Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Radha Devi (Smt.) v. State Of Raj. & Anr.

Rajasthan High Court
Jan 27, 2005
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner has worked in the respondent Department as a part-time Sweeper since 26.6.1996. She was initially paid Rs. 180 per month, which was increased to Rs. 350 per month w.e.f. 18.7.2000 by order dated 24.9.2000. The petitioner alleged that she performed regular duties for more than eight hours per day and was paid less than the minimum wages fixed by the State Government and less than the regular pay-scale of a Sweeper (Class-IV). The respondents replied that she was engaged purely on a part-time basis and worked about four hours; however, the letter dated 24.9.2000 records that because she worked more than four hours her salary was increased. The petitioner had served for more than eight years with no record of complaints, and the respondents did not justify why a regular appointment was not made despite continuous work.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner, a long-serving part-time sweeper, is entitled to regularisation of her services given continuous work and absence of complaints.
  2. Whether a scheme for regularisation used for part-time employees in the Social Welfare Department (as approved by the Supreme Court in SLP (C) No. 16471/95 dated 21.1.1995) ought to be applied to part-time employees in other Departments.
  3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to payment at least at the minimum of the pay-scale of a Class-IV employee from a specified date pending regularisation.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • She performed regular duties exceeding eight hours per day despite being employed as part-time.
  • She was paid less than the minimum wages fixed by the State Government and less than the regular pay-scale for a Sweeper (Class-IV).
  • No reason was given by respondents for not regularising her despite continuous work and absence of complaints.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The petitioner was engaged purely on a part-time basis and worked only about four hours per day.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No. 16471/95 decided on 21.1.1995 Approval of a Scheme for regularisation of part-time Chowkidars/Cooks in the Social Welfare Department and direction to regularise as per the Scheme; determination of groups, dates of regularisation, seniority, and applicability of Class-IV rules for eligibility. The court held there was no justification for not applying a similar Scheme to part-time employees in other Departments and directed respondents to frame a comparable scheme and consider the petitioner for regularisation; relied on the Scheme as persuasive authority for regularisation measures.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court noted the factual dispute on hours worked but observed the respondents' own letter (24.9.2000) recorded work of more than four hours and that the petitioner had served for over eight years without complaint. The court expressed concern about exploitation of part-time/contractual employees and relied on the Supreme Court's approval of a regularisation Scheme for part-time employees in the Social Welfare Department (SLP (C) No. 16471/95). The court found no justification for denying application of a similar Scheme to part-time employees in other Departments and held that applying the same yardstick was consonant with protections under the Constitution of India. On that basis the court directed respondents to frame and implement a similar Scheme and to consider the petitioner for regularisation; until then the petitioner was to be paid at least the minimum of the Class-IV pay-scale from 1.7.2003. The court also ordered that consideration be completed within three months from receipt of certified copy of the order and warned against victimisation of the petitioner for litigating.

Holding and Implications

WRIT PETITION PARTLY ALLOWED

Direct effects on the parties:

  • Respondents are directed to frame a Scheme for regularisation of such part-time employees similar to that framed for the Social Welfare Department and to consider the petitioner for regularisation.
  • Until regularisation, the petitioner is to be paid at least the minimum of the pay-scale of a Class-IV employee with effect from 1.7.2003.
  • Respondents must complete necessary consideration within three months from receipt of a certified copy of the order and make the ordered payments during that period.
  • The petitioner must not be victimised for having brought the litigation.

No broader precedent was declared by this court beyond directing application of the existing Scheme's principles to similar part-time employees in other Departments; the decision's direct consequence is limited to framing/implementation of a comparable regularisation scheme and relief to the petitioner.

Show all summary ...

Ashok Parihar, J.:— Petitioner has been working in the respondent Department as a part-time Sweeper w.e.f 26.6.1996 Initially she was paid Rs. 180/- per month which was subsequently increased to Rs. 350/- per month w.e.f 18.7.2000 vide order dated 24.9.2000 It has been alleged by the petitioner that she has been performing her regular duties for more than eight hours per day, whereas she has been paid even less than minimum wages as fixed by the State Government what to say of regular pay-scale of Sweeper which is equivalent to Class-IV employee.

2. Though it has been submitted in the reply that the petitioner was engaged purely on part-time basis and had performed her duties only for about four hours, however, in the letter dated 24.9.2000 itself it has been mentioned by the concerning authorities that in view of her work for more than four hours, the salary had been increased from Rs. 180/- per month to Rs. 350/- per month. The petitioner has served now for more than eight years and there is nothing on record to show any complaint about her work. No justification has also been given by the respondents as to why the regular appointment could not be made on the post in question whereas there has been continuous work in the office of the respondent Department.

3. The courts, time and again, have expressed their anxiety and concern about the exploitation of such employees more or less by the State Government under the garb of part-time or contractual appointment. It appears that the State Government submitted a Scheme for regularisation of services of part-time Chowkidars/Cooks in Social Welfare Department before the Supreme Court in Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No. 16471/95 decided on 21.1.1995 The following order was passed by the Supreme Court:—

“We have heard the learned counsel for the State of Rajasthan as well as the respondents in the present case. The learned counsel for the State of Rajasthan has placed before us for regularisation of the part-time employees in question for the purpose of dividing them into three groups. The first group comprising those who have on May, 1995. The second group comprises those who have been working on May 1, 1995 and have continued to work thereafter. These employees are intended to be regularised from August 15, 1996, April 1, 1997 a.04.1998 respectively. The seniority will be determined on the basis of the first working day in accordance with the relevant rules. The eligibility in regard to age, educational qualification and physical fitness have also to be determined in accordance with the Rules applicable to Class-IV employees in different departments at the relevant point of time. The final implication has also been separately worked down. The Scheme has been appended to the list of dates as Annexure-‘A’ which we take on record. The Scheme appears to be reasonable and acceptable and the Government of Rajasthan may proceed to finalise and implement the same except that in the first phase a clarification would be required since it says that the employees who have completed five years on May, 1995 and ‘those part-time employee who have given pay scale No. 1 in compliance of various Court judgments' which gives the impression that they may not have completed five years of service and even so they are accepted to be regularised. In regard to the later group of employees falling into the first phase a clarificatory statement may be required to be made which the State would be at liberty to do. Taking this Scheme to be just and reasonable, we dispose of these petitions by substitution the High Court's order by an order directing regularisation as per the Scheme.

The petitions are disposed of accordingly.”

4. In my opinion, there is no justification for not applying the similar Scheme for part-time employees in other Departments. Applying the same yardstick shall also be inconsonance with the protection provided to such employees under the Constitution of India itself.

5. Accordingly, the writ petition is partly allowed. The respondents are directed to frame a Scheme for regularisation of such part-time employees as has been framed for Social Welfare Department and consider the petitioner also for regularisation of her services. Till then, the petitioner may be paid minimum of the pay-scale of Class-IV employee w.e.f 1.7.2003 Necessary consideration be made within three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order and payment, as ordered above, may also be made during the above period. It may further be observed that the petitioner may not be subjected to victimization because of this litigation.