Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bhiva Doulu Patil v. State Of Maharashtra .

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 29, 1962
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Bhiva Doulu Patil (Accused 2), along with three others, was charged with the murder of Lahu Vithu Patil at Village Pasarde during the night of May 23–24, 1960. The prosecution alleged that the appellant suspected an illicit relationship between the deceased and his wife and, therefore, conspired to kill the deceased. A large knife was allegedly fabricated on March 17, 1960, by Accused 1 and the appellant. On the night of the incident, Accused 1 inflicted two fatal blows with that knife while the appellant held a torch; the two remaining associates were unarmed. The police recovered a towel and turban at the scene, later linked to Accused 1.

At trial, the Sessions Court convicted Accused 1 of murder and sentenced him to death (later reduced to life imprisonment on appeal), convicted the appellant under Section 302/34 IPC and sentenced him to life imprisonment, acquitted Accused 3, and treated the fourth participant, Deoba, as an approver (PW 5). The Bombay High Court affirmed the appellant’s conviction. The present Supreme Court judgment addresses the appellant’s appeal against that affirmance.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the testimony of the accomplice–approver, Deoba (PW 5), was corroborated in material particulars qua the appellant so as to sustain his conviction under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R v. Boyes Rule of prudence that accomplice evidence should be corroborated. Quoted to underscore the longstanding judicial caution against relying solely on accomplice testimony.
Bhuboni Sahu v. King (Privy Council) Need for independent evidence implicating the particular accused when acting on accomplice testimony. Cited to stress that courts should be slow to depart from the requirement of corroboration specific to each accused.
Re Rajagopal, ILR 1944 Mad 308 Example of conviction based on accomplice evidence corroborated only by a co-accused's statement. Referred to show the Privy Council’s disapproval of dispensing with independent corroboration.
R v. Baskerviller (1916 2 KB 658) Formulation of the common-law practice: warn the jury of dangers of uncorroborated accomplice evidence, though conviction is legally permissible. Adopted to articulate the balance between Section 133 (law) and Section 114(b) (prudence) of the Evidence Act.
R v. Attwood (1787 1 Leach 464) Early authority noting inadmissibility/danger of uncorroborated accomplice evidence. Invoked via the quotation from Baskerviller to highlight historical consistency of the cautionary rule.
R v. Stubbs, Dears 555 Illustration that a jury may legally convict on unconfirmed accomplice evidence. Referenced in the explanatory quotation from Baskerviller.
In re Meunier (1894 2 QB 415) Same proposition as Stubbs: legal competence of uncorroborated accomplice evidence. Also contained in the Baskerviller quotation to show historical lineage of the rule.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reiterated the dual framework governing accomplice evidence: Section 133 of the Evidence Act makes an accomplice a competent witness and does not render a conviction illegal merely because it rests on uncorroborated testimony, whereas illustration (b) to Section 114 embodies a rule of prudence directing courts to look for corroboration in material particulars against each accused.

Applying this framework, the Court scrutinised the supposed corroborative pieces relied upon by the courts below:

  • Confession to Santu (PW 6): This merely confirmed that the approver had narrated his story to his brother; it did not independently implicate the appellant.
  • Knife preparation by PW 7: Although the appellant and Accused 1 had the knife made nine weeks before the murder, the temporal gap left open the possibility that the appellant might have withdrawn from the plan, thereby failing to corroborate participation at the time of the crime.
  • Recovery of the knife at Accused 1’s instance: This connected the weapon to Accused 1, not to the appellant, and thus provided no corroboration against him.

Because none of these circumstances provided independent confirmation of the appellant’s presence or participation at the murder scene, the Court concluded that the mandatory prudential safeguard of corroboration was absent. Consequently, reliance on the approver’s testimony alone was unsafe and impermissible to sustain the conviction under Section 302/34 IPC.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed – Conviction Set Aside. The Supreme Court quashed the appellant’s conviction and directed his immediate release.

Implications: The judgment reaffirms that accomplice testimony must be corroborated in material particulars against each accused. It does not create new law but reinforces the established evidentiary safeguard, signalling to lower courts that generalized corroboration insufficiently tied to a specific accused cannot sustain a conviction under the doctrine of common intention.

Show all summary ...

Kapur, J.— This is an appeal against the judgment and order of the High Court of Bombay confirming the conviction of the appellant for an offence under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, read with Section 34 for the murder of one Lahu Vithu Patil on the night between May 23, and 24, 1960 at Village Pasarde.

3. Four persons Rama Krishna Patil Accused 1, Bhiva Doulu Patil Accused 2 (now appellant before us), Lahu Santu Patil, Accused 3 and Deoba approver PW 5 are alleged to have taken part in the murder of Lahu Vithu Patil. Rama Krishna Patil Accused 1 was convicted of murder and sentenced to death but on appeal his sentence was reduced to one of imprisonment for life. The appellant was convicted as above stated and sentenced to imprisonment for life. The third accused Lahu Santu Patil was acquitted and the 4th participant Deoba turned approver and is PW 5.

4. The case for the prosecution was that the appellant had a suspicion that the deceased had a liaison with his wife. He, the appellant, approached the approver and suggested that the deceased should be killed. This was on March 16, 1960. On March 17, I960, Rama Krishna Patil, Accused 1 and appellant got a knife prepared by Nanu Santu Sutar PW 7 from a crowbar. The deceased was a wrestler and he and his brothers used to sleep in the fields and they also had dogs and for that reason the murder could not be committed for sometime. When rains set in, the deceased started sleeping at Patil's Talim (gymnasium). There, on the night of the murder the deceased was killed with the knife which was used by Rama Krishna Patil, Accused 1. At that time the appellant had a torch and two others Lahu Santu Patil and Deoba were unarmed. Two blows were given by Accused 1 one on the throat and the second one on the left side of the chest. At the place of the occurrence the assailants left a towel and a patka (turban). Both these articles have been found to belong to Accused 1, Rama Krishna Patil. Hearing the noise and groaning of the deceased, Lahu Vithu Patil, other persons who were sleeping were awakened and one of them went and informed the brother of the deceased and then the first information report was made to the police but no names were mentioned therein. On June 6, 1960, Deoba was arrested on information received by Police Sub-Inspector Mandke. On June 25, 1960, as a result of a statement made by Accused 1, the knife which is alleged to have been used for the murder was recovered. This knife is stated to be stained with blood but it has not been proved to be human blood. It may be stated that the knife was of rather unusually large dimensions. The two injuries on the deceased were very extensive and according to the medical evidence they could have been caused with the knife which was recovered.

5. The question that arises in the present case is whether the statement of the approver has been corroborated in material particulars and qua the appellant. The trial court convicted the appellant on the testimony of the approver and found corroboration for the approver's testimony in the statement of Nanu Santu Sutar, PW 7 who had prepared the knife alleged to have been used for the offence on March 17, 1960 and his motive to commit the murder because of the suspicion he had about his wife having a liaison with the deceased. These facts according to the learned Judge were sufficient to convict the appellant. The High Court on appeal found corroboration in material particulars; from the evidence of Santu PW 6, brother of Deoba to whom Deoba had made a confession of his participation in the offence; the discovery of the knife at the instance of Accused l and the knife being found bloodstained and the unusual character of the knife which fitted in with the dimensions of the injuries caused to the deceased. From those facts the learned Judges came to the conclusion that the approver Deoba was giving a true version of the occurrence. With great respect to the High Court we are unable to agree because without corroboration of the approver qua the appellant the conviction is unsustainable, the law being that there should be corroboration of the approver in material particulars and qua each accused.

6. The statement of Santu, brother of the approver is no corroboration of the approver. It only means that approver made a confessional statement to his brother. That cannot be called, in the circumstances of this case, to be a corroboration of the approver. The evidence of Nanu Santu Sutar PW 7 also cannot operate as a corroboration of the approver's story because the knife was got prepared by Accused 1 and the appellant nine weeks before the murder and that fact by itself will not corroborate the charge under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code against the appellant. The time gap between the preparation of the knife and murder is great and it is possible in such circumstances that the appellant might have recanted and not proceeded with the commission of the offence. The finding of the knife at the instance of the first accused also is no corroboration of the approver's story which would be sufficient to connect the appellant with the murder, under Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code. It may be that in this case the approver's evidence was sufficiently corroborated for the conviction of the first accused upon which we express no opinion but so far as the appellant is concerned we find that there is no corroboration of the approver's story and it is not sufficient that there is evidence to corroborate the participation of the first accused in the murder. It is also necessary for there being independent corroboration of the participation of the appellant in the offence With which he has been charged. In these circumstances the conviction of the appellant is not sustainable.

7. In coming to the above conclusion we have not been unmindful of the provisions of Section 133 of the Evidence Act which reads —

“133. An accomplice shall be a competent witness against an accused person; and a conviction is not illegal merely because it proceeds upon the uncorroborated testimony of an accomplice.”
It cannot be doubted that under that section a conviction based merely on the uncorroborated testimony of an accomplice may not be illegal, the courts nevertheless cannot lose sight of the Rule of prudence and practice which in the words of Martin B in R v. Boyes “has become so hallowed as to be deserving of respect” and the words of Lord Abinger “it deserves to have all the reverence of the law.” This Rule of guidance is to be found in illustration (b) to Section 114 of the Evidence which is as follows:
“The court may presume that an accomplice is unworthy of credit unless he is corroborated in material particulars.”
Both sections are part of one subject and have to be considered together. The Privy Council in Bhuboni Sahu v. King when its attention was drawn to the judgment of Madras High Court in re Rajagopal ILR 1944 Mad 308 where conviction was based upon the evidence of an accomplice supported by the statement of a co-accused, said as follows:
“Their Lordships ... would nevertheless observe that courts should be slow to depart from the Rule of prudence, based on long experience, which requires some independent evidence implicating the particular accused. The danger of acting upon accomplice evidence is not merely that the accomplice is on his own admission a man of bad character who took part in the offence and afterwards to save himself betrayed his former associates, and who has placed himself in a position in which he can hardly fail to have a strong bias in favour of the prosecution; the real danger is that he is telling a story which in its general outline is true, and it is easy for him to work into the story matter which is untrue.”

8. The combined effect of Sections 133 and 114, illustration (b) may be stated as follows: according to the former, which is a Rule of law, an accomplice is competent to give evidence and according to the latter which is a Rule of practice it is almost always unsafe to convict upon his testimony alone. Therefore though the conviction of an accused on the testimony of an accomplice cannot be said to be illegal yet the courts will, as a matter of practice, not accept the evidence of such a witness without corroboration in material particulars. The law may be stated in the words of Lord Reading, C.J in R. v Baskerviller (1916) 2 KB 658 as follows:

“There is no doubt that the uncorroborated evidence of an accomplice is inadmissible in law (R. v. Attwood, 1787, 1 Leach 464). But it has been long a Rule of practice at common law for the judge to warn the jury of the danger of convicting a prisoner on the uncorroborated testimony of an accomplice, and in the discretion of the Judge, to advise them not to convict upon such evidence, but the judge should point out to the jury that it is within their legal province to convict upon such unconfirmed evidence (R. v. Stubbs, Dears 555; In re Meunier, 1894 2 QB 415).”
We therefore allow this appeal, set aside the order of conviction and direct that the appellant be released forthwith.