Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Nav Ratan Mal Alias Babu v. State Of Rajasthan

Rajasthan High Court
Jul 22, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Court Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The accused-appellant Navaratan Mal alias Babu was convicted under Section 302, IPC for causing the death by burning of his wife Smt. Prem and sentenced to life imprisonment.

The prosecution case, in brief, is that Navaratan Mal lived at Municipal No. 697, Ghee-Walon-ka-Rasta, Jaipur, with his wife Smt. Prem (deceased), son Bhanwar Lal, father Ram Chandra and others. On March 3 (the opinion contains references to both 1973 and 1978), at about 2:30 p.m., the accused allegedly came home drunk, quarreled with his wife, sprinkled kerosene on her clothes, lit a match and set her on fire while she was in the kitchen. The accused did not attempt to extinguish the flames. Smt. Prem exited the house, took an auto-rickshaw with her son to SMS Hospital, Jaipur, and was admitted in the Emergency Ward. Medical Jurist Dr. D.S. Chauhan examined her injuries and recorded a statement (Ex. P 10) in which she purportedly stated that her husband had set her on fire. A compounder on duty, Purshotam Mehta, informed the police control room by telephone that the patient had said her husband had burnt her; a general diary entry was made at the Police Station, Ramganj (No. 156).

SI Ram Bahadur (PW 11) investigated, recorded the statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C., prepared site memos and submitted a charge-sheet. A charge under Section 302, IPC was framed; the accused pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. The prosecution examined 11 witnesses. The accused's defence was denial, an alibi that he was at his office of the Rajasthan State Electricity Board at the relevant time, and an alternative theory (first raised in defence evidence) that the deceased committed suicide after a quarrel with her father-in-law, Ram Chandra.

The Sessions Judge convicted the accused relying on three dying declarations which the Judge found to be true and consistent. This appeal challenges that conviction and sentence. During appellate proceedings, additional examinations were directed by the Division Bench (including recall and further examination of certain hospital staff and the Magistrate).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the dying declaration(s) made by Smt. Prem were truthful and could be relied upon to support a conviction for murder.
  2. Whether the dying declarations and other statements complied with Rule 6.22 of the Rajasthan Police Rules, 1965 and the requirements for recording such statements (including the interplay with Section 161 and Section 162 Cr.P.C.).
  3. Whether a conviction can be sustained solely on the basis of a dying declaration in the facts of this case (i.e., whether corroboration was necessary or available).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The dying declarations vary in material particulars and contain contradictions, undermining their reliability.
  • The dying declaration recorded by the Magistrate (Ex. P 9) was recorded in contravention of Rule 6.22 of the Rajasthan Police Rules, 1965, and therefore cannot be acted upon.
  • There was no strained relationship or motive between the accused and the deceased; the accused had fathered three children with the deceased and thus lacked motive to kill her.
  • The accused raised a defence of alibi and an alternate theory that the deceased committed suicide after a quarrel with her father-in-law (this defence was presented in defence evidence).

State's Arguments (Public Prosecutor)

  • The dying declarations are true and find corroboration in other evidence.
  • If a dying declaration is true, it alone is sufficient to convict the accused.
  • The statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., later used as a dying declaration, was properly admissible and the precautions under Rule 6.22 were not strictly necessary at the moment it was recorded because it was recorded under Section 161.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramawati Devi v. State of Bihar There is no requirement that a dying declaration must necessarily be made to a Magistrate; the evidentiary value depends on facts and circumstances; conviction may, in a proper case, be based solely on a dying declaration. The court relied on the principle to support the proposition that a truthful dying declaration can by itself sustain a conviction depending on the facts of the case.
Kusa and Ors. v. State of Orissa, AIR 1985 SC 559 Authority cited for the proposition that in appropriate cases a conviction can be based on a dying declaration (supporting the weight accorded to dying declarations). The court cited it as supporting authority for accepting a dying declaration as sufficient in the correct factual context.
Jaswant Singh v. State (Delhi Administration) Cited as further authority on the evidentiary force of dying declarations and the circumstances in which they may support conviction. The court referenced it to reinforce the legal position that a dying declaration may be sufficient for conviction depending on its truthfulness and circumstances.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed the central inquiry as whether the dying declarations made by Smt. Prem were truthful and were rightly acted upon by the Sessions Judge.

Assessment of defence case: The court found the defence story of suicide and the new claim of quarrel between the deceased and her father-in-law to be afterthoughts. The court noted these points in rejecting the defence:

  • The alleged suicide theory and quarrel with the father-in-law were not suggested to prosecution witnesses and emerged only for the first time in defence evidence.
  • The accused in his Section 313 statement did not present the quarrel-with-father-in-law theory earlier.
  • The court considered the behaviour of the injured woman — she voluntarily went to the hospital in an auto-rickshaw and was admitted — and found that conduct inconsistent with a person who intended to commit suicide.
  • On site inspection, no signs of suicide were found.

Evaluation of dying declarations and recording formalities:

  • The court identified three written dying declarations/statements: (a) Ex. P 10 — the injury report/endorsement where Smt. Prem told Dr. Chauhan that her husband caused the burns (this was in presence of the compounder Purushottam Mehta); (b) the statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. by SI Ram Bahadur (also acted upon as a dying declaration); and (c) Ex. P 9 — the dying declaration recorded by Magistrate Mani Shankar Vyas after a fitness certificate by Dr. S.S. Yadav.
  • Dr. Chauhan's account (Ex. P 10 portion C-D) was that he asked the history of injury and the deceased said her husband caused burns; his evidence on that point was not subjected to cross-examination and thus remained unchallenged. The compounder's testimony corroborated Ex. P 10 and his testimony was recorded before the Court.
  • The court analyzed Rule 6.22 of the Rajasthan Police Rules, 1965 and its sub-rules (including the requirement to record dying declarations by a Magistrate when possible, medical examination to ensure fitness, and procedures if a gazetted officer or independent witnesses are unavailable). The appellant argued that sub-rules (3) and (4) were not complied with when the SI recorded the Section 161 statement.
  • The court observed that the statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. was recorded when it was not yet necessary for the Investigating Officer to take the particular safeguards enumerated in Rule 6.22 (i.e., those precautions would have been required if the SHO had proceeded as a Magistrate to record a dying declaration). The court noted that Ram Bahadur (PW 11) was not cross-examined about the mental status of the deceased when he recorded the Section 161 statement, which was subsequently acted upon as a dying declaration.
  • With respect to the Magistrate's dying declaration (Ex. P 9), the court recorded that Magistrate Mani Shankar Vyas obtained a fitness certificate from Dr. S.S. Yadav before recording it. Dr. Yadav testified that he examined the patient and certified she was fit to give a statement; the Magistrate stated he recorded the narration (though not in questionnaire form) and explained a seal/endorsement issue. The court accepted that the Magistrate recorded the declaration after taking necessary precautions.
  • Overall, the court found the three dying declarations consistent with each other as to the essential fact that the accused caused the burns.

On the legal sufficiency of the dying declarations: The court reiterated the settled legal position that a truthful dying declaration, if found reliable, can alone sustain a conviction; corroboration is prudential but not mandatory where the court is satisfied of voluntariness and truth. It applied that principle to the present facts and found the declarations truthful and sufficient.

Conclusion of analysis: Given the consistency among the declarations, the corroboration by the compounder and doctor, the lack of credible support for the suicide theory, and compliance (in the Magistrate-recorded declaration) with necessary precautions, the court concluded that the Sessions Judge rightly relied on the dying declarations and that the defence explanations were fabricated or afterthoughts.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed and the conviction and sentence imposed by the Sessions Judge are upheld. The court found the dying declarations truthful and sufficient to support the conviction under Section 302, IPC.

Implications:

  • The immediate effect is that the accused's conviction for murder and his life sentence stand affirmed.
  • The court applied established principles that a truthful dying declaration may alone sustain a conviction; it did not purport to lay down any new legal principle or depart from existing precedents.
  • The opinion does not state or announce any broad new precedent; it applies settled law on dying declarations to the facts before it.

Show all summary ...

1. Accused-appellant Navaratan Mal alias Babu stands convicted under Section 302, IPC for having caused the death of his wife Smt. Prem by burning. He has been sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life.

2. The facts, in brief, are that the accused owns a house, bearing Municipal No. 697, situated in Ghee-Walon-ka-Rasta, Jaipur. He used to reside in it along with his wife Smt. Prem deceased, son Bhanwar Lal, and father Ram Chandra and other persons. There were some other persons in the house, viz. Smt. Yasoda (PW 1), Sukhkaram (PW 2), and Smt. Sushila (PW 5). According to the prosecution case, accused Navaratan Mal was in the habit of taking alcohol, used to quarrel with his wife Smt. Prem used to beat her off and on. On March 3, 1973, at about 2.30 p.m. the accused came from outside under the influence of alcohol and started quarreling with his wife Smt. Prem, deceased. The accused sprinkled kerosene on her clothes, lit a match stick and set fire to her. This was done when she was busy in kitchen. She was soon in flames. The accused did not make any attempt to extinguish the fire to save his wife. Smt. Prem some how or the other gathered strength, came out of the house, took an auto-rickshaw and went to the SMS Hospital, Jaipur with her son Bhanwarlal (DW 6). She was admitted in the Emergency Ward. Her injuries were examined by Medical Jurist Dr. D.S. Chauhan (PW 9) at about 5.10 p.m. The said Dr. Chauhan also recorded the dying declaration of Smt. Prem which is available on record as Ex.P 10, where in the deceased, Smt. Prem is said to have made at statement to the Doctor that it was her husband who had set fire to her. The Compounder on duty Shri Purshotam Mehta telephoned to the Incharge of the control room informed on telephone to the Police Station, Ramganj about the incident and also gave out that the woman has given out that her husband has sprinkled kerosene on her and set fire to her. A report was entered at No. 156 in the general diary of the Police Station, Ramganj.

3. Ram Bahadur SI Ramganj (PW 11) took over the investigation, reached the SMS Hospital, Jaipur and recorded the statement of Smt. Prem under Section 161, Cr.PC, where in also she stated that her husband, accused appellant, after sprinkling kerosene set fire to her. As her condition improved a bit on March 6, 1978, Ram Bahadur (PW 11) addressed a letter to the Judicial Magistrate, First Class, No. 7, Jaipur City, requesting him to record the dying declaration of Smt. Prem. Ex. P 8 is the letter of Ram Bahadur, which was presented before the learned Magistrate, Shri Mani Shankar Vyas (PW 8) on the March 5, 1978 at the residence. Mani Shankar Vyas went to the Hospital and there Dr. S.S. Yadav certified that Smt. Prem was in a fit state of mind to make dying declaration.

4. It may be stated at this stage that arguments in this case had been heard by a Division Bench of this Court and, it was thought proper on April 23, 1984, that compounder, Purshottam Mehta of the SMS Hospital and Dr. S.S. Yadav should be explained in the interest of justice. It was further ordered that Shri Mani Shankar Vyas and Dr. B.S. Chauhan should be recalled. In pursuance to the aforesaid letter of this Court, Shri Mani Shankar and Dr. B.S. Chauhan were called and were further examined. Dr. S.S. Yadav and Shri Purushottam Mehta Compounder were also examined by this Court.

5. Ram Bahadur (PW 11) went to the spot, prepared site-memo and other memos and, after investigation a charge-sheet filed against the accused appellant. A charge under Section 302, IPC was read over and explained, to which the accused pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.

6. On behalf of the prosecution as many as 11 witness were examined and thereafter the accused was examined under Section 313, Cr.PC and explained the circumstances coming in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses. The accused stands on a bare plea of denial. He has pleaded alibi and, according to him, at the time of the incident, i.e. at 2.30, p.m. on March 3, 1978 he was in the office of the Rajasthan State Electricity Board. The accused examined as many as seven witnesses and, a plea was set up in defence that on the day of the incident there was some quarrel in between the deceased, Smt. Prem and her father-in-law Ram Chandra (PW 4) and Smt. Prem committed suicide by sprinkling kerosene on her body and setting fire.

7. The learned Sessions Judge placing reliance on the dying declaration, which according to him, were three in number and, were true and consistent, convicted and sentenced the accused aforesaid.

8. We have heard the learned Advocate for the accused appellant and the learned Public Prosecutor for the State.

9. There were two stories, one of suicide and the other on the husband having caused the death of Smt. Prem and there were three dying declarations in the case. So far as the dying declarations are concerned, contention of the learned counsel for the accused-appellant is that they very in material particulars they are not consistent and there are contradictions in them. So far as the dying declaration (Ex. P 9) recorded by the Magistrate, Shri Mani Shankar Vyas, is concerned, the contention of the learned Advocate for the accused-appellant is that it was recorded in contravention of Rule 6.22 of the Rajasthan Police Rules, 1965 and, as such, it cannot be acted upon. It is also contended by him that the relations between the deceased, Smt. Prem and the accused-appellants were not strained and there was no motive for the accused to have committed the murder of his own wife who had given birth to as many as three children to him.

10. The learned Public Prosecutor has supported the judgment of the learned Sessions Judge. Her contention is that the dying declaration is true and finds corroboration from other evidence. She states that if a dying declaration is true, it alone is sufficient to convict the accused.

11. We have given our due consideration to the arguments advanced before us. In a case like the present one, where the death of a house wife took place inside the house, and the relatives remain present most of them do not come forward to depose against the accused, cases mostly depend on circumstantial evidence. The law of dying declaration is that if the victim survives for some time and is in a fit state of mind to make a declaration, such declaration should be recorded. In the instant case, there cannot be any dispute that Smt. Prem wife of the accused appellant died of the severe burns. As stated earlier, even the accused does not dispute that the death of Smt. Prem was homicidal and it is not his case that it was natural. As stated earlier, he has come out with a case that because of strained relations and because of the quarrel with Ram Chandra (PW 4), father-in-law of the deceased, Smt. Prem, committed suicide. We reject out-right the defence story in as much as it was not even suggested to any of the prosecution witnesses. For the first time, it was brought out in the statement of the defence witnesses. Even the accused appellant in his statement under Section 313, Cr. PC did not come out with this case that the relations between his father and Smt. Prem were not good. Thus, this story about the alleged quarrel in between the father-in-law of the deceased and Smt. Prem, deceased, is an after thought and, the learned Sessions Judge did not rightly place any reliance on it.

12. The sole question in this case, is whether the dying declaration made by Smt. Prem is truthful and has been rightly acted upon by the learned Sessions Judge. So far as the law of dying declaration is concerned, it is well-settled that if the dying declaration is truthful, it alone is sufficient to base conviction. The rule of prudence is that the court may, if possible, seek corroboration from other witnesses and if the Court is satisfied that the victim made a declaration voluntarily and that it was truthful, then there is no impediment to base conviction. In this connection, reference may be made to Ramawati Devi v. State Of Bihar. , where in it has been laid down that there is no requirement of law that dying declaration must necessarily be made to a Magistrate. What evidentiary value or weight has to be attached to such statement, must necessarily depend on the facts and circumstances of each particular case. In a proper case, it may be permissible to convict a person only on the basis of a dying declaration in the light of the facts and circumstances of the case. Reference may be made to Kusa and Ors. v. State of 0rissa AIR 1985 SC 559 and Jaswant Singh v. State (Delhi Administration .

13. So far as the relations in between the deceased Smt. Prem and her husband, accused appellant, are concerned there is no evidence on record to show that they were strained. As per the dying declaration the occurrence had taken place in the house. The accused appellant sprinkled kerosene, lit a match stick and set fire to her clothes. The occurrence, as stated earlier, took place at 2.30 p.m. on March 3, 1978 and she of her own accord went to the hospital in an auto-rickshaw. If, as stated on behalf of the defence, it is a case of suicide, woman who wanted to commit suicide would be the last person to go of her own accord in an auto-rickshaw to the hospital, get admitted there in order that every attempt may be made by the Doctor to save her life. The conduct of Smt. Prem is inconsistent with the theory of the alleged suicide put up by the defence.

14. We, now take up the evidence of the compounder Shri Purushottam Mehta who was examined as a witness by this Court. Shri Mehta has stated that he was working as male nurse at the SMS Hospital on March 3, 1978. On the day, Smt. Prem wife of Navratan Mal was admitted in the hospital, at 5.10 p.m. Her injury report is Ex. P 10, which is in his hand and signed by Dr. Chauhan. He his stated that he informed the police control room on telephone that Smt. Prem had been admitted in the hospital in Ward No. 3A-B and that she had burn injuries. At that time Smt. Prem had told before him that her husband had burnt her and he (Shri Purushottam Mehta) convyed this information to the Police control room. He has further stated that this information was given to him by Smt. Prem when asked her as to what was the cause of the burn. This information was given to him at the time of examination, voluntarily. At that time, Dr. Chauhan was also present. In the cross-examination, he stated that he has given the statement on the basis of Ex. P 10, portion X to Y. He has further stated that he did not inquire from those persons who brought Smt. Prem to the hospital as to what was the cause of the burns. He did not record any statement of Smt. Prem on any separate paper. Whatever she had stated is noted in Ex. P. 10. The earlier dying declaration was made by Smt. Prem to Dr. Chauhan who was examined by this Court as a witness and that statement was made in presence of Dr. Chauhan (PW 9). Dr. Chauhan who was posted as Medical Jurist in the SMS Hospital, Jaipur on 3-3-1973, had examined the injuries of Smt. Prem at the time of admission in the hospital at 5.10 p.m. Besides deposing about the burns found on her body, he has further stated that he asked Smt. Prem about the history as to how she got the burns, she told that the burns were caused by her husband. He has mentioned this fact in Ex. P 10 and the same is marked as portion C to D. In his opinion, all the injuries were ante-mortem in nature and were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. Surprisingly, Dr. Chauhan was not cross-examined on that part of his examination-in-chief where in he has deposed about dying declaration of Smt. Prem. Not a single question was put to him. Thus, his statement that Smt. Prem made a dying declaration to him that burns had been caused to her by her husband stands uncross examined. As stated earlier. Dr. Chauhan was called by this Court and was further examined. He stated that the injured Smt. Prem wife of Navaratan Mal herself gave him the information and on its basis he made a detailed endorsement C to D in Ex. P 10. In cross-examination by the defence counsel before this Court, Dr. Chauhan has further stated that he simply asked the patient as to how she got the injuries and whatever was replied was mentioned in the injury report. It is also stated by him that burning was done by her husband and, he did not make any further inquiry from her because it is the function of the Investigation Officer. He has also stated that he did not recommend for recording the dying declaration because usually that function is to be done by the Doctor attending her after admission in the Ward.

15. Dr. S.S. Yadav has stated in this Court that endorsement A to B is in his hand writing and signed by him. He has further stated that some body came to him in the hospital and told that he is Magistrate and he has to record the dying declaration and he needed the permission for this. Before, the application, Ex. P 8 was submitted to him by the Magistrate, he has already taken round in the Ward and also examined the patient named in the said application. Her name is Smt. Prem. He did not examine the patient again on submission of the application Ex. P 8 and he certified that the patient was in a fit state of mind to make a dying declaration. In cross-examination, the Doctor stated that he made the endorsement A to B in the application Ex. P 8. He did not personally know the Magistrate, but he relied on him when he said that he is a Magistrate. He is unable to say whether the fact of granting the certificate for dying declaration was mentioned by him in the bed-head ticket, or not as the bed head ticket is not before him. The dying declaration was not recorded in his presence. Dr. Yadav has also stated that certain questions were put to the patient for ascertaining her level of consciousness. The patient responded well to the questions and therefore he gave the fitness certificate for her statement. She was conscious enough and, therefore, she was responding well and on account of that the fitness certificate was recorded..

16. Shri Mani Shankar Vyas was also called by this Court. He has stated that he directed the reader to make the endorsement E to F on Ex. P. 8. This endorsement E to F is unsigned, but it bears the seal of the Court of Munsif Magistrate No. 7 and due to mistake he could not sign the endorsement.

17. We have already referred to an earlier dying declaration made by the deceased Smt. Prem to the Compounded We will now deal with three dying declarations made in writing to the different persons by Smt. Prem. The first in time is Ex. P. 10. We have already referred to it, while dealing with the evidence of Purshottam Mehta recorded in this Court. It has been stated therein that Smt. Prem gave out that her husband is responsible for causing burns to her. At the time when the statement was made by Smt. Prem to Dr. Chouhan (PW 9) in the presence of Purushottam Mehta, none else was present. We have already said earlier that there is no material on record to show that the relations in between the accused appellant and Smt. Prem, deceased, were not cordial and the occurrence took place when the accused took alochol and came to his house. There is no reason why Smt. Prem would have falsely implicated the accused if he was not responsible for causing the burns to her. As such, the defence story of suicide does not stand the test of scrutiny in as much as. we have already stated earlier, that she would not of her own accord go to the Hospital in an auto rickshaw. That apart, even on the sight inspection no signs were found of suicide. Thus, Ex. 10 is the first written declaration which stands corroborated by the oral testimony of Shri Purushottam Mehta, Compounder. The second is Ex. P. 10, the statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.PC. It was recorded by Ram Bahadur (PW 11). The submission of the learned Advocate for the accused appellant is that the dying declaration cannot be acted upon because it was not recorded as provided under Rule 6 22 of the Rajasthan Police Rules, 1965. The said Rule provides that a dying declaration shall, whenever possible, be recorded by a Magistrate. Then Sub-rule (2) provides that the person making the declaration shall, if possible be examined by a Medical Officer with a view to ascertaining that he is sufficiently in possession of his reason to make a lucid statement. Sub-rule (3) provides that if no Magistrate can be obtained, the declaration shall, when a gazetted police officer is not present, be recorded in the presence of two or more reliable witnesses unconnected with the police department and with the parties concerned in the case. Sub-rule (4) provides that if no such witnesses can be detained without risk of the injured person dying before his statement can be recorded, it shall be recorded in the presence of two or more police officers. Sub-rule (5) provides that a dying declaration made to police officer should, under Section 162 Code of Criminal Procedure, be signed by the person making it. According to the learned Advocate for the accused appellant a look at Ex. P. 13 will show that there is non-compliance of Sub-rules (3) and (4) of Rule 6.22 of the Rajasthan Police Rules, 1965. The contention of the learned Public Prosecutor is that in this case statement under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was recorded and such statement does not require the signatures of the witness and at that state, therefore, compliance of Rule 6.22 of the said Rules was not necessary. It is further contended by her that because Smt. Prem died later on this statement under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is being used and can be used as a dying declaration. In our opinion, because the statement was recorded under Section 161, Code of Criminal Procedure at that point of time it was not necessary for the Investigating Officer to have taken the precaution as enumerated in Rule 6.22 of the said Rules while recording the statement. Those precautions would have been necessary in case the SHO would have proceeded to record the dying declaration of Smt. Prem. Ram Bahadur (PW 11) has clearly stated in his statement before the learned Sessions Judge that he recorded the statement of Smt. Prem under Section 161 Cr.PC. Surprisingly, he was not cross-examined about the mental status of Smt. Prem at the time when her statement under Section 161 Cr.PC was recorded, which is now acted upon as dying declaration, The third and the last dying declaration is contained in Ex. P. 9, which was recorded by Shri Mani Shankar Vyas, who said that the dying declaration was recorded after taking all necessary precautions as provided under Rule 6.22 of the Rajasthan Police Rules, 1965. Shri Mani Shankar Vyas recorded the statement of Smt. Prem only after seeking necessary information that she was in a fit state of mind to make a statement. No doubt, it would have been belter if the dying declaration would have been recorded in the form of questionaire, but even if it has been recorded in narration it cannot be discarded. Shri Mani Shankar Vyas is a Magistrate and has no reason to state falsely. A look at Ex. P. 9 would show that Smt. Prem has made a statement to Shri Mani Shankar Vyas and it contains that her husband sprinkled kerosene on her clothes and set fire to her. The three dying declarations have been consistent so far as the fact that the accused is responsible for causing burns to the deceased is concerned. These dying declarations appear to be true sufficient to base conviction of the accused appellant.

18. In the result, we do not find any merit in this appeal which is here by dismissed.