- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Gayoor Ahmad Khan v. Hazarimal
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a revision application by Gayoor Ahmad Khan (applicant) of Barmer against an appellate order of the District Judge, Balotra, which held that the executing court (Munsif Barmer) had jurisdiction to attach a camel that was in the custody of the Sessions Court, Balotra, under Order 21, Rule 52 C.P.C.
Hazari Mal and Prabhu Lal (respondents Nos. 1 & 2) hold a money decree against Achar (respondent No. 3). In execution, an Amin attached Achar's camel. Achar seized the camel from the Amin by force and was prosecuted under s. 394 I.P.C. The Sessions Court, Balotra, delivered the camel into the custody of Gayoor Ahmad Khan. The decree-holders applied again under Order 21, Rule 52 C.P.C. and the camel was attached. Gayoor failed to produce the camel, and execution was levied against him. He resisted on the ground that the Barmer court lacked jurisdiction to attach property in the custody of the Balotra court, relying on Gyarsilal v. Shankar Rao. The appellate court overruled the objection relying on Bhagwati Prasad Bajpai…Judgment-Debtor, v. Jai Narain Hanuman Das…Decree-Holder.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an executing court can attach property that is already in the custody of another court under Order 21, Rule 52 C.P.C., notwithstanding the rule of territorial jurisdiction.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The Munsif Barmer had no jurisdiction to attach the camel while it was in the custody of the Sessions Court, Balotra; reliance on Gyarsilal v. Shankar Rao.
Respondents' Position (as accepted by appellate court)
- The attachment under Order 21, Rule 52 C.P.C. was valid despite the camel being in custody of another court; reliance on Bhagwati Prasad Bajpai…Judgment-Debtor, v. Jai Narain Hanuman Das…Decree-Holder.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Gyarsilal v. Shankar Rao | Relied on by applicant to support absence of jurisdiction to attach property in custody of another court. | Not followed by this Court; referenced as the contrary single-judge Nagpur High Court decision. |
| Bhagwati Prasad Bajpai…Judgment-Debtor, v. Jai Narain Hanuman Das…Decree-Holder, . | Authority for permitting attachment notwithstanding territorial limits under the circumstances. | Adopted and relied upon by this Court; the Judge was in respectful agreement with the Allahabad Division Bench view. |
| Promothanath Malia v. H.V Low & Co. | Supports the exception that a receiver appointed under s. 51(d) C.P.C. may deal with properties outside the local jurisdiction. | Used to illustrate that exceptions to territoriality exist and to analogize the position under O.21, R.52 C.P.C. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court observed that the Code of Civil Procedure does not explicitly prohibit execution against properties situated outside the executing court's local limits, though the general rule of territorial jurisdiction governs suits and executions. The Court identified recognized exceptions to territoriality: a receiver under s. 51(d) C.P.C. (citing Promothanath Malia v. H.V Low & Co.) and the provision in O.21, R.48 for withholding government or analogous salaries irrespective of local limits.
The Court analyzed O.21, R.52 C.P.C. and found its mode of attachment differs from ordinary attachment under O.21, R.24: under R.52 actual seizure is not required; attachment is effected by notice to the court or officer having custody of the property. Because the property was already in custody of a court/officer, there was no question of physical seizure by executing-court officers who operate within local limits. On that basis the Court treated attachment under O.21, R.52 as analogous to the exception in O.21, R.48 and therefore as an exception to the general rule of territoriality.
Holding and Implications
The revision application is dismissed and the decision of the court below is confirmed.
Direct consequences: the executing court (Munsif Barmer) was held to have jurisdiction to attach the camel that was in the custody of the Sessions Court, Balotra, under Order 21, Rule 52 C.P.C.; the revision is dismissed with costs. The Court treated attachment under O.21, R.52 as an exception to the general territorial rule governing execution of decrees.
Jagat Narayan, J.:— This is a revision application by one Gayoor Ahmad Khan of Barmer against an appellate order of the District Judge, Balotra, holding that the executing court (Munsif Barmer) had jurisdiction to attach a camel which was in the custody of a court at Balotra under Order 21, Rule 52 C.P.C
2. Hazari Mal and Prabhu Lal respondents Nos. 1 and 2 have a money decree against Achar respondent No. 3. In execution of this decree a camel belonging to Achar was attached by the Amin. Achar seized the camel from the custody of the Amin by force and was prosecuted under sec. 394 I.P.C The camel was delivered in the custody of Gayoor Ahmad Khan applicant by the Sessions Court, Balotra. The decree-holders again applied for the attachment of this camel in execution of their decree under Order 21, Rule 52 G.P.C and the camel was attached. Gayoor Ahmad Khan failed to produce it before the court. Execution was then levied against Gayoor Ahmad Khan. This was resisted by him on the ground that the court at Barmer had no jurisdiction to attach the camel which was in the custody of the court at Balotra. Reliance was placed on the decision of a learned Single Judge of the Nagpur High Court in Gyarsilal v. Shankar Rao (1).
3. The appellate court overruled this objection relying on the decision of a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court in Bhagwati Prasad Bajpai…Judgment-Debtor, v. Jai Narain Hanuman Das…Decree-Holder, . (2).
4. I have carefully considered both these decisions and am in respectful agreement with the view taken in the Allahabad case. The Code of Civil Procedure does not specifically provide that execution cannot be had against properties situated outside the jurisdiction of the executing court to which an application is made, yet it has been recognised that the rule of territorial jurisdiction which governs suits also governs execution of decrees. However there are exceptions to this rule. One of these exceptions is that a receiver appointed by the court under sec. 51(d) C.P.C can deal with properties situated outside the local limits of the jurisdiction of the executing court. See Promothanath Malia v. H.V Low & Co.(3) O. 21, R. 48 C.P.C contains another exception. It is provided in it that where the property to be attached is salary or allowances of a Government servant or the servant of a railway company or local authority, the court may order that the amount shall be withheld from such salary or allowances either in one payment or by monthly instalments as the court may direct, whether the judgment-debtor or the disbursing officer is or is not within the local limits of the court's jurisdiction. The mode of attachment under O. 21, R. 52 C.P.C is different from the mode of attachment in ordinary cases for which provision is made in O. 21, R. 24. Actual seizure of the property is not required under O. 21 R. 52 C.P.C The attachment is made by a notice to the court of officer having custody of the property. As the property is already in the custody of a court or a public officer no question of actual seizure of the property arises. Actual seizure is made by the officers of the executing court who normally function within the local limits of its jurisdiction. As actual seizure is not necessary in case of attachment under O. 21, R. 52 C.P.C the procedure is more or less analogous to that under O. 21, R. 48 C.P.C Execution by attachment under O. 21, R. 52 C.P.C is also to be treated as an exception to the general rule of territoriality.
5. I accordingly confirm the decision of the court below and dismiss the revision application with costs.
Alert