- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Filmistan Private Ltd., Bombay v. Bhagwandas Santprakash And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant obtained special leave to appeal against an order of Vimadalal, J. in S. Suit No. 109 of 1962 on the original side of the Bombay High Court. The impugned order directed that a letter of request be issued to the Ambassador of India in Kabul for the examination, on commission, of several witnesses residing in Kabul. All the witnesses were concededly relevant but lived outside the jurisdiction of the Bombay High Court, rendering them beyond the Court’s ordinary process. The Supreme Court was asked to review this discretionary order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Supreme Court should interfere with the trial judge’s discretionary decision to issue a letter of request for examination of witnesses in Kabul.
- Whether the absence of a reciprocal agreement between India and Afghanistan precludes the lawful examination of witnesses in Kabul under Sections 75 and 77 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- Whether the potential inability of the Commissioner to compel attendance or administer an oath renders the commission futile.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- One of the Kabul witnesses is an agent of the first defendant and could have been produced in India; therefore a commission was unnecessary.
- Matters expected from the remaining witnesses could be proved through other evidence available domestically.
- Examination on commission would impede effective cross-examination and impose heavy costs.
- A Commissioner in Kabul cannot compel witnesses to appear, making the exercise futile.
- Because no reciprocal arrangement exists between India and Afghanistan, witnesses cannot be lawfully examined in Kabul.
Respondent's Arguments
This information was not available in the provided opinion.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court characterised the impugned directive as a discretionary order. It found no persuasive ground to disturb that discretion, noting that the trial judge would have considered the appellant’s objections regarding alternative evidence and the agency relationship of one witness. Concerns about costly or ineffective cross-examination were deemed insufficient to overturn a discretion validly exercised.
Addressing the alleged futility of a commission because witnesses might refuse to attend, the Court held the point premature: the present record contained no indication of unwillingness, and the defendant could voluntarily present the witnesses before the Commissioner.
On the absence of a reciprocal treaty, the Court relied on Sections 75 and 77 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which empower Indian courts to issue letters of request to examine witnesses “at any place not within India” without conditioning that power on inter-governmental reciprocity. The Court stated it was unaware of any Afghan law prohibiting such examinations and that questions about the Commissioner’s authority to administer oaths or the admissibility of the evidence could be raised at the trial stage, not at the interlocutory stage.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Dismissed. The order authorising issuance of a letter of request to the Indian Ambassador in Kabul stands affirmed, with no order as to costs.
Implications: The decision underscores the broad discretionary power of trial courts under Sections 75 and 77 CPC to commission evidence abroad, unconditioned by reciprocal arrangements. It clarifies that challenges to the mode of execution or admissibility of such evidence are matters for the trial, not grounds for interlocutory interference. No new precedent was set beyond affirming established principles on judicial discretion in issuing commissions.
K.S Hegde, J.— This appeal by special leave is directed against the order issued by Vimadalal, J., in S. Suit No. 109 of 1962, on the original side of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay directing the issue of a letter of request to our Ambassador at Kabul to examine certain witnesses who are residing in Kabul on commission.
2. Admittedly the witnesses sought to be examined at Kabul are relevant witnesses. All of them are living outside the jurisdiction of the Court and hence they are not amenable to the process of the Court. It was said on behalf of the appellant that one of the witnesses sought to be examined is an agent of the 1st defendant and therefore that defendant could have produced him in Court for examination. As regards the other witnesses, it was said that the facts that they were expected to depose could have been established by other evidence. We have no doubt that these facts must have been considered by the learned Trial Judge. The order under appeal is essentially a discretionary order. We do not think that a case is made out for interfering with the discretion of the learned Trial Judge. The fact that the witnesses examined on commission cannot be effectively cross-examined or their cross-examination will entail heavy costs are not sufficient circumstances to interfere with the discretion of the learned trial Judge.
3. It was urged on behalf of the Appellant that the Commissioner cannot compel the witnesses to appear before him for examination and therefore the attempt to examine them is a futile one. We think this consideration is irrelevant at this stage. We do not know whether the witnesses in question are willing to be examined by the Commissioner or not. It is for the defendant to produce them before the Commissioner, if he wants them to be examined.
4. It was further urged that as there is no reciprocal agreement between our Government and the Government of Afghanistan, the witnesses cannot be lawfully examined in Kabul. Section 77 of the Code of Civil Procedure, read with Section 75 empowers the Court to issue a letter of request to any person other than a Court to examine witnesses residing at any place not within India. This power of the Court is not subject to any reciprocal agreement between the Governments. We do not know whether there is any law in Afghanistan prohibiting the examination of witnesses by Consular authorities. Nor is there any material before us on the basis of which we can decide whether the Commissioner can administer oath or not. These questions do not appear to have been urged before the trial court. The question whether the evidence recorded by the Commissioner is legally admissible or not can certainly be canvassed at the trial of the case. It is not necessary to go into that question at present.
5. For the reasons mentioned above this appeal fails and the same is dismissed — no order as to costs.
Alert