- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Patori Devi And Another v. Amar Nath And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
On 23 April 1976 three brothers—Balbir Singh, Bharat Singh and Lajja Ram—were killed at about 3-4 p.m. in agricultural fields. According to the prosecution, a quarrel began after a buffalo belonging to the deceased strayed into the field of Bhagat Ram (alias Bhagtu). An initial verbal exchange was followed, roughly an hour later, by the return of Bhagat Ram, Jai Narain and several other persons allegedly armed with an axe, a gandasi and lathis. The prosecution asserted that these men assaulted Balbir Singh, and when his brothers attempted to intervene, all three were beaten with sharp and blunt weapons, dying on the spot.
Hari Singh (PW-4), brother of the deceased, lodged the First Information Report at Police Station Butane. Sub-Inspector Beant Singh (PW-9) investigated, and eleven prosecution witnesses were eventually examined. The autopsies revealed numerous sharp-edged and blunt-force injuries on each victim.
During examination under Section 313 CrPC the accused denied the allegation and advanced a counterversion: Jai Narain claimed that the deceased brothers were the aggressors, attacked him first, and that the accused retaliated in self-defence, sustaining multiple injuries themselves.
The Sessions Court rejected the plea of private defence, convicted all accused under Section 302 read with Section 149 and Section 148 IPC, and imposed sentences accordingly. On appeal, the High Court of Punjab & Haryana (judgment dated 17 September 1979) reversed the convictions, accepting the right of private defence and acquitting every accused. Both the State and the complainant obtained special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, leading to the present decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court erred in accepting the defence plea of private defence and acquitting the respondents.
- Whether, even if a right of private defence existed, the respondents exceeded that right in causing the deaths of the three deceased persons.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants (State of Punjab and Informant)
- Contended through counsel Mr. R. K. Kohli that the respondents had exceeded any possible right of private defence given the gravity and number of injuries inflicted on the deceased (thirty injuries in total, some sharp-edged).
- Highlighted alleged “soft-pedalling” and suppression of material facts during investigation, which, they argued, had led the High Court to an erroneous appreciation of evidence.
Respondents (Accused Persons)
- Maintained that the deceased brothers were the aggressors, having first assaulted Jai Narain and others with lathis.
- Asserted that they acted only to defend themselves, pointing to 22 blunt-weapon injuries suffered by three of the accused—including a grievous injury (fracture) to Bhagat Ram.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court confined its scrutiny principally to the contention that the accused had exceeded the right of private defence. It noted:
- The material record displayed a significant number of injuries on both sides—thirty on the deceased versus twenty-two on three accused—suggesting a two-sided confrontation rather than a one-sided assault.
- The investigation appeared to be “soft-pedalled,” and portions of the incident were likely suppressed by the prosecution, preventing a full reconstruction of events and casting doubt on the prosecution narrative.
- Because of these evidentiary uncertainties, the Court deemed it unsafe to disturb the High Court’s finding that the defence version was “reasonably true.”
- While acknowledging that injury counts can be relevant in determining whether the right of private defence was exceeded, the Bench expressly declined to rest its conclusion solely on that factor; instead, it relied on the overall inability of the prosecution to present a truthful and complete account.
Consequently, the Court found no legal error in the High Court’s acceptance of the right of private defence or in its ultimate acquittal of all accused.
Holding and Implications
Appeals Dismissed; High Court acquittal affirmed.
Immediate effect: all accused remain acquitted of charges under Sections 302/149 and 148 IPC. The judgment turns on the specific evidentiary shortcomings of the prosecution and does not articulate new legal principles, thereby having limited precedential value beyond reinforcing that appellate courts will not interfere with acquittals where the prosecution’s version is found unreliable and the defence version reasonably true.
K. Jagannatha Shetty, J.— These appeals are directed against the judgment dated 17-9-1979 of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana acquitting all the accused by setting aside the conviction and sentence under Section 302 read with Sections 149 and 148 of the Indian Penal Code.
2. Three brothers, Balbir Singh, Bharat Singh and Lajja Ram were murdered on 23-4-1976 at about 3-4 p.m The prosecution story was that Hari Singh, PW 4 and his brothers, Balbir Singh and Bharat Singh along with Lajja Ram were working in their fields on that fateful day. At that time, their buffalo chanced to have trespassed into the fields of Bhagat Ram alias Bhagtu, son of Rulia Ram. On this Bhagtu and his brother Jai Narain accompanied by Raja Ram came to the fields of the deceased to make a complaint. Lajja Ram, deceased assured these people that such a thing would not happen again. On this assurance being given, the said three persons went away. The prosecution story further went on to state that after about one hour of the said incident not only the three persons mentioned above but the remaining accused persons also came and stayed on the doul of the field of these persons. Bhagat Ram was stated to have been armed with kulhari (axe), Jagan Nath armed with a gandasi and the remaining persons were carrying lathis. They started raising lalkars and calling bad names. Balbir Singh brother of the complainant asked them not to do so. The accused took Balbir Singh towards their fields and started beating him. Lajja Ram and Bharat Singh deceased started running towards the accused in order to rescue their brother Balbir Singh. Smt Patauri (PW 5), mother of Balbir Singh also started running raising a raula “bachao, bachao”. On hearing her alarm, one Surinder Singh, son of Kala Ram also came there. Bhagat Ram gave a kulhari blow on the head of Balbir Singh while he was being dragged to the field of one Mangal. Jagan Nath gave two gandasi blows on his head on receipt of which the latter fell down and thereafter Amar Nath gave lathi blows on his back and neck. Balbir Singh died there and then. When Lajja Ram tried to intervene to save Balbir Singh, then on the lalkara of Amar Nath, Baij Nath, Parshotam Das, Raja Ram and Bhagat Ram gave some lathi blows to him. When Lajja Ram fell down on receipt of injuries, Bhagat Ram son of Sardha Ram and Jagan Nath gave kulhari and gandasi blows on his head and face. Amar Nath also gave lathi blows to him. As a result of injuries, Lajja Ram also died there and then. Ram Naresh, Ram Autar, Jai Narain and Rameshwar Dass surrounded Bharat Singh and they started causing injuries to him with their lathis. When Bharat Singh fell down, Bhagat Ram son of Sardha Ram and Jagan Nath gave injuries to him with kulhari and gandasi. Bharat Singh succumbed to his injuries. Surinder Singh and Smt Patauri raised alarm. It is stated that Amar Nath gave lalkara that the informant may also be caught and then the latter ran away to save his life.
3. This information was given to the Police Station, Butane by Hari Singh, PW 4, younger brother of the deceased. Sub-Inspector, Beant Singh (PW 9) started investigation and later on arrested the accused. The autopsy on the dead body of Balbir Singh was conducted by Dr S.L Chhabra, PW 1. He has found 5 injuries. Injury 3 was crushing on the left back of the head. The post-mortem of the dead body of Bharat Singh was conducted by Dr J.K Jain, PW 10. He found 12 injuries. The autopsy of Lajja Rani was conducted by Dr Subita Anjwai, PW 11, who found 13 injuries. Some of them were incised and perforated.
4. The prosecution examined in all 11 witnesses. Hari Singh, PW 4 and Mst Patauri, PW 5 furnished their own version of the incident being eye-witnesses.
5. When the accused were examined under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, they denied the prosecution allegation. Jai Narain gave his own version as under:
“I was working in the pair in my field. The wheat crop had been entirely cut. Balbir Singh came to me. He said that we people had removed the wheat bhaar. It was a little after dopehar. I said that we had not removed the wheat bhaar. He asked me to accompany him to his fields saying that I should have a look at his fields. I refused to accompany him. He started calling bad names to me. I also called bad names to him. Both of us exchanged abuses. He then started going away towards the fields. While going away he said that I would soon learn and that he would tell me. After a short while Bharat Singh, Lajja Ram and Balbir Singh armed with lathis came towards me. When they were at a distance of half a killa or ¾th of a killa from me I started running away out of fear. My brother Bhagat Ram, my son Ram Autar and my nephew Ram Naresh were working near the tube well of Mangal and therefore I started running in the direction of tube well of Mangal. I started running at a fast speed but they also started running after me. I reached that place but they also came and started showering lathi-blows on me. My brother Bhagat Ram and son Ram Autar came to rescue me but lathis were showered on them also. Bhagat Ram picked up the khalwa of a gaddi. I picked up a bamboo stick which was lying there. Ram Naresh picked up a khalwa of the gaddi. Ram Autar pulled out a baans from a chhan. In order to save ourselves and our lives we also started to beat them well (khoob marney lage). They fell down, we also fell down. The leg of my brother Bhagat Ram was fractured. I also received many injuries. Ram Autar also received injuries. That is how the ladai took place.”
Bhagat Ram and Ram Naresh adopted the version given by Jai Narain but adduced no evidence in defence.
6. The trial court on a consideration of the evidence did not find it possible to accept in toto the prosecution version. The trial court said thus:
“The court may be justified in not accepting the entire version of any one of the parties. It appears to me that Balbir Singh, the two brothers of the complainant fell into the hands of the accused persons, but it is difficult to state whether injuries to him were caused as soon as he fell into the hands of the accused persons at the adjoining doul, or whether injuries to him were caused to him when he was being taken towards the field of Mangal or whether injuries to him were caused for the first time after he was taken up to some distance. It appears that the remaining brothers of the said person did not know all this until the said person had been taken away up to a distance of three killas. It appears to me that the remaining two brothers of the said person who also got killed, then went to the field where at that moment Balbir Singh was being manhandled by the accused persons and in the first flush they were able to wield lathi blows, resulting in injuries to three of the accused persons. It appears that on this the accused persons retaliated ferociously and committed the murder of the said two brothers also. I am not impressed by the defence version that the complainant party ran after Jai Narain accused and that Jai Narain accused started running towards the tube well of Mangal, but he was overtaken and injuries were caused to him and that when Bhagat Ram son of Rulia Ram, Ram Naresh and Ram Autar came forward to help him they were also beaten up and then all the four of these accused persons gave beating to Balbir Singh and his two brothers. I have already stated that Jai Narain who has given out his age as 74 and Bhagat Ram as 76, could not have participated in such a manner that these two along with Ram Autar and Ram Naresh would have been in a position to cause such extensive injuries to three young persons as have been caused in the present case. I am of the view that the injuries to the three brothers, resulting in their deaths, were caused in the manner stated just now. From this it does not appear to be a case of even free fight, a case which was not been argued upon by anyone of the parties. I am of the view that the theory of self-defence has not been proved either directly or indirectly. I am of the view that the prosecution case is proved that the accused persons, would (sic) armed with deadly weapons, formed an unlawful assembly, the common object of which was to commit the murder of Balbir Singh and whose common object during the course of achievement of the initial common object, also became the murders of the remaining two brothers of Balbir Singh. I am of the view that all the accused persons are guilty of an offence under Section 148 of the Indian Penal Code and all of them are guilty of an offence under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code read with Section 149 of the same Code for causing the murders of Balbir Singh, Lajja Ram and Bharat Singh. The accused persons are therefore, convicted accordingly under Section 148 of the Indian Penal Code and under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code read with Section 149 of the same Code.”
7. It will be seen from the above conclusion of the trial court that the right of private defence put forward by the accused was not accepted. The High Court, in appeal, however had accepted that version. The High Court compared the injuries suffered by the deceased and also by the accused. The High Court found that the deceased in all suffered as many as 30 sharp and blunt weapon injuries whereas three accused sustained in all 22 blunt weapon injuries. In regard to the eyewitnesses, PW 4 and PW 5, the High Court found it difficult to accept their version. The High Court was of the opinion that brother and mother of the deceased appeared to have suppressed their own part and exaggerated the part played by the accused. The High Court also found fault with the prosecution for having suppressed the fact of causing injury to three of the accused. Upon an appraisal of the evidence, the High Court concluded:
“On the aforesaid analysis the true state of affairs on the record as appears to us is that the prosecution had advanced a false story that the appellants had assaulted the deceased persons. The version given by the defence that they were attacked first and were given various injuries indiscriminately appears to be reasonably true. At any rate, the prosecution has suppressed the true version of the story and the court is not in a position to arrive at the truth so as to discard the defence version as not being reasonably true.”
8. So stating the High Court gave the verdict in favour of the accused since the first assault by the deceased on the accused was bound to create a reasonable apprehension in their mind that grievous hurt, if not death, would be the consequence. The support to this conclusion was drawn from the injuries suffered by the accused and in particular, Injury 1 on the person of Bhagat Ram, which was grievous.
9. Challenging the decision of the High Court, both the State and the informant have appealed to this Court with leave. We gave our anxious consideration to rival contentions urged in this appeal and in particular, the contention of Mr R.K Kohli that the accused had exceeded the right of private defence. Indeed, that appears to be the only contention that requires to be considered, but unfortunately, in view of the intrinsic evidence on record and the number of injuries suffered by the accused, we do not think we can accede to the contention of Mr Kohli. We are of the view that there was a soft-pedalling in the investigation, if not suppression of a part of the incident. If the prosecution had revealed the entire story, we would have been able to find the nugget of truth. On the material on record, however, we are unable to find fault with the findings recorded by the High Court.
10. The number and nature of injuries sustained by the accused and the deceased in any case, may furnish good evidence to consider whether the accused had exceeded the right of private defence. But in the instant case, we do not want to rest our conclusion solely on the injuries sustained by the accused and the deceased.
11. In the result, these appeals fail and are dismissed.
Alert