Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Jaidayal Shanti Kumar v. Gajadhar

Rajasthan High Court
Mar 1, 1956
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These are two connected civil references made by the Board of Revenue to the High Court under section 57 of the Stamp Act as adapted to Rajasthan. Two suits were pending before the Civil Judge, Gangapur, concerning two Hundis that allegedly bore stamps of sufficient amount but of an improper description. The plaintiffs in those suits applied to the Collector for a certificate under section 37 of the Stamp Act (a certificate that an instrument bearing a stamp of sufficient amount but of improper description may be certified as duly stamped upon payment of the duty).

The Collector refused to grant the certificate, holding that he could not issue such a certificate until rules were framed by the State Government and that the pre-existing Jaipur Stamp Rules did not continue in force after the Rajasthan Act came into effect. The plaintiffs then brought the matter to the Board of Revenue under section 56(1) of the Stamp Act. The Board made the present references under section 57, taking the view that the Jaipur Stamp Rules did continue in force by virtue of the first proviso to section 6 of the Rajasthan Act, and requested the High Court to declare the law and issue necessary directions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Board of Revenue had jurisdiction to make a reference under section 57 of the Stamp Act where the Collector had already decided the application under section 37 (i.e., whether the Board may interfere or revise Collector's orders after they have been made under the powers covered by section 56(1)).
  2. Whether the Jaipur Stamp Rules remained in force after the coming into force of the Rajasthan Act by virtue of the first proviso to section 6 of the Rajasthan Act, thereby permitting the Collector (or Board) to issue certificates under section 37 in accordance with those rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Bhagwan Sahai (Opposite Party) — Preliminary Objection

  • The Board of Revenue had no jurisdiction to make the reference under section 57 because the Collector had already decided the matter; therefore nothing was then pending before the Collector.
  • Because nothing was pending, the Board could not interfere under section 56 and consequently could not make a reference under section 57.
  • Reliance was placed on several authorities (cases) concerning the effect of section 40(2) of the Stamp Act to support the contention that certain Collector certificates are conclusive and not open to revision.

Board of Revenue / Plaintiffs (as described in the opinion)

  • The Board considered that the Jaipur Stamp Rules continued in force after the Rajasthan Act by reason of the first proviso to section 6 of the Rajasthan Act and that, since those rules authorized the Collector to grant certificates under section 37, the Collector should have granted the certificates.
  • The Board treated the matter as having come to its notice under section 56(1) and therefore proceeded to make references under section 57, seeking directions from the High Court and a declaration of law.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Case No. 14 of 1901 (Madras) — stated under sec. 57 of Act II of 1899 (Stamp Act) Consideration of whether the Board (or High Court) can interfere with Collector's certificate under provisions analogous to sec. 40; three-judge disagreement on whether Board may revise after Collector's decision (Moore, J. took a permissive view; another judge thought sec.40(2) makes Collector's certificate conclusive). The Court reviewed the conflicting views and held Moore, J.'s view to be the correct view for present purposes: the Board may interfere with Collector's orders that fall within sec.56(1), subject to other provisions of the Act that make Collector's order conclusive.
Khub Chand (Special Bench decision) Addressed a case under sec.40(1)(b); the decision treated sec.40(2) as making the certificate conclusive (though the Court here notes this was a mistake since sec.40(2) does not refer to sec.40(1)(b)). The Court observed that because of the mistake in applying sec.40(2) to sec.40(1)(b), the authority of Khub Chand is of little value for the present question.
Usuf Dadabhai v. Chand Mahomed Case under sec.37 where Collector had allowed proper stamps and, subsequently, Board made a reference though documents had been admitted in evidence and a decree passed; principle that an abstract question cannot be referred where no pending case exists before Chief Revenue Authority. The Court considered this inapplicable to the present contention on interpretation of sec.56(1) and said the view in that case has no relevance to the present issue.
In re Cook & Kelvey Involved determination under sec.31 (Chapter III); Board made reference before Collector impounded the document; issue whether sec.56(1) applied (it does not to Chapter III). The Court held that this case is not helpful for interpreting sec.56(1) because sec.56(1) does not apply to matters under Chapter III (sec.31).
Thakurdas v. The Crown Held that sub-sec. (1) of sec.56 confers wide powers on the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority to interfere with Collector's orders and to make references under sec.57; Madras case distinguished. The Court relied on and approved this view as supporting the conclusion that sec.56(1) confers revisory jurisdiction on the Board over Collector's orders within its ambit.
Kedarmal Raghunath v. Ratiram Noted that a Collector's certificate under sec.40(1)(a) is final; suggested that an order under sec.40(1)(b) might also be final, but did not directly address sec.56(1) powers. The Court observed that this case did not deal specifically with the Board's powers under sec.56(1), and so it does not determine the present issue.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in two principal strands of analysis: (A) the scope of the Board of Revenue's jurisdiction under section 56(1) (and the competence to make a reference under section 57), and (B) the continued force of the Jaipur Stamp Rules after the Rajasthan Act.

A. Jurisdiction under sections 56(1) and 57 — The Court observed that section 57 empowers the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority (the Board of Revenue) to state any case to the High Court which may have been referred to it under section 56(2) or which otherwise comes to its notice. The present matter came to the Board otherwise (not under sec.56(2)). The Court held that section 57 is expressed in wide terms and that all that is necessary for a reference to be competent is that there should be a case pending before some revenue authority to enable that authority, under section 59(2), to dispose of the case conformably to the judgment of the High Court.

The Court then examined the language of section 56(1), which subjects the powers exercisable by a Collector under Chapters IV and V (and under the clause mentioned) to the control of the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority. Rejecting a narrow reading urged by the opposite party (that the words "powers exercisable by a Collector" mean the Board may only act before the Collector exercises them), the Court concluded that section 56(1) confers revisory jurisdiction on the Board: the Board may interfere either before or after the Collector exercises those powers, provided no other provision of the Stamp Act makes the Collector's order conclusive (for example, where sec.40(2) makes a certificate conclusive).

The Court reviewed precedent authorities. It found (i) the Madras case contained differing judicial views but endorsed Moore, J.'s permissive approach; (ii) some earlier decisions were inapposite because they concerned provisions (like sec.31 or sec.40(2)) outside the scope of sec.56(1) or involved factual situations where no case was pending; and (iii) Thakurdas v. The Crown supported the wide revisory power of the Board. On balance the Court concluded that sec.56(1) permits revision of Collector's orders within its ambit unless a specific provision in the Stamp Act makes those orders final.

B. Continuity of the Jaipur Stamp Rules — Turning to section 37 (which permits certification only where the collecting Government has made rules to that effect), the Court accepted that a certificate can be given only if State rules exist. The Collector had refused on the ground that no State rules had been framed under the Rajasthan Act and that the Jaipur Rules had ceased to operate. The Board, however, relied on the first proviso to section 6 of the Rajasthan Act.

The Court analyzed that proviso, which declares that anything done under a prior law shall be deemed to have been done under the corresponding provision of the Indian Act as adapted to Rajasthan, and shall continue in force until superseded. The Jaipur Rules were actions taken under the Jaipur Stamp Law and are therefore deemed to have been framed under the corresponding provision of the Indian (central) Act as adapted (specifically, section 75 of the Stamp Act, which empowers Government to make rules). Concluding from this language, the Court held that the Jaipur Stamp Rules continued in force until superseded by rules made under the Rajasthan Act, and thus the Collector was incorrect in holding they were no longer in force.

Combining the two strands, the Court concluded that the Board may revise the Collector's order under section 56(1) and, when the Board receives a copy of the judgment, is entitled to deal with the pending application in conformity with the Jaipur Stamp Rules.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • The Court held that section 56(1) of the Stamp Act gives the Board of Revenue revisory jurisdiction over orders of the Collector passed under Chapters IV and V (and the clause referred to), and that the Board may interfere either before or after the Collector has exercised those powers, except where other provisions of the Stamp Act make a Collector's order conclusive (for example, by sec.40(2)).
  • The Court held that the Jaipur Stamp Rules continue in force after the coming into force of the Rajasthan Act by virtue of the first proviso to section 6 of the Rajasthan Act (they are deemed to have been framed under the corresponding provision — section 75 — of the Stamp Act as adapted to Rajasthan), and consequently the Collector was incorrect in holding those rules to be no longer in force.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The Board of Revenue is entitled to revise the Collector's order refusing the certificate under section 37 and, upon receipt of a copy of this judgment, may dispose of the pending application in conformity with the Jaipur Stamp Rules under its powers pursuant to section 56(1).
  • The Court expressly limited the scope of its ruling: it did not decide issues of a different character (specifically cases coming under sections 40(1)(b) and 42), and noted that where the Stamp Act itself declares a Collector's order to be conclusive (for example sec.40(2)), revision will not be permissible.
  • The Court ordered that a copy of the judgment be sent to the Board of Revenue and made no order as to costs.

Note: This summary is strictly confined to the content and findings expressed in the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

Wanchoo, C.J:— These are two connected civil references by the Board of Revenue under sec. 57 of the Stamp act as adapted to Rajasthan by the Rajasthan Stamp Law (Adaptation) Act (No. VII of 1952) (hereinafter to be referred to as the Rajasthan Act). As the point raised in the two references is exactly the same, we propose to decided it by one judgment.

2. We set out briefly the facts which have led to these references. Two suits were pending before the Civil Judge, Gangapur on two Hundis. In both cases the Hundis are said to bear sufficient stamps but of improper description. Therefore, the plaintiffs of the two suits applied to the Collector for a certificate under sec. 37 of the Stamp Act. The Collector refused to give the certificate holding that he could not issue a certificate under that section till rules were framed by the State Government as provided therein. He was of the view that the Jaipur Stamp Rules which were in force could not be said to have continued after the coming into force of the Rajasthan Act. Thereupon, the two plaintiffs brought the matter to the notice of the Board of Revenue under sec. 56(1) of the Stamp Act and the Board has made these references under sec. 57 of the Stamp act as it is of the opinion that the Jaipur Stamp Rules continued in force after the Rajasthan Act came into force by virtue of this first proviso to sec. 6 of the Rajasthan Act. The Board has prayed that necessary direction be issued in this matter by this Court after declaring the law.

3. A preliminary objection has been raised on behalf of Bhagwan Sahai, the opposite party, that the Board has no jurisdiction to make a reference to this Court under sec. 57 of the Stamp act, and the argument is that the Collector having decided the matter, there is nothing pending before him, and the Board has no jurisdiction to interfere under sec. 56 and therefore cannot make a reference under sec. 57. In support of this argument reliance is placed on a number of cases relating to sec. 40 sub-sec. (2) of the Stamp Act.

4. Sec. 57 gives power to the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, namely, the Board of Revenue, to state any case to this Court, which may have been referred to it under sec. 56(2) or which might have otherwise comes to its notice. The present is not a case referred to the Board under sec. 56(2). It is a case which came to its notice otherwise. The power of the Board to make a reference to this Court under sec. 57 is in very wide term, and it can refer any case to this Court which comes otherwise to its notice. All that is necessary to make a reference competent is that there should be a case pending before any revenue authority in order to enable it under sec. 59(2) of the Stamp Act to dispose of the case conformably to the judgment of the High Court, which is to be forwarded to the Revenue Authority.

5. This raises the question whether a case can be said to be pending before the Board of Revenue Authority that has made the reference. In order to decide this, we have to consider what are the powers of the Board of Revenue as the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority under sec. 56(1) of the Act. That section reads as follows—

“The power exercisable by a Collector under Chapter IV and V, and under cl. (a) of the first proviso to sec. 56 shall in all cases be subject to the control of the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority.”

The present is a case under sec. 37 which falls in Chapter IV. Therefore, the powers exercisable by a Collector under sec. 37 are subject to the control of the Board of Revenue. It has, however, been contended on behalf of Bhagwan Sahai that under sec. 56(1) the Board of Revenue can only pass orders while the case is pending before the Collector and that after the Collector has decided a case under chapter IV or Chapter V, or under clause (a) of the first proviso to sec. 26, the Board of Revenue has no power to revise it. Stress in this connection is laid on the words “powers exercisable by a Collector”, and it is urged that these words mean that the Collector should not have exercised the powers, and that if he has exercised them, the Board of Revenue cannot pass any orders under sec. 56(1). We are of opinion that such a restricted meaning cannot by given to these words. What sec. 56(1), in our opinion, lays down is that the powers, which the Collector can exercise under Chapter IV and Chapter V, and under clause (a) of the first proviso to sec. 26, are subject to the control of the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority. That Authority can, in our opinion, interfere with the orders of the Collector under these provisions even after they have been made provided there is no other provision in the Stamp Act which forbids such interference. Sec. 56(1), in our opinion, gives revisory jurisdiction to the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority over those powers which the Collector can exercise under chapters IV and V, and under clause (a) of the first proviso to sec. 26. The Chief Controlling Revenue Authority may interfere before the Collector exercises those powers, or may revise them after they have been exercised under the provisions of sec. 56(1), subject always to there being nothing in other parts of the Stamps Act which prohibits such interference.

6. We may here examine certain cases which have been cited by learned counsel for Bhagwan Singh in support of his contention that the reference is incompetent because the Collector has already exercised his power under sec. 37.

7. The first case to which reference may be made is referred as case No. 14 of 1901 (1), stated under sec. 57 of Act II of 1899 (Stamp Act) by the Secretary to the commissioner of Salt, Abkari and Separate Revenue, Madras, in a letter Mis. No. G.R, 1334, dated 14th December, 1901. The case went before a Special Bench, and the facts were these. A Sub-Registrar impounded two documents which had been produced before him for registration, and forwarded them to the Deputy Collector. The Deputy Collector certified under sec. 40(1)(a) that they were exempt from stamp duty. The Inspector General of Registration disagreed with this opinion, and reported the matter to the Board of Revenue for orders. The Board of Revenue thereupon made a reference under sec. 57. It was held that the High Court had no jurisdiction to decide the question. Each of the three judges delivered a separate judgment. The Chief Justice was of opinion that the High Court had jurisdiction to decide the matter. The other two judges, however, took the view that because of the provision contained in sec. 40, sub-sec. (2), the decision of the Collector could not be interfered with because sub-sec.(2) makes every certificate under clause (a) of sub-sec. (1) of sec. 40 conclusive evidence of the matters stated therein. Further Bhashyam Ayyanagar, J. was of the opinion that the word ‘exercisable’ used in sec. 56(1) showed that the Board of Revenue could only intervene before the Collector exercised the powers, and not afterwards. Moore, J., however, was of the view that the Board could interfere with the orders of the Collector, which come within the ambit of sec. 56(1) subject to the other provisions of the Act. He was further of the view that if other provisions of the Act made the order of the Collector conclusive, the Board could not interfere. The three judges thus took three different views in this case, and with all respect we are of opinion that the view taken by Moore, J. is the correct view.

8. The next case, to which reference may be made, is in the matter of Khub Chand (1). That was also a Special Bench decision, and the Madras case cited above was relied upon. That case, however, was not a case under sec. 40(1)(a). It was a case under sec. 40(1)(b); but the learned Judges somehow say in their judgment that under sec. 40, sub-sec. (2) this certificate is, for purposes of the Stamp Act, conclusive evidence of the matter stated therein. A perusal of sec. 40, sub-sec. (2) would show that it does not refer to cases covered by sec. 40(1)(b). How the learned Judges made the mistake is difficult to say; but, in view of this mistake the value of this case is, if we may say so with respect, very little.

9. The next case is Usuf Dadabhai v. Chand Mahomed (3). That was a case under sec. 37 of the Stamp Act, and the Collector had allowed stamps of the proper description to be affixed. Thereafter, the Board of Revenue made a reference; but the documents had been admitted in evidence, and a decree had been passed on them. In those circumstances, the learned Judges held that an abstract question could not be referred when there was no pending case before the Chief Revenue Authority. The view taken in this case has no relevance to the interpretation of sec. 56(1) with which we are really concerned in the present case.

10. The next case, to which reference may be made, is In re Cook & Kelvey (4). In that case a certain instrument was presented before the Collector under sec. 31, and the Collector determined the duty with which it was chargeable. The Collector, however, did not impound the document. It may be mentioned that sec. 31 is in Chapter III, and sec. 56(1) does not apply to it. What the Board of Revenue did in that case was to make a reference before the Collector impounded the document. It was then held that the Board could not make a reference. This case also is not helpful to us for interpreting sec. 56(1).

11. The next case is Thakurdas v. The Crown (5) In that case, it was held that sub-sec. (1) of sec. 56 confers very wide powers on the Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, and it has the power to interfere with the order of the Collector in exercise of his powers under sec. 56, and also to make a reference under sec. 57. The Madras case (1) cited above was distinguished, and it was pointed out that case should only be confined to cases covered by sec. 40, sub-sec. (2). This was a case which came under sec. 40(1)(b), and was thus not covered by sec. 40, sub-sec. (2).

12. The last case, to which reference may be made, is Kedarmal Raghunath v. Ratiram (6). In that case, it was pointed out that the certificate of a Collector under sec. 40(1)(a) was final. It was also said that probably an order under sec. 40(1)(b) is also final. That case, however, did not deal specifically with the powers of the Board of Revenue under sec. 56(1).

13. On a review of these authorities, we are of opinion that sec. 56(1) gives powers to the Board to interfere with the orders of the Collector passed under Chapters IV and V, and under clause (a) of the first proviso to sec. 26, whether the Col lector is about to exercise those powers or has exercised those powers, subject however to such provisions in the Stamp Act, which declare the orders of the Collector conclusive as for example sec. 40, sub-sec. (2). We may also remark that what we have said in this case should not be taken to decide a case coming under secs. 40(1)(b) and 42, as this case is not of that type. But so far as other orders of the Collector are concerned which are within the ambit of sec. 56(1), the Board has the right to revise them if no provision of the Stamp Act makes them conclusive, and to make a reference in that connection if the matter comes to its knowledge otherwise. The matter that is pending in this case is the application before the Board requesting it to set aside the order of the Collector under sec. 37, and the Board, after it receives a copy of our judgment, would be entitled to deal with the application pending before it according to our judgment.

14. Now we come to sec. 37 itself. That section provides that the collecting Government may make rules providing that where an instrument bears a stamp of sufficient amount, but of improper description, it may on payment of the duty, with which the stamp is chargeable, be certified to be duly stamped, and any instrument so certified shall then be deemed to have been duly stamped as from the date of its execution.

15. It is clear from the words of this section that the certificate under it can only be given when there are rules framed to that effect by the State Government the Collector has refused a certificate in this case on the ground that there are no rules framed by the State Government. He has also held that the rules framed under the Jaipur Stamp Act are no longer in force. The Board of Revenue is of opinion that the rules framed under the Jaipur Stamp Law remain in force till new rules are, framed by the State of Rajasthan, and as Jaipur Stamp rules allow the Collector the certify such cases, the Collector should have proceeded accordingly.

16. We are of opinion that the view taken by the Board is correct, and does not require much authority in support of it. The first proviso to sec. 6 of the Rajasthan Act clearly saves the rules framed under the Jaipur Stamp Law till the Rajasthan State frames its own rules. The proviso is as follows—

“Provided that anything done or any action taken under any such law shall be deemed to have been done or taken under the corresponding provision of the Indian Act, and shall continue to be in force accordingly unless and until superseded by any thing done or any action taken under the Indian Act as hereby adapted to Rajasthan.”

Now the Jaipur Rules were framed under the Jaipur Stamp Act. That was an action taken under the Jaipur Stamp Law. That action would now be deemed to have been taken under the corresponding provision of the Indian Act adapted to Rajasthan namely sec. 75 of the Stamp Act which gives power to the Government to make rules to carry out generally the purposes of the Act. Therefore, the rules framed under the Jaipur Stamp Act continue to be in force under the first proviso to sec. 6 of the Rajasthan Act as having been framed under sec. 75 of the Indian Act as adapted to Rajasthan. The Collector, therefore, was not right in holding that the Jaipur rules were not in force, and he should have disposed of application made to him under sec. 37 according to Jaipur Rules. The Board of Revenue, where the matter is now pending, is entitled to revise the order of the Collector, and to pass an order in conformity with the Jaipur Stamp Rules, and dispose of the application before it under its powers under sec. 56(1) of the Stamp Act.

17. A copy of this judgment will be sent to the Board of Revenue. In the circumstances of the case, we pass no order as to costs.