Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Abdul Shahid v. Smt. Naraini And Others

Rajasthan High Court
Mar 2, 1988
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Bhargava, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a miscellaneous appeal filed by the owner of a truck against an award dated 24 July 1985 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Jaipur, which had awarded Rs. 1,20,000 to the claimants (legal representatives and dependants Nos. 1 to 6 of the deceased, Daula Ram). The accident occurred on 15 April 1982 when the truck (No. R.J.G 3277), driven by Abdul Shakoor (respondent No. 7), caused the death of Daula Ram. The claim petition sought Rs. 3,22,000; the insurer admitted liability only to Rs. 50,000. The Tribunal found the driver negligent and awarded Rs. 1,20,000, holding the insurer liable to the extent of Rs. 50,000 and the balance recoverable from the owner and driver. The owner appealed against the Tribunal's apportionment of liability on the basis that the vehicle was insured under a "Commercial Vehicles Comprehensive (India)" policy and, he argued, the insurer should be liable for the entire award. The appeal was admitted and later argued before a Full Bench constituted by the Chief Justice.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, where a motor vehicle is insured under a policy described as a "comprehensive" policy, the insurer is liable to pay the entire amount of an award of compensation by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (i.e., liability beyond the limits otherwise specified in the policy or under section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act), or whether liability is limited to specified sums (for example, Rs. 50,000 as asserted by the insurer).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Owner of the truck)

  • Contended that because the truck was insured under a comprehensive policy, the entire amount awarded by the Tribunal (Rs. 1,20,000) should be recoverable from and payable by the insurance company.
  • Placed reliance on a number of decisions (notably Smt. Chand Kanwar v. Mannaram and subsequent judgments) supporting the view that liability under a comprehensive policy extends to the limit of the award and can be unlimited.
  • Cited Supreme Court and High Court decisions (including New Asiatic Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pessumal Dhanamal Aswani; Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd.; Sheikhupura Transport Co. Ltd.) to support the contention that policy conditions cannot defeat the third party's statutory right of recovery where insurer has undertaken liability to third parties.

Insurance Company (Respondent No. 8)

  • Argued that the insurer's liability was limited to Rs. 50,000 as per the terms/schedule of the insurance policy and relied on decisions such as Kanan Bordoloi v. Balwant Rai Mukkar (Gauhati High Court) to that effect.
  • Characterised three types of policies—(i) "Act" policy (to comply with the statutory requirement), (ii) third party policy (with fixed limits of liability under section 95(2)(d)), and (iii) comprehensive policy (which insures loss/damage to vehicle and accessories as well as liability to third parties) — and contended that a comprehensive policy does not automatically mean unlimited liability to satisfy tribunal awards beyond stated limits.
  • Noted that an appeal by the insurer against one of the earlier favorable decisions (Chand Kanwar) was pending, and urged that the point was important and should be authoritatively decided (hence reference to a larger Bench).
  • However, the insurer did not produce documentary or oral evidence, literature, or authoritative material before the court to explain or distinguish a comprehensive policy from other policy types despite requests by the court.

Respondents / Claimants (Nos. 1 to 6)

  • Relied on a Division Bench decision of the same High Court in Sohan Lal v. Bal Swaroop Bal Bhatnagar which held that the word "comprehensive" does not necessarily mean the insurer agreed to indemnify to an unlimited extent; where the policy contained no clause for unlimited liability the insurer was only liable to Rs. 50,000.
  • The opinion records that respondents placed "great reliance" on that Division Bench decision in support of limiting insurer's liability.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Chand Kanwar v. Mannaram, AIR 1986 Raj 2; [1988] 63 Comp Cas 721 (Raj) Held by a learned single judge that liability of the insurer under a comprehensive policy extends to the limit of the award (i.e., insurer liable for the whole amount awarded). The court confirmed the interpretation adopted in Chand Kanwar and held it fully justified in the absence of contrary evidence; relied upon it to allow the present appeal.
Srisailam Devasthanam v. Bhavani Prameelamma, AIR 1983 AP 297 Decision of Andhra Pradesh High Court relied in Chand Kanwar (supportive on interpretation of comprehensive policy). Referenced as one of the authorities supporting Chand Kanwar; the court noted Chand Kanwar was based on this decision among others.
Rajeswari Transports (Firm), Theni v. M.G. Rajan, [1982] ACJ (Suppl.) 118; 1982 1 MLJ 248 Madras High Court decision cited in support of wider insurer liability under comprehensive policies. Noted as supporting authority relied upon in the single judge decision (Chand Kanwar) which this court confirmed.
Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. v. V. Ganapathi Ramalingam, AIR 1981 Mad 299; [1982] ACJ (Suppl.) 106 Madras High Court decision cited with similar significance to Rajeswari Transports. Mentioned among authorities underlying the single judge view which the court found persuasive.
Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd. v. Gujarat Steel Tubes Mazdoor Sabha, (1980) 2 SCC 593 : AIR 1980 SC 1896 Observation by Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer favouring beneficial interpretation for weaker parties ("Recall the face of the poorest..."). The court invoked these observations to support a benevolent/beneficial interpretation in favour of third-party claimants when interpreting insurance policy terms in the absence of contrary evidence.
New Asiatic Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pessumal Dhanamal Aswani, AIR 1964 SC 1736; 1964 34 Comp Cas 693 (SC) Supreme Court held that once an insurer undertakes liability to third parties, third party rights under the Act are not affected by conditions in the policy; insurer bound to satisfy award under comprehensive policy unless it proves breach. The court relied on this Supreme Court authority to support the proposition that terms in the policy cannot be allowed to defeat third-party rights and to justify indemnification by insurer where no breach is proved.
Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, (1987) 2 SCC 654 : AIR 1987 SC 1184 Supreme Court authority invoked by appellant (specific principle not elaborated in the opinion beyond citation). Cited by the appellant; the court recorded the citation among materials considered but did not extract a distinct discussion from it in the body of its judgment.
Sheikhupura Transport Co. Ltd. v. Northern India Transport Insurance Co., (1971) 1 SCC 785 : AIR 1971 SC 1624 Supreme Court authority cited in support of insurer liability to third parties under policy obligations. Referenced as supporting authority; the court noted its support for the view that insurer's obligations to third parties are not easily curtailed by policy conditions.
Kanan Bordoloi v. Balwant Rai Mukkar, [1984] ACJ 469 (Gauhati) Gauhati High Court held insurer liable only to Rs. 50,000 (i.e., limited liability asserted for insurer). Relied upon by the insurer; the court expressly stated it was not convinced by this view and disagreed with its reasoning in the present context.
Sohan Lal v. Bal Swaroop Bal Bhatnagar, [1987] ACJ 113 (Division Bench) Division Bench held that "comprehensive" does not necessarily mean unlimited liability; absent clause for unlimited liability insurer liable only to Rs. 50,000. The court considered this decision but treated its observations as obiter dicta on this specific point and declined to follow it in preference to the single judge view confirmed here.
Kota Sand Co. v. Santosh Talwar, [1985] ACJ 98 Decision of a single judge; in that case the insurance policy was not produced. The court found this case not relevant to the specific question because there was no discussion of the point here involved.
Sampat Lal v. Geeta Devi, [1984] RLR 1052 Case cited but noted not to involve a comprehensive policy. The court observed it had no relevancy to the present question and did not rely on it.
Vimla Srivastava v. Rajnidevi Sharma, [1986] ACJ 922; [1988] 64 Comp Cas 613 (Raj) [Full Bench] Earlier Full Bench decision of the same court (no discussion on comprehensive-policy point noted). The court recorded that this Full Bench decision did not address the point in issue and therefore was of no assistance.
Smt. Darshani Devi v. Shri Sheo Ram, [1989] 65 Comp Cas 353 Single judge decision referring to Chand Kanwar and holding insurer liability unlimited under a comprehensive policy (noting Division Bench objections were obiter). The court relied on the fact that Chand Kanwar had not been overruled and that observations against it were obiter; Darshani Devi was cited as supportive of Chand Kanwar's position.
Bomanji Rustomji Ginwala v. Ibrahim Vali Master, [1982] ACJ 380 (Gujarat) Gujarat High Court observed insurer can cover a wider risk by contract beyond statutory limit depending on the terms of the policy. Cited to show that policy terms can enlarge insurer's liability; the court noted it depends on facts and policy terms but found it supportive of the broader interpretation when policy language permits.
Narcinva V. Kamat v. Alfredo Antonio Doe Martino, [1985] 58 Comp Cas 383; [1985] ACJ 397 (Supreme Court) Supreme Court observed that insurer must prove breach of the policy terms before denying liability under a comprehensive policy; otherwise liability remains intact. Cited as authority for the proposition that, in absence of proved breach, insurer's contractual liability remains; the court noted this decision but found it did not discuss the exact question before them.
British India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Minor Khagesh Devendra Prasad Jani, [1977] ACJ 416 (Gujarat) Division Bench placed whole liability of the award on the insurance company. The court indicated that, although this decision fastened whole liability on insurer, it did not contain discussion on the particular point and thus was not directly helpful.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Mahadev, [1986] ACJ 362 (Calcutta) Held that where policy liability is not limited to statutory minima, insurer's liability is governed by the policy terms; comprehensive policy may make liability more extensive. The court quoted this passage (including reference to section 95) and used it to support the view that a comprehensive policy can provide wider coverage governed by its terms.
Mahinder Singh v. Manju Sawhney, [1986] ACJ 446 (Delhi) Case where policy was not proved in accordance with law; court held insurer liability unlimited. Noted as not throwing direct light on the present question because of factual differences (policy proof issue).
New India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. M.P.S.R.T. Corporation, [1986] ACJ 1144; [1988] 64 Comp Cas 309 (Madhya Pradesh) Madhya Pradesh High Court held insurer liable to Rs. 2,000 in property damage cases as per section 95(2)(d) and terms of policy; owner liable for balance. The court observed this case did not discuss the question before it and so was not directly relied upon.
M.K. Kunhimohammed v. P.A. Ahmedkutty, [1987] ACJ 872; [1988] 64 Comp Cas 7 (Supreme Court) Supreme Court made suggestions to Central Government on Motor Vehicles Bill provisions (procedural/legislative suggestions rather than point on comprehensive policy). Noted as unrelated to the specific question and not relied upon for the decision in this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a textual, contextual and purposive analysis of the insurance policy and the statutory scheme (Chapter VIII of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939) as recorded in the opinion. The analysis proceeded in the following steps, strictly as they appear in the opinion:

  1. Fact-finding confirmation: The Tribunal had found death caused by negligent driving and had awarded Rs. 1,20,000. The Tribunal apportioned liability by holding insurer liable only to Rs. 50,000 (relying on the schedule of limits in the policy) and the balance recoverable from owner and driver. The owner appealed this apportionment.
  2. Examination of the policy text: The heading of the policy read "Commercial Vehicles Comprehensive (India)". The printed terms were divided into two sections: (i) Loss or damage (indemnity for loss/damage to vehicle and accessories) and (ii) Liability to third parties (subject to limits of liability, indemnify the insured against sums the insured becomes legally liable to pay for death, bodily injury or property damage arising out of use of the motor vehicle).
  3. Schedule of Limits: The schedule contained language under "Limits of Liability" stating (a) for section II-1(i): "Such amount as is necessary to meet the requirements of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939" and (b) for section II-1(ii): a limit of Rs. 50,000 "in respect of any one claim or series of claims arising out of one event". The court read these provisions together in interpreting the policy.
  4. Statutory context and object: The court reviewed Chapter VIII of the Act (sections 94 and 95), emphasizing the legislative purpose: to ensure that third parties injured by motor vehicles can recover damages irrespective of the owner/driver's financial status. The policy contemplated by section 94 must insure the particular vehicle and specify persons or classes insured and the extent of liability as per section 95.
  5. Absence of evidence from insurer: The court explicitly noted the insurer failed to produce any documentary material, literature, instructions or oral evidence to explain the distinction or impact of a "comprehensive" policy compared to an "Act" policy or a third-party policy. The court requested such material but none was provided, leaving the policy text and statutory scheme as the primary interpretive materials.
  6. Meaning of "comprehensive": In the absence of evidence, the court consulted dictionary and secondary source meanings (Random House Dictionary and Corpus Juris Secundum) which portray "comprehensive" as broad, extensive, inclusive and covering a wide scope. The court used these meanings to inform policy interpretation.
  7. Interpretive choice in favour of statutory object: The court stated that even if multiple interpretations were possible, it should prefer an interpretation that better advances the objects of the statutory provisions (i.e., ensuring recoverability for third parties). The court opted for an interpretation that gives effect to the legislative intent behind compulsory third-party insurance provisions.
  8. Precedents and comparative authority: The court reviewed and contrasted conflicting authorities. It found persuasive the reasoning of the single judge in Chand Kanwar (and supporting authorities such as New Asiatic Insurance and other High Court decisions), relied on beneficial interpretive guidance from Justice Krishna Iyer, and disapproved the Gauhati High Court decision in Kanan Bordoloi and similar views. It considered the Division Bench decision in Sohan Lal but treated its contrary observations as obiter and not binding on the specific issue.
  9. Conclusion from text and context: Reading the policy wording (including the schedule phrase "such amount as is necessary to meet the requirements of the Motor Vehicles Act") together with the statutory purpose and the ordinary meaning of "comprehensive," the court concluded the insurer's liability under the comprehensive policy should be interpreted so as to cover the full award in this case, particularly in the absence of any evidence to the contrary from the insurer.
  10. Reservation for future evidence: The court expressly left open the possibility that if in some future case an insurance company adduces tangible documentary or oral evidence demonstrating a different understanding or impact of a comprehensive policy (distinguishing it from an Act policy or a third party policy), the courts may decide differently on that basis.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court allowed the appeal and held that the insurance company is liable to pay to the claimants the whole amount of the award passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (i.e., the insurer must satisfy the award of Rs. 1,20,000). The opinion also records the direction "Costs easy."

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The insurer is required to indemnify the claimants for the entire Tribunal award in this case rather than being limited to Rs. 50,000 as asserted in the policy schedule.
  • Interpretive guidance: The court confirmed and followed the interpretation adopted in the single judge decision of Chand Kanwar that a comprehensive policy can, in appropriate circumstances and on its terms, require the insurer to satisfy the full award, particularly where the policy language and statutory purpose support such a reading and where the insurer adduces no contrary evidence.
  • No blanket rule closed: The court emphasized that its decision rests on the policy text, statutory purpose, dictionary meanings and the absence of contrary evidence; it acknowledged that if insurers produce tangible evidence in future cases indicating a different commercial understanding or contract terms distinguishing comprehensive policies from Act or third-party policies, courts may reach different conclusions in those cases.
  • Precedential position: The court expressly disagreed with certain contrary High Court decisions (e.g., Kanan Bordoloi) and regarded some Division Bench comments (Sohan Lal) as obiter on this point; it thereby gave authoritative weight to the view that, in the circumstances like those before it, a comprehensive policy can require the insurer to pay the full award.

Note: This summary is prepared exclusively from the content of the provided opinion. No information has been added or inferred beyond what is expressly contained in that text.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Bhargava, J.:— This is a miscellaneous appeal by the owner of a truck, against the award dated July 24, 1985, passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Jaipur, amounting to Rs. 1,20,000. The appeal came up for admission on October 18, 1985. Shri Rajendra Soni appeared on behalf of respondents Nos. 1 to 6 and notices were issued to respondents Nos. 7 and 8 as to why the appeal should not be admitted. It was admitted on October 29, 1985, and notices were issued to respondent No. 8. When the appeal came up for hearing, one of the points raised in this appeal was that since the goods vehicle (truck) was insured under a comprehensive policy, the whole amount awarded as damages by the Tribunal should be recoverable from and payable by the insurance company, and reliance was placed on Smt, Chand Kanwar v. Mannaram, AIR 1986 Raj 2; [1988] 63 Comp Cas 721 (Raj). Learned counsel for the insurance company submitted that he had already filed an appeal against the said judgment which is still pending for service but since the point involved was very important and it was likely to arise in other cases, the case was referred to a larger Bench for an authoritative pronouncement. Thereafter, the Hon'ble Chief Justice constituted the Full Bench.

2. Truck No. R.J.G 3277, which was being driven by Abdul Shakoor, respondent No. 7, met with an accident on April 15, 1982, as a result whereof Daula Ram died. The legal representatives and dependants Nos. 1 to 6 of Daularam filed a claim petition before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Jaipur, claiming an amount of Rs. 3,22,000. The insurance company in reply submitted that it was responsible only to the tune of Rs. 50,000. The owner and the driver of the truck also contested the claim. The Tribunal, after recording evidence, came to the conclusion that Daularam died on account of rash and negligent driving by the driver, Abdul Shakoor, respondent No. 7, and that the claimants were entitled to a compensation of Rs. 1,20,000 in all. The Tribunal further held that the insurance company, respondent No. 8, is responsible only to the extent of Rs. 50,000 and interest thereon, and the remaining amount of claim would be recoverable from the owner of the truck and the driver. It is against this award that the present appeal has been filed by the owner of the truck. Learned counsel for the appellant has placed reliance on a decision of this court in Smt. Chand Kanwar v. Mannar am, AIR 1986 Raj 2; [1988] 63 Comp Cas 721 (Raj) wherein the learned single judge, relying on a decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Srisailam Devasthanam v. Bhavani Prameelamma, AIR 1983 AP 297; [1983] ACJ 580; [1985] 58 Comp Cas 816 (AP) and also two judgments of the Madras High Court in Rajeswari Transports (Firm), Theni v. M.G Rajan, [1982] ACJ (Suppl.) 118; [1982] 1 MLJ 248, and Oriental Fire & General Insurance Co. v. V. Ganapathi Ramalingam, AIR 1981 Mad 299; [1982] ACJ (Suppl.) 106, and keeping in mind the observations of Justice V.R Krishna Iyer in Gujarat Steel Tubes v. Gujarat Steel Tubes Mazdoor Sabha, (1980) 2 SCC 593 : AIR 1980 SC 1896, held that the liability of the insurance company would extend to the limit of the award given by the Tribunal and since the vehicle was insured comprehensively, the whole amount awarded as compensation is recoverable from and payable by the insurance company.

3. Learned counsel for the appellant also placed reliance on New Asiatic Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pessumal Dhanamal Aswani, AIR 1964 SC 1736; [1964] 34 Comp Cas 693 (SC), Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kokilaben Chandravadan, (1987) 2 SCC 654 : AIR 1987 SC 1184; [1987] 62 Comp Cas 138 (SC) and Sheikhupura Transport Co. Ltd. v. Northern India Transport Insurance Co.† , (1971) 1 SCC 785 : AIR 1971 SC 1624.

4. On the other hand, learned counsel for the insurance company has placed reliance on Kanan Bordoloi v. Balwant Rai Mukkar, [1984] ACJ 469 (Gauhati) wherein the Gauhati High Court has held that the insurer is liable to pay only a limited amount of Rs. 50,000 and no more.

5. Great reliance has been placed by the respondent on a Division Bench judgment of this court in Sohan Lal v. Bal Swaroop Bal Bhatnagar, [1987] ACJ 113, wherein their Lordships have held that merely because the insurance policy is stated to be a comprehensive policy, it cannot be said that the insurance company has agreed to indemnify the owner to an unlimited extent because this term is used only in distinction with third party risk, and, in that case, since there was no clause under the insurance policy for the unlimited liability of the insurer, the insurance company was not liable to pay the whole amount of the award but only to the extent of Rs. 50,000.

6. Our attention was also drawn by learned counsel for the respondent to another decision of this court by a single judge in Kota Sand Co. v. Santosh Talwar, [1985] ACJ 98 as also another decision of this court in Sampat Lal v. Geeta Devi, [1984] RLR 1052, but none of these two cases has any relevancy because there is no discussion on the point which is involved in the case at hand because in Santosh Talwar's case, [1985] ACJ 98, the insurance policy was not produced and Sampat Lal's case, [1984] RLR 1052 was not a case of a comprehensive policy.

7. Our attention was also drawn to an earlier Full Bench decision of this court in Vimla Srivastava v. Rajnidevi Sharma, [1986] ACJ 922; [1988] 64 Comp Cas 613 (Raj) [FB] but in that case also, we do not find any discussion about the point involved in this case and, therefore, it is also of no assistance to us.

8. Reliance was also placed by the appellant on a recent decision of this court in Smt. Darshani Devi v. Shri Sheo Ram, [1989] 65 Comp Cas 353 wherein the learned single judge, referring to his earlier judgment in Smt. Chand Kanwar, AIR 1986 Raj 2; [1988] 63 Comp Cas 721 (Raj) held that the liability of the insurance company is unlimited. In that case, learned counsel for the insurance company submitted that the Division Bench of this court in Sohan Lal's case, [1987] ACJ 113 held that the interpretation of the comprehensive policy by the single judge in Chand Kanwar's case, AIR 1986 Raj 2; [1988] 63 Comp Cas 721 (Raj) is not correct. The Hon'ble Justice G.M Lodha, after discussing both these cases, observed that Chand Kanwar's case, AIR 1986 Raj 2; [1988] 63 Comp Cas 721 (Raj) has not been overruled, and it had not been declared no longer good law by the Division Bench and that the observations made by the Division Bench were in the nature of obiter dicta only. It was further mentioned that it will be for a larger Bench in a proper case to consider whether the observations made in this respect are correct or not, so that the clouds which have gathered on the horizon are cleared and no confusion is left. We shall be adverting towards this aspect a little later.

9. Our attention was also drawn to a decision of the Gujarat High Court in Bomanji Rustomji Ginwala v. Ibrahim Vali Master, [1982] ACJ 380 where, after considering an earlier decision of the Gujarat High Court, it was observed that the insurance company can cover a wider risk by contract other than the statutory limit of Rs. 2,000 and it will depend on the facts of each case and on the basis of the terms of the insurance policy.

10. Our attention has also been drawn to Narcinva V. Kamat v. Alfredo Antonio Doe Martino, [1985] 58 Comp Cas 383; [1985] ACJ 397, wherein the Supreme Court has observed that if the insurance company fails to prove that there was a breach of the terms of contract of insurance as evidenced by the policy of insurance, its liability under the contract of insurance remains intact and unhampered and it was bound to satisfy the award under the comprehensive policy of insurance. In this case also, there is no discussion on the question involved in the present case.

11. Our attention was also drawn to a Division Bench decision of the Gujarat High Court in British India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Minor Khagesh Devendra Prasad Jani, [1977] ACJ 416 wherein the whole liability of the award was fastened on the insurance company. In this case also, there is no discussion about the point in issue before us.

12. Reliance was also placed on a Division Bench decision of the Calcutta High Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Mahadev, [1986] ACJ 362 wherein their Lordships have observed as under (at p. 365):

“When under an insurance policy, the liability of the insurer was not limited to the requirements of section 95(1) of the said Act, then the insurer's extent of liability would be governed by the terms of the particular policy. Only in the absence of a contract to the contrary, the measure of the liability of the insurer would be ascertained with reference to section 95(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act. An insurance company may, however, issue a comprehensive policy and agree to cover all risks, and in that event, its liability would be more extensive than contemplated by section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The extent of the insurer's liability in each case would be determined with reference to the terms of the particular policy.”

13. Our attention was also drawn to a decision of the Delhi High Court in Mahinder Singh v. Manju Sawhney, [1986] ACJ 446 wherein it has been held that since the insurance policy was not proved in accordance with law, the liability of the insurance company was unlimited. This Case also does not throw any light on the question involved before us.

14. Reliance was also placed by learned counsel for the insurance company on a decision of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in New India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. M.P.S.R.T Corporation, [1986] ACJ 1144; [1988] 64 Comp Cas 309; wherein it has been observed that as regards the liability of the insurer in case of damage to property, the insurer was held liable to the extent of Rs. 2,000 only as per the provisions of section 95(2)(d) and terms of policy, i.e, such amount as is necessary to meet the requirements of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, and the owner was held liable to pay the balance. In this case also, we do not find any discussion regarding the question before us.

15. Our attention was also drawn to the recent decision of the Supreme Court in M.K Kunhimohammed v. P.A Ahmedkutty, [1987] ACJ 872; [1988] 64 Comp Cas 7 wherein their lordships of the Supreme Court have proposed some suggestions to the Central Government in respect of certain provisions of the Motor Vehicles Bill then pending before Parliament but that also does not relate to the question before us.

16. Learned counsel for the insurance company has submitted that there are three types of policies—(i) Act policy, i.e, a policy only to comply with the provisions of section 94 of the Act of 1939 which provides that no person shall use a motor vehicle in a public place unless there is in force in relation to the use of the vehicle, a policy of insurance, complying with the requirements of the Motor Vehicles Act; the second one is the third party policy as per section 95(2)(d) of the Motor Vehicles Act and the third one is the comprehensive policy. The Act policy fulfils only the requirement of law, i.e, the obligation under section 94 of the Act whereas, in the third party policy, the limits of the liability are fixed and in case of a comprehensive policy, the insurance company is liable to indemnify the insured against loss or damage of the motor vehicle and its accessories. Even if the vehicle is insured comprehensive, it does not mean that the insurance company is liable to indemnify the insured against the total award beyond the limits of the liability mentioned in the insurance policy or in terms of section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act. We requested learned counsel for the insurance company to produce before us some evidence, literature, instructions or books in support of his contention as to the meaning of the three types of policies, especially the comprehensive policy, but no such documentary evidence like some journal, books, instructions, literature has been produced before us by learned counsel for the insurance company. Therefore, it is very difficult to accept his contention. The insurance company must be having some literature to canvass to its clients as to why they should go in for a comprehensive policy. What is the difference between a comprehensive policy and a policy under the Act or for covering third party risk? No oral evidence has been led on this point by either party as this was never in issue at the stage of trial before the Tribunal as is obvious by going through the points which have been framed by the Tribunal for the purpose of a decision in the judgment, nor is there any discussion on this point in the award of the Tribunal. It is barely mentioned that since, as per the terms of the insurance policy, the limited liability was to the tune of Rs. 50,000, the insurance company is liable to pay only a sum of Rs. 50,000. Even in the reply to the claim petition filed on behalf of the insurance Company, this aspect of the matter, involving the impact of the policy being comprehensive, has not been asserted. No oral evidence was led by the insurance company nor have any documents been produced and, therefore, we are left only with the insurance policy as such. The heading of the policy reads as under:

“Commercial Vehicles Comprehensive (India)”.

17. The printed terms of the policy are divided into two sections—(i) Loss or damage and the other liability to third parties. With regard to section 1 it has been stated that the company will indemnify the insured against loss or damage to the motor vehicle and/or its accessories whilst thereon;

(a) by accidental extraordinary……

whereas with regard to section 2, liability to third parties, it has been stated that “subject to the limits of liability, the company will indemnify the insured against all sums including the claims, costs and expenses which the insured shall become legally entitled to pay in respect of—

(i) death or bodily injury to any person caused by or arising out of the use of the motor vehicle;

(ii) damage to property caused by the use of the motor vehicle.

18. Then, it also contains some provisos which are not very relevant for discussion in the present case. It also provides some general exceptions which are also not relevant for the purpose of deciding the issue before us.

19. When we look at the Schedule attached to the policy which gives the names of the insured, vehicle No., particulars of the vehicle, etc., there is a mention of limits of liability. On the back portion of the Schedule, there are some conditions printed but they also do not help us in deciding the point in issue before us.

20. In this view of the matter, we do not get any assistance either by going through the insurance policy or by the evidence on record. The word “comprehensive” has not been defined in the Motor Vehicles Act, The dictionary meaning of the word “comprehensive” is as under:

As given in The Random House Dictionary of the English Language, College Edition, 1977 Reprint, at page 276

“Comprehensive’—……3. Insurance covering or providing broad protection against loss.”

21. The meaning of the word “Comprehensive” as given in Corpus Juris Secundum 15A, part page 166, is as under:

“Comprehensive’—The word ‘Comprehensive is defined as meaning including much; comprising many things; having a wide scope, inclusive, having the power to comprehend many things; of wide mental grasp, intensive. The term is not superlative in significance.

‘Comprehensive’ has been held to be synonymous with ‘compendious’, ‘extensive ‘, ‘full ‘large and ‘wide’ and has been held to be the antonym of ‘circumscribed’,’ limited’, ‘narrow’ and restricted.”

22. In the absence of any evidence, oral or documentary, by either party, we have to interpret the meaning of the two clauses mentioned in the insurance policy. The insurance policy claims to be a commercial vehicle comprehensive policy. In the policy, section II of its terms has the heading Liability to third parties, which reads as under:

“1. Subject to the limits of liability, the company will indemnify the insured against all sums including claimant's costs and expenses which the insured shall become legally liable to pay in respect of

(i) death of, or bodily injury to, any person caused by or arising out of the use (including the loading and/or unloading) of the motor vehicle.

(ii) damage to property caused by the use (including the loading and/or unloading) of the motor vehicle……”

23. It appears that this provision in the policy is based on section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, which runs as under:

“95. Requirements of policies and limits of liability.—In order to comply with the requirements of this Chapter, a policy of insurance may be a policy which— …….

(b) insures the person or classes of persons specified in the policy to the extent specified in sub-section (2)—

(i) against any liability which may be incurred by him in, respect of the death of, or bodily iniury to, any person or damage to any ‘property of a third party caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle in a public place;

(ii) against the death of, or bodily injury to, any passenger of a public service vehicle caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle in a public place;……”

24. The Schedule attached to the policy, under the heading Limits of Liability, provides as under:

“Limit of the amount of the company's liability under section II-1(i) in respect of any one accident: Such amount as is necessay to meet the requirements of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939.

Limit of the amount of the company's liability under section II-1(ii) in respect of any one claim or series of claims arising out of one event: Rs. 50,000.”

25. In this limit of liability, section II-1(i) and (ii) relate to the conditions of the insurance quoted above. After reading all these together and taking their overall meaning and the fact that this is a comprehensive policy, we have to interpret the meaning of the words “such amount as is necessary to meet the requirements of the Motor Vehicles Act”. Though there is no evidence as to what is the premium payable for an ordinary policy like an Act policy or a third party policy and for a comprehensive policy, as no literature in this regard has been produced in spite of our requests to learned counsel for the insurance company, we take it that the premium for a comprehensive policy is higher than that for the other two policies. Even if there are two possible interpretations of this phrase, we have to opt and select the one which goes a step further to fulfil the objects of these provisions which would have been in the mind of the Legislature.

26. Chapter VIII of the Motor Vehicles Act deals with “Insurance of Motor Vehicles against third party risks”, that is to say, it is a provision to ensure that third parties, who suffer on account of the user of the motor vehicles, would be able to get damages for injuries suffered and that the recoverability of the damages will not be dependent on the financial condition of the driver or the owner of the vehicle. Section 94 of the Act prohibits, as a matter of necessity, for insurance against third party risk, the use of a motor vehicle by any person unless there exists a policy of insurance in relation to the use of the vehicle by that particular person, complying with the requirements of Chapter VIII. The policy must, therefore, provide insurance against any liability to third party incurred by that person when using that vehicle. The policy should, therefore, be with respect to that particular vehicle. It may, however, mention the person specifically or generally by specifying the class to which that person may belong, as it may not be possible to name specifically all the persons who may have to use the vehicle with the permission of the person owning the vehicle and effecting the policy. The policy of insurance contemplated by section 94, therefore, must be a policy by which a particular vehicle is insured.

27. Section 95 of the Act lays down the requirements which are to be complied with by the policy of insurance issued in relation to the use of a particular vehicle. They are: (1) the policy must specify the person or classes of persons who are insured with respect to their liability to third parties; (2) the policy must specify the extent of liability which must extend to the extent specified in sub-section (2); and (3) the liability which may be incurred by the specified person or classes of persons in respect of death or bodily enjury to any person caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle insured in a public place.

28. Sub-section (4) of section 95 requires the issue of a certificate of insurance, in the prescribed form, to the person who effects the policy. The form of the certificate prescribed by the Motor Vehicles Third Party Insurance Rules, 1946, requires the specification of persons or classes of persons entitled to drive. The authorised insurer is also to certify in the certificate that the policy to which the certificate relates, as well as the certificate of insurance, are issued in accordance with the provisions of Chapter VIII of the Act of 1939.

29. Sub-section (5) of section 95 makes the insurer liable to indemnify the person or classes of persons specified in the policy in respect of any liability which the policy purports to cover in the case of that person or those classes of persons. If the policy covers the insured for his liability to third parties, the insurer is bound to indemnify the person or classes of persons specified in the policy.

30. The Supreme Court in New Asiatic Insurance Co., AIR 1964 SC 1736; [1964] 34 Comp Cas 693, has observed that “once the company had undertaken liability to third parties incurred by the person specified in the policy, the third party's right to recover any amount under or by virtue of the provisions of the Act, is not affected by any condition in the policy. Considering this aspect of the terms of the policy, it is reasonable to conclude that proviso (a) of para. 3 of section II (in that case) is a mere condition affecting the rights of the insured who effected the policy and the person to whom the cover of the policy was extended by the company and does not come in the way of third parties’ claims against the company.

31. In this era of social justice, we cannot ignore the observations of Justice Krishna Iyer (as he then was) in a number of decisions, appealing to the judges to have an edge of beneficial interpretation for the havenots and innocent persons which are based on the clarion call of the father of the nation, Mahatma Gandhi, quoted by Justice Krishna Iyer in Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd. v. Gujarat Steel Tubes Mazdoor Sangh, (1980) 2 SCC 593 : AIR 1980 SC 1896, 1932: “whenever you are in doubt…apply the following test. Recall the face of the poorest and weakest man whom you may have seen, and ask yourself, if the step you contemplate is going to be of any use to him.”

32. Keeping these observations in mind, the object and purpose of getting the motor vehicle insured and looking to the classes mentioned in the insurance policy based on section 95 of the Act, and specially when there is no evidence or any document or literature to throw any light as to the impact of a comprehensive policy, and in the absence of any evidence, keeping in mind the dictionary meaning of the word “comprehensive” and, as stated in the Corpus Juris Secundum Part 15 A, page 166, we are of the view that the interpretation taken by the learned single judge (Justice G.M Lodha, as he then was), seems to be fully justified and we hereby confirm the same. We need not repeat his observations which are based on Srisailam Devasthanam, AIR 1983 AP 297; [1983] ACJ 580; [1985] 58 Comp Cas 816 (AP) and Rajeshwari Transport's case, [1982] ACJ (Suppl.) 118; [1982] 1 MLJ 248, which get support from the observations of the Supreme Court in New Asiatic Insurance Co., AIR 1964 SC 1736; [1964] 34 Comp Cas 693 (SC) and Sheikhupura Transport Co., (1971) 1 SCC 785 : AIR 1971 SC 1624. We respectfully disagree with the observations of the Gauhati High Court in Kanan Bordoloi, [1984] ALJ 469, and other cases in which the view similar to that in Kanan Bordoloi, [1984] ACJ 469 (Gauhati) has been taken. We are not convinced by the views expressed by the Division Bench in Sohan Lal's case, [1987] ACJ 113, interpreting the decision in Chand Kanwar, AIR 1986 Raj 2; [1988] 63 Comp Cas 721, more so because they are in the nature of obiter dicta only, as in that case, this point was never agitated at any earlier stage. It was for the first time in the High Court only because of the decision in Chand Kanwar's case, AIR 1986 Raj 2; [1988] 63 Comp Cas 721, that this argument had been put forth.

33. As and when, in some other case, the insurance company adduces or produces come tangible evidence, oral or documentary, stating the impact of a comprehensive policy or distinguishing it from an Act policy or third party policy, it will be open for the courts to decide that case in the light of evidence adduced or produced by the parties.

34. We are really very sorry to observe that in spite of our repeated requests to learned counsel for the insurance company, no such material was placed before us and, therefore, we were left with interpreting the terms of the insurance policy as they existed, in the light of the decisions we have quoted above.

35. In the result, we allow this appeal and hold that the insurance company is liable to pay to the claimants, the whole amount of the award passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal. Costs easy.