Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

S.K Chakraborty And Others v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 11, 1988
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case concerns 75 employees of the Production Control Organisation (PCO) at the Kharagpur Railway Workshop (South Eastern Railway). The PCO had existed since the days of the B.N. Railway and was expanded in 1958. A Railway Board Circular dated 22-4-1963 mandated that all PCO posts be treated as ex cadre, but implementation at Kharagpur was stalled due to labour opposition.

Following negotiations with labour on 4-6-1973, two memoranda (21-7-1973 and 15-12-1973) were issued locally, declaring the posts cadre posts and granting staff an option to revert to shop floors. Later, a Railway Board Circular dated 9-7-1978 introduced a 10 % special pay for shop-floor staff posted to the PCO, excluding those permanently absorbed there. This prompted labour to seek implementation of the original 1963 circular. After meetings on 4-9-1979 and 22-9-1979, a memorandum dated 4/5-10-1979 implemented the 1963 policy and again classified all PCO posts as ex cadre.

The employees challenged the 1979 memorandum before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Calcutta Bench, which dismissed their application on 8-12-1986. They then sought special leave to appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution. The Supreme Court decided the present application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether declaring the Kharagpur PCO posts ex cadre by the 1979 memorandum unlawfully impaired vested service rights of the petitioners.
  2. Whether maintaining cadre status for PCO employees of the Integral Coach Factory (ICF) while treating Kharagpur PCO posts as ex cadre amounted to hostile discrimination in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The 1973 memoranda created vested rights to maintain the posts on a cadre basis; those rights could not be taken away in 1979.
  • A Railway Board Circular dated 13-9-1984 allowed the ICF PCO to remain on a cadre basis, so treating Kharagpur employees differently constituted hostile discrimination.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The 1973 memoranda were inconsistent with the binding Railway Board Circular of 1963 and therefore could not confer vested rights.
  • The differentiation between Kharagpur and ICF PCOs was based on union preferences at each unit and was a reasonable classification serving the objective of efficient administration; hence it did not violate Article 14.
  • The Railway Board has statutory authority to reorganise staff structures, including declaring posts ex cadre.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
T.R. Kapur v. State of Haryana, 1986 Supp SCC 584; (1987) 2 ATC 595 Vested rights cannot be taken away by subsequent administrative action. Used to show that no vested rights arose here because the 1973 memoranda conflicted with the superior 1963 Railway Board circular.
D.S. Nakara v. Union of India, (1983) 1 SCC 305 Article 14 permits reasonable classification; discrimination must be hostile or without rational nexus to be unconstitutional. Cited to uphold the differentiation between Kharagpur and ICF PCOs as reasonable and non-discriminatory.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. No vested rights were impaired. The Court held that the 1973 memoranda, having been issued contrary to the Railway Board’s 1963 circular, were invalid to the extent of that inconsistency. Consequently, employees could not claim vested rights based on those memoranda, and the 1979 re-classification did not infringe any legally protected interest.

2. Administrative re-organisation is permissible. The Court reaffirmed that an employer, especially a statutory authority like the Railway Board, may reorganise its workforce to improve efficiency, even if individual expectations are thereby affected, so long as no vested rights are taken away.

3. No hostile discrimination. The Court examined the 1984 circular that retained cadre status for the ICF PCO. It found a rational basis for treating the two PCOs differently: recognised unions at ICF wished to maintain cadre status, whereas unions at Kharagpur had already agreed to implement the 1963 policy. This differential treatment bore a reasonable nexus to administrative efficiency and labour relations, satisfying the twin tests under Article 14.

4. Tribunal’s modifications favoured employees. The Tribunal had directed that employees be given an option to remain in the PCO with promotional avenues. The Supreme Court observed that this direction was beneficial to the petitioners and did not justify interference.

Holding and Implications

APPLICATION DISMISSED. The Supreme Court refused leave to appeal and affirmed the Tribunal’s decision.

Implications: The 1979 memorandum remains operative; all Kharagpur PCO posts continue as ex cadre. The employees receive no further relief, but they retain the option-and-promotion safeguards ordered by the Tribunal. The decision turns on established principles of administrative authority and reasonable classification and sets no new precedent beyond applying those principles to the facts.

Show all summary ...

Sabyasachi Mukharji, J.— This is an application for leave to appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution, directed against the judgment and order of the Central Administrative Tribunal, Calcutta Bench (Justice Ashamukul Pal and Mr B. Mukhopadhyay) dated 8-12-1986. The Tribunal had dismissed the challenge made by the petitioners herein to the memorandum of 1979 declaring that the posts in Production Control Organisation (for short PCO) in Kharagpur would be treated as ex cadre.

2. There are 75 applicants in this case. At the relevant time they all were employees of the PCO at Kharagpur Railway Workshop of South Eastern Railway. The petitioners contend that these posts could not be declared as ex cadre posts because vested rights of the petitioners could not have been affected. Secondly, it was contended that they were treated differently from the employees of the Integral Coach Factory on the Southern Railway and those of PCO there continued to hold the cadre posts. This is hostile discrimination and amounts to violation of the rights of the petitioners. The Tribunal by its impugned order rejected both the contentions.

3. The PCO was in existence from the time of the B.N Railway. The staff of the PCO were either directly recruited or drafted from different shops of the workshop. In 1958 the PCO was considerably expanded. After considering the question the Railway Board brought out a Circular dated 22-4-1963 laying down the rules for determination of seniority of workshop staff employed in the PCO. It was laid down in the circular that all posts in the PCO should be treated as ex cadre posts. This is Annexure “B” to the writ application which was ultimately disposed of by the Tribunal. The circular, however, could not be implemented in the Kharagpur workshop on account of the stiff opposition of organised labour. In the premises the local authorities could not implement the circular of 1963. The question was discussed with the organised labour in a meeting held on 4-6-1973 and in pursuance of the decision taken in that meeting the memorandum dated 21-7-1973 which is also Annexure ‘B’ was issued by the Superintendent. It was evidently stated that all posts in PCO would be cadre posts.

4. It may, however, be reiterated that this was in violation of the order of 1963. Another memorandum was issued by the same authority on 15-12-1973 which not only declared all posts in PCO to be cadre posts but also laid down that an option would be given to the persons already working in the PCO to revert to the shops. It appears that the question of having incentive schemes for the staff of the PCO was under consideration of the Railway Board and by a Circular dated 9-7-1978 the Railway Board declared that the staff from shop-floors posted in the PCO would receive special pay of 10 per cent of their pay but this would not be available to the staff who were permanently absorbed in the PCO or directly recruited in the PCO. It appears that this brought a change in the attitude of the labour and representations were made to the Railway Board for implementing its Circular dated 22-4-1963 so that the staff of the PCO would be eligible for the special pay. Joint meeting were held with the labour on 4-9-1979 and 22-9-1979 and in pursuance of the decisions taken in these meetings the memorandum dated October 4-10-1979 5-10-1979 at Annexure “I” was issued which declared that the Railway Board's circular of 1963 would be implemented in the PCO and that all posts would be treated as ex cadre posts. This was impugned before the Tribunal.

5. It was contended that the vested rights which accrued in favour of the petitioners by the operation of the memoranda dated 21-7-1973, and 15-12-1973 were affected by declaring that the posts in PCO would be on cadre basis. These were issued, it appears, in violation of the clear directives of 1963 of the Railway Board. Hence, these circulars were in violation of Rule 158 of the Indian Railway Establishment Code, Volume I, which lays down that the General Managers of the Indian Railways have full powers to make rules with regard to non-gazetted railway servants under their control provided they are not inconsistent with any rules made by the President or the Railway Board.

6. It, however, appears that the memorandum dated 21-7-1973 was clearly inconsistent with the circular issued by the Railway Board in 1963 for the former stipulated that all posts in the PCO would be cadre posts. Both these memoranda were issued as a result of the meeting with the workers. In that view of the matter, in our opinion, it cannot be contended that vested rights have been affected. Administrative reorganisation is permissible and as a result of the same rights may be affected but the vested rights could not be taken away. See in this connection the observations of this Court in T.R Kapur v. State of Haryana (1986) Supp SCC 584, (1987) 2 ATC 595. Here, however, inasmuch as the memorandum dated 21-7-1973 was inconsistent with the circular issued by the Railway Board, no right vested in the petitioner and, hence, no question of affecting vested rights arises.

7. The second ground was that there was discrimination against the petitioners referred to the Railway Board's Circular dated 13-9-1984 which made an exception for the Integral Coach Factory at the Southern Railway and allowed the PCO to continue on cadre basis. It was submitted that this was a case of discrimination. It appears that the impugned circular of 1984 of the Railway Board was issued pursuant to the negotiations with the staff in the Departmental Council of Ministry of Railways. The existing arrangement in the PCO of Integral Coach Factory was not disturbed because the recognised Unions there did not want it to be so disturbed; whereas in the PCO of Kharagpur the recognised Unions had already agreed, as appears from the impugned memorandum at Annexure “I” that the Railway Board's Circular dated 22-4-1963 would be implemented in the Kharagpur, PCO and that all posts in the PCO would be treated as ex cadre posts. The Railway Board is fully competent to bring about necessary changes in the staff pattern of the various units under its control for the purpose of streamlining the organisation and improving the efficiency of the administration. Hence, there was a good ground for this differentiation which has a rational nexus with the object of streamlining the organisation. This differentiation cannot be condemned as violative of the rule of equality. It does not amount to hostile discrimination. Article 14 of the Constitution forbids class disposition but permits reasonable classification for the purpose of disposition which classification must satisfy the twin tests of classification being founded on an intelligible differentia which distinguishes persons or things that are grouped together from those that are left out of the group and that differentia must have a rational nexus to the object sought to be achieved by the disposition.

8. See D.S Nakara v. Union of India (1983) 1 SCC 305, (1983) 2 SCR 165, 1983 UPSC 263.

9. Further, the Tribunal modified certain portions of the impugned memorandum and directed that the provisions should be made for those who opt to continue in the PCO at Kharagpur after the issue of the Circular dated 13-9-1984 so that they may be given an opportunity to exercise their option in this regard and be provided with avenue for promotion within the PCO. Previously, in 1963 such option was provided and it was stipulated that employees permanently absorbed in the PCO or directly recruited in the PCO who did not exercise option in favour of transfer, they would be considered for promotion along with others to higher grade posts in the PCO only. In our opinion, it was done to help the petitioners.

10. In the aforesaid view of the matter, the Tribunal was right in rejecting the contentions urged on behalf of the petitioners. The challenge to the Tribunal's order, therefore, cannot be entertained.

11. Before concluding it is worthwhile to note that none appeared for the petitioners when the matter was called on. The matter was called twice. We have disposed of the matter on perusing the order of the Tribunal and also upon considering the submissions made by the respondents. The application, therefore, fails and dismissed. No order as to costs.