- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sunil Kumar Roy v. Bhowra Kankanee Collieries Ltd. And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
In 1900 the Zamindar of Jharia granted a registered lease over land in Mauza Gourkhanti to the Eastern Coal Co. Ltd. The company erected structures for coke manufacture. On 17 May 1946 it sold its machinery and sub-leased the land with the buildings to the present appellant. The lease fixed royalty at Re 1 per ton of coke, subject to revision “by mutual arrangement … as may be justified by market condition.” The appellant contended that:
- In 1950 the royalty on breeze coke was mutually revised to Rs 2 per ton.
- In December 1951 the royalty on hard coke was reduced to 8 As. per ton, effective 19 July 1952, the alleged terms being contained in document Ex. A-4.
With effect from 1 January 1955 the colliery was transferred to Bhowra Kankanee Collieries Ltd. (Respondent 1), which demanded royalty at the original rate of Re 1 per ton. When the appellant remitted payments at the alleged reduced rates, Respondent 1 sued on 31 January 1956 for Rs 23,287-4-3 as unpaid royalty for January–November 1955, plus damages.
The trial court dismissed the suit, accepting the appellant’s version and holding Ex. A-4 admissible. On appeal, the Patna High Court reversed, finding no proof that the revised rates had ever been brought into effect from July 1952 and leaving undecided the registration issue. The appellant obtained a certificate of fitness and appealed to the Supreme Court of India.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellant had proved a valid mutual arrangement, effective from 19 July 1952, reducing the royalty payable under the registered lease.
- If such an arrangement existed, whether Ex. A-4, being unregistered, could legally vary an “essential term” (the rate of royalty) of the existing registered lease under the Indian Registration Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The 1950 and 1951 arrangements, embodied in Ex. A-4, validly reduced royalty to Rs 2 per ton on breeze coke and 8 As. per ton on hard coke from 19 July 1952.
- The trial court correctly treated Ex. A-4 as admissible and operative.
- Additional contentions on Issues 3 and alleged subsequent conduct were also advanced but only faintly pressed in the Supreme Court.
Respondent's Arguments
- No change in market conditions warranted a reduction; hence royalty remained Re 1 per ton.
- Even if Ex. A-4 existed, it was inadmissible because an unregistered document cannot vary the rent reserved by a registered lease.
- Damages were claimed for delayed or deficient payment during January–November 1955.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Durga Prasad Singh v. Rajendra Narain Bagchi | A document that varies an essential term (e.g., rent) of an existing registered lease must itself be registered. | Relied upon as the primary authority to hold that Ex. A-4 required registration to effect a reduction in royalty. |
| Lalit Mohan Ghosh v. Gopal Chuck Coal Company Ltd. (Full Bench) | Approved and reaffirmed the principle laid down in Durga Prasad Singh. | Cited to reinforce that the requirement of registration is well-settled and binding. |
| Obai Goundan v. Ramalinga Ayyar (Madras High Court) | Contrary view—held that registration was unnecessary in similar circumstances. | The Supreme Court noted that this view has not been followed elsewhere, underscoring the uniform acceptance of the registration requirement. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court first observed that the High Court’s factual finding—no proof of a mutually agreed reduction effective from July 1952—stood unassailed; counsel for the appellant did not request its reversal. Consequently, the appeal could succeed only if the alleged reduction were legally enforceable even assuming Ex. A-4 contained such a term.
Invoking Durga Prasad Singh and its approval in Lalit Mohan Ghosh, the Court reiterated that any document purporting to alter an essential term of a registered lease (including the rent or royalty) must be registered under the Indian Registration Act. Ex. A-4 was admittedly unregistered; therefore, even if executed, it could not lawfully vary the royalty clause of the 1946 registered lease. The contrary view of the Madras High Court in Obai Goundan was expressly rejected.
Other minor contentions—regarding Issue 3, alleged subsequent conduct, admission of additional evidence, and impleadment of Oriental Coal Co. Ltd.—were found insubstantial and were summarily dismissed.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS.
The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s decree, reinstating Respondent 1’s entitlement to royalty at Re 1 per ton for the period in dispute. The ruling confirms the settled law that an unregistered document cannot vary the rent or royalty reserved in a registered lease, thereby reinforcing uniformity among High Courts and providing clear guidance to lessors and lessees engaged in similar transactions.
A.N Grover, J.— This is an appeal by certificate from a judgment of the Patna High Court. The facts may be shortly stated. By a registered indenture of lease, dated December 18, 1900, the Eastern Coal Co. Ltd. was granted a lease by the Zamindar of Jharia of certain land in Mauza Gourkhanti in pargana Jharia. The Eastern Coal Co erected buildings for manufacture of coke and also constructed office and the quarters for the staff and the labourers. On May 17, 1946, the Eastern Coal Co. sold the machineries on the demised land to the appellant and also granted a lease of the land on which the buildings stood to him. One of the terms of the lease was that royalty would be paid by the appellant at the rate of Re 1 per ton on despatches of coke. The rate was subject to being revised from time to time by mutual arrangement between the parties “as may be justified by market condition”. According to the appellant the Eastern Coal Company came to an arrangement in 1950 with him by which royalty on breeze coke was to be paid at the rate of 2 Rs per ton. In December, 1951, another arrangement was arrived at by which royalty on hard coke was to be paid at the reduced rate of 8 As. per ton instead of Re 1 per ton stipulated in the lease dated May 17, 1946. This arrangement was to be given effect to from July 19, 1952. On January 5, 1955, the Eastern Coal Company informed the appellant that the colliery had been sold to the Bhowra Kankanee Collieries Ltd., Respondent 1, the sale being effective from January 1, 1955. Respondent 1 claimed royalty on all despatches of coke including breeze coke at the rate of Rs 1 per ton. The appellant took up the position that by mutual agreement Eastern Coal Company had agreed to the royalty being payable on hard coke at the rate of 8 Rs per ton and on breeze coke at 2 Rs per ton. The appellant paid to Respondent 1 the amount calculated according to the above rates.
2. On January 31, 1956, Respondent 1 instituted a suit against the appellant claiming a sum of Rs 23,287-4-3 on account of royalty on all kinds of coke despatched during the period January, 1955 to November, 1955 at the rate of Re 1 per ton. The Company further claimed damages at 6 per annum amounting to Rs 1212-11-9. The appellant contested the suit, his main plea being that by virtue of the arrangement arrived at with the Eastern Coal Company in accordance with the terms of the lease, dated May 17, 1946, the royally was payable at the rate of Re 1 per ton for hard coke and 2 Rs per ton for breeze coke. The Trial Court accepted the plea of the appellant about reduction of the rates of royalty in terms of the arrangement arrived at with the Eastern Coal Company. It was further held that the document Ex. A-4 in which this agreement or arrangement was incorporated did not require registration compulsorily and was admissible in evidence. The suit was dismissed. Respondent 1 preferred an appeal to the High Court. Although the point with regard to the admissibility of Ex. A-4 for lack of registration was raised before the High Court it did not give any decision on it. The judgment of tlie High Court rested on the finding that the appellant had failed to prove that the reduction in the rate of royalty had been given effect to from July 1952.
3. Mr B. Sen for the appellant sought to raise the question about the admissibility of Ex. A-4 for want of registration. In the first place this contention cannot be entertained so long as the finding of the High Court on the only point which was canvassed before it about the reduction of the rate of royalty is not set aside. The High Court had held after an examination of the evidence that it had not been proved that there was any change in the market condition in July or in December 1953, to call for a reduction in the rate of royalty or that there was any mutual arrangement or agreement between the lessor or the lessee for such a reduction which was to become effective from July 1952. No attempt was made by Mr Sen to persuade us to reverse this conclusion. Even on the assumption that a mutual arrangement or agreement as evidenced by Ex. A-4 was arrived at between the appellant and the Eastern Coal Co. Ltd., we are unable to agree that any reduction in the rate of royalty could have been effected by means of Ex A-4 which had not been registered under the provisions of the Indian Registration Act. It is well-settled by now that a document which varies the essential terms of the existing registered lease, such as the amount of rent, must be registered: See Durga Prasad Singh v. Rajendra Narain Bagchi, which was approved by the Full Bench in Lalit Mohan Ghosh v. Gopal Chuck Coal Company Ltd. The decision of the Madras High Court in Obai Goundan v. Ramalinga Ayyar taking a contrary view has not been followed by the High Courts in India and the consistent view that has been taken is that registration of an agreement is necessary which reduces the rent of an existing registered lease. (See Mulla on Indian Registration Act, 7th Edn.., pp. 75-76.)
4. The other contentions faintly raised before us arising out of Issue 3 and that Ex. A-4 had been acted upon do not survive in view of the conclusions arrived at by the High Court and the view that we have taken about the admissibility of the aforesaid document. The Civil Miscellaneous Petitions which were filed in this Court shall stand dismissed as, in our opinion, no ground has been made out for admitting additional evidence or for impleading the Oriental Coal Co. Ltd., as a party respondent here.
5. The appeal fails and it is dismissed with costs.
Alert