- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Om Parkash Petitioner v. Golden Forest India Ltd. And Others S
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, alleging dishonour of a cheque for Rs. 1,05,200/- due to insufficient funds. After preliminary evidence was recorded, the complaint was scheduled for further proceedings on March 04, 2004. Neither the petitioner nor his counsel appeared on that date, resulting in dismissal of the complaint in default. Subsequently, the petitioner’s application for restoration of the complaint was dismissed as not maintainable. The petitioner contended that the non-appearance was due to a mistaken diary entry noting the date as March 09, 2004 instead of March 04, 2004, and argued that he had appeared on all other dates. The respondent opposed the petition, asserting that the remedy lay in filing an application for leave to appeal rather than restoration of the complaint.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an application for restoration of a complaint dismissed in default under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is maintainable.
- Whether the complaint dismissed in default due to the petitioner’s non-appearance, allegedly caused by a bona fide mistake in noting the date, can be restored by the Court under its inherent powers.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The petitioner and his counsel failed to appear on the fixed date due to an honest mistake in noting the date as March 09, 2004 instead of March 04, 2004, supported by a copy of the diary and file cover.
- The petitioner had appeared on all other dates after filing the complaint and should not be penalized for non-appearance on a single date.
- The application for restoration was filed despite an admission that such an application was not maintainable before the Court below.
Respondent’s Arguments
- The petition for restoration of the complaint dismissed in default was not maintainable as the petitioner had the remedy of filing an application for leave to appeal before the High Court.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Purushotam Mantri v. Vinod Tandon alias Hari Nath Tandon, Criminal Misc. No. 36522-M of 2006 | Clarification that an application for restoration of complaint dismissed in default is not maintainable if the petitioner has remedy by appeal or revision. | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the application for restoration before the lower court was not maintainable. |
| Jitender Bajaj v. State (U.T Chandigarh) and others, 2005 (3) RCR (Criminal) 69; 2005 Crl. L.J 3136 | When a Magistrate dismisses a complaint due to complainant's absence, the remedy lies in appeal, revision, or petition under Section 482 of the Code, not restoration by the Magistrate. | The Court cited this to emphasize that dismissal in default cannot be set aside by restoration in the lower court but may be challenged before the High Court under Section 482. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the maintainability of the application for restoration of a complaint dismissed in default under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. It relied on precedents establishing that such restoration applications are not maintainable before the Magistrate once the complaint is dismissed in default, and the proper remedy lies in appeal, revision, or a petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure before the High Court.
Regarding the petitioner's claim of non-appearance due to a bona fide mistake in noting the date, the Court found this explanation to be genuine. Exercising its inherent powers under Section 482, the Court accepted the revision petition, set aside the dismissal order dated March 04, 2004, and restored the complaint to its original number for further proceedings.
Holding and Implications
The petition is allowed.
The Court held that the application for restoration of the complaint dismissed in default was not maintainable before the Magistrate. However, exercising its inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 of the Code, the High Court set aside the dismissal order and restored the complaint due to the bona fide reason for non-appearance. The parties were directed to appear before the trial Court for further proceedings. This decision directly reinstates the complaint for trial but does not establish a new precedent beyond reaffirming existing legal principles regarding restoration and remedies available after dismissal in default.
Rajesh Bindal, J. — Challenge in the present petition is to the order passed by learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Faridabad dated March 04, 2004 whereby the complaint filed by the petitioner under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (for short “the Act”) was dismissed in default. In addition to this, the challenge is also to the order dated August 18, 2006 passed by Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Faridabad vide which application for restoration of the complaint was dismissed as not maintainable.
2. Briefly the facts are that the petitioner filed a complaint under Section 138 of the Act against respondents on account of dishonour of cheque for Rs. 1,05,200/- due to insufficient funds. After recording the preliminary evidence, the complaint was fixed for further proceedings on March 04, 2004. On the date fixed neither the petitioner nor his counsel appeared and the same was dismissed in default. Even the application for restoration of the complaint filed by the petitioner was also dismissed. The contention is that petitioner as well as his counsel could not appear on the date fixed for the reason that date was wrongly noted as March 09, 2004 as against March 04, 2004. In order to prove, he produced even copy of the diary and the file cover. He submitted that after filing of the complaint, petitioner had been appeared on all the dates and merely because of his non appearance on one date he should not have been penalized. However, he admits that application for restoration was not maintainable before the Court below.
3. On the other hand learned counsel for the respondent No. 5 submitted that present petition for restoration of the complaint, which was dismissed in default is not maintainable as the petitioner had remedy of filing application for leave to appeal before this Court.
4. This Court while considering an identical issue in Criminal Misc. No. 36522-M of 2006 (Purushotam Mantri v. Vinod Tandon alias Hari Nath Tandon) vide judgment dated January 30, 2008 opined as under :—
“Learned counsel for the petitioner did not dispute that application filed by the petitioner before the Court below for recalling the order was not maintainable and accordingly the same was rightly dismissed by the Court below. However, submission is that this Court under Section 482 of the Code can certainly direct restoration of the complaint, which was dismissed in default if sufficient reason is found for his nonappearance on the date fixed. For the purpose he has relied upon the observations made by this Court in Jitender Bajaj v. State (U.T Chandigarh) and others, 2005 (3) RCR (Criminal) 69 : 2005 Crl. L.J 3136, which are reproduced below :—
“……..When the Magistrate, in a summon case, has dismissed the complaint and acquitted the accused due to absence of the complainant on the day of hearing, he cannot later on restore the complaint and set aside the order of acquittal, even if the complainant shows very good reasons for his failure to be present on the day of dismissal of the complaint. In such situation, the only remedy available with the complainant is to file appeal or revision against such order or petition under Section 482 of the Code before this Court for setting aside the said order of dismissal of the complaint and acquittal of the accused on the ground that in the given facts and circumstances, the dismissal of the complaint and acquittal of the accused was not justified or there were sufficient reasons for non-appearance of the complainant before the Court on the date fixed, or the Magistrate has not properly exercised his discretion while not adjourning the complaint and dismissing the same.”
5. In view of the above enunciation of law, it is held that application for restoration of complaint under Section 138 of the Act, which was dismissed in default was not maintainable.
6. As far as the claim of the petitioner with regard to challenge to the order dismissing the complaint in default is concerned, the reason for non appearance given by the petitioner is that as against March 4, 2004, the date was noted as March 09, 2004 and it was on that account neither the petitioner nor his counsel could appear in case and the complaint was dismissed in default. The reason for non appearance is bona fide. Accordingly, while accepting the revision petition, impugned order dated March 04, 2004 dismissing the complaint filed by the petitioner in default is set aside. The complaint filed by the petitioner is restored to its original number.
7. The parties are directed to appear before the trial Court on March 29, 2008 for further proceedings.
Petition allowed.
Alert