- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Fateh Kumari Sisodia v. State Of Rajasthan And Others
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner appeared in the two-year M.A. Hindi course examinations of Mohanlal Sukhadia University, Udaipur. In the M.A. (Previous) Examination she secured 251/400 (first position). In the M.A. (Final) Examination result declared on 14.3.1993 she was shown to have obtained 226/400, giving a combined total of 477/800. The mark-sheet for one subject in the M.A. (Final), “Hindi Natya Avam Rangamanch”, recorded 40/100. The petitioner sought re-evaluation of that answer-book because she suspected an error in totalling or computation.
Initially the University informed her there was no change, but subsequently, after re-checking and re-evaluation, her marks in that subject were increased to 51/100. This produced a revised aggregate of 488/800. At the time of the original declaration the petitioner was placed second (477) while another student with 487 was placed first. After re-evaluation the petitioner’s aggregate exceeded that of the earlier first-placed student.
The petitioner requested correction of the merit list and the award of the Gold Medal (customarily awarded to the first position holder). The University replied that its instructions or rule disallow awarding the Gold Medal when marks are increased by re-evaluation, and communicated this position by a letter dated 9.6.1994. Aggrieved, the petitioner filed the present writ petition seeking inclusion in the merit list as first position holder and award of the Gold Medal.
In its written statement the University admitted the totalling mistake (the record incorrectly showed 40 instead of 48) and admitted that re-evaluation later raised the subject marks to 51. The University relied on a rule (instruction) that the increase in marks consequent upon revision/re-evaluation would not make a candidate eligible for award of Gold Medal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a candidate whose marks are increased on re-totalling and re-evaluation can be placed higher in the merit list (specifically, be declared first) when a university rule disallows taking re-evaluation increases into account for awards/medals or ordering of merit.
- Whether the university rule/instruction that disbars a candidate from receiving a Gold Medal because their marks were revised by re-evaluation is valid, or whether it is ultra vires and must be struck down or disregarded so that the revised marks are given full effect for merit and medals.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner contended that her aggregate after re-checking and re-evaluation became 488/800 and that she should therefore be placed at the first position in the merit list and be awarded the Gold Medal normally given to the highest scorer.
- Counsel for the petitioner relied on precedents (Ram Karan v. The University of Raj[Jaipur], Rajendra Kumar Chandrakant Nadkarni v. University of Bombay, and Anjay Bansal v. Bangalore University) to show that rules excluding revaluation increases from affecting merit lists and awards have been struck down or disapplied.
Respondents' (University) Arguments
- The University admitted the totalling error and that marks were raised on re-totalling (from 40 to 48) and later to 51 on re-evaluation, but relied on an internal instruction/ordinance provision that a candidate whose marks are increased on revision/re-evaluation shall not be eligible for the award of Gold Medal (and, as stated elsewhere, for ordering of merit or awards).
- In its written statement the University also explained the sequence of corrections: initially the correct total after correcting the totalling error was 48 (aggregate 485), and a further 3 marks from re-evaluation produced 488 — indicating the administrative steps the University records reflect.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ram Karan v. The University of Raj( Jaipur ) | Challenged a rule (Ordinance 157A(11)) providing that an increase in marks as a result of revaluation shall not be taken into account for preparing the merit list of the first 10 candidates. | The single Judge struck down Clause 11 as unreasonable and invalid, holding that revaluation must have effect and that denying revised marks their normal consequences frustrates the purpose of revaluation. The petition in that case was allowed and the petitioner was to be included in the merit list with marks as per revaluation; the Court directed that a gold medal be awarded to the petitioner in addition to the one already given to the earlier first candidate. |
| Rajendra Kumar Chandrakant Nadkarni v. University of Bombay | Respondent university's regulation stated revised marks after revaluation shall be taken into account for amendment of results but "shall not be taken into account for the purpose of award of scholarships, prizes, medals and/or the order of merit." | The Bombay High Court held that where revaluation vindicates a candidate, the full benefit must be given; the exclusion of awards/prizes/medals/order of merit was quashed. The Court made the rule absolute and ordered appropriate relief (special certificate/award confirmed). |
| Anjay Bansal v. Bangalore University | A university notification stated no revised rank would be declared for those who obtain benefit in revaluation, and no incidental benefit except declaration of class would be granted. | The Karnataka High Court declared such a rule ultra vires and quashed the notification, directing the University to award proper rank to the petitioner in accordance with revised marks. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began from the undisputed factual matrix: the University record initially showed 40 marks in the subject owing to a totalling error, which when corrected became 48, and further re-evaluation increased the marks to 51; this changed the petitioner’s aggregate from the originally declared 477 to 488.
The Court identified the core legal question as whether a university instruction that denies the effect of re-evaluation increases for purposes of merit placement and awards can be applied to deny the petitioner the benefit of higher marks obtained by re-evaluation. The Court reasoned that if the University permits re-evaluation and, on such re-evaluation, a candidate's marks are found to be higher, the benefit of those higher marks must accrue to the candidate. The credit for the higher marks should go to the student whose assessment, on proper totalling and re-evaluation, shows higher marks.
The Court examined and relied upon prior decisions (Ram Karan; Rajendra Kumar Chandrakant Nadkarni; Anjay Bansal) where similar rules or notifications excluding the effect of re-evaluation on merit lists, medals or other incidental benefits were struck down or disapplied. The Court agreed with the reasoning in Ram Karan that the clause excluding revaluation benefits is unreasonable and would frustrate the very purpose of re-evaluation, and with the Bombay and Karnataka High Court decisions that full benefit must be awarded to the vindicated candidate.
Applying these principles to the present facts, the Court held that the university's rule that debars a candidate from being eligible for the Gold Medal due to revision of results following re-evaluation is ultra vires and cannot be applied to deny the petitioner the higher merit position and attendant medal. On that basis the Court directed the respondents to place the petitioner in accordance with the revised mark-sheet (total 488) and to award the Gold Medal accordingly.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The Court directed that the petitioner be included in the merit list with the revised total of 488 marks, be declared the first position holder, and be awarded the Gold Medal. The Court held that the rule which debars a candidate from being eligible for the Gold Medal consequent upon revision of results due to re-evaluation is ultra vires and cannot be enforced.
Implications and immediate consequences:
- The petitioner must be placed in the merit list according to the revised marks (488/800) and declared first in the examination in question.
- The respondents are directed to award the Gold Medal to the petitioner. If the University does not wish to withdraw the Gold Medal already awarded to the earlier first-placed candidate, the court directed that the Gold Medal be awarded to the petitioner in addition to the medal already awarded.
- The rule/instruction that denies medal/merit benefits arising from re-evaluation has been held ultra vires in these circumstances (the Court fully agreed with the cited precedents).
- No orders were made as to costs.
Note: This summary is strictly confined to the content and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not introduce information beyond that opinion.
J.C Verma, J.:— The petitioner had applied for M.A Hindi Examination a Two Years course of Mohanlal Sukhadia University Udaipur (hereinafter called ‘the University’). She appeared in M.A(Examination under Roll No. 92019 and secured first position by obtaining 251 marks out of 400 marks. After clearing the M.A(Previous) Examination she appeared in the M.A (Final) Examination, the result of which was declared on 14.3.1993 and in the result so declared, it was shown that she had secured 226 marks out of 400 marks in the M.A (Final) Examination and, thus, the total marks in the M.A (Previous) and M.A (final) Examinations came to 477 marks out of 800 marks. It is stated by the petitioner that in one of the subjects in the M.A (Final) Examination i.e ‘Hindi Natya Avam Rangamanch’ in the result sheet it is shown that she had secured 40 marks out of 100 marks. She had apprehension that by way of inadvertance or otherwise or by way of mistake the totalling and computation of marks had not been done properly and, therefore, she applied for re-evaluation of her answer-book of the said subject. The University had initially informed her that there was no change in the marks obtained by her in the said subject but later on immediately she was informed that on re-checking of totalling and re-evaluation there is a total increase of 11 marks in the said subject i.e she had obtained 51 marks out if 100 marks and, thus, the total of the marks obtained by her in the M.A (Previous) and M.A (Final) Examinations had come out to be 488 out of 800 marks. Earlier at the declaration of the result when she is said to have obtained 477 marks she was placed at second position in the merit list and the student having obtained a higher aggregate of 487 marks was said to be the first position holder. After re-totalling and re-evaluation (re-marking) the aggregate marks of the petitioner became higher to the student who had obtained the first position. Therefore, the petitioner approached the University to correct the position list and merit and also to award her the Gold Medal, which is normally given to the student who stands first in the examination. She was informed that because of certain instructions, if the marks are increased because of re-evaluation then in that situation she cannot be given the first position, despite the fact that she stands higher than the student who has got the first position. Aggrieved by the communication dated 9.6.1994, the petitioner had filed the present writ petition on the ground that her total aggregate marks comes to 488 out of marks and the student lower in merit i.e 487 marks out of 800 has been awarded the Gold Medal.
2. A written-statement has been filed by the respondents No. 1 and 2 and the position as stated above is not denied. It is admitted by the University that there was a mistake in the totalling of such subject and instead of 48 marks by mistake 40 marks had been mentioned in the details of the marks and, therefore, her marks were increased by way of removing the mistake in the total by 8 marks. It was further admitted that the total marks after re-evaluation in such subject has come to 51 i.e 40 marks initially awarded to the petitioner were raised to 48 marks by correcting the wrong totalling and on re-evaluation the total marks were raised to 51.
3. A contention has been raised that the University has issued certain instructions wherein it has been provided that the candidate shall not be eligible for award of Gold Medal consequent upon the revision in his/her result, due re-evaluationor improvement. As per the written-statement of the University, the petitioner after re-totalling and after correcting the total in that subject had obtained aggregate of 485 marks and if 3 marks after re-evaluation are also added then the position of the petitioner goes higher to the student who was awarded the Gold Medal.
4. From the facts of the case, the situation becomes clear that before the re-evaluation the petitioner had obtained 485 marks and another candidate had obtained 487 marks out of 800 marks but on re-evaluation another three marks were added to the total of the petitioner, thus, raising her total to be that of 488 marks out of 800 marks.
5. The contention of the petitioner that she is entitled to be placed at number one position after re-evaluation is to be accepted for the reason that if the University allows reevaluation of the answer-books and on re-evaluation the University does find the raising of the marks, the credit must go to the student who has obtained such higher marks. In the present case the record of the University was incorrectly made and instead of 48 actual marks in the subject a wrong total was mentioned as 40 marks and later on re-totalling the marks in the subject were raised to 51 marks.
6. Counsel for the petitioner relies on a single Bench Judgment delivered in Ram Karan v. The University of Raj. Jaipur (1), wherein in similar circumstances and under the same provision of debarring a person to be put on higher position after re-evaluation of marks, the petitioner in that case was given the benefit. The rule in that case was also similar to the one as in the present case. In Ram Karan's case, the rule was as under:—
“(11) The increase in marks obtained by a candidate as a result of revaluation shall not be taken into account for preparing the merit list of first 10 candidates standing in order of merit at an examination.”
7. It was held by the learned single Judge while interpreting Rule 11 as under:—
“It was submitted that the result would become final only after the revaluation is over otherwise applying for revaluation would be meaning-less. There is lot of substance in this submission. Ordinance 157A(11) is absolutely unreasonable and liable to be struck down. The candidate would not be at fault if there is mistake committed by the examiner in giving or totalling the marks. If this clause (11) of the Ordinance 157 A is allowed to stand then it will frustrate the very purpose of revaluation. Clause 11 is wholly unreasonable and, therefore, liable to be struck down and accordingly, it is declared to be invalid and struck down.”
“Accordingly, this petition is allowed. The respondent is directed to include the name of the petitioner in the merit list for by including the marks obtained by him in the revaluation. Now the question is what will happen to the gold medal awarded to the first candidate who secured highest marks before revaluation. This petition is of 1987, therefore, it would not be proper at this stage to direct the respondent to withdraw the gold medal from the first candidate and award to the petitioner. However, the respondent can certainly be directed to award gold medal to the petitioner in addition to the gold medal awarded to the first candidate. Accordingly, the respondent is directed to present gold medal to the petitioner for securing the highest marks in M.Sc Final Examination in Botany held in March, 1986.”
8. Learned counsel for the petitioner also relies on a judgment of the Bombay High Court in Rajendra Kumar Chandrakant Nadkarni v. University of Bombay (2), wherein in the Ordinance/Regulations of the University of Bombay a similar clause was incorporated, which is reproduced as under:—
“The revised marks obtained by a candidate after revaluation as accepted by the University shall be taken into account for the purpose of amendment of his results in accordance with the rules of the University in that behalf, but these marks shall not be taken into account for the purpose of award of scholarships, prizes, medals and
/or the order of merit.”
9. It was held by the Bombay High Court as under:—
“If revaluation is permitted and if ranking in so far as class is concerned is awarded to candidates who get the benefit of revaluation, there is no reason to restrict the result to the mere declaration of a class. The full benefit to the vindicated candidate has to be awarded and his marks have to be taken into account for the purpose of scholarship, prizes, medals and/or the order or merit. Agreeing with the learned single Judge of the Karnataka High Court, I make the rule absolute by quashing Ex.F and confirming the correctness of Ex. D.i.e the special certificate awarded on 17.8.1983 Rule in these terms is made absolute with parties being left to bear their own costs.”
10. In another Judgment of the Karnataka High Court in Anjay Bansal v. Bangalore University* (3), a similar rule made by the University was
Declared to be ultra vires and the notification to the fact that no revised rank will be declared in respect of those who get benefit in the revaluation (review) and no incidental benefit which accrue due to the revaluation (review) will be granted except declaration of class was quashed with the direction to the University to award rank to the petitioner in that case and to place the petitioner in that case at a proper rank.
11. In view of the law discussed above, the writ petition of the petitioner is allowed and a direction is given to the respondents to put the Petitioner in due merit in accordance with the revised mark-sheet by allocating total 488 marks and she may be declared to be at first position holder in the merit and the rule formulated in regard to the conditions of award for medals so far as it debars the candidate to be eligible for award of Gold Medal consequent upon the revision in the results due to re-evaluation, is held to be ultra vires, by fully agreeing with the judgment of the learned single Judge delivered in the case of Ram Karan referred to above.
12. In the facts and circumstances of the case, the writ petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to include the name of the petitioner in the merit list and award the gold Medal to her and in case the University does not want to withdraw the gold medal from the candidate who had lower marks than the petitioner, the University is directed to award Gold Medal to the petitioner in addition to the gold medal already awarded to the candidate who had been put earlier at first position for the examination in question. No orders as to costs.
Alert