Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M.R Singhal v. Assistant Commissioner Of Income-Tax

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Oct 16, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Based exclusively on the information in the provided opinion.

A search and seizure operation was conducted at the assessee's premises on December 21, 1995. The assessee earned commission income from encashment of demand drafts. Returns for the assessment years 1994-95 and 1995-96 were filed on October 3, 1996, after the search and seizure. The income disclosed in these belated returns was treated as undisclosed income under section 158BB of the Income-tax Act by the Assessing Officer, who rejected the assessee's contention that returns filed under section 139(4) should be treated as within the "due date" for the purpose of section 158BB.

The assessee also claimed deductions totalling a composite amount of Rs. 3,20,000 for the assessment years 1991-92 to 1995-96; the Assessing Officer allowed Rs. 1,35,000 for the assessment year 1995-96. The assessee appealed against the order of the Assessing Officer; the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Chandigarh Bench, upheld the Assessing Officer's positions by its order dated July 1, 2003 in IT (SS)A. No. 2.Chandi/98 (block assessment period April 1, 1985 to December 21, 1995). The assessee preferred the present appeal against the ITAT order, raising two substantial questions of law.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the ITAT was correct in not allowing deduction of expenses amounting in the composite to Rs. 3,20,000 for assessment years 1991-92 to 1995-96, particularly when a deduction of Rs. 1,35,000 was allowed for assessment year 1995-96.
  2. Whether the ITAT was correct in upholding the ACIT's order that declared the income for assessment years 1994-95 and 1995-96 as undisclosed, notwithstanding the provisions of section 139(4) (i.e., whether returns filed under section 139(4) could be treated as returns filed within the due date for the purpose of section 158BB).

Arguments of the Parties

Assessee's Arguments

  • The assessee contended that returns for assessment years 1994-95 and 1995-96, though filed after the statutory due dates, were filed within the time permitted under section 139(4) and therefore should be treated as returns filed within the meaning of the expression "due date" under section 158BB.
  • The assessee claimed entitlement to deductions aggregating Rs. 3,20,000 for assessment years 1991-92 to 1995-96 and pointed out that a deduction of Rs. 1,35,000 had been allowed for assessment year 1995-96.

Revenue's Arguments

  • The Revenue opposed the assessee's contentions and supported the ITAT's findings: that the deductions claimed lacked supporting bills, vouchers and details; and that the belated returns could not nullify the effect of not filing returns by the due date for purposes of section 158BB.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sat Pal Singh v. ACIT (Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench) Where income for a particular assessment year falling in the block period, even after additions and disallowances, remains below the taxable limit, it cannot be treated as undisclosed; however, where declared income exceeds the taxable limit on account of addition or surrender, the entire income for that year is treated as undisclosed and liable to tax at 60%. The court found this decision directly applicable and followed it to conclude that here the income (as assessed) exceeded the taxable limit and therefore should be treated as undisclosed under the block assessment provisions.
Smt. Usha God (I.T.A. No. 1178/96, decision dated February 24, 2000 — ITAT, Chandigarh Bench) Applied by the ITAT in the Sat Pal Singh line of decisions to determine when income in block years should be treated as undisclosed. Referred to as an antecedent decision relied upon by the ITAT in explaining the Sat Pal Singh principle; used as part of the line of authority supporting treatment of the declared income as undisclosed in the present facts.
B.K. Agarwal v. ACIT (Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Lucknow Bench) Illustrates facts where a belated return was held to be disclosure because books/details were in possession of the Department, audit report under section 44AB existed, TDS was deducted, and advance/self-assessment tax was paid. The court distinguished this case: it held that its factual matrix (no records in regular books, no advance tax or self-assessment tax paid) did not match B.K. Agarwal, so the decision was not applicable to the present case.
Shri Surekha Singh v. ACIT (I.T (SS) A. No. 1.Chandi/97 — ITAT, Chandigarh Bench) In that case a return was filed on January 22, 1996 declaring income marginally above exemption; the decision's applicability depends on facts such as whether income was recorded in books or taxes paid. The court held that full facts of that case were not on record here and therefore that decision was not applicable to the present case.
Smt. Renu, Thanesar, Kurukshetra v. ACTT, Investigation Circle, Ambala (I.T.A. No. 1129.Chandi/96, decided June 25, 2003) Another decision of the ITAT, Chandigarh Benches, consistent with the Sat Pal Singh approach in treating income as undisclosed where appropriate. Noted by the court as part of the consistent line of ITAT, Chandigarh Bench decisions followed in this matter.
CIT v. M.M. George, [2002] 254 ITR 45 (Kerala High Court) Held that for block assessment under section 158BC, even income below the taxable limit of any previous year falling in the block period has to be included in undisclosed income if not declared in the regular return under section 139(1). The court stated this decision was not applicable to the present facts because, in the present case, the income declared in the belated returns and finally assessed far exceeded the minimum taxable limit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court affirmed the ITAT's factual findings and legal conclusions after considering the parties' submissions and the record. The analysis is presented separately for the two pleaded questions.

Issue (i): Deduction of Expenses

  1. The ITAT found that the assessee did not produce bills, vouchers or details (for example, names of employees) to substantiate the claimed expenses for the relevant years. Major components of the claimed expenses related to salaries for successive years which were unsupported by evidence in the seized documents.
  2. One seized document — the income and expenditure account for the period ending March 31, 1994 — showed salary expenses of Rs. 60,000, which indicated that work was carried out through regular employees; therefore there was no evidentiary support for the higher claimed amounts.
  3. Given the absence of supporting material, the ITAT held that the Assessing Officer's allowance of Rs. 1,35,000 was fair and reasonable and that disallowance of the remaining claim was justified. The court accepted these factual findings, observing that absence of relevant material made the disallowance legal and not arbitrary.
  4. The court concluded that no substantial question of law arose from this factual conclusion and affirmed the Tribunal's dismissal of the ground of appeal on this point.

Issue (ii): Treatment of Belated Returns under Section 158BB and Section 139(4)

  1. The court reviewed section 158BB(1)(ca), which treats income declared in the regular return as nil where the due date for filing has expired and no return was filed; the Tribunal applied a line of its own decisions (notably Sat Pal Singh and related cases) to explain when income in an assessment year falling in the block period should nevertheless be treated as undisclosed.
  2. The Tribunal distinguished favorable precedents for belated returns (e.g., B.K. Agarwal) on their facts: in those cases, records in employers' audit reports, TDS, and payment of advance/self-assessment tax supported the conclusion that the belated return represented disclosure. Those factual elements were absent here.
  3. The court observed that section 139(4) permits filing of returns after the due date, but that for the purposes of section 158BB(1)(c) (and related block assessment provisions) the consequence of not filing by the due date cannot be negated simply by later filing under section 139(4) where the statutory conditions for treating income as undisclosed are otherwise met.
  4. Section 158BB(1)(d) was also invoked by the Tribunal as indicating that transactions recorded in books of account are material; the absence of entries in the seized documents and the failure to pay advance or self-assessment tax at the relevant times were significant factors militating against treating the belated returns as bona fide "disclosures" for block assessment purposes.
  5. Given the above, and the inordinate delay in filing and absence of tax payments at the relevant times, the court agreed with the Tribunal's conclusion that the income declared in the belated returns for assessment years 1994-95 and 1995-96 fell within the definition of "undisclosed income" for block assessment purposes.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeal is DISMISSED.

Direct consequences of the court's decision (as recorded in the opinion):

  • The Tribunal's factual finding that the assessee failed to substantiate the claimed deductions was affirmed and the Assessing Officer's allowance of Rs. 1,35,000 was held to be reasonable; the remainder of the claimed composite deduction (Rs. 3,20,000 claimed overall) was not permitted due to lack of evidence.
  • The Tribunal's determination that the income declared in the belated returns for assessment years 1994-95 and 1995-96 constituted "undisclosed income" under the block-assessment provisions was upheld. The court held that filing under section 139(4) did not cure the consequence of not having filed by the due date for purposes of section 158BB where, as here, taxes were not paid and no entries existed in books to show disclosure.
  • The court found that no substantial question of law arose from either issue, effectively leaving the Tribunal's factual and legal conclusions intact.

Broader legal impact: The opinion applies and follows a line of ITAT, Chandigarh Bench decisions (e.g., Sat Pal Singh and related cases). The court did not indicate that a new legal principle was established; it affirmed existing Tribunal conclusions on the specific facts before it.

Show all summary ...

1. This appeal has been preferred by the assessee against the order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, “B”, Chandigarh (for short, “the ITAT”) dated July 1, 2003, in IT (SS)A. No. 2.Chandi/98, in respect of the block assessment period from April 1, 1985, to December 21, 1995, proposing the following substantial questions of law:

“(i) Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case the learned Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was right in not allowing the deduction of expenses to the tune of the composite amount of Rs. 3,20,000 for various assessment years 1991-92 to 1995-96, especially when it is an admitted fact that deduction of expenses to the tune of Rs. 1,35,000 as claimed for the assessment year 1995-96 has been allowed?

(ii) Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case the learned Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was right in upholding the order of the ACIT wherein the income for the assessment years 1994-95 and 1995-96 were declared to be undisclosed overlooking the provisions of section 139(4) ?”

2. The facts relevant for decision of the appeal appearing from the order of the Tribunal are that search and seizure operation was conducted at the premises of the assessee on December 21, 1995. It was observed that the assessee was earning commission income from the encashment of demand drafts. The assessee filed returns on October 3, 1996, after the search and seizure for the assessment years 1994-95 and 1995-96. The income disclosed was treated as undisclosed income under section 158BB of the Act, rejecting the contention on behalf of the assessee that though filing of returns was due on October 31, 1994, and October 31, 1995, respectively, the returns were within the time allowed under section 139(4) of the Act and the return filed within the said time should also be treated as return filed within the meaning of the expression “due date” under section 158BB of the Act. It was next submitted that deduction of expenses to the tune of the composite amount of Rs. 3,20,000 for the assessment years 1991-92 to 1995-96 should have been allowed having regard to the fact that deduction of expenses to the tune of Rs. 1,35,000 had been allowed for the assessment year 1995-96.

3. Learned counsel for the Revenue opposed the submissions made on behalf of the assessee and supported the findings recorded by the Tribunal. We have considered the rival submissions and perused the record.

4. Our findings on the questions proposed are as under:

Re: Q. No : (i)

5. On this question, the Tribunal has recorded the following finding:

“8. As regards the assessee's claim for deduction of expenses, we find that the assessee has not given any details in the form of bills and vouchers for any such expenditure incurred. Major component of the expenses claimed relates to salaries of Rs. 12,000, Rs. 24,000, Rs. 72,000 and Rs. 90,000 for the assessment years 1992-93, 1993-94, 1994-95 and 1995-96, respectively. Even if the details of other expenses like local conveyance, entertainment and miscellaneous expenses were not available, the assessee could have given the name of the employees to whom salary had been paid. No such details have been furnished. Besides, in none of the seized documents, there is any entry in regard to incurring of such expenditure. A copy of the income and expenditure account for the period ending on March 31, 1994, is on record. The same separately shows salary expenses of Rs. 60,000 debited to such account. Therefore, it can be said that the assessee was getting such work done through regular employees. In any case, there is no evidence to support the claim of the assessee for deduction at higher amount. Moreover, commission income has also been estimated at a rate of 0.35 per cent, which works out to nominal amount of Rs. 3,500 per lakh. The amount covered in the bank drafts is also sizeable. Therefore, it would have not required much effort in depositing the same in the bank account, withdrawing the money and returning the same to the person to whom these drafts actually belonged. In the light of these facts and circumstances of the case, we are of the considered opinion that deduction of Rs. 1,35,000 allowed by the Assessing Officer is fair and reasonable and the order of the Assessing Officer does not merit any interference. This ground of appeal is dismissed.”

6. The above observations show that the Tribunal has recorded a finding of fact that the claim for deductions could not be proved by the assessee by relevant evidence and in these circumstances, deduction of Rs. 1,35,000 allowed by the Assessing Officer was upheld. From the mere fact that the Assessing Officer required the assessee to give proof of expenditure for a particular year, did not mean that the same was to be treated as precedent for all times to come. In the absence of any material, disallowance of the expenses claimed could not be held to be illegal.

7. Accordingly, while affirming the findings of the Tribunal on this issue, we do not find any substantial question of law arises.

Re: Q. No. (ii)

8. The finding recorded by the Tribunal on this question is as under:

“20. Section 158BB(1) deals with the computation of undisclosed income. The case of the assessee is covered by clause (ca) of section 158BB(1), which provides that where the due date for filing the return of income has expired but no return of income has been filed, income declared in the regular return is to be taken as nil. This means that the entire income computed in the block assessment relating to those assessment years would be treated as undisclosed income. In the case of Sat Pal Singh v. ACIT, supra Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, had by relying on its earlier decision dated February 24, 2000, in the case of Smt. Usha God in I.T.A No. 1178/96 for block assessment years 1986-87 to 1995-96 has held that where income for a particular assessment year falling in the block period, even after making additions and disallowances remains below the taxable limit, the same cannot be treated as undisclosed for the purpose of block assessment. However, where income so declared exceeds the minimum taxable limit on account of any addition, surrender made, the entire income for that assessment year would be treated as undisclosed and liable to tax at 60 per cent. In this case, income declared in the return filed beyond the period allowed under section 139(1) itself exceeds the taxable limit and after making addition, the income for the assessment years 1994-95 and 1995-96 has been assessed at more than Rs. 6 lakhs and Rs. 10 lakhs, respectively. Moreover, the assessee had also not paid advance tax or self-assessment tax at the relevant time and there was inordinate delay in filing the return. Therefore, it could not be said that the assessee had ever intended to disclose such income. Therefore, the entire income has to be treated as undisclosed income. Reliance of learned counsel on the decision of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Lucknow Bench in the case of B.K Agarwal v. ACIT, (supra), is misplaced. In that case, the assessee had explained that he could not file the return for the assessment year 1995-96 before the due date as his books of accounts and other details were in the possession of the Department following search and seizure operations. However, details of payment of salary and commission, etc. were available in the record of the employer in the form of audit report under section 44AB. Tax was deducted at source and the assessee also paid advance tax and the remaining amount was paid as self-assessment tax. Therefore, such income declared in the belated return was held to be disclosed. These are not the facts of the present case. The assessee had neither recorded the transactions in the regular books of account nor filed the returns before the due dates. No advance tax and self-assessment tax had also been paid. Further, no reason for delay in filing the return of income had also been explained. Therefore, the income declared in the belated returns fall in the category of undisclosed income within the meaning of section 158B(b) of the Income-tax Act read with section 158BB(1)(ca) of the Act. Learned counsel for the assessee has relied on the decision of Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench in the case of Shri Surekha Singh v. ACIT, Circle 1(2), Ludhiana in I.T (SS) A. No. 1.Chandi/97, supra. In that case, the search and seizure action had been carried out on December 21, 1995. The assessee filed the return for the assessment year 1995-96 on January 22, 1996, declaring therein income of Rs. 41,730 which was marginally above the exemption limit. Full facts of the case are not on record. It is not known whether such income was recorded in the regular books of account or whether the assessee had paid advance tax or self-assessment tax or even otherwise was in the knowledge of the Department. Therefore, in the absence of such details, we are of the opinion that this decision is not applicable to the facts of the present case. The facts of the present case clearly show that the entire income is undisclosed within the meaning of section 158B(b). Moreover, the view taken by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench in the case of Sat Pal Singh v. ACIT, supra is consistently being followed by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Benches. In fact, one such case was decided on June 25, 2003 in I.T.A No. 1129.Chandi/96 in the case of Smt. Renu, Thanesar, Kurukshetra v. ACTT, Investigation Circle, Ambala. In fact, in the case of CIT v. M.M George, [2002] 254 ITR 45, the hon'ble Kerala High Court has taken the view that for the purpose of block assessment under section 158BC, even the income below the taxable limit of any previous year falling in the block period has to be included in the undisclosed income if such income has not been declared by the assessee in the regular return under section 139(1). This judgment is not applicable to the facts of the present case because the income declared in the returns and finally assessed far exceeds the minimum taxable limit and, therefore, the decision of Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench in the case of Sat Pal Singh v. ACTT, supra, is directly applicable to the facts of the present case.”

9. Though learned counsel for the assessee has relied upon section 139(4) of the Act which permits the return to be filed even after the expiry of due date, for purposes of section 158BB(1)(c) of the Act, the consequence of the return having not been filed by the due date cannot be nullified by a return filed under section 139(4) of the Act. Even otherwise, section 158BB(1)(d) of the Act clearly provides that even where the date for filing the return has not expired, transactions recorded on the basis of entries relating to income in the books of account have to be taken into account. In the present case, no advance tax or self-assessment tax had been paid at the relevant time. In such a situation, the return filed under section 139(4) of the Act could not be taken into account.

10. We are in agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal that where no advance tax or self-assessment tax is paid, the return filed under section 139(4) cannot be treated as a return filed before the due date specified under section 139(1) of the Act. Accordingly, while affirming the findings of the Tribunal on this issue, we do not find any substantial question of law arises.

11. In view of the above, the appeal is dismissed.