- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Punjab And Others v. Bhai Ardaman Singh & Others Etc.
Factual and Procedural Background
Seventy tenants of agricultural land in village Dialpura-Bhaika, District Bhatinda, alleged that they had been forcibly dispossessed of their holdings in May–June 1943 by Bhai Arjan Singh. After the enactment of the Pepsu Tenancy and Agricultural Act, 1953 (Act 8 of 1953), the tenants applied to the Collectors of Sangrur and Bhatinda for restoration of possession under section 43. The Collectors allowed the applications and ordered restoration. The Commissioner affirmed the orders, reasoning that the Collector could act on his “subjective satisfaction.” The Financial Commissioner also confirmed the orders on the ground that “substantial justice” had been done.
Bhai Ardaman Singh (who had inherited the lands in 1946) challenged the revenue orders before the Punjab High Court. A single-judge bench (Gosain J.) dismissed the petition, holding that Act 8 of 1953 constituted a complete code and vested jurisdiction in the Collector. On Letters Patent Appeal, a Division Bench reversed the decision, holding that section 43 had no retrospective effect and that the Collector had denied the respondent an adequate opportunity to lead evidence. The State of Punjab obtained special leave and appealed to the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether section 43(1)(b) of the Pepsu Tenancy and Agricultural Act, 1953 has retrospective application to dispossessions that occurred prior to the Act’s commencement.
- Whether the Collector’s jurisdiction under section 43(1)(b) depends on a judicial determination that the person in possession is disentitled to use and occupation under the Act, or whether subjective satisfaction suffices.
- Whether orders passed without jurisdiction can be sustained on the ground that they achieve “substantial justice.”
Arguments of the Parties
State of Punjab (Appellants)
- Urged the Supreme Court not to disturb the revenue authorities’ orders even if technically erroneous, contending that those orders did substantial justice because the tenants had been wrongfully dispossessed.
Bhai Ardaman Singh & Ors. (Respondents)
- Contended that section 43 had no retrospective operation and therefore could not be invoked for dispossessions that occurred in 1943.
- Argued that the Collector had acted without giving the respondents a proper opportunity to adduce evidence.
- Advanced (though ultimately not ruled upon) the submission that section 43 does not apply to disputes strictly between a landlord and his own tenant.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court focused on the text of section 43(1)(b). Jurisdiction under that clause arises only when two cumulative conditions exist: (1) the person sought to be evicted is in “wrongful or unauthorised possession,” and (2) such person is “not entitled to the use and occupation” of the land under the Act. The Court found no provision in Act 8 of 1953 that disentitled the first respondent to occupy the land; hence the second, jurisdictional condition was absent. Because the statutory pre-condition failed, the Collector lacked authority to entertain the tenants’ applications.
Rejecting the Commissioner’s view, the Court stressed that the Collector’s proceedings, though summary, are “judicial in character” and must rest on an objective judicial determination of jurisdictional facts, not mere subjective satisfaction.
The Court affirmed the High Court’s conclusion that section 43 is not retrospective; it cannot govern dispossessions that occurred before 13 December 1953, the date on which the Act came into force.
Finally, the Court dismissed the State’s plea that the impugned orders should stand because they achieved substantial justice. Orders passed without jurisdiction cannot be validated on that ground; power may be exercised only within its statutory limits.
Holding and Implications
Appeals Dismissed with Costs.
The Supreme Court upheld the Punjab High Court’s quashing of the Collector’s ejectment orders. The immediate effect is that possession is not restored to the tenants under section 43, and the respondent landowner’s title and possession remain undisturbed by those orders. The judgment clarifies that: (1) section 43(1)(b) of Act 8 of 1953 is not retrospective, and (2) Collectoral jurisdiction under that provision depends on a judicial finding of statutory disentitlement, not subjective satisfaction. No broader precedent beyond these statutory interpretations was set.
http://JUDIS.NIC.IN SUPREME COURT OF INDIA Page 1 of 4
PETITIONER:
STATE OF PUNJAB AND ORS.
Vs.
RESPONDENT:
BHAI ARDAMAN SINGH & ORS. ETC.
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
03/05/1968
BENCH:
SHAH, J.C.
BENCH:
SHAH, J.C.
BHARGAVA, VISHISHTHA
CITATION:
1969 AIR 13 1969 SCR (1) 283
ACT:
Pepsu Tenancy and Agricultural Act 8 of 1953, s. 43(1)(b)- scope of-if has retrospective operation conditions precedent for exercise of jurisdiction by collector-whether order can be passed on subjective satisfaction or on judicial determination.
HEADNOTE:
Certain tenants of land applied to the Collector, Sangrur and Bhatinda, alleging that they had been forcibly deprived of the lands in May/June, 1943 and sought an order for restoration of possession under s. 43 of the Pepsu Tenancy and Agricultural Act 8 of 1953. The Collector granted the applications and ordered possession to be restored to the tenants. His orders were confirmed by the Commissioner who was of the view that an order under s. 43 could be passed by the Collector on his subjective satisfaction that a person was in wrongful or unauthorised possession of land. The Financial Commissioner also confirmed the orders on the ground that substantial justice had been done by the subordinate revenue authorities.
The first respondent challenged these orders by a writ petition but this was dismissed by a Single Bench holding that the Act 8 of 1953 was a code in itself and provided for a complete machinery for the decision of disputes like the resent one. But a Division Bench in appeal allowed the petition and held that Act 8 of 1953 which came into force on December 13, 1953, had no retrospective operation. On appeal to this Court
HELD, dismissing the appeals
(i) Apart from the allegation of the tenants that the first respondent was in wrongful or unauthorised possession of the lands previously occupied by them, it was further necessary to establish that under cl. (b) of s. 43(1) the person in wrongful or unauthorised possession was not entitled to the use and occupation of the lands under the provisions of the Act. There was no provision which disentitled the first respondent to the use and occupation of the lands. Section 43 (1) (b) therefore had no application in the present case. The condition precedent to the investment of jurisdiction in the Collector being absent, the revenue authorities had no power to pass the order in ejectment which they purported to
1
pass.
(ii) The proceedings of the Collector are judicial in character and although the trial is summary, the Collector is bound to exercise the jurisdiction vested in him not on a subjective satisfaction, as the Commissioner assumed, but on a judicial determination of facts which invest him with jurisdiction to pass an order in ejectment. When the condition precedent to the exercise of jurisdiction does not exist the Collector cannot clothe himself with authority to pass the impugned orders. Furthermore, the High Court had rightly held the terms of cl. (b), s. 43(1) had no retrospective operation.
(iii) If the Collector had no jurisdiction except in the special condition prescribed by s. 43, his order could not be sustained merely because
284
another authority may, if the proceeding were before that authority, on the findings recorded, have granted relief to the tenants of restoration to possession of their respective lands. Authorities which are vested with powers-judicial or quasi-judicial--can exercise their power within the limits of their jurisdiction and their actions without jurisdiction cannot be sustained merely because another body or authority, which if lawfully approached, may have jurisdiction to pass the order complained of.
JUDGMENT:
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeals Nos. 1016 to 1050, 1052 to 1075 and 1077 to 1084 of 1964. Appeals by special leave from the judgment and order dated May 14, 1959 of the Punjab High Court in L. P. Appeal No. 148 of 1 9 6 8 etc.
N. S. Bindra and R. N. Sachthey, for the appellant. M. C. Chagla and R. V. Pillai, for the respondents. The Judgment of the Court was delivered by Shah, J. In this group of appeals the dispute relates to agricultural lands situate in village Dialpura-Bhaika, District Bhatinda in the former State of Pepsu and now in the State of Punjab. The lands originally belonged to Bhai Arjan Singh. On his death in 1946 the lands devolved upon his son Bhai Ardaman Singh, the first respondent in these appeals. Alleging that Bhai Arjan Singh forcibly deprived them of the lands some time in May-June 1943, seventy tenants applied to the Collector Sangrur and Bhatinda for an order for restoration of possession tinder s. 43 of the Pepsu Tenancy and Agricultural Act 8 of 1953. The Collector granted the applications and ordered that possession be restored to the tenants. The orders were confirmed in appeal by the Commissioner. The Commissioner was of the view that the order under S. 43 could be passed by the Collector on his subjective satisfaction that a person was in wrongful or unauthorised possession of lands. The Financial Commissioner confirmed the order of the Commissioner on the ground that substantial justice had been done by the subordinate revenue authorities, and no inter- ference with the. orders was called for.
Bhai Ardaman, Singh then filed writ petitions in the High Court of Punjab challenging the orders passed by the Financial Commissioner. The petitions were heard by Gosain, J. In the view of the learned Judge Act 8 of 1953 was a complete code in itself and provided for a complete machinery for the decision of disputes like the dispute before him. He observed :
2
"Under this law Tribunals of special jurisdiction have been created and invested with powers which should enable them to effectively deal with disputes not on ly those
which arise between the landlord and the tenant, but also those which arise between persons
285
entitled to possession and persons wrongly dispossessing them. It may be that in the latter case the enquiry contemplated to be made by the Collector is only summary and that the aggrieved party may be able to have re- course finally to the civil court but the jurisdiction to make, enquiry and to order eviction has been given by the law to the Collector."
In appeals under the Letters Patent the High Court reversed the order passed by Gosain, J. The High Court was of the opinion that Act 8 of 1953 which came into force on December 13, 1953, had no retrospective operation and that Gosain, J., was in error in making an order for possession of the lands when dispossession had taken place before the Act was brought into force. The High Court also held that the proceedings of the Collector were vitiated because the Collector declined to give to the first respondent opportunity to lead evidence which he desired to lead. With certificate granted by the High Court, these appeals have been preferred by the State of Punjab.
Section 43 of the Pepsu Act 8 of 1953 provides
"(1) Any person who is in wrongful or unauthorised possession of any land
(a) the transfer of which either by the act of parties or by the operation of law is invalid under the provisions of this Act, or
(b) to the use and occupation of which be is not entitled under the provisions of this Act, may, after summary enquiry, be ejected by the Collector who may also impose on such person a penalty not exceeding five hundred rupees. Clause (a) has evidently no application. It is not the case of any party that there was any transfer of the lands which was invalid by virtue of the provisions of the Act. The tenants alleged that the first respondent was in wrongful or unauthorised possession of the lands previously occupied by them. But in order that the jurisdiction of the Collector to hold a summary enquiry and to pass the order complained of may be attracted, it was further necessary to establish that under el. (b) of S. 43(1) the person in wrongful or unauthorised possession was not entitled to the use and occupation of the lands under the provisions of the Act. Counsel for the State of Punjab is unable to invite our attention to any provision which renders the first respondent disentitled by virtue of the provisions of the Act to the use and occupation of the lands. Section 43 (1)
(b) has, therefore, no application. The condition precedent to the investment of jurisdiction in the Collector being absent, the revenue authorities had no power to pass the order in ejectment which they purported to pass. LI 2 Sup. CI/68-4
286
We must point out that the proceedings of the Collector are judicial in character. The trial is summary, but the Collector is bound to exercise the jurisdiction vested in
3
him not on a subjective satisfaction, as the Commissioner assumed, but on a judicial determination of facts which invest him with jurisdiction to pass an order in ejectment. When the condition precedent to the exercise of jurisdiction does not exist the Collector can not clothe himself with authority to pass the impugned orders. We also agree with the High Court that in view of the terms of cl. (b), S. 43 had no retrospective operation. On the view we take, it is unnecessary to consider the argument advanced by Mr. Chagla on behalf of the first respondent that S. 43 has no application to cases in which a dispute relating to tenancy of land arises between the landlord and his tenant. It is also not necessary to consider in this group of appeals whether the proceedings of the Collector were vitiated, because as alleged by the first respondent the Collector did not afford sufficient opportunity to lead evidence on the first respondent's plea that there had been no wrongful dispossession of the tenants.
Mr. Bindra on behalf of the State contended that in any event this Court should not countenance interference with the impugned orders of the revenue authorities, even if erroneous, because those authorities have in passing the orders done substantial justice. Counsel contended that the tenants had been wrongfully deprived of possession of the lands by the use of force by the first respondent and the order passed by the Collector though not strictly warranted by law was not liable to be disturbed by the High Court in exercise of their jurisdiction to issue a writ of certiorari. We are unable to agree with that contention. If the Collector had no Jurisdiction except in the special conditions prescribed by S. 43, his order could not be sustained merely because another authority may, if the proceeding were before that authority, on the findings recorded, have granted relief to the tenants of restoration to possession of their respective lands. Authorities which are vested with powers--judicial or quasi-judicial-can exercise their power within the limits of their jurisdiction and their actions without _jurisdiction cannot be sustained merely because another body or authority which if lawfully approached, may have jurisdiction to pass the order complained of.
The appeals are therefore dismissed with costs. One hearing fee.
R.K.P.S. Appeals
dismissed.
287
Alert