Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Babu Lal v. Raj Kumar And Others

Rajasthan High Court
Mar 2, 1994
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision petition under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure was filed by Babu Lal, a stranger to the original decree, seeking to set aside an ex-parte order dated 15.12.1992 passed in favour of the decree-holders. The original suit was filed by the deceased decree-holder Shyam Lal Saxena in 1966 for specific performance of an agreement to sell a house situated in Ballabh Bari, Kota. The suit was decreed in 1973, and the sale deed was executed and registered by 1981. The decree holder subsequently applied for police aid to obtain possession of the property, which was granted by the court. Babu Lal contested the execution application but was not given notice before the ex-parte order was passed. The petitioner challenged this order through an application dated 17.12.1992, which was dismissed by the Munsif, Kota on 31.1.1994, upholding the original ex-parte order. The petitioner then filed the present revision petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a revision petition under Section 115 CPC lies against an interlocutory order passed ex-parte in an execution proceeding.
  2. Whether a person who is not a party to the decree (a stranger) has the locus standi to challenge or object to an order granting police aid for possession under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC.
  3. The scope and applicability of Order 21 Rule 97 CPC in cases where possession is resisted by a third party.
  4. The extent of interference permissible by the High Court under Section 115 CPC in revisional jurisdiction.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The order dated 15.12.1992 was passed illegally and ex-parte against Babu Lal without giving him notice, violating principles of natural justice.
  • The petitioner contended that since no order for dispossession was passed, no order under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC could be validly passed.
  • The petitioner argued that no decree for specific performance was passed against him, hence no execution order could be enforced against him.

Decree-holder's Arguments

  • The decree holder asserted the entitlement to possession under the decree for specific performance passed in 1973 and the registered sale deed.
  • Police aid was lawfully granted under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC as the decree holder was obstructed in taking possession.
  • The petitioner, being a stranger to the decree and not a judgment debtor, had no right to object or file an application against the execution order.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nisar Ahmad v. Addl. Distt. Judge, Azamgarh (1992 All. L.J. 635) Application of Order 21 Rule 97 CPC regarding surrender of possession by non-judgment debtors Held that a person not party to the decree must surrender possession before objecting; petitioner's objection was not maintainable as possession was not delivered.
Usha v. Manmohan (Full Bench decision) Execution Court's discretion when third party objects to possession The court is not bound to stay execution pending full investigation; third party can file separate suit for title and injunction.
Rajendra Kumar v. III Addl. District Judge, Moradabad Third party's right to object in execution proceedings Third party who is neither decree-holder nor auction purchaser has no right to object or file application; Order 21 Rule 97 applies only to decree holder facing resistance.
Keshardeo v. Radha Kishan Scope of Section 115 CPC and revisional jurisdiction Section 115 applies where no appeal lies; High Court can interfere only if jurisdictional error, illegality or material irregularity is shown; errors of fact or law alone are insufficient.
Venkatagiri Ayyanagar v. Hindu Religious Endowments Boards, Madras (76 Ind. Appl. 67) Principles governing Section 115 CPC Confirmed that Section 115 empowers High Court to examine jurisdiction, exercise of jurisdiction, and legality/material irregularity but not factual or legal errors per se.
Joy Chand Lal Babu v. Kamalaksha Chaudhary (1976 Ind. Appl. 131) Clarification on interference under Section 115 CPC Reiterated that jurisdictional error or illegality is required for interference; mere error of decision does not suffice.
Narayan Sonaji v. Sheshrao Vithoba (AIR 1948 Nag. 258) Definition of "illegally" and "material irregularity" under Section 115 CPC Errors must relate to procedural defects, not errors of fact or law after compliance with legal formalities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the nature of the order challenged, finding it interlocutory and not final, thus not amenable to revision under Section 115 CPC. It emphasized that the petitioner, being a stranger to the decree and not a judgment debtor, had no locus standi to object to execution proceedings or the grant of police aid under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC. The court relied on precedents establishing that only the decree holder can apply under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC when facing resistance and that third parties must seek separate remedies to protect their possession or title. The court further clarified the limited scope of Section 115 CPC, stating that the High Court can interfere only on jurisdictional errors, illegality, or material irregularity, not on mere errors of law or fact. The petitioner's contention that the order violated natural justice was rejected as the order was interlocutory and the execution proceedings were correctly conducted. The court therefore upheld the ex-parte order granting police aid to the decree holder for possession.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the revision petition filed by Babu Lal with costs of Rs. 700/- in favour of the respondents. The direct effect of this decision is to uphold the ex-parte order granting police aid to the decree holder for possession of the property under the decree for specific performance. No new precedent was set; the decision reaffirms established principles that interlocutory orders in execution proceedings are not subject to revision under Section 115 CPC absent jurisdictional errors, and that third parties not bound by the decree cannot obstruct execution but must seek separate legal remedies.

Show all summary ...

1. This revision petition filed under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure by Babu Lal (a stranger to the decree) seeks setting aside of the order dated 15.12.1992 alleged to have been passed ex-parte against him and in favour of the decree-holders. This has been claimed through the application dated 17.12.1992. The order challenged in the revision is dated 31.1.1994.

2. Briefly, deceased decree-holder Shyam Lal Saxena filed a suit for specific performance of an agreement to sale against deceased Smt. Bhoori and deceased Prabhu Lal on 5.10.1966. The suit was decreed on 18.10.73 in pursuance to which the court executed the sale-deed on 9.12.80, which was registered on 28.1.1981. This was the suit in respect of a house situtated in Ballabh Bari, Kota. The decree for specific performance became final. Thereafter, the decree holder applied for police aid for getting possession in pursuance to the decree. Police aid was given by the order of the court below.

3. Learned Counsel for the petitioner took us through the entire history of the case and submitted that the order dated 15.12.92 had been illegally passed in favour of the decree-holder in as much as Babu Lal who was the contestant of the application for execution was not given any notice. He urged that the order dated 15.12.92 being against the principles of natural justice, was liable to be set aside on that ground. For staying operation of the order dated 15.12.92, the petitioner had applied through an application on 17.12.92. The court below holding that Babu Lal was entitled to hearing, hence the order passed on 15.12.92 behind his back was liable to be set aside.

4. On 2.2.1993, an application was moved by the decree holder for being given possession of the house which he had purchased through an agreement and for which decree for specific performance had been passed. Enlarging the controversy involved in the application for delivery of possession made by the decree holder, the petitioner alleged that Shravan Kumar Punjabi, Shyam Sunder Punjabi and Babu Lal Punjabi were living in the house along with their sons.

5. The decree holder had applied for possession through police aid. This application was contested by the petitioner saying that as no decree for specific performance had been passed, there was no decree for order, which could be executed against him. What happened in the case was that in the application filed by the decree holder for possession, a Nazir was appointed by the Court. He submitted his report on 25.7.87 mentioning about being obstructed to in the possession of Shravan Kumar, who was the man of the petitioner. Vide order dated 31.1.94, the Munsif, Kota dismissed the application of the petitioner filed on 17.12.92 and upheld the order dated 15.12.92. The order dated 15.12.92 was the order passed ex-parte in favour of the decree holder by which the Munsif held that police help should be given to the respondents.

6. Having heard counsel for the parties, I am of the opinion that as against the impugned order, no revision will lie as the order will not be final between the parties and also being interlocutory in nature. The revision is also liable to be dismissed on the ground that no jurisdictional error was committed by the court below.

7. Considering the scope of Order 21 Rule 97 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the Allahabad High Court in Nisar Ahmad v. Addl. Distt. Judge, Azamgarh 1992 All. L.J. 635 held that a person like the petitioner, who was not a judgment-debtor, had to surrender possession to the decree holder and thereafter may initiate such proceedings as was advised. In the present case, admittedly, possession of the house was not delivered by petitioner Babu Lal, hence, the objection filed was not maintainable. During the course of argument, the petitioner slated that unless the order for dis-possession was passed, no order could be passed under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC.

8. The question is as to who can apply under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC. It is the decree holder complaining resistence or obstruction, can apply under Order 21 Rule 97 CPC. It is he, who can take recourse under the aforesaid provision. In a Full Bench decision in Usha v. Manmohan , the view taken was that were in a decree for possession a third party objects to execution, the executun, Court is not bound to stay its hands till full investigation into the objections have been made. The third party could not in any manner by thereby deprived of its remedy to protect his possession and have his title judicially investigated prior to his dispossession; he can institute a separate suit for declaration of his title and claiming therein a temporary injunction to protect his possession. In the instant case, the adjudication of rights has not reached to that level. In Rajendra Kumar v. III Addl. District Judge, Moradabad it was held that a third person neither being a decree-holder nor auction-purchaser, had no right to make any objection or application. Hence, an application or objection filed by the petitioner was not maintainable. Order 21 Rule 97 applies only when the decree holder having obtained a general order of the character specified in Rule 96, meets with resistance from any particular person. Therefore, the decree holder could lawfully get police aid for getting possession of the house which was obtained by him in the suit for specific performance filed in 1966. It is a lamentable state of affairs that litigations in this country take too long to come to termination.

9. While considering the scope of Section 115 CPC, the Supreme Court in Keshardeo v. Radha Kishan agreed with the Privy Council's judgment reported in Venkatagiri Ayyanagar v. Hindu Religious Endowments Boards, Madras 76 Ind. Appl. 67 in which it was said:

Section 115 applies only to cases in which no appeal lies, and, where the Legislature has provided no right of appeal, the manifest intention is that the order of the trial Court, right or wrong, shall be final. The section empoweres the High Court to satisfy itself on three matters, (a) that the order of the subordinate Court is within its Jurisdiction; (b) that the cases is one in which the Court ought to exercise jurisdiction; and (c) that in execising jurisidiction the Court has not acted illegally, that is, in breach of some provisions of law, or with material irregularity, that is, by committing some error of procedure in the course of the trial which is material in that it may have affected the ultimate decision. If the High Court is satisfied on those three matters, it has no power to interfere because it differs, however profoundly, from the conclusions of the subordinate Court on questions of fact or law.

10. In Joy Chand Lal Babu v. Kamalaksha Chaudhary 1976 Ind. Appl. 131, their Lordships had against adverted to this matter and reiterated what they had said in their earlier decision. They pointed out:

There have been a very large number of decisions of Indian High Courts on Section 115 to many of which their Lordships have been referred. Some of such decisions prompt the observation that High Courts have not always apreciated that although error in a decision of a subordinate Court does not by itself involve that the subordinate Court has acted illegally or with material irregularity so as to justify interference in revision under Sub-section (c), nevertheless, if the erroneous decision results in the subordinate court exercising a jurisdiction not vested in it by law, or failing to exercise a jurisdiction so vested, a case for revision arises under Sub-section (a) or Sub-section (b) and Sub-section (c) can be ignored.

11. In Keshardeo v. Radha Kishen (Supra), the Supreme Court has also laid down the law in paragrapy 20 by approving the decision of the Nagpur High Court reported in Narayan Sonaji v. Sheshrao Vithoba AIR 1948 Nag. 258 wherein it was said that the words "illegally" and "material irregularity" do not cover either errors of fact or law. They do not refer to the decision arrived at but to the manner in which it is reached. The errors contemplated relate to material defects of procedure and not to errors of either law or fact after the formalities which the law prescribed have been complied with.

12. The present proceedings are against an interlocutory order and as such on this ground also the petitioner had no right to obtain an order in his favour. In a revision the High Court can interfere only when there is a jurisdictional error. The error pointed out by the learned Counsel for the petitioner is that of law if the submission putforth by him is accepted. I have stated above that there being no force in his arguments, this submission could not be accepted and that the decree holder is entitled to the possession of the house.

13. The citations placed before me by the petitioner's counsel do not apply to the facts of the present case.

14. For the reasons given above, this revision petition fails and is dismissed with costs, which is assessed at Rs. 700/- (Rs. seven hundred) in favour of the respondents.