Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dr.Devi Singh v. State

Rajasthan High Court
Mar 15, 2010

Heard learned counsel for parties.

This writ petition was filed by petitioner way back in the year 1995 assailing validity of Notification dated 16.09.1991 by which amendment was made in Schedule-I appended to the rajasthan medical & health service rules, 1963, (for short, 'the rules of 1963'), which provides that for promotion to the post of Junior Specialist, a Medical Officer/Medical Officer (Dentist) must have 8 years service to his credit for those possessing Post Graduate Degree in the Speciality concerned, or must have 11 years service on the Post of Medical Officer including service as Senior Medical Officer if any, for those possessing Post Graduate Diploma in the concerned discipline. By that amendment, a deviation was made from earlier provision contained in the Schedule that for promotion to the post of Junior Specialist, a Medical Officer/Medical Officer (Dentist) must have 8 years service on the post mentioned in Column No.3 out of which three years service must be rendered after obtaining Post Graduate Degree in the concerned Specialty, meaning thereby a candidate, out of 8 years service on the post mentioned in Column 3, must have obtained experience of at-least three years after his post graduation.

Shri Shanuj Kulshrestha, brief holder of Shri Sanjeev Prakash Sharma, learned counsel for petitioner, has argued that the petitioner is aggrieved by this amendment because it has been given retrospective effect. He contended that petitioner within three months of his appointment as Civil Assistant Surgeon by order dated 31.12.1982 obtained the post graduation degree in Psychiatry and thus became eligible for promotion earlier in point of time than private respondents No.3, 4, 5 and 6. Learned counsel submitted that taking this fact into consideration, the respondents by order dated 22.01.1990 promoted petitioner and three other candidates, although on urgent temporary basis, to the post of Junior Specialist (Psychiatry). The petitioner was continued on the post of Junior Specialist (Psychiatry) until the regular promotions were made by order dated 03.06.1995 in which the petitioner was assigned quota of the year 1992-93, whereas private respondents, who were not eligible for promotion at the time when petitioner was promoted on adhoc/temporary basis, were assigned quota of the years 1989-90, 1990-91 and 1991-92, respectively. Learned counsel submitted that retrospectivity could not be given to the amended Rules because it has taken away right of petitioner to work on the post of Junior Specialist on which he stood already promoted prior to the said amendment. Learned counsel submitted that sub-rule (5) of Rule 24-A of the Rules of 1963, was violated. Similarly sub-rule (11-A) of Rule 24-A was violated, which provides that if in any subsequent year after promulgation of these rules, vacancies relating to any earlier year are determined under sub-rule (2) of rule relating to determination of vacancies, which were required to be filled by promotion, the Departmental Promotion Committee has to consider all such persons who were eligible in the year to which the vacancies relate irrespective of the year in which the meeting of the Departmental Promotion committee takes place.

It is contended that the amendment Notification dated 16.09.1991 ought to have applied prospectively and if that would have been done, the private respondents would not be eligible for promotion. By making the impugned amendment, the chances of promotion of the petitioner have been marred or delayed.

Learned counsel for the petitioner, in support of his argument, relied upon a judgment of Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court in Chairman, Railway Board and Others Vs. C.R. Rangadhamaiah and Others (1997) 6 SCC 623.

Shri S.D. Khaspuria, learned Additional Government Counsel, appearing for respondent State, and Shri M.M. Ranjan, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.6, have opposed the writ petition and submitted that even the petitioner was promoted in relaxation of the Rules with permission of the Department of Personnel of the Government of Rajasthan as at that point of time candidates having the requisite experience were not available, and it would not make him senior to others or eligible earlier to them. It was purely an adhoc arrangement thereby petitioner and three others were promoted on urgent/temporary basis for a period of four months or till regularly selected candidates by DPC are made available, whichever was earlier. Appointment of petitioner in that position was continued till the DPC selected candidates were made available by order dated 03.06.1995. It is contended that private respondents were much senior to the petitioner as Civil Assistant Surgeon and their that seniority could not be diluted just because petitioner was promoted on urgent/ temporary basis. Learned counsel, in support of their arguments, cited a judgment of the Supreme Court in State of Himachal Pradesh Vs. Narain Singh -2009 (5) Supreme 357, and argued that the Supreme Court in that case held that the power of the Rule Making Authority to legislate within its field can be exercised both prospectively and retrospectively.

Having heard learned counsel for parties and perused material on record, I find that contention of petitioner that by way of the amendment Notification his vested and accrued rights have been taken away, cannot be accepted for simple reason that he was promoted purely on urgent/temporary basis by way of stop-gap-arrangement for a specified period or till regularly selected candidates by DPC were made available, whichever was earlier. The order of promotion of petitioner was not only on urgent/temporary basis but was also conditional one that it was made till duly selected candidates by the DPC were available and on availability of regularly selected candidates by the DPC for promotion, the petitioner had to make room for them. The ratio of judgment of the Supreme Court in Chairman, Railway Board's case (Supra), whereupon reliance has been placed by the petitioner, cannot be applied in the facts and circumstances of the present case. All that has been done by the respondents by the impugned Notification was to do away with requirement of having 3 years out of 8 years experience after acquiring degree of post graduation. This does not in any manner take away the right of petitioner because if he was eligible earlier, he would continue to be eligible for promotion in future also. It is for the benefit of those, who by reason of the aforesaid requirement were not eligible earlier that they have been now made eligible by virtue of the amendment Notification. The Rule Making Authority has power to make rule by giving both effect prospectively or retrospectively. The retrospectivity given to the Rule in the present case has not in any manner taken away any right of petitioner of consideration for promotion. The only effect of the amendment would be that some such persons, who were earlier not eligible would now become eligible and chances of the petitioner would be somewhat delayed. The writ petitioner can claim right of promotion but cannot insist that others cannot be considered for promotion.

I therefore do not find any merit in this writ petition and the same is dismissed.

(Mohammad Rafiq) J.

//Jaiman//