- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramnarain v. State Of Rajasthan
Structured Summary of Opinion: Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions Nos. 190 of 1987, 5 of 1987 and 145 of 1986
Factual and Procedural Background
This Order deals with three Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions filed under Section 482, Cr. P.C., decided together because they raise a common question of law.
(1) Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 190 of 1987 (Ramnarain v. State of Rajasthan): Roop Singh filed a criminal complaint alleging that Kulwant Singh, Ram Narain and Harmit Singh forged an exchange deed and caused mutation in their favour concerning agricultural lands. The Judicial Magistrate forwarded the complaint to the police under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. The police filed a charge-sheet against Ramnarain and Kulwant Singh under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 109, I.P.C.; cognizance was taken and proceedings commenced. Roop Singh had earlier filed a revenue suit (Revenue Suit No. 81/89 of 1981 referenced) in which a certified copy of the exchange deed was produced; the petitioner contended that because the matter was before the Revenue Court, the magistrate was barred from taking cognizance under Section 195(1)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C.
(2) S. B. Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 5 of 1987 (Hetram v. State of Rajasthan): Petitioners Hetram, Ramchander, Sukhdas and Laduram were the accused in a criminal complaint alleging a forged will and conspiracy to effect mutation. The Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate forwarded the complaint under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. The FIR (Case No. 73 of 1986) was registered and investigation proceeded. Petitioners alleged that a revenue suit had been filed in which a photostat copy of the alleged will had been produced, and they sought quashing of further investigation on the basis of Section 195(1)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C.
(3) Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 145 of 1986 (Mangilal v. State of Rajasthan): Mangilal had been granted a patta and was in possession of a plot; disputes arose and civil proceedings including Order XL Rule 1-2 CPC interim reliefs and revision to this Court followed. Ramuram (present Sarpanch) filed a criminal complaint alleging forgery and conspiracy; the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate forwarded the complaint to the police under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. The petitioner sought dismissal of the criminal complaint and quashing of the related investigation (FIR No. 2 of 1985).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the bar under Section 195(1)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C. applies when only a copy (photostat/certified copy) of an allegedly forged document has been produced in a civil/revenue proceeding, and not the original document.
- Whether a Magistrate forwarding a complaint to the police for investigation under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. amounts to "taking cognizance" of the offence within the meaning of Section 195(1)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C.
- Whether an investigation initiated after a complaint is forwarded under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. can be quashed on the ground that Section 195(1)(b)(ii) bars cognizance of the offence.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners in Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 190 of 1987 (Ramnarain)
- Contended that the alleged forged exchange deed was already the subject-matter of a pending revenue suit before the Assistant Collector, Hanumangarh, and that the revenue court was the only competent authority to initiate a criminal complaint in respect of a document produced in that court.
- Argued that Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Hanumangarh wrongly took cognizance on a complaint filed by an incompetent person and that taking cognizance was barred by Section 195(1)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C.
- Sought quashing of the Magistrate's order dated June 20, 1987 (Criminal Complaint No. 32 of 1987) and further proceedings.
Petitioners in S. B. Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 5 of 1987 (Hetram and others)
- Alleged that the complainants had suppressed the fact that a revenue suit was pending in which a photostat/copy of the alleged forged will had been produced in the Revenue Court (Court of the Assistant Collector/Sub-Divisional Officer) — i.e., that only a copy was before the revenue court.
- Argued that Section 195(1)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C. barred further proceedings and that, in the interest of justice, the FIR (No. 73 of 1986) and further investigation should be quashed.
- Later produced material indicating that an original will had been produced in some revenue proceedings only after the present petition was filed, but the Court noted that at the time of filing this petition the original had not been produced in any revenue suit.
Petitioner in Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 145 of 1986 (Mangilal)
- Prayed that the criminal complaint against him be dismissed and the investigation (FIR No. 2 of 1985) quashed on the basis that the complaint had been forwarded to police under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. and the matter concerned documents tied to prior revenue/civil proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sanmukhsingh v. King (1949) LR 77 Ind App 7; AIR 1950 PC 31; 1950-51 Cri LJ 651 (Privy Council) | Interpreted earlier CrPC language: production of a copy of an allegedly forged document in a Court does not amount to production of the original document 'in evidence' before that Court. | Cited to support the conclusion that merely producing a certified/photostat copy in revenue proceedings does not trigger Section 195(1)(b)(ii)'s bar. |
| Budhu Ram v. State of Rajasthan (Supreme Court) | Followed the Privy Council view on copy vs original in the context of the corresponding provisions. | Cited as precedent supporting the proposition that a copy's production is not equivalent to the original being produced in evidence. |
| Shushil Kumar v. State of Haryana (1987/1988) | Supreme Court decision endorsing the grammatical and practical view that a copy is not the original for purposes of the relevant provision. | Relied upon as the latest Supreme Court authority supporting the court's conclusion on the applicability of Section 195(1)(b)(ii) where only copies are produced. |
| R. R. Chari v. State of U.P.; Gopaldas v. State of Assam; Jamunasingh v. Bhadaishan; Nirmaljeet Singh Hoon v. State of West Bengal (supra) — Supreme Court decisions | Established that when a Magistrate merely orders investigation under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. or issues search warrants for investigation, he is not to be treated as having 'taken cognizance' of the offence; taking cognizance occurs when the Magistrate applies his mind for proceedings under Chapter XVI. | Used to support the proposition that forwarding a complaint for investigation under Section 156(3) does not constitute taking cognizance and therefore the bar under Section 195(1)(b)(ii) (which prohibits taking cognizance) does not ipso facto invalidate investigations ordered under Section 156(3). |
| Shankarlal v. Chaturbhuj (1987) 1 Rajasthan LR 43 (M. B. Sharma, J.) | Held that Section 195(1), Cr. P.C. prohibits taking cognizance, not the investigation of the case; if an original document is involved and police after investigation files a charge-sheet, the court will decide the objection regarding cognizance. | Adopted by the Court as the correct view over contrary decisions of co-ordinate benches; used to reject quashing of investigations which were forwarded under Section 156(3). |
| Dharamchand v. State of Rajasthan (1985 Rajasthan LR 282) (K. S. Lodha, J.) | A single-judge decision that, on facts before that Court, quashed investigation even though the complaint had been forwarded under Section 156(3), on the basis that when cognizance is barred continuance of investigation would be harassment. | Not followed by the present Court; the present Court considered that decision erroneous in light of the Supreme Court authorities and declined to quash investigations on that basis. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a fact-sensitive and precedent-based analysis focused on two interrelated legal points: (a) whether the bar in Section 195(1)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C. applies where only a copy of an allegedly forged document was produced in revenue/civil proceedings; and (b) whether forwarding a complaint to police under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. amounts to "taking cognizance" of an offence so as to trigger the bar of Section 195(1)(b)(ii).
For Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 190 of 1987 the Court examined the pleadings and materials and found that only a certified copy of the alleged forged exchange deed had been presented in the revenue court. Relying on the Privy Council decision in Sanmukhsingh (and subsequent Supreme Court authorities including Budhu Ram and Shushil Kumar), the Court held that production of a copy does not amount to production of the original document 'in evidence' in the revenue proceeding. Consequently, the bar created by Section 195(1)(b)(ii) did not apply; the Judicial Magistrate's taking of cognizance was not barred on that basis, and the petition was dismissed.
In S. B. Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 5 of 1987 the Court again found that at the time of filing the petition only a copy/photostat of the alleged will had been produced in revenue pleadings; the original will was produced in some revenue proceedings only later and in different proceedings than those originally pleaded. More fundamentally, the Court analyzed the legal effect of a Magistrate forwarding a complaint under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. The Court reiterated the well-settled principle from Supreme Court decisions that when a Magistrate applies his mind only to order investigation under Section 156(3) (or issues search warrants for investigation), he has not "taken cognizance" of the offence in the sense used in Section 195(1)(b)(ii). Section 195(1)(b)(ii) bars taking cognizance of offences connected with documents produced in court proceedings, but it does not operate as an absolute bar to an investigation ordered under Section 156(3).
The Court expressly considered and rejected the view taken by a co-ordinate single judge in Dharamchand (which quashed investigation despite Section 156(3) having been used). The Court explained that quashing investigations in such circumstances would be wrong because investigations may disclose offences other than those claimed to be barred by Section 195(1)(b)(ii) or may result in a final report that will allow the trial court to decide any objection about cognizance after investigation.
Applying the above reasoning to Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 145 of 1986, the Court held that the same principles apply: the complaint had been forwarded under Section 156(3), so the ongoing investigation could not be quashed on the basis of Section 195(1)(b)(ii).
Holding and Implications
Holding:
- All three petitions are dismissed.
- Criminal Misc. Pet. No. 190 of 1987 (Ramnarain v. State of Rajasthan): Petition dismissed because only a copy of the alleged forged exchange deed had been produced in the revenue proceedings; Section 195(1)(b)(ii) did not apply.
- S. B. Criminal Misc. Pet. No. 5 of 1987 (Hetram v. State of Rajasthan): Petition dismissed; because the Magistrate had forwarded the complaint under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C., the investigation could not be quashed on the basis of Section 195(1)(b)(ii), and at the time of petition only a copy (not the original) of the alleged will had been produced in revenue proceedings.
- Criminal Misc. Pet. No. 145 of 1986 (Mangilal v. State of Rajasthan): Petition dismissed for the same reasons as in Hetram (investigation forwarded under Section 156(3) cannot be quashed on the basis of Section 195(1)(b)(ii)).
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the investigations which had been initiated by police after complaints were forwarded under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. are permitted to continue; the FIRs will not be quashed on the grounds argued in these petitions.
- The Court reaffirmed the legal distinction between production of a copy versus production of an original document in court proceedings for the purposes of Section 195(1)(b)(ii), and reiterated settled law that Section 195(1)(b)(ii) bars taking cognizance but does not, by itself, automatically bar investigations ordered under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C.
- The opinion applied and followed established authorities of the Privy Council and the Supreme Court cited in the judgment; the Court expressly declined to follow a contrary single-judge decision (Dharamchand) insofar as it would require quashing investigations forwarded under Section 156(3).
- No new legal principle beyond application and clarification of the cited authorities was stated in sweeping terms; the decision resolves the petitions by applying existing precedent to the factual record.
This summary is limited to and derived exclusively from the content of the provided opinion.
1. This Order will decide three Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions Nos. 190 of 1987, 5 of 1987 and 145 of 1986 filed before this Court under Section 482, Cr. P.C. by a common order as the same question of law comes for consideration in all these three petitions.
2. Facts leading to the filing of Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 190 of 1987 are that on June 6, 1981 Roop Singh son of Mukhtiar Singh had filed a criminal complaint in the Court of Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Hanumangarh against Kulwant Singh, Ram Narain and Harmit Singh complaining of the commission of offences under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471, 166, 167 and 120B, I.P.C. It was alleged by Roop Singh in his complaint that he was Khatedar tenant of agricultural land in 'chak' No. 27 PTP, Sq. No. 24 and comprised in 'killa' Nos. 1 to 19 and in Sq. No. 24, Killas Nos. 14 and 15, measuring in all 20 Bighas 10 Biswas (nahari), and he was in its peaceful possession. It was mentioned that Kulwantsingh and his deceased brother Raghuveersingh held agricultural land in their Khatedari in 'chak' No. 28 AMP measuring 3 Bighas and in 'chak' No. 25 PTP measuring 16 Bighas, in all 19 Bighas, over which Kulwantsingh and his deceased brother Raghuveersingh were in possession. It was alleged that Kulwantsingh and his deceased brother used to insist upon the complainant to exchange his agricultural land with their land to which the former did not agree. Due to this refusal, Kulwantsingh and his deceased brother Raghuveersingh in collusion with Ramnarain and Harmitsingh prepared a forged exchange deed and got affixed forged thumb impression of the complainant on that deed and presented the same before Deputy Superintendent, Sadul Sahar for the purpose of getting a mutation effected in their favour. Roopsingh complainant denied that he had executed any exchange deed and asserted that Kulwantsingh, Ramnarain and Harmitsingh committed various offences under the above mentioned sections of the Indian Penal Code. This criminal complaint was forwarded by the Judicial Magistrate No. 2. Hanumangarh, to the Station House Officer, Police Station, Sadulsahar under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. for investigation. It is asserted that the police after investigation filed a charge-sheet against the petitioner Ramnarain and Kulwantsingh in the Court of Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Hanumangarh on Oct. 30, 1982 under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 109, I.P.C. The Magistrate took cognizance for the said offences, issued process against the petitioner and Kulwantsingh and proceeded further to frame charges. Later on, this criminal case was transferred to the Court of Judicial Magistrate, Sadulsahar. It is mentioned that on June 8, 1981, Roopsingh filed a Revenue Suit No. 81 of 1981 in the Court of the Assistant Collector, Hanumangarh challenging the above exchange deed. In that suit, Roopsingh filed a certified copy of the exchange deed. A certified copy of the Revenue Suit No. 89 of 81 has been filed by the petitioner. In that suit Roopsingh claimed for a declaration of his rights in respect of 19 Bighas 10 Biswas agricultural land detailed above and also claimed for a declaration that the alleged exchange deed purporting to bear the date August 20, 1974 was void and ineffective as against him.
3. The second S. B. Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 5 of 1987 has been filed by Hetram, Ramchander, Sukhdas and Laduram as against the State of Rajasthan, Gangaram and Hiraram. It has been alleged by them that on May 2, 1986 Gangaram and Hiraram non-petitioners Nos. 2 and 3 filed a criminal complaint against the petitioners in the Court of Additional Judicial Magistrate, Nohar stating that the petitioner No. 4 Laduram got prepared a forged will purporting to have been executed on July 7, 1985 by Tulcharam in favour of one Omprakash son of Laduram petitioner No. 4 even after the death of Tulcharam. Petitioner No. 3 Sukhdas was the scribe of that forged will and the petitioners Nos. 1 and 2 Hetram and Ramchandra were its attesting witnesses, This will was purported to be executed with respect to a part of the land out of the land comprised in khasra No. 346 situated in village Thirana. On the basis of this forged will, it was alleged, the petitioner got mutation effected in favour of Omprakash son of Laduram petitioner No. 4 from Gram Panchayat, Nimla, This Criminal complaint was forwarded by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nohar to the Station House Officer Police Station, Nohar under Section 156(3) for investigation. The Nohar Police Station forwarded the papers to Pallu Police Station where FIR Case No. 73 of 1986 was registered on December 13, 1986 against the petitioners for the offences under sections 467, and 120b, i.p.c. It is alleged by the petitioners that the Police is now bent upon arresting them during the course of investigation. The petitioners have approached this Court for quashing further investigation by the Police on the complaint forwarded to it by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nohar under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C.
Facts leading to the filing of the third Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 145 of 1986 are that the petitioner Mangilal was granted a patta of land measuring 30' x 45' out of khasra No. 1223 situated in village Ria by the Sarpanch Tulchharam on April 30, 1977. The petitioner was in possession of this plot since then. On April 9, 1984 Mangilal petitioner filed a suit along with an application for temporary injunction under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2, C.P.C. before the Munsif, Piparcity alleging that the disputed plot had been allotted to him but the present Sarpanch, owing to election enmity, wanted to dispossess the petitioner. The application for temporary injunction was rejected by the Munsif on April 9, 1984. The petitioner filed an appeal before the District Judge which was transferred to the Court of Additional Civil Judge, Jodhpur. The Additional Civil Judge dismissed the appeal. It is further stated that it was observed by him that it would be open to the trial Court to get the matter of grant of patta enquired into by the Gram Panchayat as directed by the trial Court in its order dt. April 9, 1984. The petitioner filed Revision No. 514 of 1984 in this Court and it is stated that this revision was partly accepted on December 9, 1985 and the petitioner's possession was protected It is next mentioned that Ramuram, the present Sarpanch of the Gram Panchayat, Ria, filed a criminal complaint against the petitioner and the former Sarpanch Tulchharam on Jan. 5, 1985. It was alleged in the criminal complaint that the petitioner and the former Sarpaneh Tulchharam entered into a conspiracy and the abadi land, which had already been allotted, was allotted to the petitioner on April 30, 1977. It was stated that a forged document was prepared and it was complained that offences under Sections 420, 467 and 471, I.P.C. were committed by the petitioner and Tulchharam. This criminal complaint filed by Ramuram (present Sarpanch) was forwarded by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Jodhpur to the Station House Officer, Police Station, Piparcity for investigation under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. The petitioner has prayed that the criminal complaint be ordered to be dismissed and the investigation which is being done by the Station House Officer, Police Station, Piparcity in F.I.R. Case No. 2 of 1985 be quashed.
4. In Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 190 of 1987 (Ramnarain v. State of Rajasthan), it was contended by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that the alleged forged deed was already a subject-matter of trial in Revenue Suit No. 8 of 1981, pending in the Court of the Assistant Collector, Hanumangarh. According to him, the only competent authority to file a criminal complaint was the Court of Assistant Collector in which the revenue suit was pending. It was contended that the Judicial Magistrate No. 2, Hanumangarh wrongly took cognizance against the petitioner and others on a complaint filed by an incompetent person. According to him, the taking cognizance by the Judicial Magistrate was barred by the provisions contained in Section 195(1)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C. It was prayed that the order passed by the Judicial Magistrate, Sadulsahar on June 20, 1987 passed in Criminal Complaint No. 32 of 1987 be quashed along with the further proceedings.
5. The contention of the learned Counsel for the petitioner has no force in it. The reason is that the petitioner has himself stated in para 3 of his petition that only a copy of the alleged forged exchange deed had been filed by Roopsingh in the Revenue Court of the Assistant Collector, Hanumangarh. The certified copy of the complaint in Revenue Suit No. 89 of 1981 also mentions in its para No. 3 that copy of the exchange deed is being produced. In Sanmukhsingh v. King (1949) LR 77 Ind App 7 : AIR 1950 PC 31 : 1950-51 Cri LJ 651, the Privy Council, interpreting similar language of the corresponding provisions in the earlier Criminal Procedure Code of 1898, observed that by production of a copy of the allegedly forged document, it cannot be said that the document itself was given in evidence. The judgment of the Judicial Committee was followed by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in Budhu Ram v. State Of Rajasthan . . The latest decision of the Supreme Court on this point is in Shushil Kumar v. State of Haryana (1987) IV SVLR (Cri) 72 : 1988 Cri LJ 427. His Lordship L. M. Sharma, J. observed that the above view accords with the plain grammatical meaning of the words and is also supported by the practical common sense.
6. I, therefore, hold that since the original document of exchange alleged to have been forged was not produced before the Revenue Court in the present case, the bar created by the provisions of Section 195(1)(b)(ii) of the Cr. P.C. has no application. Accordingly Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 190 of 1987 is dismissed.
7. I may next deal with S. B. Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 5 of 1987 (Hetram V, State of Rajasthan and others. In this case also, the petitioners mentioned in para (b) at page 4 of their petition that the complainant Gangaram and Hiraram suppressed the fact while filing the criminal complaint that a revenue suit had already been filed by non-petitioner Gangaram in the Court of Sub-Divisional Officer, Nohar against Laduram petitioner and others wherein a photostat copy of the alleged will was produced by Gangaram himself. It is thus clear that in this case also only a photostat copy of the alleged forged will was produced in the the Revenue Court. The proceedings of this Court dated 11th Mar., 1987 would go to show that the counsel for the parties sought time to ascertain whether the original will in question had already been filed before the Revenue Court or not. On 26th Mar., 1987, the petitioners filed a certified copy of the plaint in Revenue Suit No. 266 of 1986 (Gangaram v. Omprakash) in order to show that in the said revenue suit, Gangaram non-petitioner No. 2 had alleged in para 7 of the plaint that the alleged will dt. July 7, 1985 was a forged document. It is important to note that paras 5 and 7 of that plaint also mention that only a copy of the alleged forged will had been produced in the Revenue Court and not the original will. For the original, it was mentioned that same will be got produced later on. Obviously Gangaram non-petitioner could not produce himself the original will which was said to be in favour of Omprakash son of Laduram petitioner No. 4. It was pointed out by the learned Counsel for the petitioners by an application that the original will dt. July 7, 1985 has been produced in original on 13th Mar., 1987 after the filing of the present petition and in that respect they have produced a certified copy of the order sheet of the Court of Assistant Collector, Bhadra. It may be stated that the document filed by the petitioner along with their application dt. July 2, 1987 goes to show that it was in some another revenue suit (different from that pleaded in para(b) of the petition at page 4) i.e. in a suit instituted by Omprakash as against Hariram and Gangaram that the original will has been produced as appears from the list of documents dated 1st Mar., 1987 produced by the petitioners. On the day the present petition was filed, the original will had not been produced in any revenue suit.
8. Be that all as it may, the other aspect of the matter is that the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nohar had only forwarded the Criminal complaint filed by Gangaram and Hatiram for investigation under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. to Police Station, Nohar. The Nohar Police Station forwarded the papers to Pally Police Station where, FIR Case No. 73 of 1986 has been registered on Dec. 13, 1986 for offence under Section 467 and 120B, I.P.C. and investigation has been alleged to be in progress. What the petitioner had prayed for in the petition is that further investigation on the complaint sent to the police under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. may be quashed because Section 195(l)(b), Cr. P.C. is a complete har to such proceedings and it would be in the interest justice to quash FIR No. 73 of 1986.
9. Section 195(l)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C. reads as under:
(ii) No court shall take cognizance of any offence described in Section 463 or punishable under Section 471, Section 475 or Section 476, of the said Code, when such offence is alleged to have been committed in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any Court.
The object and purpose of Section 195(1)(b)(ii) of the Code is that it is the Court before which an offence is alleged to have been committed in respect of a document produced in a proceeding before it which should file or cause to be filed a complaint and not a private party. This section is intended to obviate the possibility of two conflicting findings being recorded by two Courts one before which e document was produced in the course of proceedings and the other trying the complaint of forgery. It is important to note that the bar created by Section 195(1)(b)(ii) is against taking cognizance and not against an investigation ordered to be made by a Magistrate under Section 190 C.R.P.C. in exercise of his powers under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. In the instant case, the Station House Officer Police Station, Pally on receipt of the complaint from the Judicial Magistrate under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C., registered a case under Sections 167 and 120B. The offence under Section 467, I.P.C. is non-cognizable and consequently the offence under section 120b, i.p.c. was also a non-cognizable case and it could only be investigated by the police under orders of the Judicial Magistrate under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. and that the police was doing.
10. It is well-settled that when on a petition of complaint being filed before him, a Magistrate applies his mind for proceedings under the various provisions of Chap. XVI of the Cr. P.C., he must be held to have taken cognizance of the offence mentioned in the complaint. When, however, the Magistrate applies his mind not for such purpose but for purposes of ordering investigation under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. or issues a search warrant for the purpose of investigation, he cannot be said to have taken cognizance of any offence. This proposition of law is well-settled J by a series of decisions of their Lordships of the Supreme Court, namely, in the case of R. R. Chari v. State of U.P. , Gopaldas v. State of Assam AIR 1961 SC 986 : 1961 (2) Cri LJ 39, Jamunasingh v. Bhadaishan and Nirmaljeet Singh Hoon v. State of West Bengal . This view was also taken by his Lordship M. B. Sharma, J. of this Court in Shankarlal v. Chaturbhuj (1987) 1 Rajasthan LR 43, his Lordship Sharma, J. rightly observed:
It is also observed that what is prohibited by Section 195(1), Cr. P.C. is taking cognizance of an offence mentioned therein and not of investigation of the case. If after investigation, the police files a chargesheet and an objection is raised that cognizance cannot be taken because of Section 195(1), Cr.P.C, even then in a case where an original document said to be forged is involved, the court will have to decide that objection.
11. The learned Counsel for the petitioners referred to me to the decision of another learned single Judge Hon'ble Mr. Justice K. S. Lodha, J. of this Court in Dharamchand v. State of Rajasthan 1985 Rajasthan LR 282 wherein an argument had been advanced on behalf of non-petitioner No. 3 that even if Section 195(1)(b)(ii), Cr. P.C. was applicable, it is only the cognizance of the case would be barred, but the investigation could not be barred. The learned single Judge rejected this contention on the ground that when cognizance of the offence is barred except on the complaint of the Court, no useful purpose will be served by continuing the investigation and that the continuance of the investigation would amount to unnecessary harassment to the petitioners. His Lordship K. S. Lodha, J. quashed the investigation upon the criminal complaint sent to the police under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. In my judgment, the view propounded by Hon'ble K. S. Lodha, J. is erroneous in view of the decisions of their Lordships of the Supreme Court in four cases referred to above and I am of the considered opinion that the view taken by Hon'ble Justice M.B. Sharma in Shankarlal's case 1987-1 Rajasthan LR 43 is correct. The reason is obvious. It is quite possible that the police after investigation may come to a conclusion that offence or offences different from those mentioned in Section 195(l)(b)(ii) are prima facie made out and make a report accordingly or it may just give a final report. It would, therefore, be clearly wrong to quash the investigation. Consequently, S. B. Cr. Misc. Petition No. 5, of 1987 also fails and is hereby dismissed.
12. Coming to the 3rd and last Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 145 of 1986 (Mangilal v. State of Rajasthan), suffice it to state that in this case also the Judicial had forwarded the criminal complaint made by Ramuram present Sarpanch of Gram Panchayat, Ria to the Station House Officer; Police Station, Pipar City for investigation under Section 156(3), Cr. P.C. and therefore, my decision in S. B. Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 5 of 1987 (Hetram v. State of Rajasthan) (supra) would apply and consequently the investigation that is being done by the Station House Officer, Pipar City in FIR Case No. 2 of 1985 cannot be quashed. This petition also has no force and it is hereby dismissed.
Alert