Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ravi Kumar v. State Of Rajasthan

Rajasthan High Court
Aug 20, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Ravi Kumar, was convicted and sentenced under section 302 IPC for the murder of his wife, based on a report lodged on October 31, 2001. The trial before the Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track) No. 2 Jhunjhunu involved examination of 12 prosecution witnesses. The appellant denied the charge but admitted the allegation under Section 313 CrPC. Despite medical evidence indicating the appellant was of unsound mind and suffering from Psychosis NOS, applications under sections 329 and 330 CrPC for postponement of trial were dismissed by the trial court. The appellant was sentenced to life imprisonment and a fine, leading to this appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in proceeding with the trial despite the appellant being of unsound mind and incapable of making his defense as per the mandate of Section 329 CrPC.
  2. Whether the trial court was required to postpone the trial and await medical evidence of the appellant's fitness before continuing the trial under Section 329 and Section 330 CrPC.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sarfu Khan v. State of Jharkhand, (2004) 13 SCC 460 Procedure for trial of accused persons of unsound mind as per Chapter 25 CrPC, including Section 329 and Section 330 CrPC. The court relied on this precedent to emphasize that if the accused is found insane, the trial must be postponed and resumed only after fitness is established, which was not followed in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the provisions of Section 329 CrPC, which mandates that if the accused is incapable of making his defense due to unsoundness of mind, the trial must be postponed after recording medical and other evidence. The court noted that the appellant was medically examined and diagnosed with Psychosis NOS, requiring further treatment. Despite this, the trial court dismissed applications to postpone the trial and proceeded without medical evidence confirming the appellant's fitness. The trial court's observation that the appellant was behaving normally was not supported by expert evidence. The court found that this failure to comply with Section 329 CrPC vitiated the trial, rendering the conviction and sentence invalid.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment dated May 27, 2003, of the Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track) No. 2, Jhunjhunu, is set aside. The case is remanded for a de-novo trial in accordance with Section 329 and other relevant provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code.

The direct effect of this decision is the quashing of the conviction and sentence and the ordering of a fresh trial with proper adherence to statutory safeguards for mentally unsound accused. No new precedent beyond the application of existing statutory provisions and established case law was set.

Show all summary ...

Shiv Kumar Sharma, J.:— This appeal stem from the judgment dated May 27, 2003 of the learned Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track) No. 2 Jhunjhunu whereby the appellant Ravi Kumar was convicted and sentenced under section 302 IPC to suffer imprisonment for life and fine of Rs. 100/-, in default to further suffer simple imprisonment for one month.

2. A report was lodged on October 31, 2001 by Rudmal Sarpanch of Village Thathwadi against the appellant to the effect that the appellant committed murder of his wife. A case under section 302 IPC was registered and investigation commenced. On completion of investigation charge sheet was filed. In due course the case came up for trial before the learned Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track) No. 2, Jhunjhunu. Charges under section 302 IPC was framed against the appellant, who denied the charge and claimed trial. The prosecution in support of its case examined as may as 12 witnesses. In the explanation under Sec. 313 CrPC, the appellant admitted the allegation made against him. Learned trial Judge on hearing final submissions convicted and sentenced the appellant as indicated above.

3. Having considered the rival submissions and on careful scrutiny of the material on record we notice that the appellant at the trial was of unsound mind and incapable to defend himself. It appears that application under section 329 CrPC was filed on behalf of the appellant and pursuant to the direction of learned trial Judge the appellant was medically examined and sent to Mental Hospital Jaipur where it was noticed that the appellant was a patient of Psychosis NOS. Dr. Paramjeet Singh Psychiatrist SMS Hospital Jaipur deposed before the learned Trial Judge that the appellant was suffering from mental disease and further three months were required to completely eradicate the disease. Thereafter learned counsel for the appellant on April 19, 2003 moved two applications under sections 329 and 330 CrPC. Learned trial Judge however vide order dated April 26, 2003 dismissed both the applications with the observation that the appellant was behaving like a normal person.

4. We have heard rival submissions and scanned the material on record. At this juncture we deem it appropriate to consider the relevant statutory provisions.

5. Section 329 CrPC lays down the procedure in case of unsound mind of the accused. It provides that if at the trial it appears that the accused is incapable of making his defence, the court in the first instance, shall try the fact of such unsoundness and incapacity, and the Court, after considering such medical and other evidence, comes to the conclusion that the accused is of unsound mind the court shall record a finding to that effect and shall postpone further proceedings in the case. The trial of the fact of unsoundness of mind and incapacity of the accused shall be deemed to be part of his trial before the Court.

6. In Sarfu Khan v. State of Jharkhand, (2004) 13 SCC 460, the Apex Court observed that in case, the appellant is lunatic, the procedure as laid down in Chapter 25 CrPC has to be followed. It would be for the appellant to make an appropriate motion before the trial court. On such a motion being made, the matter would be decided, keeping in view the provisions of the said chapter of CrPC and, of course, if the trial court comes to the conclusion that the appellant is insane, the order in terms of Section 330 CrPC would be passed.

7. Evidently mandate of section 329 CrPC is that where the court comes to the conclusion that the accused is of unsound mind and incapable of making his defence the trial should be postponed. Subsequently, the trial should be commenced only after recording medical evidence about fitness of the accused. Flouting of the mandate of section 329 CrPC would vitiate the trial. But in the instant case, as already noticed, learned trial Judge completely overlooked the mandate of Section 329 CrPC. Despite the fact that the appellant was of unsound mind and he had been admitted in Mental Hospital Jaipur, the trial court did not wait till the appellant was completely treated for his mental disease. It was incumbent on learned trial court to call for the report of Mental Hospital Jaipur about the fitness of the appellant. Learned trial court without the evidence of Psychiatrist could not have observed that the appellant was fit and normal from his mental disease. We find no material on record which could establish that the appellant was completely treated before the trial commenced. Learned trial Judge was required to follow the mandate of Section 329 CrPC. It thus vitiate the trial and the impugned judgment of learned trial Judge is liable to be set aside.

8. For the reasons aforementioned, the appeal stands allowed and the impugned judgment dated May 27, 2003 of learned Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track) No. 2, Jhunjhunu is set aside and the case is remanded back to learned Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track) No. 2 Jhunjhunu for de-novo trial in accordance with Section 329 and other relevant provisions of Cr. P.C

Record of the case be sent back forthwith.