Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Arjun Singh v. A.D.J Behror And Another

Rajasthan High Court
Sep 2, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, defendant in a specific performance suit filed by plaintiff-respondent No. 2 Hukam Singh in 1997, was initially granted four months to lead rebuttal evidence but failed to do so. Despite this, a last opportunity was granted. When the case was listed on 19-7-2003, the petitioner neither led evidence nor sought adjournment. Consequently, the trial Court closed the defendant's evidence and scheduled the matter for arguments on 31-7-2003. The petitioner challenged this order via a writ petition, asserting that revision was not maintainable due to amendments in the Code of Civil Procedure, and relying on Supreme Court precedent to argue that a writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution was maintainable against interlocutory orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution is maintainable against the trial Court’s order closing the defendant’s evidence and listing the matter for arguments.
  2. Whether the petitioner’s failure to lead rebuttal evidence despite sufficient opportunity justifies the trial Court’s closure of evidence.
  3. The scope and limits of the High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 in interfering with interlocutory orders of subordinate courts.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • A revision petition against the impugned order is not maintainable due to amendments in the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • A writ petition under Article 227 is maintainable because the impugned order is interlocutory and does not conclude the proceedings before the trial Court, relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in Surya Dev Rai v. Ram Chander Rai.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Surya Dev Rai v. Ram Chander Rai, (2003) 6 JT (SC) 465 : AIR 2003 SC 3044 Maintainability of writ petition under Article 227 against interlocutory orders; distinction between interlocutory orders not concluding proceedings and those that do. The Court considered this precedent to analyze whether the impugned order was interlocutory and if a writ petition was maintainable. It concluded that since the evidence was closed and arguments scheduled, the order effectively concluded proceedings, making writ petition not maintainable.
Babhut Mal Raichand Oswal v. Laxmi Bai R. Tarta, AIR 1975 SC 1297 Scope of High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227; limited to grave miscarriage of justice, dereliction of duty, or flagrant violation of law. The Court reiterated that Article 227 jurisdiction is not appellate or revisional and must be exercised sparingly, applying this principle to reject the petitioner’s writ petition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the petitioner’s failure to lead rebuttal evidence despite multiple opportunities. It observed that closing the defendant’s evidence and listing the matter for arguments effectively concludes the trial proceedings. Therefore, a writ petition under Article 227 is not maintainable in such circumstances as per the Supreme Court’s precedent in Surya Dev Rai. Even assuming maintainability, the petitioner’s case lacks merit on the facts because the petitioner did not avail the granted opportunities. The Court emphasized the limited scope of Article 227 jurisdiction, which is confined to addressing grave injustice or jurisdictional errors, not for reappreciation of evidence or errors of a technical nature. Applying these principles, the Court found no ground to interfere with the trial Court’s order.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is dismissed at the admission stage.

The direct effect is the upholding of the trial Court’s order closing the defendant’s evidence and proceeding to arguments, paving the way for conclusion of the suit. No broader precedent is established beyond affirming the settled principles limiting the High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 and the conditions for maintainability of writ petitions against interlocutory orders.

Show all summary ...

1. The petitioner is the defendant in a suit for specific performance which was filed by the plaintiff-respondent No. 2 Hukam Singh in the year 1997. The defendant-petitioner was granted four months time to lead the evidence of rebuttal in the suit which he failed to avail; yet last opportunity was granted to him thereafter to lead evidence and finally when the matter was listed on 19-7-2003, the defendant-petitioner neither led any evidence nor he made a request to the Court to adjourn the matter and grant further time to lead evidence. Consequently, the trial Court closed the evidence of the defendant-petitioner and the matter was ordered to be listed for arguments on 31-7-2003.

2. The petitioner thereafter has filed this writ petition challenging the aforesaid order on the ground that a revision is not maintainable against the impugned order in view of the amendment introduced in the Code of Civil Procedure. It is however, contended that a writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution is maintainable in view of the pronouncement of the Supreme Court in Surya Dev Rai v. Ram Chander Rai reported in (2003) 6 JT (SC) 465 : AIR 2003 SC 3044, wherein it has been held that the writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution can be held maintainable if the impugned order does not result into conclusion of the proceeding before the trial Court. However, if the impugned order has the effect of concluding the proceedings in the suit before the trial Court, a revision would be maintainable. The counsel for the petitioner relying on this authority has submitted that the impugned order is interlocutory in nature and hence a writ petition is maintainable since a revision is not maintainable.

3. Having considered the argument of the counsel for the petitioner it is clear that if the defendant-petitioner's evidence has been closed and the matter is listed for arguments, the same is bound to result into conclusion of the proceedings in absence of evidence of rebuttal and passing of a decree in favour of the plaintiff would be the obvious consequence. Hence a writ petition in this view of the situation, cannot be held maintainable. But even if the plea of the petitioner's advocate were to be accepted that a writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution is maintainable since the proceeding before the trial Court might not result into conclusion of the proceeding, the petitioner on merits has no case as he had failed to lead evidence of rebuttal in spite of sufficient opportunity and long length of time which was granted to him.

4. The counsel for the petitioner has missed that the power of the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution is restricted to interference in cases of grave miscarriage of justice, dereliction of duty or flagrant violation of law by the Subordinate Court and has to be exercised most sparingly as it cannot be used as an appellate or revisional power. It has to be borne in mind that the jurisdiction under Article 227 is limited only for examining whether the Subordinate Court kept itself within the bounds of its authority in reaching to a conclusion or failing, if its conclusion were perverse which has been the consistent view expressed by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in numerous cases including the case of Babhut Mal Raichand Oswal v. Laxmi Bai R. Tarta reported in AIR 1975 SC 1297. Their Lordships of the Supreme Court Hon'ble Mr. Justice R.C Lahoti and Hon'ble Mr. Justice Ashok Bhan in a landmark judgment delivered in the case of Surya Dev Rai v. Ram Chander Rai reported in (2003) 6 JT (SC) 465 : AIR 2003 SC 3044 while considering the effect of amendment of Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure vide the 1999 Amendment Act along with the ambit and scope of maintainability of a writ petition under Articles 226 & 227 of the Constitution of India against an interlocutory order passed by the trial Court while trying a suit, have themselves observed as follows:

“In exercise of certiorari or supervisory jurisdiction, the High Court will not convert itself into a Court of appeal and indulge in re-appreciation or evaluation of evidence or correct errors in drawing inferences or correct errors of mere formal or technical character. Where a subordinate Court has assumed a jurisdiction which it does not have or has failed to exercise a jurisdiction which it has or the jurisdiction though available is being exercised in a manner not permitted by law and failure of justice or grave injustice has resulted, the High Court may step into exercise its supervisory jurisdiction.”

5. While examining the present case on the anvil of the law laid down as referred to hereinabove, interference with the impugned order is not warranted at all as it does not satisfy the parameters of the scope and ambit of Article 227 of the Constitution in view of the facts related hereinbefore. This writ petition, therefore, is not fit to be entertained and hence the same is dismissed at the admission stage itself.

Petition dismissed.