Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Krishna Roadways, Nathdwara v. Madan Lal

Rajasthan High Court
Nov 11, 1983
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by S.K. Mal Lodha, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal under Section 110-D of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 was filed by Krishna Roadways, Nathdwara and its driver Saligram (non-petitioners Nos. 1 & 2) against the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Udaipur's judgment and award dated 15 October 1973. The Tribunal had awarded Rs. 11,000 in favour of the petitioners (respondents) — parents of an eight-year-old boy, Someshwar — for injuries and subsequent death resulting from boiling water/scalds from a bus radiator. Rubi General Insurance Company Ltd. was non-petitioner No. 3 (the insurer).

Factual events (as found and narrated in the opinion): Bus RJY 1517 (owned by non-petitioner No. 1) left Udaipur for Bhilwara on 21 June 1969. Someshwar (about 8 years old) was seated on the lap of his maternal relative, Daulal, near the left side of the engine where a portion of the radiator protruded. At Eklingji some water was poured into the radiator and the lid was closed. After the bus proceeded, the radiator reached boiling point, the cap was thrown off by force of steam and boiling water/scalding liquid fell on Someshwar (and others). Someshwar was taken to hospital and subsequently died (medical testimony attributed death to shock from extensive scalds). The Tribunal found negligence on the part of the driver and awarded Rs. 11,000 (Rs. 10,800 for future pecuniary loss and Rs. 200 for treatment), while limiting the insurer's liability to Rs. 2,000 under the Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain the claim under Section 110 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (i.e., whether the event amounted to a "motor accident" arising out of use of a motor vehicle).
  2. Whether the driver (non-petitioner No. 2) was negligent and such negligence caused the scalding injuries and death of Someshwar.
  3. Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal (Rs. 11,000; specifically Rs. 10,800 for pecuniary loss and Rs. 200 for treatment) was correct or required interference.
  4. What was the extent of the insurer's liability under the Act (whether the insurer's liability was limited to Rs. 2,000 under the statutory provision cited).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (non-petitioners Nos. 1 & 2) Arguments

  • The claim should not have been entertained under Section 110 of the Act because the event was not a "motor accident" as contemplated by the statute.
  • The Tribunal was incorrect in finding that the driver (Saligram) acted rashly or negligently in a manner that caused Someshwar's burns.
  • The Tribunal had no jurisdiction to award an amount exceeding what was specifically claimed in the claim petition (contention regarding limits of award relative to claim).
  • The Rs. 200 awarded for treatment expenses should not have been granted (this point was argued though not specifically raised in the memo of appeal, per the court).

Respondents' (petitioners') Position

  • Supported the Tribunal's findings on jurisdiction, negligence of the driver, and the quantum of compensation awarded.
  • Presented evidence (witnesses P.W.1, P.W.3, P.W.6 and medical witness P.W.2) to establish the occurrence, the driver's conduct, and the cause of death.

Non-petitioner No. 3 (Insurance Company)

  • Resisted the claim along similar lines as non-petitioners Nos. 1 & 2 and contended that its liability was limited to Rs. 2,000; it also suggested that the claimed compensation was exaggerated and that it was liable for a lesser amount (it submitted that it was liable for Rs. 2,000 only).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
C.K.S. Iyer v. T.K. Nair Principles under Ss. 1A and 2 of the Fatal Accidents Act, 1955 concerning measure of damages for wrongful death: damages limited to pecuniary loss, consideration of life expectancy, exclusion of mere speculation, parents' entitlement to present cash value of prospective services and reasonable expectation of future pecuniary benefits. The court relied on these principles to affirm that compensation should be confined to pecuniary loss and to validate the Tribunal's approach to measure future pecuniary loss from the minor child to parents.
Gobald Motor Service v. R.M.K. Veluswami Guidance on principles for assessing compensation in motor-death cases (used by the Tribunal in determining the monthly rate and period for loss of future earnings/contributions). The Tribunal applied the approach from this case in fixing Rs. 30 per month for 30 years (totaling Rs. 10,800) as future pecuniary loss; the High Court held that the Tribunal's application of that principle did not warrant interference.
Sheikhpura Transport Co. v. N.I.T. Ins. Co. Observation that pecuniary loss in such matters involves estimates and conjecture to an extent; also referred to in relation to insurer's statutory liability limits under the Act. The court cited this authority to acknowledge the unavoidable estimate involved in assessing pecuniary loss and to support the Tribunal's treatment of the insurer's statutory limit under Section 95(2)(b) as limiting the insurer's liability to Rs. 2,000 per passenger.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through the issues methodically:

  1. Jurisdiction / "Motor Accident": The court observed that "accident" is not defined in the Act and examined dictionary meanings to establish that an "accident" contemplates a sudden, unforeseen, or unexpected event. It held that the statutory phrase "arising out of the use of motor vehicles" uses "use" in a wide sense. Given that Someshwar was sitting in the bus while the vehicle was in use, and that the lid was thrown off by steam causing boiling water to fall on him, the event constituted a motor accident within Section 110. Medical evidence (P.W.2) established death due to extensive scalds, supporting the conclusion that the incident was a motor accident arising out of vehicle use; accordingly the Tribunal had jurisdiction.
  2. Negligence of the driver: The court analyzed competing testimonies. Several witnesses (P.W.1 Daulal, P.W.3 Dr. Uma Kant, P.W.6 Shyam Sunder) stated that the driver had poured water and placed the lid and that passengers complained the lid was not placed properly, but the driver ignored complaints. The driver/pursuant witnesses (D.W.1, D.W.4) gave differing versions, including that a khalasi poured water or that structural failure (shaft/body) caused the issue. The court found the evidence supporting the petitioners more credible, disbelieved interested defence witnesses whose statements contradicted pleadings, and held that the driver had not properly placed the cap. The court applied the orthodox definition of negligence (failure to act as a reasonable prudent person would) and concluded the driver should have foreseen that an improperly fitted cap might be thrown by steam causing boiling water to injure passengers. Therefore the Tribunal was justified in finding negligence by Saligram.
  3. Causation and medical evidence: The court relied on the medical witness (P.W.2) to confirm that death resulted from shock due to extensive scalds, thereby connecting the negligent act to the fatal outcome. The Tribunal's finding that death was due to the negligent act was upheld.
  4. Quantum of compensation: The Tribunal awarded Rs. 11,000 (Rs. 10,800 as future pecuniary loss and Rs. 200 for treatment). The court examined the Tribunal's calculation: noting Someshwar's age (8), his status as the only son, school report indicating he was brilliant, and his father's testimony about possible future earnings/contributions. Applying the principles from C.K.S. Iyer, Gobald Motor Service, and Sheikhpura Transport, the Tribunal fixed Rs. 30 per month for 30 years (30 x 12 x 30 = Rs. 10,800) for future pecuniary loss. The High Court observed that some arbitrariness is inevitable in such assessments and that appellate interference is warranted only if a wrong principle was applied or the award was inordinately low or high. The court found no misdirection and declined to interfere with Rs. 10,800.
  5. Challenge that the Tribunal exceeded the claim: The appellants argued the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to award more than what was specifically claimed. The court examined the claim petition (para 11) showing a total assessment of Rs. 60,000 as pecuniary loss and held the contention lacked substance.
  6. Treatment expenses (Rs. 200): Although this point was not specifically pressed in the memo of appeal, the appellants contested the Rs. 200 award. The court found no persuasive reason to set it aside and upheld the award.
  7. Insurer liability: The Tribunal limited the insurer's liability to Rs. 2,000 relying on Section 95(2)(b) of the Act which limits statutory liability where a vehicle is allowed to carry more than six passengers (statutory limit Rs. 2,000 in respect of each passenger though total liability may go up to Rs. 20,000). The High Court accepted this limitation and referred to Sheikhpura Transport Co.'s case in this context.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

APPEAL DISMISSED.

The court upheld the Tribunal's findings in all material respects:

  • The Tribunal had jurisdiction under Section 110 of the Motor Vehicles Act to entertain the claim because the event constituted a motor accident arising out of the use of a motor vehicle.
  • The driver (non-petitioner No. 2 Saligram) was negligent in not properly placing the radiator cap, and such negligence caused the scalding injuries and death of Someshwar.
  • The Tribunal's award of Rs. 11,000 (Rs. 10,800 for future pecuniary loss and Rs. 200 for treatment) was appropriate and not to be interfered with on appeal.
  • The insurer's statutory liability was limited to Rs. 2,000 in respect of the passenger as per the provision relied upon by the Tribunal.
  • There will be no order as to costs.

Implications:

The decision affirms (a) a broad interpretation of "arising out of the use of motor vehicles" for purposes of Section 110 jurisdiction, (b) that negligence can be inferred from proved facts and witness credibility in the context of vehicle operation and maintenance, and (c) that assessment of future pecuniary loss in fatality cases necessarily involves estimation guided by established principles (as applied from cited authorities). The opinion did not purport to establish a new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities; its direct legal effect is to uphold the Tribunal's award and the statutory limit on insurer liability in this case.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

S.K Mal Lodha, J.:— Krishna Roadways, Nathdwara and Saligram, who were non-petitioners Nos. 1 and 2 respectively before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Udaipur (for short ‘the Tribunal’) have filled this appeal under s. 110-D of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (No. IV of 1939) (for short ‘the Act’ herein) against the Judgment and award dated October 15, 1973 of the Tribunal. The Tribunal has passed an award for Rs. 11,000/- in favour of the petitioners (Respondents). Respondents No. 1 and 2, are father and mother of one Someshwar. The appellants shall be referred as non-petitioners No. 1 and 2 and respondents No. 1 and 2 shall be referred as the petitioners.

2. Respondent No. 3 Rubi General Insurance Company Ltd., Bapu Bazar, Udaipur, was non-petitioner and it will be referred as non-petitioner No. 3 hereinafter.

3. Bus RJY 1517 was owned by non-petitioner No. 1. Its driver was non-petitioner No. 2. This bus left Udaipur bus stand for Bhilwara on June 21, 1969 at 6.45 p.m Someshwar, aged about 8 years was also going with Daulal, Head Master, Phalna Middle School, who is maternal uncle of Madan Lal. Daulal was sitting in front near the engine on the left side seat. Someshwar was sitting in his lap. It is not in dispute that the radiator of the engine was also inside the bus and it was coming out about 6″ of the body of the engine. Its mouth was towards the left side where Dau Lal with Someshwar and a few other passengers was sitting. When the bus reached Eklingji on way to Nathdwara, Salig Ram, driver opened the head of the radiator and some water was poured in it. Thereafter the lid of the radiator was closed. According to the petitioners after the bus had left Eklingji and had travelled about a mile ahead of Gedgia the Driver drove the bus fast. When it had travelled about ten miles from Eklingji towards Nathdwara all of a sudden the water in the radiator reached boiling point. The lid (cap) was thrown by the force of the steam and the boiling water fell over Someshwar who was sitting in the lap of Daulal, as a result of which there were scalds which involved face, front of neck, front of chest, upper half of abdomen right, forearm and arm in front left arm and forearm front, left thigh upper ¼, penis, etc. of Someshwar. Daulal also received burns. The passengers alighted from the bus. At that time, the car was seen going from the side of Udaipur and Daulal took Someshwar in that car to Nathdwara Hospital, where first aid was administered, but it was advised that Someshwar should be taken to Udaipur. Someshwar was brought to Udaipur and he was admitted in General Hospital on June 22, 1979, where he died because of the extensive burn on June 23, 1979. The petitioners have alleged that Someshwar was in pain and agony because of the extensive burns till he died. The age of Someshwar at the time of death was eight years. He was studying in 2nd standard in School at Udaipur. He was brilliant boy and had a bright future. The details of the compensation claimed by the petitioners are given in para 11 of the claim petition. Three items, with which I am concerned in this appeal have been stated in para 11 as follows:—

The claim petition was resisted by all the non-petitioners. Non-petitioners No. 1 and 2 admitted that non-petitioner No. 2 was driving the vehicle at the relevant time. This fact has also been admitted that the lid (cap) of the radiator was thrown and the boiling water fell over Someshwar. Amongst others, an objection was taken that this happening is not a motor accident and as such the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to entertain and decide the claim. The amount of compensation was disputed on the ground that it was exaggerated. Non-petitioner No. 3 (Insurance Company) also resisted the claim on the grounds, which were raised by non-petitioners No. 1 and 2. It submitted that it is liable for Rs. 2000/- only. In the judgment and award under appeal, the Tribunal has reproduced the five issues. On behalf of the petitioners, statements of P.W 1 Daulal, P.W 2 Dr. Ramesh Chandra, P.W 3 Dr. Uma Kant, P.W 4 Abdul Rehman, P.W 5 Madan Lal and P.W 6 Shyamsunder have been recorded. On behalf of non-petitioners No. 1 and 2, statements of D.W 1 Saligram, D.W 2 Girdhari Singh, D.W 3 Bhanwarlal, D.W 4 Bhim Singh and D.W 5 Ramlal have been recorded. Documentary evidence has also been place on record. The Tribunal has recorded the following findings:—

(1) that the Tribunal, under s. 110 of the Act had jurisdiction to entertain the claim;

(2) that Someshwar was burnt and died on account of the negligence of non petitioner No. 2 Saligram;

(3) that the petitioner is entitled to get Rs. 11,000/- (Rs. 10,800/- as compensation and Rs. 200 as the expenses on treatment);

(4) that the liability of the Insurance Company is limitted to Rs. 2000/-.

On the aforesaid findings, award of Rs. 11000/- was passed on October 15, 1973. Non-pttitioners No. 1 and 2 have filed this appeal as aforesaid.

4. I have heard Mr. A.L Mehta and Mr. A.R Mehta for the appellant; Mr. M.C Bhandari for respondents No. 1 and 2 and Mr. Rajendra Mehta for respondent No. 3 and have carefully considered the record.

5. Learned counsel for the appellants argued, in the first instance, that the claim for compensation in this case should not have been entertained by the Tribunal under s. 110 of the Act, as it is not a motor accident as envisaged by s. 110 of the Act. He has assailed findings on issue No. 3. Learned counsel for respondents No. 1 and 2 have supported the finding.

6. The first question that emerges for determination is whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain the claim.

7. Relevant portion of s. 110 of the Act is as follows:—

“110. Claims Tribunals.-(1) A State Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette, constitute one or more Motor Accidents Claims Tribunals hereinafter referred to as Claims Tribunals) for such area as may be specified in the notification for the purpose of adjudicating upon claims for compensation in respect of accidents involving the death of, or bodily injury to, persons arising out of the use of motor vehicles, or damages to any property of a third party so arising, or both:

Provided that where such claim includes a claim for compensation in respect of damage to property exceeding rupees two thousand, the claimant may, at his option, refer the clain to a civil court for adjudication, and where a reference is so made, the claims Tribunal shall have no jurisdiction to entertain any question relating to such claim)”.

S. 110-A deals with the application for compensation. It provides for procedure and circumstances under which the family of victim of a motor accident can get compensation.

8. ‘Accident’ or ‘motor accident’ has not been defined under the Act. In O. ford English Dictionary,

‘accident’ has been defined as ‘an unfortunate event, disaster, a mishap; as also anything that happens without foresight or expectation; an unusual event, which proceeds from some unknown cause, or is an unusual effect of a known cause; a casualty, a contingency”. In Wabstet's Third New International Dictionary, ‘accident’ has been defined as sudden event or change occurring without intent or volition through carelessness, unawareness, ignorance or a combination of causes and producing an unfavourable result; an unexpected happening causing loss or injury which is not due to any fault or misconduct on the part of the person injured but from the consequences of which he may be entitled to some legal relief. In Chambers Twentisth Century Dictionary the ‘accident’ has been defined to mean an unforseen or unexpected event, a chance.” The expression used in s. 110-A is “arising out of the use of motor vehicles. The word “use” has been used in wide sense. The word “use” in the Oxford Dictionary has been defined to mean “purpose for which thing can be used”, “application to a purpose”, “employ for a purpose” and right or power of using. It has been admitted that Someshwar was sitting in the bus and he was sitting on the front seat on the left of the engine of which a portion of the radiator was coming out. The lid (cap) of the radiator was thrown by the force of the steam and the boiling water from the radiator fell on the body of Someshwar, which resulted in causing extensive burns over his body. It cannot be denied that the vehicle was not in use at that time. This sudden event or unexpected happening or misfortune happened causing burns not due to the fault of Someshwar but from the consequence of which he may be entitled to some legal relief. The vehicles was in use and while it was in use the unexpected event had happened.

9. P.W 2 Dr. Ramesh Chandra has been examined. From his statement, it is clearly established that Someshwar died due to shock as a result of extensive scalds on the body surface area. In these circumstances, there is no room for debate that Someshwar had died in an accident which arose out of use of the motor vehicle. The Tribunal has correctly held that the accident in question is motor accident within the meaning of sec. 110 of the Act and, therefore, the Tribunal had jurisdiction to entertain it. The first contention raised by the learned counsel for the appellant is therefore, repelled.

10. It was, then, argued by the learned counsel for the appellant that the Tribunal was not right in recording the finding that Someshwar was burnt to death on account of rash or negligent act of Salig Ram. The first question in this connection that arises is whether non-petitioner No. 2 Saligram, had poured the water and placed the lid (cap) on it. On behalf of the petitioners, P.W 3 Dr. Uma Kant, who was also a passenger in the bus, has been examined. He has stated that at Eklingji water was poured in the radiator by the Driver and that the Driver put the lid over it. P.W 6 Shyam Sunder has stated that it was Driver, who had poured the water in the radiator at Eklingji D.W 1 Saligram has stated that he stopped the bus at Rani Bawri and there water was poured in the radiator. According to D.W 1 Saligram water was poured in the-radiator by Khalasi and he put the cap on it. In the reply it was not alleged that Khalasi had poured water in the radiator and he has also put the lid (cap) on it. D.W 4 Bhim Singh is conductor. He is son of non-petitioner No. 2 Salig Ram. He has stated that he has poured the water in the radiator and placed the lid (cap) on it. No reliance can be placed on the testimony of D.W 1 Salig Ram and D.W 4 Bhim Singh who is an interested witness particularly when this fact was not stated in the reply. In these circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in not believing non-petitioner No. 2 and holding that it was non-petitioner No. 2 who had poured water in the radiator at Eklingji and placed cover on it.

11. The other question is whether Saligram was negligent and on account of that the lid (cap) was thrown and boiled water fell on Someshwar and him. P.W 1 Daulal has deposed that the lid (cap) was not placed properly; that there was some leakage of water from the radiator and that he told the Driver Salig Ram but he did not pay any heed to it. A perusal of the statement shows that the bus went ahead and on account of the jerks; the lid (cap) was thrown and the boiling water fell on Someshwar and on him. P.W 3 Dr. Uma Kant has stated that when the bus left Eklingji, after the Driver had poured water in the radiator there was some leakage from the radiator. A complaint was made in this regard by one of the passengers to the Driver but he did not pay any heed, and when the bus had travelled a little distance, the lid (cap) was thrown and the boiling water fell over the chid (Someshwar). To the same effect is the statement of P.W 6 Shyam Sunder. He has stated that he had complained to the Driver that he has not placed the lid (cap) properly but no heed was paid by the Driver. In rebuttal, D.W 1 Salig Ram has denied that any passenger complained to him. He has introduced the cause of the water falling on Someshwar and P.W 1 Dau Lal, that shaft of water body had been broken and that was the reason of the engine's becoming not it has been admitted by him that the water was poured in the radiator and this was the usual practice as engine became not because of the level being higher and the bus had to climb it. No copy of the report has been filed by any of the parties. However, P.W 4 Abdul Rehman was examined by the petitioner. He has stated that the bus was inspected on July 16, 1969, but he did not find any defect. He has also deposed that the water only reaches boiling point when the circulation system of the radiator is defective. D.W 5 Ram Lal has deposed that if the shaft of the water body is broken, the circulation stops and the water in the radiator in the engine becomes not. The Tribunal has not believed this statement for the reason that he has not inspected the bus after the accident and therefore, on the basis of this statement it cannot be said that the shaft of the water body was broken. From this evidence, it is clear that the Tribunal was not unjustified in holding that D.W 2 Salig Ram, the Driver, has not placed the cap properly. There appears to be some defect as the water in the radiator reached boiling point and the steam through the lid (cap) leaked and boiling water fell on the body of Someshwer. It may be recalled here that the mouth of the radiator was towards the left side where Dau Lal together with Someshwar and few other passengers was sitting. He should have placed the lid (cap) properly. This was an act of negligence on the part of the Driver Salig Ram, for, he has not put the lid (cap) on the radiator properly.

12. ‘Negligence’ is the omission to do which a reasonable man, guided upon the considerations, which ordinarily regulate the conduct of human affairs, would do or doing something which a prudent and reasonable man would not do. Negligence is not a question of evidence; it is an inference to be drawn from proved facts. Negligence is not an absolute term, but is a relative one, it is rather a comparative term. Where there is a duty to exercise care, reasonable care must be taken to avoid acts or omission, which could be reasonably foreseen to be likely to cause physical injury to persons. Salig Ram (Driver) should have kept the lid (cap) properly and as a reasonable and prudent man should have foreseen that the lid (cap) might be thrown by the force of steam and the boiling water could come on Someshwar causing burnt injuries. In my opinion, the Tribunal was right and justified in holding that it was the negligence of the Driver Salig Ram, which resulted in the accident.

13. P.W 2 Dr. Ramesh Chandra has examined the injuries on the person of Someshwar. He has stated that there were scalds involving the body surface area. He has also stated that the death was due to shock as a result of extensive scalds on the body of surface area. It has, therefore, rightly been concluded by the Tribunal that Someshwar was burnt to death on account of the negligent act of Salig Ram. No valid exception can be taken to the finding recorded by the Tribunal in this regard.

14. Now I come to the question of compensation.

15. The Tribunal has awarded Rs. 11,000/- as compensation (Rs. 10,800/- being loss of the future pecuniary benefits and Rs. 200/- as the amount incurred over the treatment of Someshwar). It is established from record that Someshwar was 8 years of age at the time of the accident: and that he was only son of his parents. It appears from Someshwar's report Ex. 7 issued by the St. Mary's Convent Higher Secondary School which was admitted by the non-petitioners' counsel, that Someshwar was a brilliant and intelligent boy. He (P.W 5) has stated that he wanted Someshwar to become a Doctor and Someshwar would have paid him Rs. 400-500 per month to him.

15. While considering Ss. 1A and 2 of the Fatal Accidents Act, 1955, in a case relating to death of boy about 8 years involved in an accident, their Lordships in C.K.S Iyer v. T.K Nair (1) observed as follows:

“Compulsory damages under Section 1A of the Act for wrongful death must be limited strictly to the pecuniary loss to the beneficiaries and that under Section 2, the measure of damages is the economic loss sustained by the estate. There can be no exact uniform rule for measuring the value of the human life and the measure of damages cannot be arrived at by precise mathematical calculations but the amount recoverable depends on the particular facts and circumstances of each case. The life expectancy of the deceased or of the beneficiaries whichever is shorter is an important factor. Since the elements which go to make up the value of the life of the deceased to the designated beneficiaries are necessarily personal to each case, in the very nature of things, there can be no exact or uniform rule for measuring the value of human life. In assessing damages, the Court must exclude all considerations of matter which rest in speculation or fancy though conjecture to some extent is inevitable. As a general rule parents are entitled to recover the present cash value of the prospective service of the deceased minor child. In addition they may receive compensation for loss of pecuniary benefits reasonably to be expected after the child attains majority.”

The Tribunal, after noticing the principles laid down in Gobald Motor Service v. R.M.K Veluswami (2) has opined that in the facts and circumstances of the case, it would be reasonable to award Rs. 30/- per month for a period of 30 years. While arriving at this figure, it has examined statement of P.W 5 Madan Lal. Had Someshwar not died, he might have paid some amount to his father and mother after attaining the age of 23-25 years. The Tribunal has taken the period of 30 years into consideration and, therefore, it has calculated the amount (30 × 12) @ rate of Rs. 30/- p.m, which comes to Rs. 10,800/-. After referring to Gobald Motor Service's case (2) Hegde, J. speaking for the Court, has expressed himself in Sheikhpura Transport Co. v. N.I.T Ins. Co. (3) in the following words:

“The pacuniary loss to the aggrieved party would depend upon date which cannot be ascertained accurately but must necessarily be an estimate or even partly a conjecture.”

The figure of Rs. 10,800/- has been arrived at by the Tribunal in accordance with the principles laid down in Gobald Motor Service's case (2), C.K.S Iyer's case (1) and Sheikhpura Transport's case (3). In fixing quantum of compensation in accident cases, there is bound to he some element of arbitrariness because, after certain salient features are indicated, the matter would normally be left to the Tribunal to take a reasonable view of those facts and to fix the quantum of compensation. It will not be distrubed unless the High Court is satisfied (i) that the Tribunal has applied a wrong principle of law, or has misdirected itself, or (ii) the amount awarded either is so inordinately low or is so inordinately high that it must be held to be erroneous. In these circumstances, the amount of award Rs. 10,800/- awarded as pecuniary loss to the petitioner does not call for any interference by this Court.

16. Learned counsel for the appellant argued that the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to award the amount, more than what has been claimed by the appellant. I have already stated above that in the claim petition, in para 11 Rs. 60,000/- has been assessed as pecuniary loss on account of the death of Someshwar. Item of Rs. 3,000/- is merely with respect to ordinary future loss which the deceased out of earnings would have contributed. Having regard to para 11 of the claim petition as a whole, this contention of the appellants is without substance.

18. In the last, it was argued that the petitioners are not entitled to the Rs. 200/- as expenses over treatment of Someshwar. It may be mentioned that this point has not been specifically taken in the memo of appeal. Even otherwise, learned counsel for the appellants could not satisfy me as to why this sum should not have been awarded to the petitioners. The finding on issue No. 2 is also correct.

19. The liability of the Insurance Company is limited to ‘Rs. 2,000/- iu’ this case. The Tribunal has referred to S. 95(2)(b) of the Act, which provides that the statutory liability of the insurer to indemnfy the insured in the case of vehicle allowed to carry more than 6 passengers extends to only Rs. 2,000/- in respect of each passengers, though the total liability may go up-to Rs. 20,000/-. Reference in this connection may be made to Sheikhpura Transport Co.'s case (3).

20. No other point survives for my consideration in this appeal.

21. For the reasons mentioned above, this appeal fails and it is, hereby dismissed.

22. There will be no order as to costs.