Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Devi Singh v. State Of Rajasthan

Rajasthan High Court
Jul 26, 1963
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Four appellants — Devisingh, Sure, Ramsingh and Bhagi (residents of Atraj-ka-pura, Tehsil Bari, District Dholpur) were tried by the Additional Sessions Judge, Dholpur for offences alleged under sections 147, 224, 307, 332 read with section 149, Indian Penal Code. The Trial Court convicted Devisingh and Sure under section 224, and Ramsingh and Bhagi under section 225, Indian Penal Code, sentencing each to a fine of Rs. 600 and, in default, rigorous imprisonment for six months; they were acquitted of the other charges.

The prosecution's factual case was that Chabraj Gujar (PW/11) filed a complaint in the Court of the Additional District Magistrate, Gwalior, accusing Devisingh and Sure of kidnapping (section 363, IPC). The Additional District Magistrate issued bailable warrants for Devisingh and Sure (Rs. 250 each) and a search warrant for the production of Mst. Gore on 11.10.60. These warrants were endorsed to the police at Panihar (Madhya Pradesh), and, according to the prosecution, were taken to Panihar Police Station and further endorsed to the Police Station, Bari (Rajasthan).

Bhagwansingh (PW/8) of Bari, with constables and personnel of the Rajasthan Armed Constabulary, went to Atraj-ka-pura about midnight. The prosecution alleges Bhagwansingh arrested Devisingh, Sure and Mst. Gore; villagers appeared armed with lathis and assaulted the police, and there was firing from both sides. Devisingh and Sure were said to have managed to secure their release from police custody and two others helped them escape. A report was made and, after investigation, the four were charged and committed to trial. Twelve prosecution witnesses were examined; the warrants could not be produced at trial (prosecution said villagers had taken them).

At trial, the accused pleaded not guilty. Devisingh admitted presence but said the police were in fact committing a dacoity, that he was slapped, fired at and injured; the other accused pleaded alibi. The trial judge rejected the defence story in part, accepting the prosecution on limited points and convicting as noted above.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the warrants issued by the Additional District Magistrate and endorsed via the Police Station, Panihar, were properly and legally endorsed to the Officer-in-charge of the Police Station, Bari (i.e., whether the endorsement to a police officer outside the local limits of the issuing court's jurisdiction was valid).
  2. Whether the general provision in section 79, Code of Criminal Procedure (which addresses execution of warrants by a police officer or by other police officers whose names are endorsed), is controlled or limited by the special provisions governing execution of warrants outside the local limits of the issuing court's jurisdiction contained in sections 83 to 86, Code of Criminal Procedure.
  3. Whether, if the endorsements and consequent arrests were not lawful, convictions under sections 224 and 225, Indian Penal Code (for obstructing arrest and for assisting escape), are sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' / Defence Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Gaur)

  • The Station House Officer at Panihar (Madhya Pradesh) had no authority to endorse the warrants to the Officer-in-charge of Bari (Rajasthan); therefore Bhagwansingh (PW/8) had no authority to effect the arrests — the apprehensions were not lawful, and consequently there could be no question of obstruction of lawful arrest or escape from lawful custody.
  • Certain procedural irregularities undermined the lawfulness of the arrests: the original warrants were not produced at trial, there was no proper legal proof of valid endorsements, the police party arrived at about midnight (around 12), and although the warrants were bailable (Rs. 250), no attempt was made to obtain security from the persons sought to be arrested. These facts made the conduct of Bhagwansingh and other police-officials suspicious.

Prosecution's Case (as presented at trial)

  • Chabraj Gujar filed a complaint alleging abduction of his wife and daughter by Devisingh and Sure; the ADM issued bailable warrants and a search warrant and these were endorsed to the Police Station, Panihar and then sent to Bari for execution.
  • Bhagwansingh and his party reached Atraj-ka-pura at about midnight, arrested the named persons (including Mst. Gore) and Heera (on an earlier tehrir), and villagers armed with lathis attacked the police; firing occurred and Devisingh was injured. Devisingh and Sure secured their release and escaped.
  • The police registered the incident, investigated and charged the four appellants. The warrants were not produced at trial because, according to the prosecution, villagers had taken them away.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed the determinative point: whether the warrants were properly and legally endorsed to the Officer-in-charge of Police Station, Bari. The analysis focused on the relationship between the general provision in section 79, Code of Criminal Procedure (authority for execution of warrants by a police officer or by others whose names are endorsed), and the special provisions in sections 83 to 86, Cr.P.C., which prescribe the procedure for execution of warrants outside the local limits of the issuing court's jurisdiction.

The court examined the alternatives provided by section 83: when a warrant is to be executed outside the issuing court's local limits, the court may either (1) forward the warrant by post or otherwise to a Magistrate, the District Superintendent of Police, or the Commissioner of Police within whose jurisdiction it is to be executed, or (2) direct the warrant to a police officer exercising powers within the local limits where it is to be executed.

If the first alternative is adopted, that authority (Magistrate/DSP/Commissioner) may direct it to a police officer and execution proceeds in accordance with section 79. If the second alternative is adopted, then section 84 applies. Section 84 was quoted and analyzed: it ordinarily requires the police officer to take the warrant for endorsement either to a Magistrate or to a police-officer not below the rank of officer-in-charge of a station within whose local limits execution is to occur; such endorsement suffices as authority to execute; sub‑section (3) permits execution without such endorsement only when delay in obtaining endorsement would prevent execution.

The court concluded that a proper analysis of section 84 demonstrates that the police officer to whom a warrant is directed must obtain the endorsement of a Magistrate or an appropriate police officer within the jurisdiction where execution is to happen, except in the special circumstances of sub‑section (3). The court held that the special provisions in sections 83–86, which prescribe detailed procedure for execution outside local limits, limit and control the general provision in section 79.

Applying this interpretation, the court found that it was not contemplated that the officer to whom a warrant is directed could endorse it to any police officer discharging duties outside the limits of the issuing court's jurisdiction. Rather, if the issuing court wanted the procedure of section 79 followed, it should have forwarded the warrant to one of the authorities indicated in section 83.

On this basis the court concluded that the endorsements by the Officer-in-charge of Police Station, Panihar to the Officer-in-charge of Police Station, Bari were ineffective — Bhagwansingh and the Bari police therefore had no authority to effect the arrests of Devisingh, Sure or Mst. Gore. Because the arrests were not lawful under the court's statutory interpretation, the court found the convictions under section 224 (for resisting/obstructing lawful apprehension) and section 225 (for rescuing or attempting to rescue a person lawfully apprehended) could not be sustained.

The court noted the defence's other objections (non-production of original warrants, lack of proof of endorsements, late-night approach, and failure to seek security for bailable warrants) but expressly declined to examine these further because it found the arrests unlawful on the basis of sections 83–86 Cr.P.C.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is accepted; the convictions and sentences against the appellants are set aside.

Implications:

  • The court held that endorsements of warrants across jurisdictions in the circumstances of this case (Panihar to Bari) were ineffective and that the Bari police had no lawful authority to arrest the appellants.
  • Because the apprehensions were held to be not lawful under the court's interpretation of sections 83–86, Code of Criminal Procedure, the convictions under section 224 and section 225, Indian Penal Code, were unsustainable and were quashed.
  • Direct effect on the parties: the convictions and sentences imposed by the trial court against Devisingh, Sure, Ramsingh and Bhagi were set aside and the appellants were relieved of those convictions and sentences.
  • No broader precedent beyond the statutory interpretation applied is explicitly discussed in the opinion; the decision's practical consequence reported in this opinion is the quashing of the convictions in these particular proceedings.

Show all summary ...

Chhangani, J.:— The four appellants before me, Devisingh, Sure, Ramsingh and Bhagi, Gujars, residents of Atraj-ka-pura, Tehsil Bari, District Dholpur, were tried by the Additional Sessions Judge, Dholpur, for offences under sec. 147,224, 307, 332 read with sec. 149, Indian Penal Code. The Additional Sessions Judge convicted Devisingh and Sure under sec. 224 and Ramsingh and Bhogi under sec. 225, Indian Penal Code and sentenced each one of them to a fine of Rs. 600/- and, in default, rigorous imprisonment for six months. They were acquitted of all other offences.

2. The prosecution case was that one Chabraj Gujar PW/11 of Nayagaon, Madhya Pradesh, filed a complaint against Devisingh and Sure in the Court of Additional District Magistrate, Gwalior accusing them of an offence under sec. 363, Indian Penal Code. According to him, his wife Mst. Gore and daughter were kidnapped or abducted by these persons and were being kept in wrongful confinement. The Additional District Magistrate passed an order on 11.10.60 directing the issue of bailable warrants of arrests in the amount of Rs. 250/- each for the arrest of Devisingh and Sure. He also directed issue of a search warrant under sec. 100, Criminal Procedure Code, for the arrest and production of Mst. Gore. These warrants were endorsed to the Police Officer incharge of the Police Station, Panihar (Madhya Pradesh). According to prosecution, Chabraj took these warrants to the Police Station, Panihar. The Police Station, Panihar endorsed them to the Police Officer, incharge of Police Station, Bari in Rajasthan. After receipt of the warrants at Police Station, Bari, Bhagwansingh PW/8 along with some police constables and certain police officials of the Rajasthan Armed Constabulary left the Police Station for executing the warrants. They reached Atraj-ka-pura at about 12 in the night. Bhagwansingh, the prosecution further alleged, arrested Devisingh and Sure and also Mst. Gore. It may be mentioned here that the Police Station, Bari had about one year before the incident, received a tehrir from Police Station, Madrail for the arrest of Heera. Heera also happened to be available at that time and he was also arrested. Devisingh. Sure and Gore asked Bhagwansingh and other police officials to release them and failing to secure the release they cried for help when some 20 to 25 villagers of Atraj-ka-pura armed with Lathies appeared on the scene and assaulted Bhagwansingh and other police officials. According to prosecution there was some firing also on the side of the villagers and the police had also opened fire in defence of which accused Devisingh is alleged to have been injured during the incident. The two appellants. Sure and Devisingh, thus managed to secure their release from the police custody. A report of the incident was made at the Police Station, Bari and after investigation, the four appellants were challaned and eventually committed for trial to the court of Additional Sessions Judge. At the trial, the prosecution examined twelve witnesses. The warrants of arrest as also the warrant for search could not be produced because, according to prosecution, they were taken away by the villagers.

3. The accused pleaded not guilty. The appellant Devisingh admitted his presence in the village at the time of the incident but he came forward with a counter version. According to him, the police officials had gone to the village Atraj-ka-pura to commit a dacoity. He was then sleeping in his room and was awakened and was enquired as to where the house of Roshan Seth was. He replied that he (Roshan Seth) had gone to Bari. Thereupon, he was slapped. He then filed away fearing that he would be killed. There was a cry in the village that dacoits had arrived in the village. Thereafter the dacoits, that is, police officials fired at the villagers. A gun was fired at him and he was injured and fell down. The Police officials then filed away. He was then taken on a cot to Hospital.

4. The other accused pleaded alibi.

5. The trial Judge partially accepted the prosecution case and rejected the defence story altogether. According to him, there was no evidence to justify a finding that the appellants along with others attempted to kill the police officials or they formed an unlawful assembly. He, however, found that the two appellants Devisingh and Sure having been lawfully apprehended, obstructed arrest and got their release and that the two other appellants helped them in escaping from police custody.

6. Mr. Gaur contended that the Station House Officer, Police Station, Panihar in Madhya Pradesh had no authority to endorse the warrants to the Police Officer-in-charge of the Police Station, Bari, in Rajasthan, and consequently, Bhagwansingh PW/8 Head Constable of the Police Station, Bari had no authority to effect the arrest of the appellants. The apprehension of the appellants was, therefore, not lawful and there could be no question of their obstructing arrest or escaping from custody.

7. The point for determination, therefore, is whether the warrants were properly and legally endorsed to the Officer-in-charge of the Police Station, Bari?

8. Now, the general provisions relating to execution of warrants directed to police officers are contained in sec. 79, which provides that a warrant directed to any police officer may not only be executed by him but may be executed by any other police officer whose name is endorsed upon the warrant by the officer to whom it is directed or endorsed. The further question then emerging for determination is: whether this general provision is controlled or limited by the special provisions relating to the execution of warrants outside the local limits of the jurisdiction of the court issuing the warrant contained in sec. 83 to 86, Code of Criminal Procedure. Sec. 83 provides two alternatives to be adopted by a court issuing a warrant to be executed outside the local limits of it's jurisdiction (1) a court may, instead of directing such warrant to a police-officer, forward the same by post or otherwise to any Magistrate or District Superintendent of Police or the Commissioner of Police in a Presidency town within the local limits of whose jurisdiction it is to be executed. (2) He may direct a warrant to a police-officer exercising powers within the local limits of his jurisdiction for execution.

9. If the first alternative is adopted, the Magistrate or District Superintendent of Police or the Commissioner of Police, as the case may be, may direct it to a police officer and the warrant may be executed in accordance with the provisions of sec. 79. Code of Criminal Procedure.

10. If the other alternative is adopted, then sec. 84 comes into operation, which provides as follows—

“(1) When a warrant directed to a police officer is to be executed beyond the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court issuing the same, he shall ordinarily take it for endorsement either to a Magistrate or to a police-officer not below the rank of an officer in charge of a station, within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the warrant is to be executed.

(2) Such Magistrate or police-officer shall endorse his name thereon and such endorsement shall be sufficient authority to the police-officer to whom the warrant is directed to execute the same within such limits, and the local police shall, if so required, assist such officer in executing such warrant.

(3) Whenever there is reason to believe that the delay occasioned by obtaining the endorsement of the Magistrate or police-officer within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the warrant is to be executed, will prevent such execution, the police officer to whom it is directed may execute the same without such endorsement in any place beyond the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court which issued it.

(4) This section applies also to the police in the town of Calcutta.”

A proper analysis of sec. 84, Cr. P.C will show that the police officer directed to execute a warrant is himself to execute the warrant but in order to acquire an authority to execute a warrant, he must obtain an endorsement of the Magistrate or police officer, not below the rank of police-officer, incharge of a station within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the warrant is to be executed. Under special circumstances mentioned in sec. 84, sub-sec. (3) he may directly execute the warrant. Sec. 85 provides for the production of a person arrested outside the local limits of the court's jurisdiction to be produced before the Magistrate, the District Superintendent of Police or the Commissioner of Police, within the local limits of whose jurisdiction the arrest was made, except when the court issuing the warrant is within twenty miles of the place of arrest or is nearer than the Magistrate or District Superintendent of Police or the Commissioner of Police. Under sec. 86, the Magistrate or District Superintendent or Commissioner of Police before whom the person is arrested in execution of the warrant shall ascertain whether the person arrested appears to be the person intended by the Court which issued the warrant. If it so appears, then the person shall be removed in custody to such Court. The purpose seems to be that if a person is arrested outside the local limits of a court's jurisdiction, then one of the three authorities mentioned in sec. 85 and 86 should be satisfied that the person arrested appears to be the person intended to be arrested. These special provisions prescribing in detail the procedure to be adopted for execution of warrants outside the local limits of the jurisdiction of the court issuing the same must, in my opinion, be deemed to limit and control sec. 79 and the position appears to be that a police officer whom warrant is directed for execution outside the local limits of the jurisdiction of the court issuing the same must execute it in accordance with the provisions of sec. 84, and it is not contemplated that he can endorse it to any police officer discharging duties outside the limits of the jurisdiction of the court issuing the same. If the court issuing a warrant desires that the procedure laid down under sec. 79 be adopted it should send the warrant by post or otherwise to one of the authorities indicated in sec. 83. This being the position under the law, I am inclined to take the view that the endorsements of warrants by the police officer-in-charge of the Police Station, Paniharin Madhya Pradesh to the Police Officer-in-charge of Police Station, Bari in Rajasthan were wholly ineffective and the police officer of the Police Station, Bari acquired no authority to effect arrest of Devisingh, sure or Mst. Gore. The apprehension of Devisingh, and Sure by them was thus not lawful.

11. Mr. Gaur also emphasised certain other facts relating to the irregularities committed in effecting the arrest. It was pointed out that original warrants had not been produced and that there is no proper legal proof of valid endorsements. It was also contended that the police party reached at Atraj-ka-pura at 12 in the night to effect execution of the bailable warrants. Further, although the warrants were bailable in the amount of Rs. 250/- only no attempt was made by the police official executing warrants to obtain security from persons sought to be arrested. On the basis of these facts, it was pointed out that the conduct of Bhagwansingh and other police-officials accompanying him was highly suspicious.

12. As the apprehension of Devisingh and Sure has been found to be not lawful on the interpretation of sections 83 to 86 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, I do not propose to examine these questions. The apprehension of the appellants by the police was not lawful and looking to the odd hour at which these persons were sought to be arrested, the appellant Devisingh and Sure cannot be said to be unjustified in avoiding or even obstructing their arrest. In this view of the matter, their conviction under section 224, Indian Penal Code, is not sustainable. On the same grounds, the conviction of the other two persons under Section 225, Indian Penal Code cannot be maintained.

13. In the result, the appeal is accepted and the convictions and sentences against the appellants are set aside.