Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

National Insurance Co. v. Smt. Dakhi

Rajasthan High Court
May 11, 1989
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Two appeals were before the court: Appeal No. 90 of 1985 (filed by the insurance company) and Appeal No. 97 of 1985 (filed by the owner of the vehicle) under Section 110-D of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, challenging an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Bhilwara dated 2 February 1985 in MACT Case No. 38 of 1982.

Respondent Nos. 1 to 6 had filed a petition under Section 110-A claiming Rs. 1,10,000, alleging that on 25 September 1975 at about 11:30 a.m. a bus bearing No. RSL 3301, driven by Mustaq (respondent No. 11), collided with the pedestrian Sobharam and thereafter with a field wall; Sobharam died on the spot. The owners (Nathulal, Shobhalal, Munnalal and Ganeshlal) and the driver admitted the accident but pleaded that a tie rod gave way suddenly and that the accident was due to vis major.

The insurance company acknowledged it had issued insurance in favour of the owners but contended that the accident occurred before the vehicle was insured (relying on a cover note and certificate of insurance showing issuance at 3 p.m. on 25.9.1975), and that material facts (the prior accident) had been suppressed, rendering the policy void. The Tribunal, after framing issues and recording evidence, held that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving by the bus driver, awarded Rs. 64,000 to the claimants and held the insurance company liable. Those findings gave rise to the two appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the insurance policy was effective at the time of the accident (i.e., did the insurance commence from the previous midnight on 25.9.1975 so as to make the insurer liable despite the cover note being issued at 3 p.m. on that date)?
  2. Whether the insurance company can avoid liability on the ground of suppression of a material fact (the alleged prior accident) by the insured/owners?
  3. Whether the liability of the insurance company was limited to Rs. 50,000 under Section 95 of the Act, notwithstanding the Tribunal's award amount?
  4. Whether the accident was caused by a sudden mechanical failure (tie rod giving way constituting vis major), thereby absolving the owners/driver from negligence?
  5. Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal (Rs. 64,000) was excessive or required reduction given the facts and the evidence on income, age and dependency of the deceased?

Arguments of the Parties

Insurance Company's Arguments

  • The accident occurred at about 11:30 a.m. on 25.9.1975 but the bus was insured only at 3 p.m. on 25.9.1975, as shown by the cover note (Exh. A/1), certificate of insurance (paper No. C-32/4) and the statement of the Insurance Inspector K.C. Taparia (NAW 5).
  • The Insurance Inspector (NAW 5) stated that the owners did not disclose the accident when obtaining insurance; therefore the policy was void because a material fact was concealed.
  • Since the bus was admittedly not insured at the time of the accident, the insurance company cannot be held liable to pay the compensation awarded by the Tribunal.
  • Even if some liability is found, the insurance company's liability should be limited to Rs. 50,000 as provided under Section 95(2) of the Act, and not the full amount of the award.

Owners' and Claimants' Arguments

  • The insurance policy was effective from the zero hour (midnight) of 25.9.1975, so that the policy was operative at the time of the accident; they relied on authorities including Jaikrishandas v. Chiruthai Ammal, United India Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Srinivasan, Maya Devi v. Hoob Raj and Indian Trade and General Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Shailal Maneklal Desai to support this proposition.
  • The owner Nathulal (NAW 1) deposed that he paid premium and submitted the proposal form on 24.9.1975 (not on 25.9.1975); he was not present on the bus at the time of the accident and was unaware of the accident when he procured insurance, so there was no suppression of the fact of the accident.
  • The owners/driver contended the accident was caused by an unforeseen mechanical failure—the tie rod gave way suddenly—which could not have been detected despite reasonable care, implying absence of negligence on their part.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jaikrishandas v. Chiruthai Ammal, 1984 ACJ 530 (Madras) Supports the proposition that where an insurance policy is obtained on the same date after the accident, the policy operates from the previous midnight (i.e., the zero hour), making the insurer liable. The court cited this authority (as relied on by parties) and followed its principle to hold that insurance effective from the date (midnight) would make the insurer liable despite issuance of cover note later in the day.
United India Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Srinivasan, 1980 ACJ 413 (Madras) Same proposition as above: a policy obtained on the same day after an accident can operate from the previous midnight, rendering the insurer liable. The court referenced and followed this decision together with Jaikrishandas to support the finding that the insurance commenced from midnight and that the insurer was liable.
Maya Devi v. Hoob Raj, 1988 ACJ 478 (P&H) Illustrates and applies the rule that an insurance policy obtained on the same date as an accident may operate from the previous midnight; discussed in the opinion as directly on point. The court quoted and relied on the observations in Maya Devi to hold that the insurance commenced from the previous midnight and so the insurer was liable to reimburse the insured.
Indian Trade and General Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Shailal Maneklal Desai, AIR 1964 Bombay 148 Relied upon by the owners/claimants (listed among authorities supporting the proposition that the policy was effective from zero hour). The opinion records that the owners relied on this authority in support of their contention but does not detail a separate, specific application or excerpt beyond noting it as relied upon.
Oriental Fire and General Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Satya Deo Dubey, 1981 ACJ 31 (Allahabad) Used to illustrate that where there is no evidence of proper maintenance and periodic checking of a vehicle, negligence on the part of the owner/driver is established. The court referred to this decision to support its conclusion that absence of pleading and proof of proper maintenance, coupled with evidence of defects and an old vehicle, established negligence of owner and driver.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the documentary and oral evidence on the questions of insurance commencement, suppression of facts, negligence, and the quantum of compensation.

On the question of insurance commencement and insurer's liability:

  • The cover note (Exh. A/1) and the certificate of insurance (paper No. C-32/4) record an "effective date of commencement of insurance for the purposes of the Act" as 25.9.1975 (the policy paper C-18/4-5 likewise records "Commencing date: 25.9.1975"). Although the cover note bears the time of issue as 3 p.m., the columns specify the effective date and not a commencement time.
  • The owner Nathulal (NAW 1) stated on oath that he gave the proposal form and premium on 24.9.1975; the proposal form was not produced by the insurance company. The receipt for premium (Exh. A/2) was issued on 25.9.1975 but bears no time; it must have been issued prior to the cover note and certificate.
  • The court accepted that the owner's testimony that the proposal and premium were presented on 24.9.1975 and found no credible proof of suppression of the accident. The non-production of the proposal form supported the owner's version (i.e., there was no clear evidence that the owner had concealed the accident).
  • The court relied on precedent (Jaikrishandas, United India, Maya Devi) holding that when a policy is obtained on the same date after an accident, it may operate from the previous midnight and thus make the insurer liable. Applying those authorities and the documentary entries showing the policy's effective date as 25.9.1975, the court held that the insurance was effective from the zero hour of 25.9.1975 and that the insurer was liable for the compensation awarded by the Tribunal.

On the question of limitation of insurer's liability:

  • The court agreed with the insurer's contention that liability under the policy was limited to Rs. 50,000 as provided under Section 95 of the Act and as expressly stated in the insurance policy; the mere mention of "full third party risk" did not extend liability beyond Rs. 50,000. The Tribunal itself had recorded findings (issue No. 9) consistent with this limitation.

On the question of negligence vs. sudden mechanical failure:

  • The owners and driver contended that a tie rod suddenly failed (a mechanical defect) causing the accident and that this could not have been detected despite reasonable care. However, the owner Nathulal and driver Mustaq's statements that routine checks were made were not pleaded in their written statement; the court emphasized that evidence not grounded in pleaded issues cannot be considered on a new unpleaded plea.
  • The Motor Transport Officer (MTO), Kundanlal (NAW 3), examined the bus and found that slipping of the tie rod ring caused the bolt to give way. The vehicle's water body had been broken before the accident and the vehicle was old; manufacturer recommendations required greasing tie rod ends periodically. There was no evidence of periodic maintenance or greasing. The court held that the omission to maintain/check the vehicle rendered the owner and driver responsible. Citing Oriental Fire & General Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Satya Deo Dubey, the court treated the facts as establishing negligence by owner/driver.
  • Physical evidence (site plan Exh. 4) showed the bus first struck the deceased, then crashed into a wall, which broke to an extent of 13 ft., and the bus stopped about 11 ft. from the deceased, demonstrating great speed. The court inferred the bus was driven with tremendous speed, further corroborating negligent driving.

On quantum of compensation:

  • The Tribunal had determined the deceased's age to be about 35 years, that he cultivated 25 bighas of land, and fixed annual income at Rs. 5,000 with annual personal expenditure of Rs. 1,000. The Tribunal assumed life expectancy to 65 years but applied a multiplier of 16 and awarded Rs. 64,000. The court found no ground to reduce that amount and upheld the Tribunal's award on quantum.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition:

  • Appeal No. 97 of 1985 (filed by the owner) — dismissed with costs. The court found no merit in the owner's challenge to the Tribunal's award and upheld the Tribunal's findings on negligence and on the quantum of compensation (Rs. 64,000).
  • Appeal No. 90 of 1985 (filed by the insurance company) — partly allowed. The court held that although the insurer was liable (because the policy was effective from the zero hour of 25.9.1975), its liability under the policy was limited to Rs. 50,000 as provided in Section 95 and as stated in the insurance policy.

Implications:

  • The Tribunal's award of Rs. 64,000 to the claimants stands.
  • The insurance company is liable to pay under the policy, but its liability is capped at Rs. 50,000 under Section 95 as reflected in the policy terms; the opinion does not elaborate upon the specific mechanism for satisfaction of the remainder of the award beyond recording the insurer's capped liability.
  • The court upheld the Tribunal's finding of negligence against the owners and driver, rejecting the contention that the tie rod's failure constituted an excusing vis major in the absence of pleaded and proved maintenance and inspection practices.
  • No broader or novel legal principle beyond the application of existing authorities (as cited) was announced; the court primarily applied established precedents to the facts before it.

This summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion text and does not add or infer facts beyond what the opinion expressly states.

Show all summary ...

1. The appeal No. 90 of 1985 has been filed by the insurance company and the appeal No. 97 of 1985 has been filed by the owner of the vehicle under Section 110-D, Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') against the award passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Bhilwara dated February 2, 1985 in MACT case No. 38 of 1982. The facts of the case giving rise to these appeals may be summarised thus. The respondent Nos. 1 to 6 (in both the appeals) filed a petition under Section 110-A of the Act for claiming compensation to the tune of Rs. 1,10,000/- with the allegations, in short, that on September 25, 1975 at about 11.30 a.m. bus bearing No. RSL 3301 was coming from village Kodimal to village Asind, it was being driven by its driver Mustaq (respondent No. 11) rashly and negligently, as a result thereof, it collided with Sobharam who was going on foot on his right side of the road and further collided with the wall of the agricultural field of Mustaq Ahmed, Advocate. Sobharam was caught and carried to a distance of 15-20 ft. by the front portion of the bus. As a result of the injuries, he died on the spot. He was earning Rs. 12,000/-per year from the agriculture and was supporting the claimants. The owners Nathulal, Shobhalal, Munnalal and Ganeshlal and the driver Mustaq admitted in their joint written statement that the bus was being driven by Mustaq and it was owned by Nathulal, Shobhalal, Ganeshlal and Munnalal and on September 25, 1975 it met with an accident at about 11.30 a.m. They further averred that all of a sudden, the tie rod of the bus gave way for which neither the driver nor the owners of the vehicle were responsible. The accident took place on account of vis major. The insurance company admits in its written statement that the said bus No. RSL 3301 was insured by it in favour of the owners Nathulal, Shobhalal, Ganeshlal and Munnalal. It further also averred that the accident had already taken place before the vehicle was insured, the material fact about the accident was concealed and as such the insurance is void and ineffective. After framing necessary issues and recording the evidence of the parties, the learned Tribunal held that the accident took place due to the rash and negligent act of the driver of the vehicle. Sobharam died on the spot as a result of the injuries received by him in the accident, the claimants are entitled to get Rs. 64,000/- as compensation, the insurance company is also liable to pay the amount and accordingly passed the award which has been challenged in these appeals.

2. It has been contended by the learned Counsel for the insurance company that the accident took place at about 11.30 a.m. on September 25, 1975 and the bus No. RSL 3301 was insured at 3 p.m. on 25.9.1975 as is proved from the cover note Exh. A/1 and certificate of insurance, paper No. C-32/4 and the statement of Insurance Inspector, K.C. Taparia, NAW 5. He further contended that K.C. Taparia, NAW 5, has clearly stated on oath that the owners of the vehicle did not disclose about the accident otherwise he would not have insured the bus. He also contended that the insurance policy was void on the ground of suppression of material fact regarding prior accident. He further contended that admittedly, the bus was not insured at the time of the accident and as such the insurance company cannot be held liable for the payment of compensation. He lastly contended that the learned Tribunal seriously erred to hold the insurance company liable to the extent of the full amount of compensation as it could be liable to the extent of Rs. 50,000/-as provided under Section 95 (2) of the Act.

3. In reply, it has been contended by the learned Counsel for the owners of the bus and claimants that the insurance policy was effective from zero hour on September 25, 1975 as is clear from the insurance policy, paper No C-18/4-5, cover note Exh. A/1 and certificate of insurance, paper No. C-32/4. They relied upon Jaikrishandas v. Chiruthai Ammal 1984 ACJ 530 (Madras), United India Fire & Genl. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. v. Srinivasan 1980 ACJ 413 (Madras); Maya Devi v. Hoob Raj 1988 ACJ 478 (P&H) and Indian Trade and General Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Shailal Maneklal Desai AIR 1964 Bombay 148. They further contended that the owner of the bus Nathulal, NAW 1, has deposed that he made payment of the premium and submitted the form of proposal on 24.9.1975 and not on 25.9.1975. They lastly contended that there was no question of suppression of the fact about the accident as the owner Nathulal, NAW 1, who got the bus insured was not at all aware of the accident.

4. The Inspector of National Insurance Co. Ltd., Beawar, K.C. Taparia, NAW 5, admits in his statement on oath that Nathulal, NAW 1, gave proposal form to him and it must be in the office of the insurance company. Nathulal has deposed that the proposal form and the amount of the premium were given to K.C. Taparia, NAW 5 on 24.9.1975. Admittedly, proposal form has not been produced by the insurance company. The receipt Exh. A/2 of the payment of the premium of Rs. 256.20 was issued on 25.9.1975. Time of issue is not mentioned on it. It must have been issued prior to the issuance of the cover note Exh. A/1 and certificate of insurance, paper No. C-32/4. It is well proved from the evidence on record that Nathulal, NAW 1, was not present in the bus when the accident occurred at 11.30 a.m. on 25.9.1975 in between the villages Kodimal and Asind. The statement of Nathulal, NAW 1, appears to be correct when he stated that he gave the proposal form and amount of premium on 24.9.1975 and it is not correct that he got his vehicle insured by suppressing the fact of accident. Non-production of proposal form supports his version.

5. The cover note Exh. A/1 mentions time of issue as 3 p.m. Its column Nos. 3 and 4 run as under:

3. Effective date of commencement of insurance for the purposes of the Act: 25.9.1975.

4. Date of expiry of insurance: 24.9.1976.

Similarly, the column Nos. 3 and 4 of the certificate of insurance, paper No. C-32/4, run as under:

3. Effective date of commencement of insurance for the purposes of the Act: 25.9.1975.

4. Date of expiry of insurance: 24.9.1976.

The relevant portion of the insurance policy, paper No. C-18/4-5, runs as under:

Commencing date: 25.9.1975.

Expiry date: 24.9.1976.

Even assuming that the receipt and cover note were issued at 3 p.m. on 25.9.1975, the insurance company is liable to make payment of the amount of compensation as the insurance policy was effective from zero hour of September 25, 1975. In other words, the insurance for the purpose of the Act commenced from the midnight of the night intervening 24th and 25th September, 1975. In these columns, effective time of commencement of insurance is not mentioned but the effective date of the commencement of the insurance is mentioned. If the time would have been the determining factor, the columns would not have been so. The time of 3 p.m. is the time of issuance of the cover note and not of the commencement of the insurance. It has been observed in Maya Devi v. Hoob Raj 1988 ACJ 478 (P&H), as under:

8. This brings me to the consideration of issue No. 4. On behalf of the insurance company, it is argued that the accident took place at about 7.30 a.m. whereas the truck was got insured on the same day after 10.00 a.m. after the opening of the office and, therefore, the insurance company is not liable. In Jaikrishandas v. Chiruthai Ammal 1984 ACJ 530 (Madras) and United India Fire and General Ins. Co. Ltd. v. v. Srinivasan 1980 ACJ 413 (Madras), it has been ruled that if the insurance policy is obtained on the same date after the accident, yet it would operate from the previous midnight and, therefore, the insurance company would be liable. The learned Counsel for the insurance company could not. show any judgment to the contrary. Following the aforesaid two decisions, I hold that the insurance company is liable to reimburse the insured, i.e., the owner of the truck. Hence, issue No. 4 stands decided accordingly.

In view of these facts and circumstances, the Tribunal has rightly held the National Insurance Co. Ltd. liable for the payment of compensation.

6. There is force in the contention of the learned Counsel for the insurance company that the liability of the insurance company was limited upto Rs. 50,000/- as provided in Section 95 of the Act. It is clearly provided in the insurance policy that the liability of the insurance company is upto Rs. 50,000/-. The mention of full third party risk does not mean that its liability will extend over and above Rs. 50,000/-. The insurance company is liable to pay amount of compensation to the extent of Rs. 50,000/-. The Tribunal has also held so while recording the findings on the issue No. 9.

7. There is no force in the contention of the learned Counsel for the owners and the driver of the bus that the accident took place due to the sudden failure of the tie rod which could not be detected despite taking reasonable care and caution. The owner Nathulal, NAW 1, has deposed that he had instructed the driver to check the oil, nuts and bolts every morning and evening before starting the bus. Similarly, driver Mustaq, NAW 2, has disclosed in his statement that he had instructions to check the bus for one hour every morning and evening and he duly checked the bus before driving it on the date of the accident. In the cross-examination, Nathulal, NAW 1, admits that these facts have not been pleaded in the written statement. It is well settled law that no amount of evidence can be looked into upon a plea which has not been put forward. Thus the position is that there is no pleading and proof to the effect that the bus was being properly checked and maintained. The M.T.O., Bhilwara, Kundanlal, NAW 3, has deposed that on examination of the bus, he found that as a result of the slipping of the ring of the tie rod, its bolt gave way. There is also nothing on the record to indicate as to when the tie rod ends were greased. Tata Diesel Vehicle Operators Hand Book requires that tie rod ends should be greased after every 1000 km. Admittedly, water body of the bus got broken before the accident. This shows that the vehicle was an old one. If it had been checked properly before driving it, the defect of the tie rod would have been detected and the accident would not have taken place. For this omission, the owners and the driver are responsible. It has been observed in Oriental Fire and General Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Satya Deo Dubey 1981 ACJ 31 (Allahabad), as follows (para 7):

In the present case the vehicle was manufactured in the year 1962 and the accident took place in the year 1973. There is no evidence produced on the part of the defendant-appellants to show as to in what manner the vehicle was being maintained. It has not been specifically shown that the vehicle was periodically checked and its parts including the tie rod were found to be in working order. In these circumstances negligence on the part of the owner of the vehicle and its driver is established.

8. It is well proved from the evidence on record, particularly site plan, Exh. 4, that the bus first dashed with the deceased Sobharam, thereafter, it dashed with the wall of the agricultural field of Mustaq Ahmed, Advocate and it stopped at a distance of about 11 ft. from the dead body of the deceased. This wall broke to the extent of 13 ft. These facts leave no doubt that the bus dashed against the deceased and the wall with great force. In other words, it was being driven with tremendous speed. It is an admitted case of the driver and owners of the bus that on that day the water body of the bus got damaged, the passengers were asked to get down and empty bus was being driven. It seems that the bus was being driven with excessive speed so that the water body might not get heated up frequently and so repeatedly trouble the driver. The Tribunal has rightly held that the accident occurred due to the negligence and carelessness of the driver.

9. The Tribunal has awarded Rs. 64,000/-only as compensation. It is well proved from the evidence on record that the age of the deceased Sobharam on the date of the accident was about 35 years and he was cultivating 25 bighas of agricultural land. After properly discussing the evidence on record the learned Tribunal has rightly held that the annual income of the deceased was Rs. 5,000/- and he was spending (Sic. Rs. 1,000/-) annually on himself. The Tribunal has estimated the compensation assuming the expectancy of the life of the deceased to be 65 years. Despite it, the Tribunal has applied the multiplier of 16 only. There exists no ground for reducing the amount of compensation. Thus there is no force in the appeal No. 97 of 1985.

10. Consequently, the appeal No. 97 of 1985 is dismissed with costs and appeal No. 90 of 1985 is partly allowed.