Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shalig Ram v. Firm Daulatram Kundanmal .

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 30, 1962
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal was brought to the Supreme Court on a certificate granted by the High Court of Bombay under Article 133(1)(c) of the Constitution. The appellant was the judgment-debtor and the respondent was the decree-holder.

A decree was passed on August 26, 1931, in Summary Suit No. 2437 of 1930 by the High Court of Bombay against three defendants, all residents of Parbhani District in the former State of Hyderabad. Before the decree, the appellant applied for leave to defend; the High Court conditionally granted leave on the appellant depositing Rs 5000 within four weeks. The appellant failed to make this deposit, did not file any written statement, and an ex parte decree was ultimately passed for Rs 52,032-7-0, including costs and future interest at 6% per annum.

The decree was later transferred for execution to the Court of the District Judge, Bhir, in Hyderabad State. On June 18, 1954, the respondent initiated execution proceedings in that court. The appellant objected, contending, among other things, that he had not submitted to the jurisdiction of the Bombay High Court, which he characterized as a foreign court, and hence its decree was a foreign decree that could not be executed by the Bhir court.

The executing court overruled the appellant’s objection. On appeal, the High Court held on July 29, 1958, that the appellant had submitted to the jurisdiction of the Bombay High Court and dismissed the appeal, thereby upholding the executing court’s order. A letters patent appeal from that judgment was dismissed in limine on October 24, 1958. The present appeal to the Supreme Court is from that order, on the strength of the certificate under Article 133(1)(c).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant, by appearing before the Bombay High Court and applying for leave to defend without objecting to jurisdiction, had voluntarily submitted to the jurisdiction of that court, thereby validating the ex parte decree for the purposes of execution.
  2. Whether, in light of the legal position at the time, the order transferring the decree for execution to the District Judge, Bhir, in the former Hyderabad State was valid and effective, enabling execution of the decree in that court.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shaikh Atham Sahib v. Davud Sahib A person who appears in obedience to the process of a foreign court and applies for leave to defend the suit without objecting to the jurisdiction of that court, when he is not compellable by law to do so, must be held to have voluntarily submitted to the jurisdiction of such court. The Court treated the appellant’s conduct—appearing before the Bombay High Court and seeking leave to defend without raising any objection to its jurisdiction—as a voluntary submission to that court’s jurisdiction. Consequently, the decree did not suffer from the defects associated with a purely ex parte foreign decree passed without such submission.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court focused on the question of jurisdiction and the nature of the appellant’s participation in the proceedings before the Bombay High Court. Relying on the principle articulated in Shaikh Atham Sahib v. Davud Sahib, the Court stated that where a person, not compellable by law, appears in obedience to the process of a foreign court and applies for leave to defend without objecting to the jurisdiction, that person must be held to have voluntarily submitted to the jurisdiction of that court.

Applying this principle, the Court concluded that the appellant, by applying for leave to defend in the Bombay High Court without raising any jurisdictional objection, had in fact submitted to its jurisdiction. On that basis, the Court held that the decree did not suffer from the defects that would attach to an ex parte foreign decree where there had been no such submission to jurisdiction.

The Court further noted that the order transferring the decree for execution to the District Judge, Bhir, was made at a time when the Indian Code of Civil Procedure had become applicable to the whole of India, including the territories of the former Hyderabad State. Accordingly, the transfer order was characterized as valid and effective, and there was no legal impediment to the execution of the decree in the Bhir court.

In light of these conclusions, the Court found no merit in the appeal against the High Court’s affirmation of the executing court’s order.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Supreme Court held that the appellant had voluntarily submitted to the jurisdiction of the Bombay High Court by seeking leave to defend without objecting to jurisdiction. The decree therefore did not suffer from defects associated with a foreign ex parte decree passed without submission, the transfer of the decree for execution to the District Judge, Bhir, was valid, and the decree could be executed. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Implications: The immediate consequence is that the decree-holder may proceed with execution of the Bombay High Court decree in the Bhir court, and the appellant, as judgment-debtor, remains bound by that decree. The opinion is confined to affirming the validity of the decree and its execution in this case and does not purport to establish any broader or new legal principle beyond the application of the cited precedent to the facts at hand.

Show all summary ...

Kapur, J..— This is an appeal on a certificate of the High Court under Article 133(l)(c) of the Constitution against the judgment and order of the High Court of Bombay. The appellant was the judgment-debtor and the decree-holder is the respondent.

2. The decree was passed on August 26, 1931, in Summary Suit No. 2437 of 1930 by the High Court of Bombay against three defendants who were residents of Parbhani District in the former State of Hyderabad. Before the decree was passed the appellant had applied for leave to defend and leave was conditionally granted on his depositing Rs 5000 within four weeks. This, he did not do and on his failure to do so an ex parte decree was granted for Rs 52,032.7-0 including costs and future interest at 6% per annum. The appellant did not file any written statement. The decree was transferred for execution to the District Judge, Bhir, in Hyderabad State. The respondent took out execution on June 18,1954, in the Court of the District Judge, Bhir, to which objection was taken by the appellant, inter alia, on the ground that he had not submitted to the jurisdiction of the Bombay High Court which was a foreign court and therefore the decree was a foreign decree and could not be executed in the court at Bhir. This objection was overruled. Against that order an appeal was taken to the High Court and it was held by that Court on July 29, 1958, that the appellant had submitted to the jurisdiction of the Bombay High Court and the appeal was therefore dismissed and the order of the executing court upheld. The letters patent appeal against that judgment was dismissed in limine on October 24, 1958. It is against that order that the appeal has been brought on the certificate of the High Court under Article 133(l)(c).

3. A person who appears in obedience to the process of a foreign court and applies for leave to defend the suit without objecting to the jurisdiction of the court when he is not compellable by law to do so must be held to have voluntarily submitted to the jurisdiction of such court. Shaikh Atham Sahib v. Davud Sahib. Therefore it cannot be said that this decree suffered from the defects which a foreign ex parte decree without such submission would suffer from. The order for transfer was made at a time when the Indian Code of Civil Procedure became applicable to the whole of India including the former territories of Hyderabad State. The order of transfer was therefore valid and effective and the decree could therefore be executed.

4. The appeal, in our opinion, is without merit and is therefore dismissed with costs.