- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Tejpal Singh v. Rajasthan State Roadways Transport Corporation And Mullan
Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The claimant, Tej Pal (Tejpal) Singh, aged 16 at the time of filing the claim petition, appealed against the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Bharatpur's rejection of his claim. The Tribunal had found that it was not proved that the bus driver (Mullan), driving Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation bus No. RJA 3601, was at fault, negligent or rash. The accident occurred on 17 January 1976 at about 10:15 a.m. while Tejpal was riding his bicycle toward his village Peerka (Nagar) via Bharatpur-Khakawali (Nagar). Near Khakawali (four miles from Nagar), the Corporation's bus allegedly struck the claimant from behind; as a result his right leg was severely crushed and ultimately amputated. Before this Court there was no dispute that Tejpal was on a cycle and that there was a collision with the bus causing serious injuries including amputation of a leg. The claimant challenges the Tribunal's finding that there was no credible evidence of driver negligence.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Tribunal erred in rejecting the claimant's petition by finding that the bus driver was not at fault, negligent or rash in causing the accident.
- If negligence on the part of the driver is established or partially established, what is the appropriate quantum of compensation for the claimant's injuries (including amputation and consequential treatment), and whether a reduction is warranted on account of any contributory or composite negligence by the claimant.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Claimant's) Arguments — as presented by Shri R.M. Lodha
- Emphasised the evidence of Zinsiram (P.W.4), a police constable who lodged the FIR (Ex. P.1) immediately after the occurrence, stating that the bus struck Tejpal from behind, causing him to fall unconscious and sustain a serious fracture to one leg.
- Argued that the evidence read as a whole suggests an initial strike by the front wheel and subsequent dragging, such that the boy could have first been hit by the front-left wheel and then thrown under the right-front wheel (or otherwise affected by successive impacts).
- Submitted that discrepancies about "left" or "right" should not be given undue importance because, practically, a sequence of impacts and throwing/dragging could account for the different descriptions.
Respondent's (Corporation's) Arguments — as presented by Shri R.N. Munshi
- Contended that both the defence evidence and the claimant's own evidence indicate the fault lay with the boy: he became nervous, moved in front of the bus after losing balance, and caused the collision.
- Argued the bus driver did all he could to stop the vehicle but the accident could not be avoided, implying no negligence on the driver's part.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Pandian Roadways Corporation v. Karunanidhi (Madras) | Principles in paras 15 and 16: higher degree of care required of drivers who ought to anticipate the presence of immature persons; the doctrine of last opportunity and the duty to stop to avoid accidents involving children/immature persons. | The Court stated it was inclined to follow these principles but, after examining evidence, found that although the driver had a duty to be careful, there was composite negligence (including the boy's conduct). The Court applied the reasoning to assess liability and apportion responsibility. |
| Chan Leo Kheo v. Lai Eiew and Ors (Federal Court of Malaysia) (1971 ACJ 408) | Used as an illustration concerning the doctrine of 'last opportunity' and a situation where leaving a vehicle on the road caused the accident—showing limits of the doctrine. | The Court noted the decision in that case while discussing the 'last opportunity' doctrine and observed it was unnecessary to deal with the decision in detail for present purposes; it was cited for context regarding the doctrine's treatment. |
| Halsbury's Laws of England (3rd Edn., Vol. 28, para 9) | The proposition that a higher degree of care is due from those who know of or ought to anticipate the presence of disabled or immature persons. | Relied on as an authority for the proposition that drivers owe heightened care when immature persons (such as children) are likely to be present; informed the Court's appreciation of the driver's duty, although the Court ultimately found composite negligence. |
| Tinsukhla Flour Mills v. Shiv Prasad (1980 ACJ 356) | Authority on quantum: in a case where a 14-year-old's left leg was amputated, the tribunal had awarded Rs. 50,000 for mental suffering, pain, treatment and permanent disability, which was upheld. | The Court was inclined to adopt the compensation estimate from this case and used it as the basis for increasing the award in the present matter (adopting Rs. 50,000 for damage and adding Rs. 2,500 for treatment sequences). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court reviewed the entire evidence led by both parties, paying particular attention to witness Zinsiram (P.W.4) and the claimant's own testimony. It noted the following points from the evidence and its analysis:
- Credibility and consistency: The Court found inconsistencies in Zinsiram's account as to whether the impact was by the left or the right wheel; the FIR (Ex. P.1) also contained differing particulars. Zinsiram was, however, accepted as a witness for his presence and that he saw the accident, though his descriptions varied.
- Claimant's testimony: Tejpal (the victim) in chief stated the bus struck his cycle from behind and the wheel of the bus was over his right leg. In cross-examination he stated the impact was from the right front wheel and that he fell thereafter. The Court regarded Tejpal as the best person to know the manner of the accident being the victim, despite his immaturity.
- Evaluation of competing reconstructions: The appellant's counsel urged a 'dragging' theory or an initial impact by the left front wheel followed by crushing by the right wheel; the Court found no clinching evidence to support this multi-impact reconstruction and observed that Tejpal himself did not present that sequence.
- Finding on collision: On a holistic reading, the Court concluded the collision occurred with the right front wheel of the bus while the cyclist was on the left side; it rejected the contention of a left-front-wheel impact followed by the cyclist being run over by the right wheel.
- Liability and apportionment: The Court recognized the legal principle that drivers owe a higher duty of care towards immature persons (citing Pandian Roadways and Halsbury). Nevertheless, after considering the evidence, the Court found composite negligence: while the driver ought to have been more careful, the boy's nervousness and movement into the bus's path (coming from left to right) contributed to the accident. Thus, liability was shared rather than placed solely on the driver.
- Quantum of damages: The Tribunal had awarded Rs. 20,000, which the Court regarded as conservative given the amputation. Applying the precedent of Tinsukhla Flour Mills (where Rs. 50,000 was awarded for a similar amputation of a young person), the Court increased the base compensation to Rs. 50,000 and added Rs. 2,500 for treatment sequences, making a total of Rs. 52,500.
- Reduction for composite negligence: Because of composite negligence, the Court awarded fifty percent of the total Rs. 52,500 to the claimant, stating that this would come to Rs. 26.225/-. The Court ordered interest at 12% from the date of application until realization and costs of Rs. 500. The impugned Tribunal award was set aside and the claim petition accepted accordingly.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The impugned award of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal was set aside; the claim petition was accepted and the appeal allowed. The Court increased the compensation and apportioned liability.
Specific orders and direct consequences for the parties (as stated in the opinion):
- The Tribunal's award of Rs. 20,000 was increased. The Court adopted Rs. 50,000 as the principal compensation (relying on precedent) and added Rs. 2,500 for treatment, totalling Rs. 52,500.
- Because of composite negligence (shared fault), the claimant was awarded fifty percent of Rs. 52,500, described in the opinion as Rs. 26.225/-.
- The awarded amount is to carry interest at the rate of 12% from the date of application until realization. Costs of Rs. 500 were also awarded to the claimant.
- The impugned award passed by the Tribunal is set aside and the claim petition is allowed insofar as consistent with the above figures and apportionment.
The opinion does not discuss or announce any broader legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities to apportion liability and determine compensation; its immediate effect is the alteration of the award and the apportionment of liability between the claimant and the bus driver/corporation.
1. Tej Pal Singh, the claimant, who was aged 16 years at the time of filing of the ciaim petition, has filed this appeal against the rejection of his claim by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Bbaratpur, on the ground that it has not been proved that the accident took place on account of the fault or negligence or rashness of the bus driver-Mullan, who was driving the Corporation's bus No. RJA 3601. The accident, as alleged, took place on 17th January, 1976 at 10.15 a.m. while the claimant-Tejpal Singh on his cycle was going to his village Peerka (Nagar) via Bharatpur-Khakawali (Nagar). While he reached near Khakawali which is 4 miles away from Nagar; Bus No. RJA 3601 which is owned by the Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation, came with a fast speed from behind him and struck the claimant, as result of which right leg of the claimant was seriously crushed by the bus.
2. Before this Court, there is no dispute and it is common ground that, Tejpal Singh, the appellant, was going on cycle and there was an accident with the bus of the Corporation, as a result of which, Tejpal Singh sustained various injuries and one of his leg was amputed, as a whole.
3. The tribunal has found that there is no credible evidence to prove the fault or, rashness or negligence of the bus driver, and this finding is being challenged before this Court by the appellant-claimant.
4. Shri R.M. Lodha, the learned Counsel, appearing for the appellant has' led great emphasis on the statement of Zinsiram (P.W. 4), a police constable, who lodged an F.I.R. immediately after the occurrence and, has stated categorically that Tejpal Singh was going on cycle and the Roadways bus struck from behind the cyclist-Tejpal Singh, on account of which Tejpal Singh fell down on the right hand of the cycle and became unconscious and, one of the leg was fractured seriously. Zinsiram brought Tejpal Singh to Nagar and lodged F.I.R. (Ex. P. 1). According to this witness, the bus and the cycle collided and the actual impact was from the left from wheel of the bus with the cycle. But, in the F.I.R. (Ex. P. 1) he has mentioned that it was from the right wheel of the front side. The submission of Shri Lodha is that from the entire evidence reading as a whole, it would transpire that first the cycle was struck by front wheel and then as a result of the impact of this accident, he was dragged and then hit by the right side wheel of the front side of the bus.
5. The tribunal has disbelieved this evidence primarily on the ground that the bus stopped forthwith without any drag the collision was by front the right wheel of the front side of the bus which shows that the defence of the corporation is correct that the boy who was driving the cycle, became nervous on knowing that the bus has come from behind and came in front of the bus and even though the driver did best to stop the bus but, there was impact of right front wheel.
6. The contention of Shri Lodha is that no importance should be given to right or left because it is possible after having impact of the left wheel the boy can be thrown under right front wheel and can be crushed. According to him, in the instant case it is difficult to work out details as various factors took place which cannot be imagined or expected or anticipating.
7. Shri R.N. Munshi, the learned Counsel for the corporation-respondent, has pointed out that not only the evidence led by the corporation but also the claimant's evidence, conclusively proved that the fault was of the boy who became nervous and suddenly came in front of bus after loosing his balances and fell down. According to him, the driver of the bus did his best to stop the bus but, noneless the accident could not be avoided.
8. I have carefully gone through the entire evidence led in the case by both the parties and particularly, the evidence of constable Zinasiram (PW 4). Zinsiram is constable and may not prepared to accept the suggestion given in the cross-examination that he has tried to involve the bus driver, as he was not given freedom, however, before appreciating the evidence of this witness, I must mention that Tejpal Singh, the boy, who is victim of this accident in his examination-in-chief, has stated that the bus struck his cycle from behind on account of which he fell down and the wheel of the bus was over his right leg. In cross-examination, this witness has stated clearly that the impact of collision, between the cycle and the bus was from right front wheel and he fell down and, thereafter in the right hand side in the Kacha so also the cycle. According to him, he fell down at the point where the accident happened. It would not therefore, be dragging theory argued by Shri Lodha and the deduction made by him that first there was impact of accident between the left and front side of the wheel of the bus and the cycle on account of which the boy was crushed by right wheel of the front side. It is not the case of Tejpal Singh and, though if there would have been clinching evidence otherwise I would have ignored the infirmity in the evidence of the boy giving due consession to his immaturity but, I find that other evidence is also consistant with the theory and details of the accident given by Tejpal Singh. Normally Tejpal Singh was the best person to know as to how the accident happened as he is victim and, the other persons are those who would have seen the accident from some other place by observing from some distance, howsoever it may be.
9. It is also significant that the witness, Zinsi whom I am inclined to accept true witness so far as the presence is concerned, and further so far as his seeing the accident is concerned, has also not been consistent about the description of left or right side of the wheel. According to him, Tejpal Singh came from the right side and the accident took place from the left wheel. He was confronted with the relevant portion of the F.I.R. in which he has stated that after the accident there was dragging on the right side upto the foot-path, then, the boy fell down. When confronted be stated that it was not there. About this version in the F.I.R. so far as Madho (AW-8) is concerned, all that he stated, was that there was an accident and the cycle of Tejpal Singh was struck by the bus but he has not alleged rashness or negligence or anything about the fault of the bus driver. According to him, the accident took place on account of impact of the right front wheel of the bus.
10. It would thus be seen that leaving aside the evidence of the Corporation, the evidence produced by Tejpal Singh, itself, is faultering on the exact manner in which the accident took place and, whether it was left wheel or right wheel, obviously, there is not of confusion and contradictions.
11. On a reading of the entire evidence of the claimant's side as well as the Corporation, I am inclined to hold that the boy was going on the cycle and, when the bus came, there was collision with the right front wheel of the bus and the cycle and, the boy came from the left side. I am not inclined to accept the theory that there was collision of left front wheel of the bus and then the boy came down below the wheel, as in the facts and circumstances, mentioned above that possibility is ruled out and it is not even the case of Tejpal Singh, himself, it hardly requires to be mentioned here that no body can be more pious than the pope, himself, and Tejpal Singh was the best witness.
12. The question which now arises for consideration is, that, in such circumstances, whether there is no liability of the bus driver. In this aspect, I am inclined to follow the principles laid down in Pandian Roadways Corporation v. Karunanidhi Madras)? Wherein in paras 15 and 16 it was held as follows:
15. In the present case, we have to find out as to what is the cause of the accident. The accident here is the running over the arm of the boy aged about 6. The driver was in a position to look out as to what was happening in the front. He saw the dogs fighting and he must have seen the boys coming on the cycle. If only he had stopped the vehicle, as a prudent man would have, he would have avoided the accident. The fact that he alleges that he did not see the boy falling until he came too close is not decisive of the question of negligence. Admittedly the cyclist was coming on at a slow speed and there was also a bus stop ahead. When he saw the boys coming in front and the dogs fighting with each other, he could have easily anticipated that the dogs would not be stationary before an oncoming bus and even likely to run this way or that. He should have immediately stopped the bus, so that neither the dogs nor the boys would have been injured. It is this doctrine of 'last opportunity' having gone into disrepute that is referred to in the decision of the Federal court of Malaysia in Chan Leo Kheo v. Lai Eiew and Ors. 1971 ACJ 408. It is unnecessary to deal with the said decision except to mention that in that case a car which had been stopped by the driver on highway and which was mistaken by the oncoming traffic as one on the move, was damage the court held that leaving the vehicle on a middle of the road was the cause of the accident and the oncoming/traffic was not responsible for it.
16. It has been pointed out that a higher degree of care is due from those who knew of or ought to anticipate the presence of disabled or immature persons. See Halsbury's Law of England, 3rd Edn., Vol 28 page 11, paragraph 9. This is such a case., when three immature persons were riding on a cycle, and were disturbed by a dog fight, the reaction of any person acting reasonably would have been to stop the vehicle, especially when the vehicle had allowed down because of the dogs and the presence of a bus stop at a short distance. It has, therefore, to be held that it is a clear case of negligence on the part of the bus driver.
An emphasis was led on the fact that a higher degree of care is due from those who know of or ought to anticipate the presence of disabled or immature persons.
13. However, it appears to me that on a thoughtful consideration of the evidence that though the bus driver cannot escape of the liability of being required to be more careful and, I feel, in such cases, his failure to stop the vehicle and avoid the accident even when the boy came in front, may be due to the fact that the boy became nervous or otherwise, cannot be avoided I also held that there was a composite negligence of the boy inasmuch as when the bus came from behind, he came from left side to right side and admittedly, he was driving on the left side and if he would not have come in front of the bus, that too on the extreme left hand side and continued to be driving the vehicle, there would have been no accident. Probability is that he became nervous and lost balance, for which the evidence has been produced or may be that he wanted to cross right side otherwise without becoming nervous a phenomenon for which there is no evidence directly and which can only be based on the conjectures. Be that as it may, it is established that the vehicle was struck driven on the right front wheel and there was no impact of the left wheel of the bus with the cyclist even though the cyclist was driving on the left side.
14. I have, therefore, no hesitation in accepting the contention of Shri Munshi that the composite negligence for the immaturity of the boy, the court has got all sympathy and considerations.
15. The tribunal has calculated the compensation at Rs. 20,000/-. In my opinion, this is too conservative assumption of the damages and loss caused to the boy whose left leg as a whole was amputed on account of the accident. The amputation of the leg makes the life miserable and sometimes, worse than death.
16. In Tinsukhla Floor Mills v. Shiv Prasad 1980 ACJ 356, the accident took place as a result of which a young boy of 14 years and studying in school was injured and shose left leg was amputed having permanently disability. The tribunal awarded Rs. 50,000/- for mental suffering pains, mental agony treatment and permanent disability and it was upheld by this Court.
17. In the present case, I am inclined to adopt the above estimate. The amount of compensation is, therefore, increased from Rs. 20,000/- to Rs. 50,000/- as per the father of the claimant's statement Narottam Das. I would, therefore, allow Rs. 2,500/- for the sequences of treatment in addition to the amount of Rs. 50.000/.
18. The result would be that the amount would be Rs. 52,500/-. On account of the composite negligence, the boy claimant would be entitled to get fifty percent of the above amount of 52,500/- which would come to Rs. 26.225/-. Consequently, the impugned Award passed by the Tribunal is set aside and, the claim petition is accepted so also the appeal, as indicated above, Tejpal Singh would also get this amount of Rs. 26,225/- with interest at the rate of 12% from the date of application till the date of realisation, with costs of Rs. 500/-.
Alert