Commissioner (AAC) later set it aside, treating the proceedings as illegal.

On 9 July 1958 the ITO issued a fresh notice under Section 34(1)(a) to all legal representatives and on 14 December 1960 reassessed the estate, treating the Rs 40,000 deposit as income from undisclosed sources. The AAC annulled this reassessment as time-barred, but the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal reversed him, holding the notice valid. In a reference under Section 66(1), the Madras High Court agreed with the Revenue, holding that Section 4 of the Income-tax (Amendment) Act, 1959 cured the limitation defect. The assessee appealed to the Supreme Court on a certificate under Section 66-A(2).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the fresh notice dated 9 July 1958 issued under Section 34(1)(a) was barred by limitation.
  2. Whether Section 4 of the Income-tax (Amendment) Act, 1959 saved that notice from the bar of limitation.

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee’s Arguments

  • The eight-year period under Section 34(1)(a) as amended by the Finance Act, 1956 expired on 1 April 1957; therefore the notice issued on 9 July 1958 was time-barred.
  • Section 4 of the 1959 Amendment Act does not protect a notice that is invalid under the limitation period prescribed by the 1956 amendment.

Revenue’s Arguments

  • Section 4 of the 1959 Amendment Act validates all notices issued before its commencement, regardless of the limitation then applicable, and thus cures any defect in the 9 July 1958 notice.
  • Alternatively, the AAC’s earlier order contained a “direction” enabling initiation of fresh proceedings within the meaning of the second proviso to Section 34(3).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S.C. Prashar, ITO v. Vasantsen Dwarkadas, AIR 1963 SC 1356; (1964) 1 SCR 29; 49 ITR 1 Interpretation of Section 4 of the Income-tax (Amendment) Act, 1959 and its interplay with differing limitation periods in Section 34. Relied upon to support the view that Section 4 only removes the bar arising from the pre-1956 eight-year period and does not wipe out the limitation introduced by the 1956 amendment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court analysed successive versions of Section 34(1)(a). Before 1956, a notice could be issued within eight years; the 1956 amendment allowed notices “at any time” only when escaped income exceeded Rs 1 lakh, and otherwise retained an eight-year limit. The amount involved here was below Rs 1 lakh, making the post-1956 eight-year period decisive.

Section 4 of the 1959 Amendment Act protects pre-1959 notices only from challenges based on the expiry of the limitation period as it stood before the 1956 amendment. The assessee’s objection, however, rested on the period prescribed after the 1956 amendment. Accordingly, the statutory saving clause did not apply. The Court found support in Sarkar J.’s observations in Prashar, which recognised that Section 4 does not obliterate all limitation provisions; a notice remains subject to any later-introduced time prescriptions.

Because the notice was issued more than eight years after the close of the accounting year (12 November 1947) and after 1 April 1957—the last date permissible under the 1956 amendment—it was time-barred. The second proviso to Section 34(3) was inapplicable, as the AAC’s earlier order contained no “finding” or “direction” to re-initiate proceedings.

Holding and Implications

Judgment of the Madras High Court set aside; question answered in favour of the assessee.

Consequently, the notice issued on 9 July 1958 and the reassessment dated 14 December 1960 are invalid. The decision affords immediate relief to the legal representatives of the deceased assessee; it does not announce a new legal principle but clarifies the limited scope of Section 4 of the 1959 Amendment Act when the 1956 amendment’s limitation period has expired.

Show all summary ...

S.M Sikri, C.J— This appeal by certificate granted by the Madras High Court under Section 66-A(2) of the Indian Income Tax Act, 1922, hereinafter referred to as “the Act”, is from the judgment of the Madras High Court in a reference made to it under Section 66(1) of the Act by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Madras Bench.

2. The Tribunal referred the following questions:

“Whether the present proceedings initiated under Section 34(1)(a) of the Act against the assessees are valid in law?”
The relevant facts may now be stated. For Assessment Year 1948-49 (accounting year ending November 12, 1947) an assessment was made on Abdullabhai Fazalali in the status of an individual on September 30, 1948, on a total income of Rs 9102. The sources of income considered in the assessment were share income from the firm of S.A Bhagat and Co., and property income. Subsequently, it came to light that Abdullabhai Fazalali had deposited Rs 40,000 in cash on July 28, 1947, in the branch of the Bank of India Ltd. at Palanpur, now in North Gujarat. Abdullabhai Fazalali died on August 1, 1954. Notice under Section 34(1)(a) of the Act was served on February 9, 1957, on Hussainbhai Abdullabhai as legal heir and representative of the estate of the late Abdullabhai Fazalali. On March 9, 1957, a return was filed showing the income as Rs 8237, but in Column ‘D’ the sum of Rs 40,000 aforesaid was mentioned.

3. While the proceedings were pending under Section 23(2) of the Act a petition was filed in the High Court challenging the validity of the proceedings under Section 34(1)(a). On March 15, 1957, assessment was made. An appeal to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner under Section 30 of the Act was filed on April 15, 1957. On March 15, 1958, the High Court dismissed the writ petition on the ground that the assessee had already availed himself of the ordinary remedies provided under the Act. (It appears from the order of Appellate Assistant Commissioner, dated April 29, 1958, that the High Court expressed the view that the proceedings under Section 34(1)(a) were illegal.) … The Appellate Assistant Commissioner, by this order following the finding of the High Court regarding the illegality of the proceedings under Section 34 set aside the assessment on the ground that the proceedings initiated under Section 34 were illegal and not valid.

4. The Income Tax Officer then issued a fresh notice under Section 34(1)(a) on July 9, 1958, to all the legal representatives of the deceased Abdullabhai Fazalali. By his order, dated December 14, 1960, the Income Tax Officer held that the cash deposit of Rs 40,000 in the Bank of India in Palanpur came from undisclosed sources of income of the assessee in the then taxable territories and assessed it accordingly.

5. We may mention that no reference was made to the Income Tax (Amendment) Act, 1959 (1 of 1959) by him.

6. The assessee appealed to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and inter alia contended that the assessment was time-barred. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner held that the Appellate Assistant Commissioner's order passed in respect of the original proceedings under Section 34 did not contain any finding or direction within the meaning of Section 34(3) and accordingly the assessment order, dated December 14, 1960, was vitiated.

7. The Revenue then filed an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. The Appellate Tribunal set aside the order of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner holding that the proceedings under Section 34(1)(a) had been properly initiated by the notices issued on July 9, 1958, and directed him to decide the other issues raised according to law.

8. We may mention that on the point of limitation the only point debated before the Appellate Tribunal was regarding the effect of the proviso to Section 34(3) of the Act. The Appellate Tribunal came to the conclusion that the order of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner dismissing the original proceedings under Section 34(1)(a) against Hussainbhai Abdullabhai, who legally represented the assessee, could be construed as giving a direction to the Income Tax Officer to initiate fresh proceedings.

9. The High Court in the reference, however, came to the conclusion that the second proviso to Section 34(3) would be inapplicable. The High Court observed:

“There was no direction or finding in the order of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, dated April 24, 1958, as would attract that proviso. A finding for the purpose of that proviso should be one on a point at issue in the assessment proceedings or in the appeal.”

10. It was contended before the High Court that a fresh notice served under Section 34(1)(a) beyond eight years of the assessment order was barred by time. The Revenue contended that Section 4 of the Income Tax (Amendment) Act, 1959 (1 of 1959) saved a fresh notice from the bar of limitation. The High Court held that Section 4 of Act I of 1959, saved the notice under Section 34(1)(a) issued on July 9, 1958, from the bar of limitation and accordingly answered the question against the assessee.

11. The short question before us is whether Section 4 of the Indian Income Tax (Amendment) Act, 1959, saves the fresh notice from the bar of limitation. But in order to fully deal with the point it is necessary to set out the relevant portion of Section 34(1)(a) as it existed at various times.

12. The relevant portion of Section 34(1), as amended in 1948, reads as follows:

“34. (1) If—
(a) the Income Tax Officer has reason to believe that by reason of the omission or failure on the part of an assessee to make a return of his income under Section 22 for any year or disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for his assessment for that year, income, profits or gains chargeable to income tax have escaped assessment for that year….
* * *
he may in cases falling under clause (a) at any time within eight years and in cases falling under clause (b) at any time within four years of the end of that year, serve on the assessee, or, … a notice containing all or any of the requirements which may be included in a notice under sub-section (2) of Section 22….”
The relevant portion of Section 34(1) as amended by the Finance Act, 1956 (Act 18 of 1956) reads thus:
“34. (1) If—
(a) the Income Tax Officer has reason to believe that by reason of the omission or failure on the part of an assessee to make a return of his income under Section 22 for any year or to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for his assessment for that year, income, profits or gains chargeable to income tax have escaped assessment for that year….
* * *
he may in cases falling under clause (a) at any time and in cases falling under clause (b) at any time within four years of the end of that year, serve on the assessee… a notice containing all or any of the requirements which may be included in a notice under sub-section (2) of Section 22:
Provided that the Income Tax Officer shall not issue a notice under clause (a) of sub-section (1)—
(i) for any year prior to the year ending on the 31st day of March, 1941;
(ii) for any year, if eight years have elapsed after the expiry of that year, unless the income, profits or gains chargeable to income tax which have escaped assessment….
amount to, or are likely to amount to, one lakh of rupees or more in the aggregate, either for that year, or for that year and any other year or years after which or after each of which eight years have elapsed, not being a year or years ending before the 31st day of March, 1941….”

Section 34(4) of the Act as inserted by the Indian Income Tax (Amendment) Act, 1959, reads as follows:

“(4) A notice under clause (a) of sub-section (1) may be issued at any time notwithstanding that at the time of the issue of the notice the period of eight years specified in that sub-section before its amendment by clause (a) of Section 18 of the Finance Act, 1956 (18 of 1956), had expired in respect of the year to which the notice relates.”

Section 4 of the Indian Income Tax (Amendment) Act, 1959, provided:

“4. Saving of notices, assessments, etc., in certain cases.—No notice issued under clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 34 of the principal Act at any time before the commencement of this Act and no assessment, re-assessment or settlement made or other proceedings taken in consequence of such notice shall be called in question in any court, tribunal or other authority merely on the ground that at the time the notice was issued or at the time the assessment or re-assessment was made, the time within which such notice should have been issued or the assessment or reassessment should have been made under that section as in force before its amendment by clause (a) of Section 18 of the Finance Act, 1956 (18 of 1956), had expired.”

The learned counsel for the State quite rightly does not rely on Section 34(4) of the Act to validate the notice because this contemplates a notice issued after the coming into force of the 1959 Act.

13. It seems to us that Section 4 of the Amending Act of 1959, does not save the notice under Section 34(1)(a) issued on July 9, 1958. In this case we are concerned with an income less than 1 lakh mentioned in Section 34 as amended by Finance Act, 1956. It is no doubt true, as urged by the learned counsel for the Revenue, that the first sentence of Section 4 includes all notices issued under clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 34 of the Act at any time before the commencement of the 1959 Act and the notice, dated July 9, 1958, falls within this description. But in our view the section does not save such notices from attack on all grounds whatsoever; the only ground which cannot be taken to attack the validity of the notice is that at the time the notice was issued the period prescribed under Section 34(1)(a), as in force before its amendment by Section 18 of the Finance Act, 1956, had expired. Is the assessee then raising this ground? It seems to us that he is not. What he is saying is that a notice under Section 34(1)(a), as amended by the Finance Act of 1956, could have been issued under that Act in respect of Assessment Year 1948-49, till April 1 1957, and when the Finance Act of 1956, came into force he came to be governed by the eight year period prescribed by the Act as amended by the 1956 Act and not the eight year period prescribed by the Act as it existed before the amendments made in 1956. Accordingly the assessee's ground of attack is that the eight years prescribed by Section 34 as amended after 1956, have expired and not that eight years prescribed by Section 34 before its amendment by Finance Act, 1956, have expired. In our view the stand taken by the assessee is correct.

14. We are supported in the view we have taken by certain observations of Sarkar, J., as he then was, in S.C Prashar, ITO v. Vasantsen Dwarkadas AIR 1963 SC 1356, (1964) 1 SCR 29, (1963) 1 SCJ 687, (1963) 49 ITR (SC) 1. The Court in that case was not concerned with assessment years in respect of which a notice could be issued under Section 34(1)(a) of the Act, as amended by the Finance Act of 1956, but the present case was visualised by Sarkar, J., in that case. He observed:

“So, though Section 4 of the 1959 Act freed a notice from the bar of limitation in respect of it imposed by the 1948 amendment, it did not altogether do away with all prescriptions of time. In spite of Section 4, a notice contemplated by it would be subject to the prescription of time as to its issue under the 1939 Act and may be, under Section 34 as it stood before the 1939 amendment. If the notice was issued after the 1956 amendment it would also be subject to the prescription as to time provided by that amendment.

(emphasis supplied)

Then it was said that if Section 4 applied to a notice issued more than eight years after the year in which the income escaped assessment but before the 1956 amendment came into force in a case where the escaped income of the year was less than Rs 1,00,000, the position would be curious. A notice issued in a similar case after the 1956 amendment would be bad under Section 34 as it then stood and Section 4 could not save it for it saved notices only from the effect of the 1948 amendment. The position then would be that in a case involving the same amount of escaped income for the same year, a notice issued before 1956 amendment and invalid under the 1948 amendment would be validated and a more recent notice equally invalid under both the earlier and present laws would remain invalid. Assume that the position is somewhat curious or incongruous. But that seems to me to be the result of the words used. For all we know that might have been intended. However strange, if at all, the result may be, I do not think the Courts can alter the plain meaning of the language of the statute only on the ground of incongruity if there is nothing in the words which would justify the alteration. As I have said earlier, in this case there is nothing to justify the alteration of the plain meaning.”

15. We agree with the observations of the learned Judge. But, as we have said, this Court was not concerned with a case governed by period of limitation as prescribed in 1956 and accordingly we do not find it necessary to refer to the reasoning of the other learned Judges.

16. Accordingly we set aside the judgment of the High Court and answer the question in favour of the assessee, with costs throughout.