Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Chiranjilal Sharma v. Raja Ramsingh Opposite Party.

Rajasthan High Court
Mar 19, 1964
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 8 June 1963 Raja Ramsingh (the complainant) filed a complaint under Sections 420, 120-B and 406 of the Indian Penal Code against Chiranjilal (the petitioner) and others. The complaint alleged that after the complainant's retirement he entered into a partnership with the petitioner (partnership deed dated 6 September 1962) to run a transport business (Associated Transport Operators). A truck (No. RJL 5047) was purchased for Rs. 19,500 from Madhesingh; the complainant alleged that the petitioner did not pay his full agreed share (paid only Rs. 2,000 initially) and urged the complainant to make payments with a promise to reimburse him later. It was alleged that the petitioner later took management control, kept partnership accounts, failed to render accounts or distribute profits, removed partnership books, removed the truck from the workshop without permission and concealed its whereabouts, and that the complainant was beaten and a false police report lodged against him.

The learned Munsif Magistrate recorded statements of the complainant and a witness, and on 8 July 1963 registered a case under Section 420, IPC and issued bailable warrants. The petitioner filed a revision before the Additional Sessions Judge, Jaipur City, which was dismissed. The petitioner then applied to the High Court under Section 561-A CrPC seeking quashing of the criminal proceedings that were pending in the Court of the Additional Munsif Magistrate, Jaipur East.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the face of the complaint and without further evidence, the allegations disclose an offence punishable under Section 420, Indian Penal Code.
  2. Whether the allegations in the complaint disclose an offence of criminal breach of trust punishable under Section 406 (and more generally Section 405) of the Indian Penal Code against a partner in respect of partnership assets and books.
  3. Whether the inherent jurisdiction to quash proceedings (under Section 561-A CrPC) should be exercised where the complaint, taken at face value, does not disclose any offence.

Arguments of the Parties

Complainant's Arguments

  • The complaint alleged that the petitioner induced the complainant to pay more than his agreed share for the truck, took management control, retained all profits, did not render accounts, caused disappearance of account books, removed the truck without permission, and concealed its whereabouts.
  • Although the complaint originally charged Sections 420, 120-B and 406, the complainant (through his counsel) conceded before the High Court that the facts would not make out an offence under Section 420, IPC, but urged that the facts disclosed an offence of criminal breach of trust under Section 406, IPC.
  • The complainant requested the Magistrate to issue a warrant for seizure of the truck once it was admitted the truck was at Pilani.

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner challenged the registration under Section 420 and sought quashing of proceedings under Section 561-A CrPC on the ground that the facts alleged did not constitute any offence.
  • The petitioner relied upon authorities (including the Calcutta Full Bench case Bhuban Mohan Das v. Surendra Mohan Das) and contended that the proper remedy for the complainant was a civil suit for accounts/dissolution rather than criminal prosecution; the opinion records that the petitioner’s counsel relied on the Bhuban Mohan Das decision.
  • It was also argued (in substance through the authorities relied upon) that partners being joint owners may retain books and that criminal liability for withholding accounts or books is not made out unless misappropriation or dishonest conversion is shown.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R.P. Kapur v. State of Punjab, AIR 1960 SC 866 The inherent jurisdiction to quash proceedings may be exercised where the allegations in the FIR or complaint, taken at face value, do not constitute an offence; in such cases no appreciation of evidence is necessary. The Court applied this principle as the threshold for considering whether the complaint, on its face, disclosed any offence and thus whether to exercise the quashing jurisdiction under Section 561-A CrPC.
R.K. Dalmia v. Delhi Administration, AIR 1962 SC 1821 Approval of earlier Full Bench observations that Section 405 (criminal breach of trust) can include a partner if he was entrusted with partnership property or dominion over it and dishonestly misappropriated it. The Court relied on this authority (and the quoted Full Bench passage) to acknowledge the legal proposition that a partner may be prosecuted under Section 405/406 if entrusted property is dishonestly misappropriated.
Queen v. Okhoy Coomar Shaw (Full Bench, Calcutta), 21 Suth WR Cr. 59 Section 405 is broad enough to include a partner entrusted with partnership property or dominion who dishonestly misappropriates it. Quoted (via R.K. Dalmia) to establish that criminal breach of trust can, in principle, apply to partners where entrustment and dishonest misappropriation are shown.
Raghunath Das & Others v. Emperor, AIR 1932 Bom 57 Beaumont, C.J.'s view that where one partner is given authority by others to collect moneys or property of the firm he is entrusted with dominion and may be liable under Section 405 if he dishonestly misappropriates. The Court cited this to support the legal test that entrustment and dishonest misappropriation are required elements to convict a partner under Section 405.
Bhuban Mohan Das v. Surendra Mohan Das, AIR 1951 Cal 69 Authority concerning partners and alleged wrongful withholding of accounts/books; relied upon by the petitioner. The Court noted that this Full Bench decision (relied upon by the petitioner) did not lay down an absolute proposition that a charge under Section 405 can never be made out against a partner; it did not support the petitioner's extreme position.
Man Mohan Das & Ors. v. Mohendra Bhowal, AIR 1948 Cal 292 Partners cannot be prosecuted under Section 424 (and by analogy under sections dealing with criminal breach of trust) for concealing or removing partnership books; partners being joint owners are entitled to retain books; proper remedy is a partnership suit for dissolution and account. The Court relied on this authority to conclude that allegations of withholding books or not rendering accounts (absent proof of misappropriation/conversion) do not ordinarily constitute an offence under Section 406 and that the civil remedy of a suit for accounts is appropriate.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by acknowledging the general reluctance to interfere at an interlocutory stage under Section 561-A CrPC, but accepted the binding proposition from R.P. Kapur that quashing is appropriate where the complaint, taken at face value, discloses no offence. Applying that standard, the Court examined whether the allegations in the complaint, without recourse to evidence, constituted any cognizable offence.

First, the Court addressed the registration under Section 420, IPC. It noted that the complainant admitted the truck was bought for Rs. 19,500 and that the payment was made in performance of the mutual agreement. The complainant's counsel also conceded that on the facts alleged an offence under Section 420 would not be made out. Consequently the Court found Section 420 inapplicable.

Second, the Court considered whether the facts disclosed criminal breach of trust under Section 405/406, IPC. The Court accepted the legal position (supported by cited authorities) that a partner can be guilty of criminal breach of trust if it is shown that he was entrusted with partnership property or had dominion over it and that he dishonestly misappropriated or converted it to his own use. However, applying that principle to the complaint's allegations, the Court found material factual deficiencies:

  • The allegations that profits were retained by the petitioner were vague—there was no assertion that profits in fact accrued, nor any quantification of amounts.
  • It was not stated that the complainant had called upon the petitioner to disclose accounts and that the petitioner refused, nor that the petitioner was under any fixed obligation to render accounts at a specific time.
  • Because the existence and extent of any profit can only be ascertained by taking accounts, the Court held that a claim for a partner’s share of profit is essentially a subject for a civil suit for accounts and possibly dissolution, not for criminal proceedings.
  • As to the alleged removal or concealment of partnership books, the Court observed (following Calcutta decisions) that partners are joint owners of partnership books and are entitled to retain them; merely withholding such books is not in itself dishonest or fraudulent.
  • Regarding the truck, the complaint itself admitted (and the complainant later affirmed) that the truck was at Pilani in the possession of the petitioner. There was no allegation of misappropriation or conversion of the truck to the petitioner’s own use. Mere removal without proof of dishonest misappropriation did not constitute criminal breach of trust.

Weighing these points, the Court concluded that the complaint, on its face, did not disclose an offence under Section 406 (or Section 405) because the essential element of dishonest misappropriation/conversion was not pleaded, and the other particulars necessary to show a criminal offence (specific sums, demand and refusal, or proof of entrustment with dominion followed by misappropriation) were missing or too vague.

Since the complaint did not disclose any offence even when accepted in entirety, the Court invoked the quashing jurisdiction under Section 561-A CrPC and allowed the application to quash the criminal proceedings pending against the petitioner in the Court of the Additional Munsif Magistrate, Jaipur East.

Holding and Implications

Revision allowed; the criminal proceedings pending against the petitioner in the Court of the Additional Munsif Magistrate, Jaipur East were quashed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The criminal proceedings against Chiranjilal, as brought in the Magistrate’s Court on the complaint, have been terminated by quashing; the warrants and the registered case under Section 420 (and any continuation of proceedings based on the impugned complaint) cannot proceed against him in that forum.
  • Remedies for the complainant: The Court indicated the proper remedy for disputes as to partnership accounts, retention of partnership books, and claims to profits is a civil suit for dissolution and rendition of accounts; the criminal forum is inappropriate where misappropriation or conversion is not alleged or established on the face of the complaint.
  • Precedential effect: The Court applied and relied upon existing authorities to resolve the matter. The decision resolves the application on the facts and applicable precedent but does not purport to lay down a novel or broader principle beyond applying settled law on quashing and the circumstances in which partners may be criminally liable.

Reported court notation in the opinion: "Revision allowed." (Final order quashing the proceedings.)

Show all summary ...

1. This is an application by Chiranjilal one of the accused under Section 561-A read with Sections 435 and 439 of the Cr PC for quashing certain criminal proceedings which are being taken against him in the Court of Additional Munsif Magistrate, Jaipur East. On 8th June, 1963, the opposite party Raja Ramsingh filed a complaint against the petitioner and others under Sections 420, 120-B and 406 of the Indian Penal Code on the following, facts, that the opposite party after his retirement from the military started transport business. The petitioner persuaded him to inter into a partnership and a partnership deed was executed between them on 6th September, 1962. The partnership was to be in the name of Associated Transport Operators. In order to carry out the business of partnership, it was agreed to purchase a truck — price of which was to be equally paid by the partners. Accordingly truck No. RJL 5047 was purchased from me Madhesingh for Rs. 19,500/-. The petitioner did not pay his share of the capital but only paid Rs. 2,000/- and urged the complainant to make the payment and promised to reimburse him later on. Subsequently Rs. 6000/- more were taken from the opposite party for being paid to Madhesingh. The petitioner took the entire management of the business in his own hands on the plea that the opposite party had not sufficient experience of the business. All the accounts were maintained by the petitioner, and for some time account books were kept at 52 Sansar Chand Road, Jaipur where opposite party was carrying on his old business. For sometime the partnership work continued but later on the petitioner told him, that the truck had gone out of order and need repairs. So the truck was left at the workshop of Fazul Uddin Mistry. In the third week of February, 1963, the opposite party cane to know that the petitioner had removed the truck from the workshop of Fazul Uddin without his permission. Although according to the agreement between the parties the truck was to run within Jaipur City only yet on enquiry the petitioner informed him that the truck was being plied at Pali where he had been able to scare same work of profit. It is further alleged in the complaint that after the purchasing of the truck whatever profits accrued in the partnership business have all been kept by the petitioner and nothing had been paid to the opposite party, nor he had rendered accounts of the same. That the petitioner in collusion with the other accused had also caused the disappearance of the account books and when the opposite party lodged a protest he was beaten and a false report was made against him in the police. It is also alleged that the petitioner was not, disclosing the whereabouts of the truck and was not prepared to return the account books of the partnership. The sum and substance of the above allegations is that:

1. The opposite party was induced to pay for the purchase of the truck more than his agreed share of money.

2. The petitioner who was maintaining the accounts and running the truck, had not rendered the accounts and had not paid the complainant's share of profits.

3. The petitioner had unlawfully taken away the books of account of the partnership and was not returning them.

4. The petitioner had removed the truck from Jaipur without the complainant's permissions and was not prepared to disclose its whereabouts.

2. The learned Munsif Magistrate recorded the statements of the complainant and of the witness Shri Pribhu Dayal. No additional facts were brought out in the statements of these two persons. The complainant however, admitted that the truck was at Pilani and requested the Court to issue a warrant for its seizure. The learned Magistrate on 8th July, 1963, having been satisfied on the above materials registered a case under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code against the accused and issued bailable warrants against them. Against that order the petitioner filed a revision application in the Court of the Additional Sessions Judge, Jaipur city on the grounds that the facts mentioned in the complaint did not constitute any offence. The learned Additional Sessions Judge did not agree with the contention and rejected the revision application.

3. On an application under Section 561-A of the Cr PC at this interlocutory stage generally this Court would be very reluctant to interfere with the proceedings which are being taken against the accused in the Court below. But as pointed out by their Lordships of the Supreme Court in R.P Kapur v. State Of Punjab., (AIR 1960 SC 866),

“there are some cases where the inherent jurisdiction to quash proceedings can and should be exercised, one of such, cases being where the allegations in the First Information Report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face value and accepted in their entirety, do not constitute the offence, alleged; in such cases no question of appreciating evidence arises; it is a matter merely of looking at the complaint or the First Information Report to decide, whether the offence alleged is disclosed or not.”

4. Now it is to be seen in the light of these observations whether the allegations made in the complaint constitute any offence or not. As already stated the learned Magistrate has registered the case against the accused only under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code. It is not the complainant's case that he was deceived to pay Rs. 14,000/- for the price of the truck or that he was fraudulently or dishonestly induced to pay that amount but it was in performance of their mutual agreement. Paragraph 7 of the partnership agreement which was produced by the complainant in the Court below recites that:

“The Capital of the partnership shall be contributed by the parties by mutual agreement. And the shares of the parties in the profits and losses of the partnership shall be as under:

First party 50% Second party 50%”

5. It is admitted by the complainant that a truck was purchased by them for Rs. 19,500/- from one Madhosingh and hence no question of deception arises. Learned counsel for the complainant has frankly conceded that on the above facts offence under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code will not be made out. He however, urges that the fact mentioned in the complaint do disclose an offence of criminal breach of trust punishable under Section 406 of the Indian Penal Code. Both the learned counsel addressed lengthy arguments on the question whether a partner can be guilty of a charge of criminal breach of trust in respect of the partnership assets. It is unnecessary to discuss all the cases relied upon by the parties in this connection in view of the observations of the Supreme Court in R.K Dalmia v. Delhi Administration, AIR 1962 SC 1821 where their Lordships quoted with approval the following observations from a Full Bench case of the Calcutta High Court in Queen v. Okhoy Coomar Shaw, 21 Suth WR Cr. 59 at p. 61 (FB).

“We think the words of Section 405 of the Penal Code are large enough to include the case of a partner, if it be proved that he was in fact entrusted with the partnership property, or with a dominion over it, and had dishonestly misappropriated it or converted it to his own use.”

6. And further the following observations by Beaumont, C.J in the case of Raghunath Das & Others…Applicants; v. Emperor…Opposite Party., AIR 1932 Bom 57:

“In my opinion, the words of the section (S. 405) are quite wide enough to cover the case of a partner. Where one partner is gives authority by the other partners to collect moneys or property of the firm I think that he is entrusted with dominion over that property, and if he dishonestly misappropriates it, then I think he comes within the section.”

7. Thus from the above it follows that even a partner can be guilty of a charge under Section 405 of the Indian Penal Code in case where he is found to have been entrusted with property or dominion over that property and is further shown to have dishonestly misappropriated it.

8. Learned counsel for the petitioner has not been able to cite any decision to show that in no case a charge under Section 405 can be made out against a partner. The full Bench case of the Calcutta High Court in Bhuban Mohan Das v. Surendra Mohan Das, AIR 1951 Cal 69 on which reliance has been, placed on behalf of the petitioner also does not lay down that extreme proposition of law. Judged in this light the question is whether the facts alleged in the complaint constitute an offence under Section 405 of the Indian Penal Code. As regards the allegation that the petitioner had not paid his share of profits to the complainant and had not rendered the accounts and had further concealed the partnership books it may be pointed out that the allegations in that behalf are in the first instance quite vague. It is not stated in the complaint that any profits have, as a matter of fact, accrued in the partnership business. If so what is their extent. It is not stated that the complainant ever called upon the petitioner to disclose the state of accounts and he failed to do so. It is also not stated that the petitioner was to render accounts at any particular time. In the absence of the above particulars it is difficult to say whether there have been any profits in the partnership business at all and the petitioner had wrongly withheld the share of the complainant out of it. But even if it be assumed that the petitioner has failed to render accounts and has concealed the partnership books, it would not bring the case within Section 406 of the Indian Penal Code. The partners are joint owners of the partnership assets and each is only entitled to such part of the profits as on account would show is due to him. If he desires to claim what he alleges is due to him from the other partners he must file a partnership suit, claim a dissolution of partnership and an account and payment to him of what is found due on taking the account. The only sum due from one partner to another is what is shown to be due to him after taking account of all the partnership transactions. Whether or not the partnership made a profit in a particular year can only be ascertained on taking an account and it is only after taking such an account that it can be said that any sum whatsoever was due to the opposite party. It cannot possibly be a criminal offence to withhold payment in the circumstances” (See Man Mohan Das & Ors.…Accused, v. Mohendra Bhowal…Complainant, Opposite Party.*, AIR 1948 Cal 292).

9. It was further observed in the above case that:

“A partner cannot be prosecuted under Section 424 for dishonestly and fraudulently concealing or removing the books of the partnership.

10. Partners who are joint owners of books are entitled to retain them and the complaining partner has no more right to the books than the partner who has them in his possession. All that the former is entitled to is inspection of these books. There is nothing dishonest or fraudulent in the partner retaining these books. The proper remedy is a partnership suit claiming dissolution and account and thus obtaining an order for production and inspection of these books.”

11. The above case is a dear authority for the proposition that a partner cannot be held liable for a charge under Section 406 of the Indian Penal Code for not rendering accounts to any partner and for withholding the share of profits of the other partner when the accounts have not been gone into and it has not been ascertained whether there have been any profits in the partnership business at all and what sum is due to the complainant in these profits. With respect I agree with the view taken in the above mentioned case. It is not the function of a criminal Court to go into the accounts of partnership and determine the specific amount due to one partner from the other for his share of profits. This can only be done by a civil Court in a suit for accounts. In such circumstances the case of the petitioner so far as the above allegations are concerned, would not come under Section 406 of the Indian Penal Code. The proper remedy for the complainant is to file a suit for dissolution of the partnership and rendition of accounts, against the petitioner. At this stage the amount of his share of profits cannot be predicted.

12. The next allegation against the petitioner is that he had removed the truck from Jaipur city without the permission of the complainant and was not disclosing its whereabouts. It would appear from the statement of facts given above that the truck was alleged to have been taken away from the workshop of Fazal Uddin in the third week of February, 1963. Thereafter the complainant was informed by the petitioner that it was plying at Pali because he had been able to secure some profitable work there. It is not alleged in the complaint that the complainant was not satisfied with this explanation and raised any further objection against the removal of the truck. For an offence of criminal breach of trust besides showing that the property was entrusted to the accused it is further necessary to show that he had dishonestly misappropriated or converted it to his own use. The complaint does not contain any allegation that the accused had misappropriated or converted the truck to his own use. It is true that direct evidence of misappropriation or conversion may sometimes not be available and may be inferred from the circumstances but even the complainant's allegation that its whereabouts were not known, is falsified by his own statement and the affidavit wherein he admits that the truck is in the possession of the accused at Pilani. In the absence of any allegation of misappropriation or conversion of the truck by the petitioner offence under Section 406, I.P.C will not be constituted. It seems that the complainant has chosen a wrong forum for the redress of his grievance. In these circumstances when the complaint does not disclose any offence, the proceedings pending against the accused cannot be allowed to continue and are therefore, quashed. This application is therefore, accepted and the proceedings pending in the Court of the Additional Munsif Magistrate, Jaipur East against the petitioner are quashed.

JH/AGJ/V.B.B

13. Revision allowed.