Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kehar Singh & Others v. Dewan Singh & Others .

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 21, 1966
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Santa Singh alias Din Mohammad, an Aulakh Jat of Tehsil Ajnala (Amritsar District), disappeared long ago and is presumed dead. The revenue authorities mutated his agricultural land in favour of the defendants, collateral relatives in the 8th degree. Megh Singh, a collateral in the 5th degree, had earlier adopted his daughter’s son, Kala Singh. After Kala Singh’s death, his sons—Dewan Singh and Gian Singh (plaintiffs)—sued for possession of Santa Singh’s lands, claiming that the adoption was a formal one that completely transplanted Kala Singh into Megh Singh’s family, thereby giving him priority in collateral succession.

The Subordinate Judge, Ajnala decreed the suit, holding that even an “appointed heir” could succeed collaterally under local custom. The District Judge, Amritsar reversed that decree, finding (i) the adoption of a daughter’s son invalid under custom and (ii) that an appointed heir who is a non-agnate cannot inherit collaterally. The Punjab High Court, in second appeal, restored the trial decree, holding that validity of adoption was not in issue and that under Amritsar Jat custom an adopted son could inherit collaterally. Defendants obtained a certificate, leading to the present appeal before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendants could challenge the validity of Kala Singh’s adoption when that issue had not been pleaded.
  2. Whether, under the customary law of Jats in Amritsar District, a person adopted by way of customary appointment of an heir acquires a right of collateral succession in the adoptive father’s family.
  3. Whether the plaintiffs proved that Kala Singh’s adoption was a formal adoption effecting a complete transplantation, rather than a mere appointment of an heir.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs (Dewan Singh & Gian Singh)

  • Megh Singh’s adoption of Kala Singh was formal, taking him entirely out of his natural family and placing him in Megh Singh’s family.
  • Under Amritsar Jat custom, such a formal adoption makes the adoptee a preferential reversionary heir entitled to succeed collaterally to Santa Singh’s property.

Defendants

  • The adoption amounted only to a customary “appointment of an heir,” not a formal adoption.
  • By custom, an appointed heir—especially a non-agnate—cannot inherit collaterally in the adoptive father’s family.
  • They also attempted (in the first appellate court) to question the validity of adopting a daughter’s son.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jai Kaur v. Sher Singh (1960) 3 SCR 979 Presumption of correctness of entries in the Riwaj-i-am; local Riwaj prevails over general digests when in conflict. Used to emphasise the evidentiary value of Amritsar Riwaj-i-am on collateral succession.
Salig Ram v. Munshi Ram (1962) 1 SCR 470 Same principle as above regarding Riwaj-i-am. Cited along with Jai Kaur to underline reliance on local custom entries.
Mela Singh v. Gurdas (1922) ILR 3 Lah 362 FB Customary adoption in Punjab usually constitutes only appointment of an heir with no collateral succession rights. Foundation for distinguishing between formal adoption and mere appointment of an heir.
Abdur Rehman v. Raghubir Singh (1949) 51 PLR 119 Formal adoption under custom completely transplants adoptee and confers collateral succession rights. Supported the principle that only a formal adoption—not an appointment of heir—creates collateral succession rights.
Waryaman v. Kanshi Ram (1922) ILR 3 Lah 17 Same as Abdur Rehman regarding effects of formal adoption. Reinforced the differentiation between formal adoptions and appointments of heirs.
Jowala Singh v. Lachmi, 14 PR 1884 Appointed heir under Amritsar Jat custom cannot succeed collaterally. Referenced as one of several consistent decisions denying collateral rights to appointed heirs.
Mangal Singh v. Tilok Singh, 61 PR 1894 Same rule; also contains observation on non-agnates. Relied upon by District Judge; Supreme Court noted but found other grounds sufficient to decide.
Chetu v. Jawand Singh, 107 PR 1913 Adopted heir does not succeed to collaterals among Sikh Jats of Taran Taran. Part of the line of decisions affirming no collateral rights for appointed heirs.
Indar Singh v. Gurdevi AIR 1930 Lah 897 Appointed heir is not a “lineal descendant” under §59 Punjab Tenancy Act. Cited to demonstrate limited legal status of an appointed heir.
Jagat Singh v. Ishar Singh (citation not provided) Appointed heir retains collateral rights in natural family. Used to show that appointment of heir does not sever ties with natural family.
Teju v. Kesar Singh AIR 1954 Punjab 30 (affirming Teja Singh v. Kesar Singh AIR 1951 Punjab 117) In Amritsar District, a complete (formal) adoption entitles the adoptee to collateral succession. Cited as illustration that formal adoptions create collateral succession rights.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Challenge to validity of adoption barred. The Court agreed with the High Court that defendants could not contest the validity of Kala Singh’s adoption because the written statement never raised that plea, and the parties had had no opportunity to adduce evidence on any special custom prohibiting adoption of a daughter’s son.

2. Customary law on collateral succession distinguished. Reviewing Rattigan’s Digest, the Amritsar Riwaj-i-am (1914 & 1940 editions), and a consistent line of judicial decisions, the Court held:

  • A mere appointment of an heir creates only a personal bond between appointer and appointee; no tie of kinship is established with the collaterals (Article 49, Rattigan).
  • A formal adoption that completely transplants the adoptee severs his natural-family ties and endows him with collateral succession rights in the adoptive family.
  • Entries in the Riwaj-i-am supporting collateral succession must, in light of case-law, be confined to formal adoptions and not to appointments of heirs.

3. Onus and factual finding. The plaintiffs bore the burden of proving that Megh Singh’s adoption of Kala Singh was formal. Concurrent findings of the trial court and District Judge, affirmed implicitly by the High Court on facts, established that the adoption was only an appointment of an heir. Evidence relied on included:

  • Kala Singh’s subsequent successions to property of his natural brother Makhan and collateral Hira Singh—showing he retained rights in his natural family.
  • No convincing instance of collateral succession in the adoptive family; the cited succession from widow Bhagan was merely reversion of a life-estate, not collateral succession.

Because the adoption was informal, Kala Singh acquired no right to the collaterals of Megh Singh, and therefore his sons (plaintiffs) had no better title to Santa Singh’s land than the defendants in the 8th degree.

4. Agnatic objection left open. The District Judge’s additional ground—that a non-agnate appointed heir cannot inherit—was noted, but the Supreme Court found it unnecessary to decide that point given its primary conclusion.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; HIGH COURT DECREE SET ASIDE; DISTRICT JUDGE DECREE RESTORED; SUIT DISMISSED.

Consequences: Plaintiffs lose their claim to Santa Singh’s lands; defendants’ mutation stands. The decision re-affirms the distinction in Punjab custom between a formal adoption and a mere appointment of an heir, but does not create new precedent beyond applying existing custom to the facts.

Show all summary ...

Bachawat, J.— The parties are Aulakh Jats of Tehsil Ajnala in Amritsar District, and are governed by customary law in matters of succession and adoption. The dispute concerns succession to the property of one Santa Singh alias Din Mohammad. Santa Singh has not been heard of for a long time and is presumed to be dead. The Revenue authorities sanctioned mutation of the lands left by him in favour of the defendants, who are his collaterals of the 8th degree. One Megh Singh was the collateral of Santa Singh in the 5th degree. Megh Singh died more than 50 years ago. Before his death, he adopted his daughter's son, one Kala Singh. Kala Singh has died leaving his sons, Dewan Singh and Gian Singh as his heirs. Dewan Singh and Gian Singh instituted a suit in the court of the Subordinate Judge, First Class, Ajnala praying for a decree for possession of the lands left by Santa Singh and alleging that Megh Singh adopted Kala Singh as his son, took him out of his natural family, transplanted him completely in the family of Megh Singh and bestowed on him the rights of a natural son, according to the custom by which the parties were governed, Kala Singh was entitled to succeed as a reversionary heir in the family of his adoptive father and was the preferential heir of Santa Singh. The contesting defendants alleged that the adoption of Kala Singh amounted to the appointment of an heir only and they denied that according to custom Kala Singh was the reversionary heir of Santa Singh or entitled to inherit his lands.

2. The Subordinate Judge, Ajnala and the District Judge, Amritsar concurrently held that the adoption of Kala Singh was the usual customary appointment of an heir. The trial court also held that by the custom of Jats in Amritsar District an appointed heir was entitled to succeed collaterally in the family of his adoptive father and consequently, Kala Singh was the preferential heir of Santa Singh. On appeal, the District Judge, Amritsar set aside the decree passed by the trial court, and dismissed the suit. He held that according to custom, the adoption of a daughter's son was not permissible and the adoption of Kala Singh was, therefore, invalid. He also held that under the customary law an adopted son could not succeed collaterally in his adoptive father's family if he was a non-agnate i.e if he did not belong to the Got of his adoptive father. On second appeal, the High Court set aside the order of the District Judge, Amritsar, and restored the decree passed by the trial court. The High Court, held that it was not open to the defendants to challenge the validity of the adoption of Kala Singh, as the point was not in issue between the parties, and under the customary law, Kala Singh, as the adopted son of Megh Singh, was entitled to succeed collaterally in his adoptive father's family. Some of the defendants now appeal to this Court on a certificate granted by the High Court.

3. In agreement with the High Court we hold that it is not open to the defendants to contend that the adoption of Kala Singh by Megh Singh was invalid. In the written statement, the defendants did not allege that Megh Singh had no power to adopt Kala Singh, as Kala Singh was the daughter's son of Megh Singh. As the validity of the adoption was not in issue, the parties had no opportunity to lead any evidence on the question whether by the special custom of the parties Megh Singh could lawfully adopt his daughter's son.

4. The substantial point in controversy between the parties is whether by the custom governing the Jats of Amritsar District Kala Singh was entitled to succeed collaterally in the family of his adoptive father. Some general customs as to adoption are found to exist in the Punjab, and they are collected in Rattigan's Digest of Customary Law. Some of the customs observed in the several Districts and Tehsils of the Punjab are collected in the Riwaj-i-am. There is a presumption that the entries in the Riwaj-i-am are correct, and if there is a conflict between Rattigan's Digest and the Riwaj-i-am, normally the Riwaj-i-am of the locality prevails, see Jai Kaur v. Sher Singh (1960) 3 SCR 979, Salig Ram v. Munshi Ram (1962) 1 SCR 470. Judicial decisions furnish reliable instances in which the custom in question was recognised or departed from. Oral and documentary evidence of mutations and other transactions in which the custom was recognised or departed from are also relevant material to prove or disprove the custom.

5. A customary adoption in the Punjab is ordinarily no more than a mere appointment of an heir creating a personal relationship between the adoptive father and the appointed heir only, see Mela Singh v. Gurdas (1922) ILR 3 Lah 362 FB. There is no tie of kinship between the appointed heir and the collaterals of the adoptive father. The appointed heir does not acquire the right to succeed collaterally in the adoptive father's family. The status of the appointed heir is thus materially different from that of a son adopted under the Hindu law.

6. The general custom negativing the right of the appointed heir to succeed collaterally in the family of his adoptive father is stated in Article 49 of Rattigan's Digest of Customary Law, 13th Edn., p. 572 thus:

“49. Nor, on the other hand, does the heir acquire a right to succeed to the collateral relatives of the person who appoints him, where no formal adoption has taken place, inasmuch as the relationship established between him and the appointer is a purely personal one.”

7. The rule in Article 49 does not apply to a formal adoption by the customary method. The customary formal adoption completely severs the connection of the adopted son with his natural family and transplants him from his natural family to the adoptive family. Such an adoption confers on the adopted son the right of collateral succession in the adoptive father's family and takes away the right of collateral succession in the natural family. The formal adoption may be made in accordance with custom and by observing the customary forms, and it is not necessary to comply with the rules of Hindu law in the matter of ritual or otherwise. See Abdur Rehman v. Raghubir Singh (1949) 51 PLR 119, Waryaman v. Kanshi Ram (1922) ILR 3 Lah 17.

8. The Manual of Customary Law of the Amritsar District by H.D Craik in 1914 records the following question and answer—

“Question 91. Can an adopted son succeed collaterally in the family of his adoptive father?
Answer 91. All the tribes state that an adopted son succeeds collaterally in the family of his adoptive father, with the exception of Brahmans and Khatris of Neshta, who say that he does not do so. The rule defined by the courts, however, is that an adopted son has no right to succeed in this manner. The latest ruling on this point is P.R 107 of 1913 in which it was held that among Jat Sikhas of the Taran Taran tehsil an adopted son, appointed by the usual customary method, does not succeed to collaterals as his adoptive father's representative.”

9. The English translation of the Urdu version of the Riwaj-i-am of the Amritsar District for the year 1940 (Ex. P. C/1) records the following question and answer:

No. of question Question Answer 90 Can an adopted son succeed collaterally in the family of his adoptive father? All the tribes, yes. See Schedule I for relevant mutations. See Schedule II for judgments in Civil cases.

10. Schedule 1 annexed to Ex. PC 1 gives 17 instances of mutations on collateral successions of adopted sons in the family of the adoptive father. Schedule 2 annexed to Ex. PC 1 is not printed in the paper book. The English version of the Riwaj-i-am of the Amritsar District published by A. MacFARQUHAR in 1947 gives the list of the relevant judicial decisions bearing on Question 90. The decided cases show that where the adoption is by way of a customary appointment of an heir, the adopted son does not succeed collaterally in the adoptive father's family. The latest Riwaj-i-am refers to the court rulings without disapproval. In the light of the decided cases, the entries in the Riwaj-i-am recognising the adopted son's right of collateral succession in the adoptive father's family should be taken to apply to cases of customary formal adoptions and not to cases of adoptions by way of customary appointments of heirs.

11. The relevant judicial decisions may be briefly noticed. In Jowala Singh v. Lachmi 14 PR of 1884 (Gil Jats of Tehsil Ajnala, Amritsar), Mangal Singh v. Tilok Singh 61 PR of 1894 (Sohel Jats of Tehsil Ajnala, Amritsar), Chetu v. Jawand Singh 107 PR of 1913 (Sikh Jats of Tehsil Taran Taran, Amritsar), it was held that an heir appointed under the customary law of Jats in the District of Amritsar does not acquire a right to succeed to the collaterals of the adoptive father, and in Indar Singh v. Gurdevi AIR 1930 Lah 897 (Amritsar Jats), it was held that he was not a lineal descendant of the adoptive father within the meaning of Section 59 of the Punjab Tenancy Act 16 of 1887. Conversely, the appointed heir retains the right of collateral succession in his natural family. See Jagat Singh v. Ishar Singh (Amritsar Jats). On the other hand, according to the customs of Jats in the Amritsar District, in a case of a formal adoption effecting a complete transplantation of the adopted son in the adoptive father's family, the adopted son is entitled to inherit collaterally in the adoptive father's family. See Teju v. Kesar Singh AIR 1954 Punjab 30 affirming the decision of Kapur, J. in Teja Singh v. Kesar Singh AIR 1951 Punjab 117.

12. We thus find that under the customary law of Jats in Amritsar District, where the customary adoption is formal and the adopted son is completely transplanted in the family of his adoptive father, he is entitled to succeed to the collateral relatives of the adoptive father. This finding is in harmony with the Riwaj-i-am of the Amritsar District, is supported by judicial decisions, and is not in conflict with Article 49 of Rattigan's Digest. On the other hand, if the customary adoption amounts to a mere appointment of an heir, the appointed heir is not entitled to succeed to the collateral relatives of the adoptive father. This finding is in harmony with Article 49 of Rattigan's Digest and the judicial decisions, and is consistent with the Riwaj-i-am properly interpreted in the light of the decided cases.

13. In Teju v. Kesar Singh AIR 1954 Punjab 30 it was said that the ordinary rule in Amritsar District is that the adoption is complete. In other cases, it was said that ordinarly such an adoption is by way of a customary appointment of an heir. The true rule appears to be that it is a question of fact in each case whether the adoption by a Jat in the Amritsar District is formal or informal. The adoption is formal if the parties manifest a clear intention that there should be a complete change of the family of the adopted son, so that he ceases to be a member of his natural family and loses his right of collateral succession in that family and at the same time becomes a member of the adoptive father's family and acquires a right of collateral succession in the family. The loss of the right of collateral succession in the natural family is strong evidence to show that the adoption is formal and effects a complete change in the family. On the other hand, retention of the right of collateral succession in his natural family indicates that the adoption was informal by way of customary appointment of an heir.

14. The onus is upon the plaintiffs-respondents to prove that the adoption of Kala Singh was formal and effected a complete change in his family. On the death of the adoptive father Megh Singh, Kala Singh inherited the properties of Megh Singh, and on the death of Kala Singh, his sons, Gian Singh and Dewan Singh, inherited those properties. But these successions are consistent with the informal appointment of Kala Singh as an heir to Megh Singh. According to custom' the appointed heir succeeds to the properties, left by the adoptive father, and on the death of the appointed heir, his male issue succeeds: see Rattigan's Digest of Customary Law, 13th Edn., Articles 52 and 54, pp. 572-573. The succession of Kala Singh as the reversionary heir of one Mst. Bhagan is cited as an illustration of collateral succession of the adopted son in his adoptive father's family in the list of mutations given in Schedule 1 of the Riwaj-i-am of 1940 (Ex. P.C/I). But the oral testimony on the record of this case discloses that Bhagan, who was the widow of a predeceased son of Megh Singh, was given some land by Megh Singh for her maintenance, and on her death, Kala Singh succeeded to this land. It will appear, therefore, that Bhagan got a life estate in this land, and on her death, the land reverted to Kala Singh as the adopted son of Megh Singh. The succession of Kala Singh to this land is, therefore not an instance of collateral succession of Kala Singh in his adoptive father's family, and this was fairly conceded by learned counsel for the respondents. Considering all the circumstances of the case, the trial court and the first appellate court concurrently found that the adoption of Kala Singh was by way of customary appointment of an heir to Megh Singh. On second appeal, the High Court did not interfere with this finding. The finding is amply supported by the materials on the record. It appears that after his adoption Kala Singh succeeded to the lands left by one Makhan, his natural brother and by one Hira Singh, his collateral in his natural family. These collateral successions in the natural family strongly indicate that the adoption of Kala Singh did not effect a change in his family. The adoption of Kala Singh was no more than a mere appointment of an heir and by the custom of the Jats in the District of Amritsar he was not entitled to succeed collaterally in his adoptive father's family. For this reason, the suit out of which this appeal arises, must be dismissed.

15. The District Judge, relying on Mangal Singh v. Tilok Singh 61 PR 1894 held that as Kala Singh was not an agnate of his adoptive father, he was not entitled to succeed collaterally in his adoptive father's family, even assuming that his adoption was valid. This aspect of the matter was not considered by the High Court at all. In view of our conclusions on other points, we do not express any opinion on this point.

16. We allow the appeal, set aside the decree passed by the High Court, restore the decree passed by the District Judge of Amritsar and direct that the suit be dismissed. The parties will pay and bear their own costs throughout.